Harper will defend Israel 'whatever the cost'

The executive director of UN Watch discusses the anti-Semitism conference. He explains the impact of Prime Minister Stephen Harper's pro-Israeli stance on Canada's international reputation.

CTV News Extended: Prime Minister Harper

Prime Minster Stephen Harper addresses the media and told an anti-Semitism conference in Ottawa that the Tories are undertaking a fight to end anti-Israel rhetoric. He says Canada is morally obligated to stand up to those who attack Israel.

CTV News Extended: Liberal Leader Ignatieff

The federal Liberal leader says the Tories need to stop acting like their failed UN bid was a moral victory. He says if you're not on the council you're not a world contender. He also says the feds need to outline their plans for troops in Afghanistan.

Watch: See all Videos in the Player

A A | Email This Email | Print | Comments (158) Tweet

Prime Minister Stephen Harper pauses as he delivers a speech on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Monday Nov. 8, 2010. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. Nov. 8 2010 6:10 PM ET

Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he is prepared to suffer any political backlash that comes his way for speaking out against anti-Israel rhetoric.

Harper told an audience Monday that while Israel is receptive to fair criticism, Canada is obligated to stand up for its ally when it comes under attack from others.

"Not just because it is the right thing to do, but because history shows us, and the ideology of the anti-Israel mob tell us all too well, that those who threaten the existence of the Jewish people are in the longer term a threat to all of us."

The prime minister acknowledged that his position is not popular with all governments and organizations, including members of the United Nations and the Francophonie.

"And I know, by the way, because I have the bruises to show for it, that whether it is at the United Nations or any other international forum, the easiest thing to do is simply to just get along and go along with this anti-Israel rhetoric, to pretend it is just about being even-handed, and to excuse oneself with the label of honest broker.

"There are, after all, a lot more votes -- a lot more -- in being anti-Israeli than in taking a stand. But as long as I am prime minister, whether it is at the United Nations, the Francophonie or anywhere else, Canada will take that stand, whatever the cost."

The prime minister's use of the phrase "honest broker" is an apparent reference to a recent speech made by Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff.

Ignatieff criticized the Harper government for using Israel as a wedge issue with his political opponents in Canada, at the expense of the country's influence on peace in the Middle East. The Liberal leader called for a return to a time when Canada was perceived to be an honest broker in the global community.

Harper made his remarks at the start of a two-day conference on anti-Semitism that is being held on Parliament Hill during Holocaust Education Week.

After his caucus meeting on Monday, Ignatieff criticized Harper for suggesting that Canada's recent failure to secure a seat on the UN Security Council can be blamed on the federal government's support for Israel.

"They're trying to claim it's a moral victory," Ignatieff told reporters.

"It's a defeat, especially if you want to support the state of Israel. What is the institution that's enforcing sanctions against Iran, which is a strategic threat to Israel? The Security Council. If you're not on it, you're not playing."

Ignatieff also reiterated his party's support of a two-state solution for peace in the Middle East.

"Why? Because we believe it's essential for the security of Israel, and because we think it's essential for the security of the Palestinian people," Ignatieff said.

He also added that "we are not neutral and will never be neutral between terrorist organizations and democratic states. That's been the position of Canada for a very long time, that's the position of the Liberal Party."

Meanwhile, the group Independent Jewish Voices, which is not taking part in the conference, accused the Harper government of trying to suppress debate about Israel.

On CTV's Power Play, spokesperson Diana Ralph said the government is trying to "criminalize criticism of Israel."

"What this conference is actually about isn't anti-Semitism," Ralph said. "What it's about is attacking and limiting dissent and criticism on expressing criticisms of Israel. And the thing is that when Harper says today that Israel is a country under attack, Israel is being attacked for its violations of human rights."

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

chris
said

Worst Prime Minister ever!!

Abiding Citizen
said

Thank you Mr. Prime Minister Stephen Harper. You continue to provide unequivocal, balanced, intelligent, fair and stong leadership. A refreshing change from the non-liberal leadership pains.

Nikki Charles
said

Harper and Ignatieff are phonies, Canada is empowering anti-Semitism within it's own borders. Many immigrating here are compelled by their religious beliefs to be anti-Semitic, and the government is complicit in this.

Moderate Me
said

Pandering to religious people is the only way Mr Harper would ever retain a majority. Pathetic. He even attempts to scare them by claiming a rise in anit-antisemitism which is simply not true. Keep Fear alive Canada!

Sue
said

Mr. Harper does not represent all Canadians. I for one would like his foreign policy to go back to what it was before, neutral. Who is he that he can just change the policy without finding out if he represents Canadians.

John Q Public
said

Disgusting pandering and an assault on democracy.

Criticism of Israel is not anti-Semitic. Full stop.

Canadian tax payer
said

They have been fighting over there for thousands of years they will never stop. So why should Canada and tax payers even get involved!. Seems like they are not happy if there not fighting with someone.

back and to the left
said

My goodness, Steve has sure brought the flock together on this topic. Hard to believe there is so much support for Israel from a right wing group. How times have changed.

mike
said

Generally I don't like Harper - but in this case I agree with the man. It would be nice if all the states there would coexist, but if not, at least Israel should be allowed to exist. I agree Gaza should as well, but only once they stop bombing Israel.

Bob
said

I wonder if Mr. Harper would like France to support Quebec's freedom?Or maybe freedom of native Americans?We have our own problems here, and one day at the north pole....I wonder if Israel will support our claim or the USA's?

viral venus
said

Neither Canada as a nation nor any of her leaders has EVER been "pro-terrorist" or "anti-Israel" no matter what the PM's media frenzy generators might say. As a democratic nation Canada should not give an "anything goes" free pass to another democratic nation simply because the terrorist enemies they fight take that approach in the conflict. It is not "anti-Israel" to ask that they use reasonable care and restraint when dealing with civilians caught in the conflict and to be willing to answer some questions for the international community if something goes wrong. How you conduct yourself in a conflict, especially regarding civilians, is the beacon that separates a legitimate government and legitimate military action from the terrorist assaults they are defending themselves against. This is what being an "honest broker" and "even handed" means and I would like to see Canada return to this approach in the middle east.

Raymond
said

A refreshing change from the days when self-indulgent Liberal MP's were marching down the street waving Hezbolla flags and stomping on GWB dolls.

Al
said

This is exactly what is wrong with this government. Harper must go!

Israeli Canadian Conservative
said

Scotty, there is a lot more to being a democracy than simply holding elections. democracy is a way of life which includes many aspects such as freedom of speech, religion, sexual orientation, just to name a few. In gaza, palestinians are given the right to none of the above. In Israel, you do. that's why you have hundred of homosexual palestinians roaming around tel aviv enjoying their freedom. that's why you have palestinians in israeli schools, benefiting from the israeli education system. that's why you have palestinians members of knesset IN THE ISRAELI GOVERNMENT representing palestinian interests in israel. Israel has already done more for the palestinian people than any other arab state. that is why Palestinians hold israeli passports, which they are not given in syria and lebanon. I could go on and on. Thank you Mister Harper for doing what's right

Kingmin
said

PM should only stand for Canadians because they vote for him. Priority, we all should focus on our Home at the time.

s
said

I am proud to be a Canadian!! Thank you for taking a bold stand Prime Minister Harper. You have my respect, admiration, and my vote!! Wise words from a wise leader who knows how to take a stand for what is RIGHT!! God Bless CANADA!

