Top Stories -   

1

Mint pushed to reconsider Highway of Heroes coin

People wave flags on the McCowan Road overpass on Friday, July 23, 2010 as the motorcade transporting the body of Sapper Brian Collier approaches on the Highway of Heroes. (Bill Doskoch/ctvtoronto.ca) People wave flags on the McCowan Road overpass on Friday, July 23, 2010 as the motorcade transporting the body of Sapper Brian Collier approaches on the Highway of Heroes. (Bill Doskoch/ctvtoronto.ca)
People wave flags on the McCowan Road overpass on Friday, July 23, 2010 as the motorcade transporting the body of Sapper Brian Collier approaches on the Highway of Heroes. (Bill Doskoch/ctvtoronto.ca)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (32) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday Nov. 24, 2010 4:38 PM ET

A movement is underway to convince the Royal Canadian Mint to reconsider a decision not to issue a commemorative coin depicting the Highway of Heroes.

As of Wednesday morning, the local councils for Cobourg, Port Hope, Trent Hills and LaSalle, Ont. had all passed motions supporting the creation of such a coin.

Northumberland MP Rick Norlock also weighed in Wednesday, saying he would be taking up the cause in Ottawa.

The Highway of Heroes is the section of Highway 401 between Trenton and Toronto used to transport soldiers killed in Afghanistan, after they are repatriated to CFB Trenton.

Local residents crowd the overpasses and bridges, carrying flags, signs, and often standing at attention to solemnly honour the fallen as they pass by.

The Mint, in correspondence provided to CTV.ca, initially supported the idea for a coin when it was proposed in February by Pete Fisher, a Cobourg-based photographer and reporter who has covered the military repatriations for years.

"This suggestion is one that we like very much and, in fact, one that received very favourable response when tested with coin consumers," wrote Francie Baltzan, communications co-ordinator for the Mint.

"The Mint is therefore in the process of considering how best to honour this solemn route and those who have travelled it, as well as to underscore the spontaneous outpouring of public support for our fallen heroes."

The email goes on to say the Mint would be in contact with Fisher "as we move through this process."

However, in her next email sent months later in November, in response to a follow up email from Fisher, Baltzan says the Mint has decided against the coin because it's too difficult to fit the concept on a 25-cent piece.

"The sentiment behind this is (sic) theme is an honourable one, but designing a coin that accurately depicts the Highway of Heroes while honouring the sentiment has proven to be difficult," Baltzan wrote.

"I am sorry to pass on this disappointing news, but please know that we are working on several other products, for 2011 and beyond, that honour the Canadian Forces -- past and present -- and their sacrifices."

Municipal councils get on board

Fisher, who was dismayed at the apparent about-face, began approaching local politicians about the situation and asking for help.

It didn't take long for local councils to get on board.

Cobourg Mayor Peter Delanty said his council unanimously passed a motion supporting the idea, and will send a letter to the Mint asking for the decision to be reconsidered.

"I think it's a really honourable thing we do and I'm at my wits end to understand why this would suddenly be stalled and blocked," Delanty told CTV.ca.

"So I gave wholehearted support for it and I just have no understanding why this really laudable thing to do is being blocked somewhere along the line."

He said the Mint seems to have "no hesitation" about honouring musicians and sports teams with special issue coins, but has balked at recognizing a movement by ordinary Canadians to honour fallen soldiers.

Delanty said every bridge between Trenton and Port Hope is packed with firefighters, police officers, and "common ordinary folks, whether it's rain or shine, day or night" when a repatriation takes place.

"I really think it's something worthwhile and I guess I'm concerned that it has been turned down," he said.

Mint downplays earlier comments

Christine Aquino, director of communications for the Mint, played down the correspondence between Fisher and Baltzan.

In an interview with CTV.ca on Wednesday morning she said that while the Mint turned down the suggestion for 2010, it is still under consideration for future pressings.

