Top Stories -   

1
Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut was made into a dike at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut was made into a dike at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut into a dike was made at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, following the dike breach in Manitoba, Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy the government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, following the dike breach in Manitoba, Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy the government of Manitoba) An aerial photo shows the Assiniboine River and the Hoop and Holler Bend (John Woods THE CANADIAN PRESS/) Members of 2nd battalion Princess Patricia's Light Infantry help load sandbags onto helicopter slings to be transported to weak sections of the dike running along the Assiniboine River some 25km from Portage La Prairie, Man. Thursday, May 12, 2011. (Jonathan Hayward / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Some residents in Portage la Prairie, Man. were evacuated at a moment's notice after officials announced they would conduct a controlled breach on a dike along the Assiniboine River, Wednesday, May 11, 2011. Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, following the dike breach in Manitoba, Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy the government of Manitoba)

Flood waters flow through Manitoba dike breach

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Doug Connery, farm owner
Doug Connery, who owns farmland close to where the dike was breached, says water is slowly flowing down a creek from the river, and discusses his concerns with farming and losing sales.
CTV National News: Jill Macyshon on the floods
The water is on the move and hundreds of Manitobans are on high alert. They're waiting and worrying after engineers deliberately broke up a dike that had been holding back the Assiniboine River near Portage La Prairie.
CTV National News: Janet Dirks on the residents
Even if homes in the flood zone are saved, the livelihoods of many are certain to be washed away.
Extended: Dike along the Assiniboine River is cut
Watch as engineers cut the dike at Hoop and Holler bend along the Assiniboine River, making water flow onto nearby land.
Extended: Aerial view of the dike breach
Aerial video footage of the dike breach is seen, as water continues to slowly flow out of the Assiniboine River in Manitoba.
CTV News Channel: Greg Selinger with an update
3:45 p.m. ET: Manitoba Greg Selinger gives an update on the amount of homes and farms that will be impacted by the deliberate breach in the river, saying there has been a superb level of cooperation and effort.
CTV News Channel: Greg Selinger with an update
3:10 p.m. ET: Manitoba Premier Greg Selinger gives an update on the deliberate dike breach, saying no homes have been negatively affected. Depending upon the water flow, cuts will be made into roads to minimize property damage.
CTV News Channel: Tony Merchant, lawyer
8:02 p.m. ET: A lawyer who specializes in class action lawsuits says that there is definitely grounds for a legal case against the Manitoba government for deliberately causing a flood because by diverting water, they become responsible for damages.
CTV News Channel: Ron Owens, resident
8:03 p.m. ET: A resident of Portage La Prairie that lives inside of the danger zone being intentionally flooded says he's been keeping his eye on the ditches and creeks around his property and that his main concern is the safety of people and animals.
CTV Winnipeg: Caroline Barghout on reactions
A number of residents have been facing questions on how much water to expect and how high to build their dikes in the flood fight. Many Manitobans are still rushing to prepare for the deliberate dike breach expected on Saturday morning.
CTV Winnipeg: Laura Lowe on flood forecasting
Now that the dike has been breached the water is flowing, but just how far has it gone? Neighbors in Manitoba investigate this, and decide to take matters into their own hands.
CTV News Channel: Jill Macyshon on the breach
6:03 p.m. ET: A CTV National News correspondent in Newton, Man., says almost every road within a mile of the breach site has been cordoned off. She says that none of the water has reached any homes yet.
CTV News Channel: Steve Ashton, minister
3:00 p.m. ET: Manitoba Emergency Measures Minister Steve Ashton discusses the speed of the water flowing out of the river, following the breach dike.
CTV News Channel: Captain Les Marshall
12:10 a.m. ET: Captain Les Marshall with the Salvation Army shares some of the stories he has heard from residents who have been evacuated.
CTV News Channel: Doug McMahon speaks
11:00 a.m. ET: The executive director of Manitoba Water Control and Structures holds a press conference to explain the procedures that are being taken to control the dike breach.
CTV News Channel: Lt.-Col. Shane Schreiber
11:05 a.m. ET: There are approximately 1,300 soldiers helping residents to sandbag in Manitoba. Shane Schreiber discusses the military's effort and the challenges they have been faced with.
CTV News Channel: Doug Connery, farm owner
9:05 a.m. ET: Doug Connery, who owns farmland close to where the dike was breached, discusses his concerns with the deliberate dike breach.
CTV News Channel: Janet Dirks in Newton
9:00 a.m. ET: CTV's Alberta bureau chief says it will take a few hours before any significant amount of water is seen, and explains how much water is being released at a time.
CTV News Channel: Janet Dirks in Newton
8:15 a.m. ET: CTV's Alberta bureau chief says the dike along the Assiniboine River has been breached, and a family has already evacuated their home in anticipation for flooding.
CTV News Channel: Cheryl Holmes, resident
8:25 a.m. ET: Cheryl Holmes, a resident who will be affected by the breach, says residents in the red zone were not given any information on what to expect from authorities. It is not known whether her dike will hold up against the intentional flooding.
CTV News Channel: Jill Macyshon in Newton
6:00 a.m. ET: A CTV correspondent in Newton, Manitoba explains how the dike will be breached, and says there is still a sense of disbelief among the residents who will be affected.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (58) Facebook   

Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut was made into a dike at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut was made into a dike at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut into a dike was made at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, following the dike breach in Manitoba, Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy the government of Manitoba) Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, following the dike breach in Manitoba, Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy the government of Manitoba) An aerial photo shows the Assiniboine River and the Hoop and Holler Bend (John Woods THE CANADIAN PRESS/) Members of 2nd battalion Princess Patricia's Light Infantry help load sandbags onto helicopter slings to be transported to weak sections of the dike running along the Assiniboine River some 25km from Portage La Prairie, Man. Thursday, May 12, 2011. (Jonathan Hayward / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Some residents in Portage la Prairie, Man. were evacuated at a moment's notice after officials announced they would conduct a controlled breach on a dike along the Assiniboine River, Wednesday, May 11, 2011. Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, following the dike breach in Manitoba, Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy the government of Manitoba)

Photos

Water is seen flowing from the Assiniboine River, after a cut was made into a dike at Hoop and Holler Bend, southeast of Portage la Prairie, Man., Saturday, May 14, 2011. (Courtesy Government of Manitoba)

View Larger Image

More on this topic

Selected Comment

I absolutely think the government of Manitoba should buy all those properties at the value they were before the controlled flood. Not to mention the shortage of food that could occur because of the loss of crops. I think there were more to consider than 800 homes elsewhere in Manitoba.

Helen Currie

Flood waters flow through Manitoba dike breach

talking about
Flood waters flow through Manitoba dike breach

Date: Sat. May. 14 2011 9:59 PM ET

Water from Manitoba's swollen Assiniboine River flowed through a break in the dike system and across prairie flatland after the province acted on a controversial plan to intentionally flood one swath of land to save another.

Excavators used heavy machinery to scrape away a layer of rock near Hoop and Holler Bend, northeast of Portage La Prairie, at about 7 a.m. local time, allowing a trickle of river water into an area that had previously been protected by sandbags.

The province said in a statement that it would take several hours before a "significant amount" of water was flowing through the dike breach.

By Saturday afternoon, the flow was spreading slowly across prairie fields and filling ditches along roads. The plan was that the water would disperse from the Assiniboine River and into the LaSalle River watershed.

The intentional breach was expected to inundate a 225-kilometre area that is home to 150 homes and farms.

As of Saturday afternoon, Premier Greg Selinger said that water had extended "about a mile" over farmland from the breach.

He added that homes in the flood path were "well-protected" by dikes, and added that "we've been able to, so far, manage it."

The controlled breach is designed to avoid an uncontrolled break that could devastate as many as 850 more homes and more than 500 square kilometres of land.

"Up to now, things have gone very well," Selinger told CTV News Channel from the scene of the flooding.

He also expressed confidence that the federal government would take part in extra compensation for property owners in the area of the breach. But he added that if the province had not created floodways and dikes in years previous, the entire area would already be under "five feet of water."