Tim
said

I agree let's stand up for the only real democracy in the Middle East instead of supporting terrorist groups like Hamas who want nothing more than Israel's destruction. Until Hamas changes that official policy, which they readily admit, only anti-Israeli's and anti-Americans support Hamas.

shloime
said

some of us still remember mr ignatieff's contribution to peace in the middle east, when he declared, from the safety of a bomb shelter in israel, that israel was committing war crimes in lebanon, the facts notwithstanding... i'm sure he had some evidence for this other than hezbollah propaganda pieces on cnn or al-jazeera. didn't he?so his comments about canada's role as an "honest broker" might ring just a teeny, weeny bit self-serving, eh?

Jake
said

No government can serve two masters. A government that serves a foreign power cannot serve the Canadian people.

shloime
said

"Scotty" said: "Israel is the only democracy in the middle east. Really? What about the democratically elected palestinian government, Hamas?" funnily enough, the arabs of the west bank also do not recognize the legitimacy of the hamas government, nor of the brutal and murderous way in which they took power and eliminated thousands of fatah members in gaza. but "democracy" in the west bank and gaza, is "of the terrorists, by the terrorists, and for the terrorists", in which only card-carrying members of terrorist groups can run, so i guess you approve of that kind of politics.i would suggest that you go and live in gaza for a while before speaking up so loudly for that sort of "democracy". and if you don't have the stomach for islamist rule, try living in an israeli town near the gaza border, where you can still enjoy a few of the more than 10,000 qassam rockets which are still being fired from gaza at israeli civilians, almost every day.

Paul ~ Kitchener
said

Mr. Prime Minister ~ Your right again ! Keep mov- ing forward, and don't take any note from the coalition partnership, across the house from you and the governement.You have lead Canada to the financial strength we have over the G-7 / G-20 - (no Liberal has ever matched this or come close).You have lifted our military to a place of excellence, & continue to support our troops 150% - (Liberals for 16 years tore them down).You Mr. Prime Minister, have encouraged our Justice Minister to get tough on revising laws to protect the innocent - (Liberals made laws to protect the criminals). Next year 2011 will be the "YEAR OF MAJORITY" for a stronger positive greater Canada under your leadership & Team.

Proud Canadian
said

Thankyou!

Doug
said

If only Prime Minister Harper had as much concern for Canadians as he does for Israel, one could support his stance.

The IDF bombed and killed 8 Canadians in the invasion of southern Lebanon. No response from Harper or his government.

Then the IDF used a laser-guided bomb to destroy a UN base killing - murdering - a Canadian soldier and 3 others. Not a word from Prime Minister Harper or his government.

If Canadian soldiers cannot rely on their government for protection, then the rest of us are doomed.

Bill Steedman
said

Anyone who has spent time in Israel can state assuredly that arab states that want peace with Israel can have it tomorrow. Those Arab states that negotiate with Israel, Egypt and Jordan come to mind, receive cooperation from the Israeli government. Terrorist organizations such as Hamas have realized that they cannot defeat Israel militarily, so have turned their efforts toward winning the propaganda war. With the assistance of the radical left, notably in universities, they seek to portray Israel as a villain. It's a classic case of blaming the victim for the crime.

Canadian
said

Harper will defend Israel - from who? Who are Israels enemies and why does she have them? What did Israel do to have enemies and why is this Canada's problem?

shloime
said

it is clear that the arab countries do not take kindly to prime minister harper's support for israel, and they voted that way. they have an unjustifiably large number of votes at the un, but that's no reason to let them dictate canada's foreign policy.but what about barack hussein obama? since when has the united states turned against canada? and in the midst of obama's trip to india, we hear that obama supported india's seat on the security council. but not canada's? why isn't the minister of foreign affairs giving indignant interviews on american and canadian television?was this about canada's support for israel, or about obama's unseemly hurry to push israel (and canada) under the bus, in order to appease the arabs? has anyone asked the "leader of the free world" what he has received in return for all his kow-towing? al-qaeda hasn't stopped blowing up americans or stopped inciting the faithful to jihad. two years into his mandate, and it's safe to say that his middle east policy hasn't been a brilliant success that we need to emulate.but it is refreshingly different to see the liberals, and not the tories for a change, lining up to kiss american behinds on a question of canadian foreign policy.

Paolo Marconi
said

Mr. Harper ignores what the rest of the world knows all too well, is that criticizing the policies of Israel does equate with anti-semitism. Israel is the only state founded by the UN which he decries, a state which its original people were kicked out, and remain the only occuppied people on the face of the earth thanks to the likes of Harper, Balir, and Bush. A great company to be with

Allan K, Vancouver, BC
said

A lot of pro-Israeli people have seemed to just jump to all sorts of random extreme hypothetical conclusions about the treatment of Israel vs the Arab world. For one, most Palestinians, if you ever meet them, will probably not be the radical fundamentalists that you fear. (Disclaimer, this is from an observer that has and will never enter the Middle East.) In fact, far from it... from pictures on BBC and elsewhere most are just trying to eke out a living in the room that they are given... and most are failing because Israel has put in so many restrictions. Second, it's true that both Palestinian insurgency groups and the Israelis government have committed grave human rights abuses... and yes BOTH have done so. Some may deny one side of the story or the other, but that's just hypocritical and distorting the documented historical evidence. Thirdly, yes, there are horrible governments elsewhere that probably should receive more focus and attention, but like any other democratic country Israel should still be able to withstand any mention of criticism about its human rights records with good solid proof, and so far it's been more rhetoric and accusations of anti-semitism than proof. Same story applies to Arab insurgency groups. Four, it is one thing to be aggressive in defending oneself against attack (which I do not mind)... and another thing completely to mistreat a whole segment of the population simply because you suspect them to have anti-Israelis sentiments (which is inexcusable and should be stopped). For these reasons I am quite reserved about adopting any position in the Middle East other than one that advocates for peace, moderation, and conciliation... something that unfortunately is really hard to find with the current far-right Israel government and the far-right Arab militant groups.

TerryR Lethbridge
said

Good job Sir. Thank you for taking a stand and not letting the rest of the world bully Canada's decisions and commitments. We are Canadian and not lap dogs begging for bloody biscuits.

John F
said

We as a nation should be less focused on being "pro-isreal" and become focused on being "pro-peace". A nation such as Isreal cannot be described as a democratic nation when they continually subject Palestinians to the third world conditions in which many Arabs in Isreal find themselves. I am not anti-semetic, I am anti-oppresion.

Jim (Udo)Montreal
said

As a born German, we came to Canada when I was 4 years old and my whole life I received the horrors that the German military at the time inflicted on the Jewish religion. I strongly support the Jewish people and feel that the Politians in Germany at the time were idiots, and if they knew that they should support the Jewish population and the persicution they have endured over the centuries, they would not have the deserved bad history the Germans have.Canada is the best Country in the world! Period. Good on you Harper!

T
said

Ask yourself or look it up; How many countries in the middle east that are Arab?. How many countries in the middle east are Jewish?. Before you make a comment, read their stories and policies . If you can't... here is just one point you may be familiar with. All the Arab countries want Israel wiped out of the face of the earth, but Israel has never said anything such. IMAGINE AMERICA AND RUSSIA BULLYING CANADA NOT TO EXIST BECAUSE WE ARE ALL IMMIGRANTS FROM DIFFERENT PLACES AROUND THE WORLD?... Harper, history will tell you make the right STAND. People, you know what makes a great leader?; Taking a stand and standing by it eve if its not popular. Am sure, nobody will say they have experienced any Israelis been a suicide bomber or been arrested for a terrorism issue around here. You be the Judge.

RP London
said

I am not anti semitic but I do not agree with us defending Israel "at all costs" and certainly not in all cases. As for the Arab nations having many homelands comment made by another, this does not give Israel the right to extend their territory and justify it in the name of defense. All sides in the "conflict" need to work this out and we can not blindly defend any actions that either Israel or others may take.

Ambientone
said

I hope Harper will not only pledge our unconditional allegiance to Israel but also our troops to Israels up-coming war with Iran.