"We are aware of this coin suggestion and we're inspired by the outpouring of emotion in support of the Highway of Heroes," Aquino said.

"And while we understand the initial dissapointment that the scene suggestion wasn't chosen for this year, it is possible that it could be selected in the future."

The correspondence from Baltzan explained that the coin was turned down because it was too complicated a concept for such a small canvas. But Aquino said the decision was in fact made because another coin concept was chosen for 2010 on the theme of remembrance.

The Mint issued a coin for 2010 depicting a soldier flanked by two poppies, in honour of the 65th anniversary of the end of the Second World War. While the Mint issues several commemorative coins each year, only one is issued on the remembrance theme, she said.

"Perhaps we maybe could have been more definitive in the letter that while it wasn't chosen for this year, because we had something else to commemorate this year, we are looking into it for the future," Aquino said.

Mayor Delanty said he's fed up with explanations and excuses and said its time for the Mint to take action.

"Let's get moving on this and get it done," Delanty said. "It's a small little way we can say say thank you."

Comments are now closed for this story

Charley
said

If the design is to large for a 25 cent peice, then why not a loonie, or a Silver dollar? Surely the Royal Canadian Mint, which has produces some tremendously intricate coins in the past, can come up with a format for such a design. If Olympians, and Provinces are worth commerative coin, surely the highyway of heros is too.


DON
said

Happy you must be a teacher .They are not hero's.Just plain folk.There is a difference.


Justjeff1972
said

A second thought has occurred to me. If the coins from the Mint are not large enough to handle some kind of tribute. Perhaps, the Bank of Canada could commisssion a new, limited run, $1 bill(like what was done for Canada's centennial). The bill would be the same green colour as before, the front depicting the Queen on one side of the bill, and the 401 signpost for the Highway of Heroes on the other. The backside of the bill could have a small-scale map from CFB Trenton to Toronto. Hope someone from the Bank of Canada is reading this one, too. ;)


Westerner
said

Two statement come to mind:1) Lost but not forgotten.2) Service to your Country.The Mint and Government OWES it to the Soldiers that paid the ultimate price - "their lives" to Honour them for what they did - Highway of Heros is an Understatement - those who served and died are Canadian Heros in my eyes. Canada waste money on other things but pays little tribute to those that travelled this route. Pay up Mint - Money over Life - get real!


Caroline McIntosh, Mississauga Ontario
said

(www.petitiononline.com/hhyoh123/petition.html)As author of the petition online asking the Mint to reconsider its position with regards to not printing a coin to commemorate the Highway of Heroes, I can tell you categorically that this was NEVER intended as a coin to be printed only for Remembrance Day.. This idea was presented to the Mint as a means to commemorate the grass roots support shown on the bridges and overpasses of the Highway EVERY TIME a member of our Services is repatriated to Trenton. By Services, I mean whether it is our soldiers fighting overseas OR even the OPP officers, tragically killed in Haiti, who were given repatriation through Trenton and thusly honoured by thousands who stood on the bridges and overpasses to honour them and their families as well. Highway of Heroes has grown into a cultural phenomenon unique to Canada where Service men and women whohave lost their lives in service to Canada are honoured in such a simple yet powerful display of support for both them and their families. We did not ask for a coin for Rememberance Day. For the Mint to attempt to "spin" the requests made as such is clearly an indication that there is some major "backpeddling" going on by those at the Mint. The backlash for the Mint has got them attempting to put forward their version of the truth. Simply put: the request has been made to mint a coin showing the Highway of Heroes and the Canadians, civilian and otherwise, who stand in the cold, rain, snow, wind, hail and sunshine to honour each and every one of the Service men and women & their families. The Mint said, NO. There is no other "spin" that can be put on this story other than the facts.