Earlier in the day, a provincial media release stated that the "controlled spill floods approximately 225 square kilometres in order to prevent flooding of a much larger area with up to about 10 times the volume of water from an unplanned dike breach.

"The controlled release affects the same area that would be at risk of flooding by an uncontrolled breach."

The breach was originally scheduled for Wednesday but was repeatedly delayed, in part because of recent improvements to the Portage Diversion, a man-made channel that runs water from the Assiniboine north to Lake Manitoba. The Diversion was designed to handle 25,000 cubic feet per second but, following hasty efforts to expand it, is now managing 33,000 cubic feet per second.

The dike breach at Hoop and Holler Bend started releasing an estimated 500 cubic feet per second, enough water to fill an Olympic-sized swimming pool in three minutes. The rate of release will increase until it reaches 3,000 cubic feet per second.

Although that sounds like a lot of water, officials said its dispersal over a large, flat area means there won't be a catastrophic deluge.

Lt.-Col Shane Schrieber said there were 1,300 soldiers from the Shilo, Man., army base and across western Manitoba working in the region to maintain and build dike and sandbag systems.

"We have focused our efforts on armouring the dikes along the Assiniboine River so we can maintain the flow rate," Schreiber told CTV News Channel. "We have also been preparing houses in the inundation area by the Hoop and Holler Bend to get them ready for whatever inundation might come."

He said soldiers would work "one or two days ahead" of the water flow in an attempt to shore up homes before the flows arrive.

The provincial government has said it will look to improve flood-proofing along the Assiniboine once the waters recede -- possibly expanding dikes or increasing the capacity of the Shellmouth reservoir system.

The federal and provincial governments have spent almost $1 billion since the so-called flood of the century in 1997 to improve flood protection along the Red River.

Selinger said that officials had built the flooding system to handle water flows two-feet above previously recorded high marks. But he conceded that this year's floods had exceeded even the worst-case scenario.

"The reality is, it's been a real shock to everybody," he said, adding that the floods have been called a "one in 300-year event."

Comments are now closed for this story

Sam C
said

@two sense... it might be a bit over the top (no pun intended) to build a run-off channel for a 300-year flood. Really, where would the construction stop -- walls around all the cities? We can only prepare for what can reasonably be expected.


my two sense worth
said

Would it be possible sometime in the future to create a "run-off canal" to divert the water away from the residential areas? It could help to decrease the potential for flooding and in the long run cost much less in man hours lost of homes and livelyhood. I am sure that if asked engineering students could come up with a way to make it work that would be cost effective.


Please get your facts straight before posting!
said

In the internet age with access to any information you need I am disappointed in the number of comments on this story that are made without getting the facts straight first.


wolfeden
said

Look...first of all, I am VERY sorry for all of you that are being flooded. It is terrible..plain and simple!!!! But...let's not turn this into a political pile of crap!! Hugh McFadyen would have done the same thing that Premier Sellinger had to do...McFadyen can only thank his lucky stars he was not Premier right now!!! THIS IS NOT an NDP thing...it is an act of nature which happened right now!!!!


Mokey
said

You were lucky Ken. For drought compensation I got $1.52, not per acre, $1.52 total. It really helped us get through the year!


ken
said

i hope the gov does not settel the damages like they paid the farmers last year for unseeded acres it was supposed to be 50$ an acre but in reality after administration and deductible i got a total of 16$ an acre witch i was then taxed on !!


Michelle
said

It's funny how some people can turn everything into politics. I'm sure this decision has not been made lightly. One controlled breach or who knows how many uncontrolled breaches all over the place. There is just simply too much water flowing in the rivers. People would be complaining either way, it's a lose-lose situation.


Vikki
said

Yes, the flooding is bad. But we won't get a crop in this year because our officials in Sask won't do as much as those in Manitoba. At least they are doing something to prevent a catastrophe there. Here we don't even have 'Road Closed' signs where it's flooded. Trying to drive to town for food is a nightmare. Just bear with it, it could be a heck of a lot worse!