Steve in wildrose country
said

Thank you Mr Harper!

[X] Harper
said

Thank you Harper.

Mark Lemoine
said

Haper's statement will not improve peace and love on earth but rather continue to divide people.Shame on him for brining Canada further into this mess. I support Jews, or any religious people for that matter, but I do not support the nation of Israel. Israel is a violent country with stubborn and dangerous leaders. Israel has not been a good world citizen. It creates just as much trouble as it receives. Canada should stay far away from the situation as possible except for helping out with peace talks and peacekeeping.

David Strauss
said

Thank you Prime Minister,

I respect you not only as a great Canadian leader, but also as a man who has profound knowledge of the true situation in the Middle East. As a Jewish liberal I believe that friendship AND international trade with Arab countries are paramount. However, the fight against international terrorism must continue until won. My enemies are not Arabs, Palestinians or Iranians, my enemies are primarily Al Quaida,
Hezbollah, and Hamas, and related garbage.

Shoe
said

ONLY reason Harper is doing this is to appease his best buddy down south. Harper has ruined Canada, and continues to do so! When can we vote this guy out!!!And by the way Adam, Canada did NOT vote Harper. He barely squeaked in...

VAHID
said

I believe our PM is making a mistake by confusing antisemitism over the criticism of the government of Israel. Israel has the right of existence . However, every government must be accountable. The present government of Israel is violating the international laws by colonizing in East Jerusalem. That is the biggest hurdle for Barack Obama's middle east peace process. Harper government has never ever condemned it. That will hurt Canada in international scenes.

Kevin in T.O.
said

I agree with Mr Harper's stance with respect to Israel. Of course the pro-Arab liberals and socialists will tar Mr Harper with the usual "he's a right wing pro Israel religious zealot" because of this policy but its nothing but inaaccurate stale rhetoric. Instead of being the neutral observer with zero backbone, Canada is asserting itself on the world stage as a power broker. Reminds me of the days when Mulroney was PM and Canada had international influence.

NS
said

A life in uniform has given me some insight. True Leaders must be able to make a stand, always capable of making decisions, being fluid when neccesary, and solid when needed.

2_Swedish_CIA_bimbos
said

The article avoids elaborating just who this conference IS:

Canadian Parliamentary Coalition to Combat Anti-Semitism,

...an NON-official conference tricked-out in quasi-official terminology, and which denies voice even to Jewish groups and interests critical of Israel.

I can see the day when Harper and Ignatieff are so mind-controlled they will regard any criticism of such Likud-aligned frauds as the CPCCAS as 'anti-semitism', and rob the latter of any real meaning at all.

Ambientone
said

Israel has a long and sordid list of documented crimes against its Arab civilian population. It is in violation of more UN Security Council resolutions than any other country in the world. It operates a clandestine nuclear weapons program in violation of the IAEA treaties, yet is the first to cry out whenever there is even a hint of such actions by another country.There is a strong attempt to quash any criticism of Israels actions by equating this legitimate criticism of zionism and Israel with the boogyman of 'anti-semitism'. Canada 'bias' towards Israeli policies, while ignoring their crimes will not do us any benefit. Harper is leading us down a path that will only spread ill-will against Canada.

rachel
said

The part about fair critism is important. I applaude Harper's stand!

thetruth1028
said

I understand it is ok to support Israel...but I'm not sure how such a statement is productive for brokering peace in the middle east. Palestinians are just going to feel even more slighted by Canada. We should probably support Palestinians (just not the extremists) as well for they have a right to exist as well. Both sides are guitly of some pretty despicable acts in this never ending conflict. Statements like this won't hel either.

John in Calgary
said

Wow! last week Harper fails to get us a UN seat. Terrible because according to some we must be that nation of influence on the world stage. Today shame on Harper for looking abroad and taking a stand. The excuses here are "he's not the PM of Israel". Well last week he wasn't a world leader, only the leader of Canada. You liberals want it both ways. I think it's referred to as seeking that which your itching ears desire. Well done Mr. Prime Minister. Let the record show we are Israels friend and supporter. The Libs just don't get it, that the Arabs do not want an Israel of any description to exist on this planet.

Sid in MTL
said

I am anything but a Harper fan, however kudos to him on this issue!I am certainly glad and perhaps a bit surprised to see he has a pair...I hope he uses them more often.

EDDIE ZAFIR
said

thank-you mr.prime-minister for standing up and defending our only free and democratic ally in the middle east, the state of israel.the only country in the middle east where you can voice your opinion,without the fear of being arrested and thrown in jail,as we see happening on a daily basis in iran,saudi-arabia etc;i salute you for taking these heroic stands,even though canada is only one of the few countries in the world today,to have the guts to call it,as it really is

haitham
said

No reasonable person is against human rights and defending people of all backgrounds

thus when israeli actions lead to starvation, desperation and worse among palestinians (ie the recent news items about the gaza blockade) it is only right to discuss and criticize israel for it.

it is blind rhetoric to say that criticizing israel in such situations is wrong or maybe give strength to arabs

to solve the middle east problems a fair and equitable solution must be reached. no one is going anywhere not the arabs and not the israelis

the right thing for harper is to actually try to get both sides to resolve their problems and not leave it to the extremists (whether muslim or christian or jewish) who believe that pushing the situation to the max will bring armageddon and judgment day (if you talk to them that is what they want)

Nice
said

Great to see some backbone... as opposed to Iggy's robber flip flop style. We know where Harper stands, no doubt. Iggy... we do not know where he considers home, or where he stands on a issue from one day to the next. Now fix the vet's pensions!

Ann Ballinger - Prince George
said

to Stephen Harper: Thank you. Right from the moment they became a nation Israel has been under attack. Yes they have made mistakes in judgement - as all nations do- but they have always tried to be honest and do the right thing. They deserve our support

John Savard
said

Does history really teach us that those who threaten Israel are, in the longer run, a threat to all of us?

I think it's all too easy to make fun of Harper's point the way Harper made it. While radical Muslims have shown some interest in retaking Andalusia, as far as anyone knows they're not trying to annex the Sudetenland or invade Poland.

But more recent history, like the events of September 11, 2001, does bear out his words.

shawbrooke
said

And none of the rest of us should put up with anti-Semitic rhetoric either, whether or not some incident that no one can verify is included in the talk. Concerning facts, get them all. Israel is not responsible for the fact that many Palestinians fled Israel decades ago due to rumor and gossip, Palestinians who stayed in Israel did pretty well. Actual issues, yes. The Israelis should not be cutting people off from their fields with the wall or razing houses without compensation. Let's make that loud and clear, too.

maggy0000
said

I am so proud of PM Harper, good stand Canada.

Jennifer
said

It sounds like Israel has 'gotten to Harper'. I have no idea what occurs after these 'state visits' between PM's, Presidents, etc. and Mr. Netanyahu, but our fearless leaders come out looking grey and shaken. It is then followed up with extremely nauseating support for Israels continued crimes and threats to shut down any comdemnation of the same. Being a citizen of both the US and Canada I am equally discouraged by this treason of OUR fawning representatives who bow and bend to Israel against the wishes of their own citizens. Uraguay may be my next residence if the veiled threats to terrorise Canadians who oppose Israels crimes continues. I will not be threatened and will never support terrorism in any form!

George the Canadian
said

Mr.PM, now I can say that Canada is on the right path. Go ahead!

bwarsin
said

I think it was Winston Churchill who once said: "The best argument against democracy is to spend five minutes reading the comments of rightwing commentators."

Vic Rahal, Medicine Hat, Alberta
said

Years ago when S. Africa was running an apartheid regime, Canada was prominent in joining scores of nations who did not support its human rights violations yet for some reason Canada supports the same type of regime? If Canada wants to be a leader of human rights, our government needs to be more objective before it gives her unconditional support to any nation and it's policies.