Mark from Cobourg
said

"Jamie in Kitchener" is invited to come to Cobourg or any of the other bridges during a repatriation to see that this highway is no "false idol".Most of the family members of fallen soldiers who have travelled the HOH with the remains of their loved ones have expressed their heartfelt thanks for the comfort given to them by seeing the outpouring of love and gratitude of complete strangers. Jamie needs to experience the deed of remembrance as we stand to honour the passage of these brave heroes and their families as they pass beneath our feet waving their appreciation.


Phil In Cavan
said

... and then we should have a dinner plate to commemorate the coin, that commemorates the highway, that commemorates the parades that commemorate the heroes ...


Nanook
said

No, we need a Toronto Maple Leafs coin next. Heck, if the 3 cup/100 years Riders can get one??????


Andy-Bob in Ottawa
said

The Jamie's (Kitchener and Ottawa) have got it right, as does the Royal Canadian Mint: how do you get the essence of this on a freaking coin? There are other, better ways to thank and honour our CF members.


JustJeff1972
said

To echo George from Calgary's comments. I do udnerstand the quarter is a small coin, perhaps our $1 coin would be a more acceptable size for some tribute. For instance, instead of the iconic loon on the obverse of the coin, replace it with the Hwy 401 shields(English and French) of the Highway of heroes. Or, on the coin's obverse, have the 401 shield with the poppy, and place 'Highway of Heroes' and 'Autoroute des heroes' on the top and bottom, and place 'Canada' and 'Dollar' on the reverse of the coin. Hope someone at the Mint is reading this. ;)


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

@ V Murphy Regina: What a cheap, trivial, petty, and whiney complaint. So, your "concern" is that the term "hero" has been bastardized (allegedly by the favorite political pinata of ranting left-wingers, George Bush) and we now, effectively, supposedly, heap too much undeserved praise and recognition upon our military-service people? Yeah. Thanks. Feel free to resume reading your latest copy of "Neo-Con Haters Monthly" and brushing up on your pointless ideological issues.


Happy
said

Point taken Pye. How about Policemen, firefighters, loggers, miners, off shore drillers ...


Gilbert in Ottawa
said

Here's an other suggestion, instead of a beaver, sailboat or moose on the backside of our coins, why not the portrait of our fallen soldiers. Already have the Queen on one side, so just put the portrait of a fallen soldier on the opposite side. ...and seems that we need to be specific with the Mint: "so please not on pennies!"


RJ in Halifac
said

I'll leave the debate about the validity of this request to others (even though I strongly support it). My concern here is with the two very different responses from the Mint. The first said it was too difficult to do. Only after a public outcry does the Mint say "no, no, you misunderstood. We already have a 2010 stamping underway but this request will certainly be considered for a future stamping". The Mint must be top heavy with politicians. They make a decision that, in hindsight, hurts their credibility, so they try to change history by "suggesting" they could have perhaps been a little "clearer" in their explanation. Whatever happened to taking responsibility and simply saying "we made a mistake, but we heard you and are taking steps to meet the public's request". Is this asking too much?


Dylan
said

Am I the only one who read this story from beginning to end? The Mint clearly stated its reasons for passing on the coin: the concept of a highway of Heroes and the sentiment behind residents honouring our fallen soldiers is too difficult to illustrate on something the size of a quarter. Perhaps a mural or statue or similar in one of these communities along the highway of Heroes would be a better way to commemorate this act and route.


Steve
said

Everyone else has said what I feel on this idea. Small Canvas, is garbage..Some of our coins have been really detailed. Here is an Ideal just like we do provincial, have a coin for each soldier that has past away. Have a picture of the person face, Highway of Heros written along the rim, as well as the persons name....Just an Idea and im sure the families would appreciate it.


D in SK
said

@happy, I couldn't agree any more with you. Soldiers are PUBLIC SERVANTS with high risk jobs. I appreciate their service to the Canadian public, I support them, I just don't support their mission (yeah, I said it, let the nation eat me alive now). @Prye Chartt, we get it! But like I said, Soldiers are public servants with high risks jobs. Their wages and service are paid by our tax dollars. When they took the job or joined the forces, nobody held a gun to their head. Much like any other public servant; I'm sure they applied for the job.