Janessa
said

As a Manitoban I find few people who have commmented here are familiar with this area of our province. It is NOT a flood plain area! And never has been.The amount of snow and other weather conditions the past two years has resulted in our current predictament in many areas not being reported. I believe the same freakish occurance happened last year in which a flood wiped out a small town east of Medicine Hat overnight in mid-June.Cdns should focus on the plight of our fellow citizens rather than political opinions. 24-7 Manitobans are living this nighmare.If you can't help phsyically;please donate or positively express your whole hearted support. Soon,forbid; it may be you going through Mother Natures'wrath.


Steve-O
said

Hey...same thing is happening in Louisiana. Cool! Part of the price of living in a flood plain and close to a major river I guess.


JTP
said

This is not to save Winnipeg, this is to save homes downstream of Portage La Prairie.While an optimist might think that this kind of decision making swings an election, it is not going to affect enough people to shake the NDP. You can gaurantee this particular area will not vote NDP, but no one expected that anyways.Hopefully compensation will be a fair shake, and not some unamusing lip service.


Sherri B.
said

Today they finally broke the dike, at least people got 3 extra days to get there dikes up now it's just a waiting game to see what the water really does, not only to people houses, but to the agriculture community in portage and surrounding areas. And the government is saying this could last for a month or so, what a long month this is going to be for so many families in this area. My Parents place is just north of the Hoop and they have been battling high water for the past few months. Water levels here are extremely high, some people in the area their sump pumps haven't stopped since November there is just that much water in the ground and no where for it to go. Going up in this area it affects everyone you know in some way. I went to school with most of the people that have homes in the path and it's just heart breaking that it's someone you have known for so long. I think it was just more of a surprise to everyone. No one knew of these plans, and that's why some are mad. But the community has gotten this far with helping out and we will get through this, Portage is a small city but we have big hearts


George
said

Lets just all pray about this disaster,nothing is stronger than prayer,


Spike
said

This is a classical example of the NDP saving the city homes and not caring about the rural areas.


ch
said

Is that right DD. So the poor people whos homes were destroyed in elie when the F5 came through there had to pay out of their own pockets to rebuild their homes and live. Thankfully they did not.


Class action suit time
said

As soon as the Manitoba government assumed control for the decision over the dykes they built, they also assumed liability for any outcome. The people affected by this should get a lawyer and file a law suit against the government of Manitoba and Premier Greg Selinger. We can quote Star Trek and other schlock new age pseudo philosophies all day but the bottom line is, the government built the dykes, the dykes were the cause of the flooding (by not allowing nature to take it's course) and the government exasperated the problem by allowing such a large volume of water to move to where it had the potential to do great harm. This decision was more political than most people know. Greg Selinger had a political interest in making this decision. To paraphrase Star Trek, the needs of your political base outweigh the needs of a bunch of dirt farmers who didn't vote NDP anyway.


MH
said

kudos to catherine medernach. she is right. it is no one's fault but mother nature's. we were flooded in 97, so my heart goes out to all affected, but you get through it and go on with your life. good luck.


Ontario Friend
said

Love how everyone is suddenly an expert. I'm quite sure that this decision didn't come lightly or on half hearted study. Good Luck to all those that will be flooded out. I hope the Provincial and Federal governments provide the required compensation. (Maybe a little tax levee on the homes that this area is being sacrafised for).


Francine
said

What I want to know is, did the family with horses get them out? How about cattle and pig farms, were there any there? Did they get the animals out? Wow, did Selinger ever open hismelf up for a massive defeat in the next election. Manitoba will be paying out on damage claims for homes, land, livestock, for a long long time.


Peter in MB
said

I don’t know why the cottage owners on twin lakes beach will not be compensated for loosing their cabins. Nearly all of them were built back in the 1960 and 70’s (30 years) before the portage diversion was built. Before the portage diversion some people had to walk a half a KM to get to the beach and water. Now the water is 20 feet from their frount door. They also pay the same amount of municipal tax and school taxes per year as home owners do in St. Laurent, so why should they be treated any different?


jim
said

if the ndp government is so concerned about the flooding, maybe they should get off their butt and help us out with sand bagging, but its just more hotair coming from their mouths.


likethecar
said

I don't think you realize that these homes are not as close to the river as you might think. It is also pasture land and production farming land being affected. Therefore fewer crops means higher prices later. This affects you to, whether you think it does or not. Please understand this is a crisis affecting canada not just the local or individual homes and businesses. If you have the attitude about don't build your house close to a river because it will flood then you better not build in an earthquake zone, or in a forest (because of all the fires in the summer) or in the prairies where severe thunderstorms and tornadoes occur or on the coast where you can be affected by hurricaines and tsunamis. Oh wait we just ruled out all of Canada.