Jim Howard
said

PM Harper is taking the appropriate stand on a theoretical level.However, it is reasonable to ask: What is "Rhetoric" and What is fair "Criticism?"While none (at least very few) of us, condone the remarks of Ahmadinejad, Assad or a number of Hamas and Hezbollah representatives, it seems clear that Israel, is not providing a clear path to peaceful co-existence in the region.I am not naive enough to believe rogue arab groups would simply go away if Palestine is properly defined as a sovereign nation. But, Israel has a responsibility to fully and thoughtfully engage all other countries in the region to develop meaningful cultural/economic/social relationships with its geographic neighbours. It has failed to do so and it has failed to gain full support from traditional allies internationally because of what appears to be an obstructionist and bullying style of negotiation.

Alexandria
said

Thank You Prime Minister Harper.You are a true Gentleman and a proponent of fair play and doing what is right. Thanks again.

Mike
said

That's right Harper...support the country with the most UN violations not to mention war crimes. Canada needs to go back being a neutral country. The support for Israel is an insult and nothing more not to mention making citizen prime targets in the future.Wake up people!

KC-Bby
said

Political suicide and hypocritical. Canada does not recognize Jersusalem as an Israeli territory anyway so there is a wee bit of hyprocrisy in his stance. On one hand he refuses to recognize it and on the other he says they are his best pals. Yeah.

Jettle
said

Supporting Israel is an accepted policy in the West. Supporting Israel at any cost is not. Israel does on occasion do terrible things and should be held accountable, as should any country.

Jamie D
said

@Doug in BC:Get a grip. The UN created Israel. Now in your little speech, you say they are irrelevant, and that getting a seat on the security council isn't in the interests of Canada? With Canada having a seat on the council we can actually form foreign policy with other countries to deal with Anti-Semitism. But instead, the PM thought that by acting american he will get votes. So how is Israel going to be helped by Canada showing unwavering support for them? We can't give them money, as we don't have any. Are we going to enter into a free trade agreement? Nope, they have no natural resources, and really they only deal in electronics, and diamond polishing. Wow. Burma's freedom movements are the people we should be battling and sticking up for. Not Israel who has a military that can probably kick Canada's military's butt. And Burma actually has a natural resource in Oil that we can go into trade agreement with them. No we have to go to Israel, and prop it up for some reason. BTW: Do you have a timeline expected for when Israel will stand on it's own without subsidies from the US? It's been more than a few decades you know. Isn't it time that they get it right?

Surrounded by Terrorists
said

Israel's 60 modern day history is one of having to constantly and daily defend herself from the radical nations that surround her. With Iran leading the charge, such countries would like nothing more than to see Israel and the Jewish people wiped off the face of the earth. It's impossible to negotiate a peace settlement with nations that hold to such ideology, hence the never-ending saga of Middle East peace talks. Bravo to PM Harper for having the integrity and backbone to stand up for Israel at a time when madmen like Ahmadinejad are denying the Holocaust and seeking to destroy the only democracy in the Middle East.

Joe
said

It's as if Harper is mimicking everything the U.S is doing... "SANCTIONS AGAINST NORTH KOREA","SANCTIONS AGAINST IRAN".."PRO ISRAEL"."PRO SOUTH KOREA".. Why is Harper tapping into the interested of the United States... What is it that Israel has that Canada can Benefit?... The U.S. supplies Israel with the lastest weaponary to kill innocent people, to take away their culture, there land to feed from the Oil... Wouldn't it be more beneficial to become more involved with trying to build peace and to really open the doors to reality about the problems that are being faced in the middle east and elsewhere? By supporting one side and ignoring another there is no doubt that you are going to build enemies.. But again Harper proves that he doesn't know what the ideology of a democracy is all about..

Lina in Cambridge,Ontario
said

@ Pip,You are your ilk are frighteningly effective at exploiting the ignorance and intellectually laziness of Canadians and Americans.
1. No Jewish state was ever created by the UN.
2. Resolution 181 refers to the Partition of PALESTINE.
3. The UN General Assembly has no power to effect change of any kind, it merely offers suggestions as a form of polticial dimplomacy.

No Jewish state was ever created or sanctioned by the UN. I refer you to another UN General Assembly resolution Resolution 3379 declaring "Zionism is Racisim". You pro-Israeli shills are adept at using the UN as means of legitimacy when you can distort the facts but, when resolutions are passed against war crimes and human rights violations AGAINST Israel, suddenly the UN is an anti-Semitic organization.

Jamie D
said

I live in the the land of free speech. I don't like Israel because the country totally sucks. It's too hot, it has no natural resources, and it seems to not get along with ANY of its neighbors EVER. So to travel to the place is dangerous. If it wasn't for the U.S. in giving over 40Billion in $$$ every year as well as military equipment then it probably wouldn't even exist. So basically Israel exists by force fueled/Armed by the US, and not by right. Is this the message to Canadians that the PM is sending? He is giving his unwavering support for a puppet country of the US? Finally, How is it my taxes paid for the PM to go and represent canada by saying this? I have asked around the office today, and folks are confused how this is representing Canada. Is this his own agenda? Is the trip costs coming out of his own pocket?

VAHID
said

I believe our PM is making mistake by confusing antisemitism over the criticism of the government of Israel. Those are two different terms which have nothing to do with each other. Israel has the right of existence . However, every government must be accountable. The present government of Israel is violating the international laws by colonizing in East Jerusalem. That is the biggest hurdle for Barack Obama's middle east peace process. Harper government has never ever condemned it and that hurts Canada internationally.

AP From Vancouver
said

So we are now nearly unequivocally supporting the existence of and continued crimes commited by a country stolen from its citizens through terrorism, wonderful. Certainly it is a fact that since Israel now exists its citizens have a right to exist peacefully in the land they've already taken but to continue to expand its settlements into land that is not theirs is a crime and one which should be punished more than it has been by the international community. I have yet to hear an argument in favour of the founding of Israel which could not be applied equally well to the creation of a proper palestinian state in some fraction of the land that was entirely theirs only a few decades ago.

francios
said

Canada is going downhill with such a policy! Support your allies when they are doing right, and criticize when they are doing wrong. And over the last sixty years Israel has been doing wrong!

Sylvain Assouline
said

Harper is a very honest who want the best for Canada contrary to all previous liberal heads of state. Ignatieff is a loss to attack Harper and to claim that liberals were honest brokers at the UN you cannot find a worse liar than him. Canada under the Liberals sucked up to the Arab bloc at the UN for... peanuts. God forbids Liberal are back in Ottawa. We will see again the Can $ at 40% to the US $. A disaster in the coming.

Inga
said

Thank You Prime Minister Harper.

Susan
said

BRAVO HARPER!The majority of people do not know the truth about Hamas, Hezbollah and the Palestinian Authority. Lies, propagandas and set-up media events under the guise of Israeli evildoers.Most people think the Israelis kicked the refugees out while it is quite the opposite that happened. It is the Arabs themselves that are responsible for the refugees' situation.Harper knows.Harper knows that it is Hamas itself that is refusing the so-called 'refugees' to leave the camps. He also knows it is Hamas that is paying its own people not to work. He knows about Hamas persecuting Christians in Palestine and more and more...My trust in is Harper. Forget Ignatieff that seems capable of being bought in exchange for votes.As for those who don't, take the time to google.