Lindsay - Pigeon Lake, Ab
said

Awesome to know that CFl players are considered more important than soldiers who fight for our freedom everyday...


George in Calgary
said

My comment is not why or when they should issue a coin but more why it must be a 25 cent piece? Why not a 50 cent piece which is larger or perhaps a special 5-dollar coin? This might just be the push to get rid of the 5 dollar bill and start a coin.As for one commentor stating that our fallen are not heroes: major re-think required on your part!!


MikeInBC
said

I can't believe that Mr. Happy thinks that being in the military and serving in a war is just a job. Maybe he should take a trip to Afghanistan and see what it's all about.


Jamie, Ottawa
said

Did anyone commenting here actually RTFA? They can't figure out how to depict a highway on a small coin. Sounds like a reasonable problem to me.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

@ happy: Your mindless comparison to doctors and teachers ignores that the "job" of being a soldier involves putting one's LIFE on the line for the benefit of all his/her fellow citizens...and that's why we refer to at least the ones who fall in the midst of their most-honorable duty as "HEROES." (Got it? Good.) The medical and teaching professions are important, indeed, but not in the same league of sacrifice. (Got it? Good.) Thanks.


Former 6 year member of the Armed Forces
said

I don't know what all the fuss is about! The mint said they would do a coin once they have got a good design. If you people are concerned about the time frame, instead of b**ching about it, come up with a design that honours own brave soldiers


wheezy
said

I am totally disgusted with the decision not to strike a coin in honour of Canadian soldiers but you can bet your ass that one for William and Kate is probably on the drawing board as I am writing.I never heard of a soldier saying, "I am not going to fight." I want to hear the mint say this will take a bit longer to do rather than we are not doing it.When are we going to stop this nonsense with stamps and coins with only the Royals on them and adorn our monies with only Canadians and things that are dear to us.


V Murphy Regina
said

Who is a 'hero'? G. W, Bush popularized the term 'hero' when referring to those 'victims' of the World Trade Centre attacks. A convenient way of avoiding the real cause of the disaster. Our troops are, for the most loyal, dedicated and brave in the face of fire. Labelling every death as 'heroic' is an overstatement. These are people doing a job - a job with a high degree of risk. A heroic action would be something done 'above and beyond the call of ordinary duty.' It seems we have fallen prey to the need to hype the commonplace - and thus serve the needs of the media that fan the flames of exaggerated expression - and benefit from the same. Vin


Vancouver Girl
said

Re Happy's comment. You can bet if MDs and teachers were being killed, b/c of their profession, in the same numbers they'd have gotten a coin already. Thanks to our military members for putting their life on the line to defend freedom! They ARE heroes!


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Let's first make sure that we "honor" Canadian coffee-and-donut icon Tim Hortons with a special Timbit coin. I'd hate to see our nation lose sight of its respectable priorities. We'll get to our fallen heroes when we can.


happy
said

I think we say thank you to our soldiers every payday with a cheque, benefits and pension contribution all from our tax dollars. They are not heroes. They are men and women who voluntarily chose to become soldiers. It's a job. They knew the risks and benefits before signing up. Are our doctors heroes? They save lives. Are our school teachers heroes? They educate our young. If soldiers are heroes then we can all be considered heroes.


Michael (Ottawa)
said

Bureaucrats just never seem to "get it". There collective heads are up to their eyeballs in this stupid "political correctness" which constipates their ability to think clearly. Its a problem in political circles.


Jamie in Kitchener
said

The support for troops, especially those who have fallen in the name of defending our country and our allies, is no doubt a sensitive issue. However, I must say that I agree with the Mint's comments about the difficulty in capturing the essence of the Highway of Heroes on a coin. I think we're incorrect to make a false idol of the Highway itself, and should perhaps focus on an initiative with the Mint to honour the sacrifice of fallen soldiers - a more fitting tribute in my opinion.