DD
said

Gee ch. I don't know any insurance company that insures against flooding, nor any other "act of god" or war.


kd
said

I have to wonder why anyone would build on a riverbank or anywhere near a river? Canada is a huge country. There is absolutely no reason to ever build a home near a river, and then when it floods, as rivers will, expect the tax-payers to bail them out! If you want to live near a river, make your own plans and cover your own costs when floods happen.


Mort
said

Not tough to figure out who just lost the next election.


Mardee
said

My heart goes out to all involved but one can't blame Harper, the government or anyone for the wrath of nature. Surely, anyone who lives near a river or waterfront, knows the risks that come with it. Just because it hasn't happened in the past doesn't mean it never will. We here on the west coast are well aware of the 'BIG one' that will eventually happen. We take the risk to stay. It's home. What else can be done? They will be compensated, many in Japan won't. Good luck to all.


John Brewer
said

Once again government has made the wrong choice, choosing mansions over food.


catherine medernach
said

It is unfortunate that it was necessary to breach the dike and clearly it was a last resort. This has been a difficult year with both major rivers flooding as well as overland flooding due to the ground being saturated and the amount of water from the south and west. However, making it a political issue makes no sense as the situation would be the same regardless of who is in government. There are times when difficult decisions have to be made regardless of the party in power and this is one of those times.




ch
said

It would be nice if people would know all the facts before making their comments. These people do not live on a floodplain and they do not live on riverfront property.As for some of the comments I've seen about the lawsuit they are considering being silly and unfounded. The only reason they are considering a lawsuit is because now their insurance will not cover their homes being flooded as it is no longer an act of god, but intentional flooding. Insurance companies will not pay for intentional damage, which is what this now is. If they had been flooded out without any intervention they would have insurance. So this is why they expect the government to pay to rebuild their lives, because it is the government that has taken away their insurance and any hopes of rebuilding.


ALS
said

'The owners of damaged homes will be eligible for compensation program beyond that of insurance claims and disaster assistance, said Selinger, covering damages, loss of income and the cost of recovering the land.'


Why in the hell would anyone who is effected by the planned breach of the dyke have to file an insurance claim?
It's bad enough that they have been fed to the wolves to save houses built on a flood plain, but to expect them to have to have to file an insurance claim to cover even one penny of damage is unacceptable!


Jayne
said

I grew up in Wpg my whole life, and saw first hand the effects of the flooding that can happen there. The gov't has done what needed to be done, and reluctantly at that. I don't think anyone who doesn't or hasn't lived there can really get any kind of idea as to the extent of it. In '97 I was 19 and remember the military personnel everywhere sandbagging, it was overwhelming. The whole community banded together to help each other out. Driving down the highways or roads and being surrounded by water on each side-absolutely surreal. Devastating for those who will now be affected. Our thoughts go out to you all.


JP
said

here lies the problem. They flooded out farmers and peoples homes some 5 miles away to save those million dollar homes built on the banks of the river. Hmmm i wonder why, could it be because the Gov is affraid that the rich have the money to afford high priced lawyers and bring a case against the province or flood those folks who just bairly have enough to get by and lets not forget the farmers who are the hardest working class in Canada and they dont get rich but they do make a living which now will be destroyed by the flood. Funny how this world works, save the rich and sacrifice the poor. And this will be a long battle and I dont expect the Gov to come running to the rescue to help the victims. My thoughts and prayers are with the folks of Manitoba .