MarkinTO
said

Good on Harper

Vincent
said

Stevie isn't stupid. There will be no backlash. He knows that his war chest will swell considerably with this move. It works in the U.S. where Jewish special interest groups play a big role in deciding who gets elected with their huge cash contributions. Heather Reisman and Jerry Schwartz were Liberals since the 60's, but when Harper came to power, they put their support behind the Conservatives. Why? Because he started parroting the U.S. line towards Israel. It's a good thing he wasn't in power in 2001 or we'd be in Iraq.

Tom
said

Well done to the PM. Our national pociies are not set in Iran or any other state. Our policies are set here in Canada and one our our fundamental positions is to support the right of Isreal and her citizens to exist.

Charles
said

Mr.Harper should go and live in the Gaza ghetto for a few months.

Donna K
said

Mr Harper
Thank You,Thank You,Thank You for taking a stand on such an important issue. Israel is our ally and as such needs to know where we stand. I thank you, Israel thanks you, but most importantly God Thanks you. This is a biblical issue and God sees. For those of you who don't know this or even give a rip, read your Bible. Dk

CWhirl
said

Ya Hoo Prime Minister Stephen Harper We Will Back You All The Way!

Derek G
said

Harper has destroyed Canada's reputation, he definitely has to go, he could have said this in so many other ways...

DON
said

He has not got a clue on what's going on around him.Keep your nose out of it HARPER.

Tyson
said

This isn't about Canada being Pro-Israeli or Anti-Arab, what it comes down to is: does or doesn't Canada support international law? Well the law is very clear on this issue- all the settlements are illegal, including the security wall that's built within the West Bank. "anti Israel rhetoric"? The U.S. has blocked 32 resolutions condemning Israel of war crimes in the occupied territories, and has blocked a two state solution that is voted on every year in the U.N. that has received overwhelming support from the entire international community including Europe, not just "Islamic states".I'd like to debunk the myth that the U.N. is controlled by a bunch of fanatical Islamic states, that's just simply not true- look it up. It's not a matter of being anti-Israel, anti-Jewish, or even anti-zionist, it's about the Palestinians that have been under a brutal military occupation by the IDF for over 40 years now, their land is stolen and they are denied any political rights. Enough with the bullsh*t. Look up B'Tselem the Israeli Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, or Gush Shalom, or Ilan Pappe, or Gideon Levy, these are ISRAELI activists that oppose the occupation, and they are labeled self-hating Jews by right wing war mongers just like Harper. It has nothing to do with anti-Semitic. It really comes down to basic questions of human rights. Do you support house demolitions, the appropriation of land, ethnic cleansing... ect. There are moderates in Israel that will be the first to tell you that this has nothing to do with Judaism.

Tina Marshall
said

Mr. Harper is doing what is right. I'm so pleased that Canada has a good man leading our country.

Norm_D
said

I can't believe some of the comments such as Canada elected Harper. We did not. Canada does not elect its Prime Ministers we only vote for riding representatives thus the political parties and Harper is only the leader of the party who received the most delegates. In fact more Canadians voted against his party in a 2 to 1 ratio against and the world knows that. In fact he only represents the constituents of his home riding nothing else. His party can turf him out without a national election any time they want.

Citizen
said

Listen to what Harper says " a country that is consistently singled out for moral condemnation", he is not giving Israel a free pass, but he is pointing out that the UN and the middle east dictators ignor human rights violations in other countries and focus only on Israel. And Canada should take a stand and say, wait a minute what about the stoning of women in Saudi Arabia, what about forced indoctrination of youth, what about genocide in Sudan. All occurring in countries that constantly shift the spotlight to Israel.

GUTSHOT!! in Thunder Bay
said

I think some people need to understand that you cannot have anti-semitism without first having semitism. You cannot have anti-zionism without there first being zionism. When these people cease to identify themselves by race, agenda, and in this case a nation, only then can there be a chance at peace... and that goes for all groups who identify themselves like this.

Welland Boy
said

Quite admirable of Mr. Harper. He will defend Israel. However, as reported, he will do so at any cost. My concern is that he will defend Israel even when the Israeli government is wrong, when the Israeli government oversteps its bounds, when the Israelis treat the Palestinians poorly by doing such things as building on Palestinian lands. Let us, as Canadians, be fair and all, defend the victims in crimes committed against them whether they be Israelis or Palestinians. Heaven knows, the Israelis have suffered but let us not forget that the Palestinians have suffered also, many say as much.

tom
said

It's pretty obvious who Harper is trying to impress with this little bit of rhetoric.Keep schmoozing old boy, you're more like an American every time you open your mouth, hail the almighty dollar. Sticking up for Israel in the 1940's was a worthy, noble thing to do. Adding your narrow world viewpoint in defense of what Israel has become today, not so much. There are more then just that one side to contend with and I personally think Harper shouldn't be speaking for all Canadians in a world forum on this subject for a number of reasons. The first and foremost being, Israel can defend itself, and has been very proactive in doing so. In my opinion, to the point of subjugating another race of people to the very same totalitarian state the Nazis imposed on them in the first place. No one can criticize Israel, if you do you're an anti-Semite, if you're Jewish and you criticize your own people then you're a "self-loathing jew."

Anderson
said

Any conversation about the region is now dominated by a string of propaganda myths, and perhaps the most basic is the belief that Israel is a democracy. Today we have three kinds of people living under Israeli rule. We have Jewish Israelis, who have full democracy and have full civil rights. We have the Israeli Arabs, who have Israeli citizenship but are severely discriminated against. And we have the Palestinians in the Occupied Territories, who live without any civil rights, and without any human rights. Is that a democracy?Israel has long claimed to be the “only democracy in the Middle East.” But for the 1.5 million Palestinians who make up 20 per cent of Israel’s population, it is another story altogether. The facts show that Israel is very much a segregated, apartheid state.

Inversity
said

Why go backwards, towards "nationalism", when we are moving forwards towards the global community, where everyone, regardless of race, nation, colour, religion, or ethnicity are treated as human beings, and defended as one human community? Harper just is like an anchor, dragging Canada back into another fight over nationalism, instead of embracing every human being as part of the global community, without singling out any person or group on some "ethnic", "religious", or "national" basis. Canada should be at the forefront of defending all groups, no matter where (on a human rights scale) they are placed, by destiny. We all have a right to exist, not just one country...

Brian Fr Langley
said

I just love it when a politician actually allows principals to trump politics. Prime Minister Harper you do us proud.

Dan in Quebec
said

Wait a minute...this is backwards! I do not agree with this backing of the US foreign policy.Israel has committed war crimes, does not recognize the international war crimes tribunal, ignores UN orders. Is Canada looking for new enemies? What the heck is going on here. Time for an election!!!!!

Kanadian
said

People are not stupid.... Harper can call himself "honest broker" or whatever, but as long as word "occupation " is attached to Israel (and no matter how hard you try to get rid of it from the context of this dispute), Israel will always elude peace.

Citizen
said

I appreciate the more moderate comments from some who feel the PM's stance is to strong for Israel. I tend to feel Israel has committed some very serious violations of International law, however, when they face governments and organizations who sole goal is to wipe them off the map it tends to radicalize the population in its own defense. No Canadian can understand this kind of constant fear (myself included) because we don't live with that reality. I applaud the Prime Minister for sticking with Israel, they are our ally and we should stand with our allies. We should also use that position of trust to press Israel towards a more moderate approach to their neighbors and I believe the PM has. The US stands by Israel yet uses that position to push for a permanent peace deal with Palestine. And yes, it has cost the Prime Minister, but frankly it is better to be a leader who stands by his convictions than one who caves just to advance themselves.