Doug # BC
said

I believe the mint now knows how important this is to Canadians.And I believe they will find a way to get something that properly honours our fallenen military men and women.And in fact, honours our entire military. That said,it may not be anything that has been submitted yet.It's a coin,people. If they try to make it too complicated for the size of the coin, the detail will be lost. It will only be significant to people who already know the story. It needs to be clear and detailed enough to cause anyone who ever handles that coin to take notice. That way, the respect we wish to convey will go on for decades to come. If the coin is not clear enough, the message will end with those of us alive when the war was in progress. It's about the "message". It's not about "art".


PROUD OF OUR SOLDIERS
said

There is no issue with getting a CFL coin for sakratchawan, but a Highway of Heroes coin has a lot of headache involved?Please Canada, Wake Up!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

CTV News

Soldiers with the Canadian Army's 1st Battalion Royal 22nd Regiment return to base on their final operation Thursday, June 30, 2011 in the Panjwaii district of Kandahar province, Afghanistan. (AP Photo/David Goldman)

Canada in Afghanistan

The latest news, photos and interactives from Canada's mission in Afghanistan.

Canadian Soldiers were injured when a Light Armoured Vehicle (LAV) Turret struck an on coming vehicle, outside Kandahar City, causing it to rotate 360 degrees wounding the two Canadian soldiers. (Cpl. Robin Mugridge / Department of National Defence)

Invisible Wounds

Angela Mulholland: Scope of injury toll in Afghanistan largely a mystery

Brain injuries among soldiers are often overlooked.

Blast-Induced Injuries

Brain injuries among soldiers serving in Afghanistan are often overlooked.

Doctor Louis-Philippe Palerme, right, from Gatineau, Quebec, is assisted by a Danish doctor, Captain Sacha Soelbeck, during a surgery at R3 MMU in Afghanistan.

Medical Advances

Soldiers survived injuries that, even 10 years ago, would have been fatal.

Cpl. Chris Klodt sits in a race chair. Klodt was shot in the neck July 7, 2006 during a Taliban ambush outside Kanadhar. The bullet was lodged in his spinal cord.

Soldiers Overcome Injuries

Wounded soldiers use sports to overcome injuries, adjust to their new reality.

Janis Mackey Frayer in Sperwan Ghar, Afghanistan

Kandahar Journal

Janis Mackey Frayer recounts sombre process of notifying next of kin.

Interactive

War Zone Medics

Lessons Learned

A number of the medical innovations that we now take for granted were conceived and tested during wartime.

Bios and Pictures

Casualties

Canadian Casualties

We remember those who lost their lives in Afghanistan since the mission began in 2002.

In Pictures

Canada's Last Days in Afghanistan

Concluding Combat

50 Pictures: Canadian troops conclude Afghan combat tour after a decade.

Kandahar transfer ceremony

Transfer Ceremony

In Pictures: Canada transfers control of Kandahar region to the U.S

Harper in Afghanistan

Harper in Afghanistan

25 Pictures: Stephen Harper meets with soldiers on his fourth Afghan trip.

Canada in Kandahar

Canada in Kandahar

30 Pictures: New tasks tackled as combat mission nears its end.

Operation Topak Shkar

Operation Topak Shkar

Canadian troops take on the Taliban in Operation Topak Shkar.

Today's Top Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012.  (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Charles Taylor gets 50 years for 'brutal' crimes

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Police probe body parts in Ottawa, torso in Montreal

More    Comments    3 Video(s) 3

Supporters of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, hold placards and banners bearing images of him before the verdict was given in his extradition case at the Supreme Court in London, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (AP / Matt Dunham)

Britain's top court backs extradition of WikiLeaks chief

More   4 Comments 4    2 Video(s) 2