Marg from Med Hat
said

I am very sorry that this action had to be taken. And I do hope that adequate compensation is give all those afffected by this "act of man". I read where the Army in the US is about to open some spillways along the Mississippi River to divert water from that huge monster away from cities further downstream. So what these poor people in Manitoba are going through, is being experienced elsewhere. As Mr. Spock and Ambassador Sarek would say "the needs of the many, outweigh the needs of the few (or the one)". My thoughts and prayers to all involved.May they "Live Long and Prosper".


oswald
said

this is all the result of some faulty predictor device further west giving incorrect data to our forecasters


Rolf
said

To Dissappointed in Halifax, Harper has already come out to see the flooding first had and promised assitance. The Canadian military is out helping and has been for some time already.


Peter in MB
said

@Dissapointed in Halifax said… “This is really too bad because you know Mr. Harper isn't going to step up and help out either. Manitoba...you're on your own...good luck.” I don’t know where your head has been MR. Dissapointed in Halifax… But Steven Harper was in Manitoba on Wednesday this week and said that the federal government WILL help the province with compensation for people who lose their homes to Flood damage. But I would not expect someone who obviously dose not like Harper and who dose not live in the province where the flood is actually happening to understand or to know what they are talking about.


DRR
said

Biggest event today is the actions of the Provincial government, their willingness to defeat a dike and intentionally flood an area. That is a game changer for the whole Province, if it is a government dike it is no longer a safety net or an assurance to save your property. I am sure all of Manitoba will be see higher insurance rates to cover this flooding uncertainty in all areas of the Province. The Late Duff Roblin is no doubt looking down with disbelief.


Helen Currie
said

I absolutely think the government of Manitoba should buy all those properties at the value they were before the controlled flood. Not to mention the shortage of food that could occur because of the loss of crops. I think there were more to consider than 800 homes elsewhere in Manitoba.


Dustin
said

I'd b ripping off the government to if they tried pulling that on me. That still wouldn't be enough for all the stuff they gotta go through


Disaster Management Engineer
said

As a professional, what I see here is the result of incompetence. Earlier action and planning woudl have make this unneccessary. What is the old expression: "penny wise and pound foolish"? Those chickens are coming home to roost and the lawsuits over this will be long and very expensive.


George
said

Being a transplanted Manitobian I truly understand the effects of the, seemly annual, flooding of my home province. I feel for both the peole and the government. BUT as my father-in-law says, "if you choose to live on a flood plain, be prepared for a flood". I've seen photos of homes that have been protected by building dikes around the buildings. Also when building, build on higher ground, man made if necessary as many have done.
Canadian compassion and caring are an important part of who we are, butagain charity begins at home, take precautions.


Peter in MB
said

Its not just the 150 some homes that will be lost, Manitoba will also lose 100 million dollars in agricultural business this year. Manitoba largest strawberry producer is going to be whipped out along with other farmers who grow vegetables for (Peck of the market). But then again the NDP don’t care because this is a Provencal conservative riding. However their NDP strong hold in Winnipeg will get angry when they have to start paying much higher prices for not as fresh vegetables that are imported from the U.S.


Bernie
said

Whats upsetting about this intentional breech is that it may save some hugh mansion homes built directly on the bank of the river and flood the farmers homes and land located five miles from the same river.


Dissapointed in Halifax
said

This is really too bad because you know Mr. Harper isn't going to step up and help out either. Manitoba...you're on your own...good luck.


Pip
said

This was a difficult decision for the government, but one that had to be made to reduce the impact. Far more difficult was the decision to open spillways from the flooded Mississippi River, whose ". . .opening will release a torrent that could submerge about 3,000 square miles under as much as 25 feet of water in some areas" (CTV report). There was time to get homes protected to some extent in Manitoba; you can't protect against 25ft/8m of water: the house is completely under water.


Randy in NW Ontario
said

To Paul...So you think there should be no problem for those intentionally flooded as long as the government pays to rebuild houses and compensates the owners for all expenses and damages. No problem really???...these peoples lives will be so disrupted should they loose everything. They may have to start from nothing and whether paid for or not, this will be a long difficult, trying and stressful time. It will take many years if ever for these people to rebuild and return to the lives they now have. No problem?...I'm not so sure.