Linda in Vancouver
said

People who suggest the PM's position on Israel cost Canada a seat at the UN should alos know that Canada received a glowing tribute in the editorial section of the New York times.We were congratulated for having the courage to take a firm stand on a contriversial issue.Now I'm not sure about the position as it realstes to the middle east.That is an area of the wolrd that cries out for a solution that no one seems to be able to come up with. But the reality is,Canada is getting more good press in the USA,and on the BBC than we have ever had in my lifetime.PM Harper does come with some warts.But please name me a PM in either this century,or the last one,who did not. Populism is not the objective of people who really lead.Good government is,and must remain the ultimate goal.If that means standing firm,and saying so,then so be it.You cannot make good choices if your only objetive is to be popular. To the poster who said he "hates" Harper,you have my sympathy.Please get help for your anger issues.Either that,or grow up.Hate never solved anything.I could suggest the same to the poster who claims Israel is the aggressor in this conflict.It's a muudy area,but I see no way that any leader can sit idly by and allow bombs to be hurled at it's citizens.The first obligation of any government is to defend the nation and the people who live there.That is likely the only constant in any government.

Glenn in Winnipeg
said

On one side, there are tens of millions of "Arabs" stating that Israel will be pushed into the sea and be removed forever from the face of the Earth. Iran employs the 2 groups Hamas and Hezbollah to carry out anti Israeli activities (rockets to Israel). These activities by the military factions have caused several nations to brand Hamas and Hezbollah as terrorist organizations. Israel has had to defend itslf against major wars from its neighbours and constant minor skirmishes, not to mention the human bomb experiences. Israel, the only true democracy in the middle east needs support from someone. It is the right thing to do. IFFY IGGY changes his position for votes so often, that he has no roots. Canadians don't know what he stands for. Prime Minister Harper is right on this issue and on others. He is the right leader for these times.

AH in calgary
said

Well said Scotty...no better words can describe this fact. 1- Harper and any Canadian government need not to be bias towards any party in the conflict in the Middle East or anywhere else in the world. 2- Harper you cannot take a stand against some (the Palestinians) or favour some (israel) for your personal political interests and as part of your tactics to manage your personal and your own cabinets member problems or mistakes or to use it to score points against your opponents (the Liberals).3- I see the timing of Harper's comments coming along with the recent gains made by the Republicans in the USA. as if Harper is trying to send a message to the Republican in the USA that please don't forget me in the near future. 4- Unfortunately, Canada will lose a lot in the future if they turned from being an honest country and nation that always seek peace and good will for others in the world.5- I wish if Harper and his government can show 10% of what they believe in regarding people's right to live in peace and freedom against China without looking to the commercial benefits from being a good commercial partner to them.

B. Kelley, Ontario
said

Doing the right thing and not the expedient thing is refreshing from a Canadian Prime Minister. Canada should stand for what is right and not just go along with anti-Israeli organizations like the United Nations. President Obama has meekly sold out the US to the cause of destroying Israel in order to curry Arab/Islamic favour but that move will inevitably damage their reputation and influence in the world. PM Harper and Canada stand tall in the world today. I'm proud of both.

Fically Left
said

So Mr. Harper, you've got bruises do ya? So what? We've got bruises too! We've been misled by you and your govt! We've been beat up in the streets! Our country has been put into a debt cycle our grandchildren will have to pay for! We've been embarrassed on the world stage! All the promises made to us, by you, have been broken! We thought we were electing a new govt, but you've given us the same old thing, only worse. At least the other guys tried to balance the books, instead of just going on a spending spree as you have! And you know what? You don't seem to care about our bruises, so why should we care about yours? You don't like it! You can always leave! I dare say you'd get Majority support for such a move! You promised us better! Instead you've taken the same old same old and made it much much worse!Now you whine and cry! Well, there is a certain way to end your pain. Call an election!

Martin Swain
said

Why exactly does the PM feel he needs to stick up for Israel? In military terms they're certainly Canada's better. I think even in economic terms they're ahead of us on a per capita basis. Is there any reason Mr. Harper shouldn't be minding Canada's business and letting Israel get on with theirs?

Lovin VancouverDave
said

Can I just say that VancouverDave, you are my new favorite Canadian!!Your statement is worth repeating:Fearless Leader, may I remind you that you're PM of Canada, not Israel. Nobody's stopping you from moving to Jerusalem and running for office there.

Manitoban
said

Wow, finally some good news! Thank you, Prime Minister Harper!

L
said

I think what many people don't consider is that, as Geoff in Lethbridge said, if Israel did not defend itself it would cease to exist. However, if the Arab nations against Israel laid down their weapons, peace would result. Israel does not promote the end of the Arab nations, however, the Arab nations promote the end of Israel. How would you feel if there were countries surrounding Canada that actively promoted the end of Canada? If they fired rockets into Canada to try and accomplish this? Should Canada stand by and do nothing? Should we just stop protecting ourselves and try to negotiate with people who scream that we shouldn't exist? How far do you think that would get us? We should protect Israel, and I'm glad Harper is standing up for that fact. Citizens of Israel are not strapping bombs to themselves to blow up those that disagree with them, yet people on this site would rather we side with countries that promote that behaviour? Thanks Harper for taking a stand for what is right and not being bullied into turning our back on our allies.

Will
said

Danny, you don't get it do you. The level of anti Israel rhetoric and anti-semetic commentary being spewed routinely in our universities is alarming. When did it suddenly become ok to spew hatred against a single group? There's lots wrong with this world without making it worse. As for the pro-arab lobby, we need to take a closer look at these wingnuts because there is more going on here that simple poltical lobbying.

mandosa
said

Abiding by principal, rather than the shifting sands of liberal media controlled public opinion. I like it. I didn't vote for Harper but I have to admit, he rarely fails to impress me.

Catwoman 38
said

Adam,This is not a noble stand.I don't know where you get these crazy ideas because this govt cares more about oil& gas and Israel then they do about people in our own country & our environment surrounding around us.When they do show it,it only benefits the rich.Not acceptable.What about men and women who can't work because they have no child care spaces, or woman's right to choose, or a national housing strategy.Don't these people matter?People want to focus on Canada first. Not everybody is Jewish .No wonder some of the churches in Canada are upset.

MuskyBuck
said

Wow...now I understand why Harper wasn't making a note of being more of a world participant.This guys speech and views on what is happening in the middle east are akin to asking a 17 year old what side he's on.What a terrible discourse of events and complete lack of understanding of the situation at hand.

Middle Ground
said

The moment you pick one side over the other you have forfeited your tenure as a leader on the world stage. Petty politics for a petty man !

Jim in Ottawa
said

It's very important that the Prime Minister take this stand against anti-Israeli rhetoric. The Jewish people have only one homeland: Israel. The Arab peoples have: Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Oman, Yemen, UAE, Qatar, Bahrain, Algeria, Libya, Morrocco, Tunisia, all of whom are hostile towards Israel and none of whom recognise Israel's legal, moral, and historical right to exist. In taking this stand, Mr. Harper has put himself right up there with Sir John A. Macdonald as one of Canada's greatest Prime Ministers.

Mark Cormier
said

Thankyou Prime Minister Harper for telling the "oppositiom" in plan ENGLISH that CANADA STAND WITH ISRAEL. Mark Cormier

duffrey
said

Danny, perhaps our Prime Minister along with a host of civilized nations, is tiring of the Arab world laying it's problems at the feet of Israel. I don't think he is anti-arab, more likely he is simply much more aware than you of the root causes of the problems in that region. I applaud his statement today.The Palestinians have been behaving like barbarians since the birth of the PLO and it's offshoots, more so now that the Islamic Militant groups allied to Syria and Iran have joined the fray, and although all cultures have behaved poorly at some point in thier history, most of us on Earth today have an agreed set of standards that do not include suicide bombs, raining thousands of missles on your neighbors and engaging in duplicitous politicing on the world stage.When the Arab world is demonstrably ready and willing to make real peace, I am sure they will find a partner in Israel and a supporter in the PMO.

Dan
said

[X] Harper

Avi Ickovich
said

Prime Minister Stephen Harper is the best leader that Canada has had since Sir John A MacDonald. Integrity carries a price, and I am sure that 1870 three years after confederation, the former had his wounds as well.The Liberal leader bends to the wind to secure votes.

RSSA in Edm.
said

"But he spoke of a "solemn duty" to defend the vulnerable..."Wow, just wow.I have no connections to any sides of the middle-east debate(s), but this comment is over the top... or should that be "below the bottom"?From what I have observed and heard from learned individuals, the Palestinians in this particular debate are far more vulnerable than their opponents or as some may see the Israelis as 'oppressors'.Forget about the land or religious issues, look at basic human needs; from ample fresh water to food, shelter and employment (almost said occupation, but they seem to have enough of that).From this metric alone, the Israelis are the least vulnerable. Taking care of these basic human needs will be a first step in the peace process because it is easier to forgive and understand when you're not thirsty and the belly isn't empty.As for our PM's support, it isn't based upon fact but upon agenda. Nothing new here, and no amount of satiation will improve my tolerance for him or his policies as a whole.

RJ in Halifax
said

To Scotty, are youo n ot aware that HAMAS was elected as a REGIONAL government, not a national one? The West Bank is part of the overall Palestinian Territory and now has two competing (read: guns, not words) governments. The governments in Iran, Syria, Libya, just to mention a few, are also "democtratically-elected" Isreal, despite its warts and self-imposed problems, is still the only trus democracy that allows its citizens to openly criticize its actions. In Iran, which the principal financial backer for HAMAS, the type of open dialgue that Isrealis have would et those individuals arrested and imprisoned.

George
said

I would like to hear our PM define what precisely is antisemitic rhetoric. Is it as simple as supporting a separate Palestinian state, in addition to Israel? When Israel invaded Gaza I emailed my Conservative MP to express my support of a Palestinian state and ask what Canada was doing in support of that goal. Never did get a reply. Apparently Canada is doing little if anything in support of a two-state solution. But my MP has gone on a trip to Israel (paid for by a local Israeli group) and stated publicly, not too long ago, that there was much more antisemitism than he had thought in Canada and it was shocking. I would say my MP is anti-Palestinian.

Wendy
said

Everybody on this earth has a right to a roof over their head and a country to call home. However, our prime ministers extreme 1 sided view of this situation is not making Canada ANY friends except Israel. The PM's stance is a dangerous one, and not well educated. When he is gone I'm sure you will see a very large shift in that position, and I look forward to that day.

Albertaboy111
said

Maybe he should not be so worried about Anti-Isreal rhetoric, and more on anti-Semitic rhetoric. One is a justifiable foreign policy related position on a state many in the international community have labeled in violation of many laws, and in fact an apartheid state. The other is discrimination based on a persons religion/race. Oh yea, I forgot, the attempt is to erase the line between the Jewish people, and the country of Isreal, and her evil Zionist controllers. Anyone else find it funny how there is only one country in the world, that if you disagree with, accuses you of being a racist?

Catwoman 38
said

What difference will this make.Same old , same old, nothing has changed.People need to really seriously look at this closely. What about the people in Canada who are not jewish, what about them?

Israel is a not a democracy
said

@ David and the usual pro-Israeli liars :Turkey, Lebanon, Kuwait, Iraq and Palestine are all democracies in the Middle East. Israel is not a democracy. You can keep telling the same lies but, the facts will not change that Israel does not meet the threshold of a democratic nation.

MARG MM
said

At least we have a PM that will take a stand against anti-Israel rhetoric, and stick with it. Then there's Michael Ignatieff who will sway back and forth depending on the "flavour of the day",but then he cares more about the vote, than taking a stand on anything. Time will tell during the next election, whether PM Harper's stand willl hurt him or help him, but at least he is decisive.

javajim47
said

There are two great records that prove the accuracy of the Prime Minister's words: history and the Bible. Those who oppose Israel and the Jews are not merely in jeopardy, they are doomed. They can never defeat or eliminate Israel. May God continue to bless Prime Minister Harper with the backbone he shows on this great issue. What a reproach it is to Canada that a man of such integrity has been given only a minority mandate!

Remy
said

God people are stupid. the American and the Israeli media pretend there is no democracy in the middle east however the Palestinian government is done through voting. in Israel you could not become a member of that state unless you were Jewish so by that alone Israel is not a democracy. a democracy is a political form of government in which governing power is derived from the people. also equality and freedom have been identified as important characteristics of democracy since ancient times.also before the creation of Israel, Jews, Christians and Muslims lived together in peace in Palestine. it was this Zionist ideology that lit the powder keg to what we have seen today. so before you ignorant people make statements go pick up a book and learn something. like your mother told you as a child if you have nothing good to say don't say it at all. also, it is better to say nothing at all and appear wise then to open your mouth and remove all doubt.

Pip
said

Mr Eizinas (commenter) states "When you decide to unilaterally change the direction of foreign policy to satisfy an agenda based on ideology then you should expect and deserve a few �bruises�" Perhaps he is unaware that Canada's ambassador to the fledgling United Nations - and later Liberal Prime Minister of Canada, Lester Pearson - set the direction of foreign policy regarding Israel by actively promoting the creation of that state under resolution 181 of 1947. Since we are, in a way, "parents" of that Jewish state, do we not have an obligation to stand up for it, particularly as the nation states around it have made every effort to try and destroy it (unsuccessfully) over the sixty two years since Israel emerged from the British Mandate. True, like many children, Israel needs to be reminded every so often on how to behave; but if your neighbour had attacked your child many times, would you not complain about the neighbour, not the child? The UN seems bent on bringing about the destruction of its child, the nation it brought into being in November 1947. Why should Mr. Harper - who is only continuing what Lester Pearson started - have to take flak from people who are unwilling to follow Pearson's example? It was not Mr. Harper who changed the foreign policy regarding Israel, but the party that helped create Israel - the LIBERALS. Harper simply restored the original Liberal attitude towards Israel.

Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Although they always try really hard to disguise their inner anti-Semitic feelings and beliefs, it doesn't take intellectual brilliance to decipher most of the complaints of the clods who angrily fashion Israel as a "terrorist state" and disingenuously bemoan the plight of the Palestinian people. You have neither history nor fact on your side...just your own glaring "issue" with "the Jews." It's painfully obvious. Quit pretending, people. (Advice: Do some research, educate yourself, and argue without the self-demeaning bias.)

allan
said

If islamic fundamentalists succeed in eliminating Israel, you will be next, because they will not stop there. Or perhaps you want your woment to wear black tarps, no schools for children, beheadings, etc. etc.? If so, go ahead and support Hamas/Hezbellah.Thank you Mr. Harper for speaking your mind and supporting humanity and freedom, not bondage, and inhumanity.

Patrick Kamloops
said

It is Harper's fundamentalist religious beliefs that set Canada's foreign policy. We no konger can play an 'honest broker' in middle eastern affairs when we stand by Israel right or wrong. To Harper, it is all biblical prophesy.Israel is a friend only to herself and driven by a minority of Zionists who are determined to drive all Arabs and Palistinians from their homeland.

The True Professor
said

To Prof. Pye Chartt: The world "terrorist" is used by every power in the world to demonize their enemies. The same applies to the situation between Israel and Hamas. The Russians, the Chinese, and the majority of countries worldwide refused to label Hamas as a terrorist organization! Only countries like Canada with excessive Israeli control over their foreign policies have adopted such a label!