TwoDogGuy
said

Such a horrible time for our Manitoban brothers and sisters...let us know what we can do to help you...we will do what we can, with what we have, were we are.


Rolf
said

These people do not live by the river, thy live out in the country, not riverfront. They are seeing their houses sacrificed to avoid a catastrophic breach of existing dikes which would be a disaster. This is a terrible situation all around, the government has done a good job, people have worked hard to help, the military is joining in. Sometimes it is not enough, driving through Brandon the amount of water is simply stunning, it is scary driving beside the dike.


RICK HEBERT
said

I hope the person that said only 150 homes affected is not the same person that made the 38% mistake in water comming to Portage and area


De Kars
said

Over the past 2 years Manitoba has stopped cutting down the weeds that grow in our ditches. Last year I phoned the Hwy's Department and complained about it not being able to let lying water move and that you couldn't see trying to enter main roads and side roads. I was told that it was budge cut backs and that they will only be cutting some roads once a year. Maybe they should have cut the weeds allowing water to flow...


Nathan
said

Have you ever seen the video of the Waimea River? Look it up, because that is exactly how this dike breach will end up with the erosion. You can quote me on that.


Mark W
said

MikefromQuebec: I think you're talking about Star Trek II: The Wrath of KhanPeople expect too much out of the government. If I chose to live near a giant river in some of the flatest parts of the country which floods every year, some years worse than others, I'd certainly expect I'm probably going to get my feet wet once in a while. Since the government (with your money and mine) is going to be compensating these 'victims' I'd rather it be done to the few than the many.


Paul
said

As long as they were given time to remove personal property, and they government will rebuild all their homes from scratch, and those people will be paid all expenses for leaving their houses, and they are all compensated for land damage and crop losses, there is no problem. But we all know that two things will happen, 1) some of the home owners will try to rip off the governement claiming non-existent losses and 2) The government will balk at paying out the justified claims.


Donald Butler
said

Like many Boomers* I'm not sure (don't have a clue) how big a Hectare is. 225 Sq Kms translated to them leaves me just as puzzled, so I checked my trusty converter app. It tells me 87 sq. miles is an area about 2/3 the size of Montreal or 1/3 as big as Toronto City (not GTA).Or finally, something some of us us boomers recognize 55,599 Acres Our best wishes to those in this area.PS An EF5 Tornado (Elie 2007)and now this.


Robert B
said

Again the NDP are showing their true colors, They have again and again show their disdain for rural Manitoba and its farmers.


Matthew
said

My heart goes out to the familys. However, having been watching this quite a bit over the last few days, my heart goes out to the Government as well. The media continues to hound the people, almost encouraging them to blame someone. Lawsuits? Inquires? I ask the residents living next to a river that has flooded in the past, (maybe not as epic in the last 100 years, but its has before), if THEY considered the possibility and were prepared. Clearly not, as they're blaming the government for mother nature. When it comes to the earth we are so ignorant of ultimately what she is capable of, and when she does get angry, we act surprised. Again my heart goes out to those effected, just not my sympathy for not being ready living next to a swelling river each spring. How can you live NEXT TO A RIVER, and not have on hand a generator, empty sand bags and boards. I mean really people, this is NOT the government fault. Start asking these people hard questions. Why were you not prepared? Why did you not have stuff ready for the 'What if this floods'. My parents live next tot he St. John river. On hand every year, needed or not, Generator, two pumps, and a bunch of empty ready to make sand bags. Its called being a responsible home owner.


so sad by this event
said

Is anybody else concerned that after the government floods, sacrificing the farmland and destroying the homes of Manitobans that something like Monsanto will come in and buy those farms at fire-sale prices? Or should I say flood sale price?


MikefromQuebec
said

I'm not sure how this meshes with Canadian principles. Normally we would sacrifice the rights of the many to protect the rights of the one. In Manitoba the government has done a complete about face and sacrificed a few to save many. I'm so confused. In any case I wish all who are affected a speedy end to the annual disaster.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

Manitoba Floods

Manitoba Floods

Updated: More preparation as officials continue to mull planned breach.

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt appears on CTV's Power Play on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    11 Video(s) 11

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1