Terry
said

The only person I HATE in this entire world is Stephen Harper. I do not hate Jews, nor Palestinians. On the UN Website a search for UN Security Council Resolution, Israel, Palestines reveals literally DOZENS of violations of international law by Israel. But none can be enforced because US has VETO. Over $6.Billion is sent by US Govt. to Israel annually in military aid. International law has found conclusively that Israel is 'occupying' Palestinian land.So the only person I hate is the one that turns a blind eye.Note, Canada does and has recognized West Bank as Palestines. Any goods imported from West Bank are deemed to originate in Palestines under the Customs Tariff.

Doug # BC
said

I sometimes think the PM is not always very clear when he expresses his views.He can be a bit terse. However,this issue appears to be an issue that will linger on,and on,and on.While I understand how some people believe that the PM's view could be seen as anti Arab,rather than pro Israel, I do not see it that way.It might be wise to clear the air. However,that "air clearing" must not abaondon the principles of the matter.Tat Isreal has a right to exist,and to defend both it's borders and it's people. I would argue that,If "Intelligent Liberal" is right about this stand costing Cnada a seat at the UN, it was worth the price.Being wishy washy in the face of middle east dictatorships is the wrong way to earn votes for a phony UN seat.Just as it would be wrong to buy African votes with more truck loads of foreign aid.In either case,Canada could win more votes in the UN.But the loss of respect would be crippling. Philosophically,I would rather be hated for what I truly believe in,than loved for pretending to be something I am not. Like it or not,standing for a principle often comes at a personal cost.Those not willing to pay that price really can't say they defend a principle at all.They are,in fact,all talk,and without the courage to really stand firm for anything. Those serving in the military are our ultimate example.They believe in Canada and the values it stands for.They don't talk up a storm, they put everything on the line so others can live free. PRO PATRIA

Aaron
said

God bless Harper. God bless Canada!

Bill
said

Israelis don't fly planes into our skyscrapers, they just buy and sell them. I support Harper. Iggy should go back to teaching.

VancouverDave
said

Fearless Leader, may I remind you that you're PM of Canada, not Israel. Nobody's stopping you from moving to Jerusalem and running for office there.

Fred
said

Mr. Harper is conflating anti-semitism with anti-Israel sentiment. The two things are not the same. Criticizing the State of Israel in no way implies that Jewish people shouldn't be allowed to exist. It's too bad so many stupid people will just go along and 'take a stand' instead of honestly evaluating the facts. Please take a stand at the ballot box ...

Scotty
said

Prof Pye - you can call them (or me) whatever names you like, it doesn't change the fact that they are the democratically elected government of the Palestinian people and any discussion of peace that doesn't include them is therefore a waste of time. The UK similarly called Sinn Fein a "terrorist organisation" for many years and, similarly, it got them nowhere. Only when they started talking to Sinn Fein did peace in Northern Ireland become possible. Harper is just prolonging the war and inciting terror, his position is traitorous to Canada.

JP
said

MR HARPERKeep your mouth shut- everytime you open it you embrass Canada

Gregory Boudreau
said

That has been the whole thing all a long, the UN and the Francafonie are not Isreal's best freinds. I think Prime Minister Harper is doing the right thing when it comes to Isreal. There have been so many who have tried to get rid of Isreal, but to no avail.

bwarson
said

Mr. Harper would be much more gainfully employed in building Alberta firewalls than in dispensing wisdom on anti-Semitism. With his simplistic view of how the world turns, he does this just cause more harm than good.

GUTSHOT!! in Thunder Bay
said

Our pro Israeli stance is the one thing I dont like about the PM, and the Conservative party. The farther we distance ourselves from them and their wars (disguised as wars against terrorism, etc..) the better off Canada will be. Supporting Israel is no different than supporting terrorism.

Geoff in Lethbridge
said

If the Arabs put down their weapons and accepted Israel on a smidgen of land in their vast region, and taught their children to be friends of Israelis, there would be peace tomorrow.If Israel put down its weapons, there would be no Israel tomorrow, and no oasis of freedom.

The Truth Hurts
said

The stance of Mr. Harper casts serious doubt about the secular nature of the Canadian government. Here we have a Canadian PM, based on his right wing Christian religious views, is declaring unconditional loyality to a foreign state accused of war crimes! In countries other than Canada, this would have been a sufficient reason for removing an official from his post! Canada's reputation worldwide has been tarnished by our blind support for obvious violations of human rights by Mr. Harper's Israeli friends. Unfortunately, it is Canada's image worldwide that is bruised not you Mr. Harper!

david siemens
said

Truer words were never spoken. When Israel suffers we all suffer. If you don't like it try another planet.

Colby
said

''Wasn't Harper elected to see to Canada's interests not Israel's? Losing Canada's chance of a seat on the security council by his unequivical su[pport for Israeli interests regardless of what they may be IS NOT in the best interest of Canada. Harper must go soon....record deficit, spendthrift management....he's leading us down the same path the US took to arrive at the fiscal mess they are in.Once again HE MUST GO SOON!!!!

Scotty
said

Israel is the only democracy in the middle east. Really? What about the democratically elected palestinian government, Hamas? Oh that's right, we don't want to talk about the free and fair elections that bring people we don't approve of to office. The West, Canada especially, is absolutely full of nonsense on this issue and Harper is the nonsense king.

Rational Western
said

There is a difference between being anti-semite and suggesting that Israel is not behaving properly. Speaking out against expanded settlement construction on the West Bank is one example of that difference. Harper needs to do more of that.

David - Ottawa
said

When you support a country, no matter what abuses the government, then you are an abuser yourself.Israel has the right to exist, no doubt, but alot of its current policies are just plain wrong, and only motivate hatred towards the country and those that support it..

Adam
said

A noble stand. This is why Canada voted for Prime Minister Harper as leader. His greatest testimony to his great leadership is his ability to take the lashings by the opposition and the media.

Allan Eizinas
said

When you decide to unilaterally change the direction of foreign policy to satisfy an agenda based on ideology then you should expect and deserve a few �bruises�. Many of these �bruise� result from fellow Canadians who do not believe that somebody representing small minority radical interests has the right to misrepresent the majority Canadian wishes. Perhaps Stephen Harper will learn from these �bruises�. Perhaps not.

SM, Montreal
said

If Ignatief is not the Honest Broker, then Harper must be!

Blair-Calgary
said

Thank God for such a great leader. It is because of his standing wtih Isreal that our country remains so great!

Charles Firetto
said

The worth of leader is measured by the integrity he conveys and lives by. Mr. Harper is a man who fits this description impeccably. May he be blessed with a majority government in the next election

Rich
said

Mr Prime Minister. A few bruises are good for you when you stand for a right cause.Israel is our friend and ally. Why do the UN, and the Postal workers union to mention a couple of minor players, spend so much time slamming the Israelis who are trying to maintain democracy, freedom as well as survive in a totally hostile environment. UN, go condemn Iran, Sudan, Mayamar, North Korea where the real human rights infractions are. Postal union shut up and get my mail to me on time which is your mandate and please stay out of things you don't understand.Thank you Mr Prime Minister for being faithful to our true friends.

Intelligent Liberal
said

Canada's pro-Israeli stance is tne main reason we did not secure a seat on the UN Security Council, the Arabic countries voted against Canada since Israeli aggression is such a dominate issue for them.

David
said

Thank you, Prime Minister Harper, for standing up with the only democratic nation in the middle east.

Graham
said

Thank goodness for Harper and his stand against the normal tirades of anti-Israel rthetoric

Danny Dinosaur
said

The problem isn't so much a pro - Israel stance as it is an anti - Arab stance. PM Harper does not understand or have the ability to work towards the betterment of both groups. The PM's style is to drive division - not just with Arabs and Israelis, but with every group he encounters. This is another reason he should not be the Prime Minister of Canada.

Today's Top Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012. (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Pick your location

Top Stories -

News Sections

News Programs

Features

Browse: