News Sections
Canadians must stand up for veterans, advocate says
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Sat. Nov. 6 2010 10:10 PM ET
Canadians must "defend the rights" of disabled soldiers, says a former military intelligence officer on a day when veterans across the country were protesting to demand changes to the way that they are compensated.
Thousands of veterans gathered outside their local MPs' constituency offices and at other sites on Saturday morning for the Canadian Veterans National Day of Protest. They were calling on the federal government to scrap the new veterans charter, which they say short-changes them by replacing life-time pensions with a combination of lump-sum payments and income support.
Sean Bruyea, an outspoken advocate for veterans, said Canadians must defend the rights of veterans, many of whom are disabled and cannot advocate for themselves.
"We're asking for the disabled veterans, the ones least able to defend themselves, to actually advocate," Bruyea told CTV News Channel on Saturday afternoon. "We really need Canadians to step up to the plate and defend the rights of veterans now that the soldiers out of uniform can't defend Canadians anymore."
In Halifax, about 50 people gathered at the war memorial in the Grand Parade, where veterans laid wreaths at the cenotaph and speakers called for improved benefits for veterans.
Signs throughout the crowd told the story of the veterans' anger. "Billions for Jets, Pennies for Vets. Shame!" read one poster. "Dump the lump sum. Give us back the pension," read another.
In Ottawa, Bruyea joined retired colonel and former veterans ombudsman Pat Stogran at a quiet, peaceful protest of about 150 on Parliament Hill.
Bruyea said demanding lifetime payments over a lump sum "isn't about getting rich" because military pensions are modest.
"But even these modest payments are substantially, when taken over the lifetime of a veteran, substantially larger than the lump sum," he said. "On top of that is that when that veteran passed away, there was always a survivor's pension for whether there were orphans left behind and definitely for spouses. That doesn't exist under the lump sum."
A handful of veterans who gathered in Toronto were joined by NDP Leader Jack Layton and Kirsty Duncan, the Liberal veterans affairs critic, both of whom called for changes to the system.
"There are people who are waiting two years to get a decision on pension. How do they live in that time?" Duncan asked. "There needs to be changes to the lump sum payments; 31 per cent of veterans say the lump sum payment is not working for them."
Prime Minister Stephen Harper's government has been under fire for months over its handling of veterans' issues, including the lump-sum payment.
Stogran led the campaign to improve benefits for veterans. It was discovered that bureaucrats used his and Bruyea's confidential medical records to try to discredit them.
The government opted to not renew Stogran's contract, and on Friday announced that retired chief warrant Guy Parent will be the new veterans ombudsman. Parent's term begins on Remembrance Day.
The new charter was introduced by Paul Martin's Liberal government in the spring of 2005 as a cost-saving move. Back then, it passed with all-party support, but the changes did not come into effect until the following April when it was enacted by the Conservative government.
An independent study commissioned by the ombudsman's office found that severely disabled soldiers in the lower ranks are most affected under the new system. The total amount of a lump-sum payment -- $276,000 -- won't make up for the loss of a life-time pension, the study found.
Stung by criticism from Stogran and other Canadian Forces veterans, the government announced in September a new five-year plan to help veterans that included an additional $200 million over the next five years for veterans unable to work because of their injuries.
Veterans Affairs Minister Jean-Pierre Blackburn issued a statement in response to the protests, saying that the government had brought in changes that are "targeting our most severely injured and vulnerable veterans and their families."
Blackburn said the most severely injured veterans will receive up to $58,000 each year, and added that the government has recently allowed veterans suffering from ALS to be eligible for benefits.
Many wounded veterans have complained their benefits are being held up by bureaucrats in Veterans Affairs and worry that any extra cash will get lost in the department's red tape.
"Putting money in the top end of this does not necessarily mean that it's going to filter out to actually help troops on the bottom," Stogran warned at the time.
Gary Zwicker, organizer of the Halifax protest and a navy veteran, said the benefits system needs to be overhauled to be less adversarial to veterans.
"It's a broken system that is falling apart in many different areas," Zwicker said. "It's run by bureaucrats that don't care and the adjudicators for pension disputes have no experience with veterans."
With files from The Canadian Press
User Tools
Related Websites
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
No one is asking Brad Wall or Dalton to ride naked with them. Asking a politician to do this is sexist pure and simple, even if he was joking.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
TERESA (retired)
said
Sarge Lafontaine
said
Dwayne
said
Dave McKnight, Chilliwack BC
said
Tom the Bosnia guy
said
BCMc
said
Pete M
said
Arby
said
The reason politicians have the freedom to bicker and argue back and forth and voice opinions is because of Veterans who fought the armies of dictators.
All MP's need to agree on this.
Pay up and shut up.
BK in Cornwall
said
CalgarySandy
said
I have studied Canada at war in University and we have great reasons to be proud. The young men had no idea what they were getting into and they came out genuine heroes. They were fighting with the UK and it was the first time Canada fought as an individual nation rather than being part of the British military. It was and remains a major step in our independence as a nation.
CalgarySandy
said
My mom, who basically lived off my dad for the rest of her life until they separated is now living in a high end seniors residence where housekeeping and meals are provided. I do not understand why my father who saw combat and spent his life in the armed forces was not as well treated as my mom. I do not understand why there are Vets begging in the streets. Is this because my cousin-in-law, who was an officer in the Navy, pulled strings for her?
It is unfair that some vets are doing fine and others are not. Peacetime or wartime they should be treated equally and the disabled should be given what they need to live decently too.
SM in Montreal
said
paul from Halifax
said
Jim-Surrey
said
Pissed off Reservist.
said
Michael
said
Chris
said
Redneck Vic
said
robin hood
said
Vets' Father in SK
said
Gord
said
Insofar as our freedoms are concerned, this coming week, be sure to give thanks to our armed services veterans who put themselves in harm's way and served our country.
One of my Uncles, now deceased came home from WW1 shellshocked before anyone had ever heard of post combat trauma. He participated in our assault and victory on Vimy Ridge. Senior officers were all British and dismissed Canadians under their command and expendable and just colonial riff raff. His promising career ended and he spent his entire life misunderstood by our family and in the Veterans ward at Sunnybrook Hospital in Toronto.
I belief veteran's pensions and health care should remain intact.
Gord. Robson, Nova Scoria
said
icanthinkformyself
said
W
said
reece
said
3rd Gen Member
said
Ret Soldier's wife
said
You know nothing about what you're talking about. The pensions CF members receive are hardly "fat". You've mixed that up with a politician's pension. BTW I dare you to get off your behind and enlist. Maybe you'll get a reality check.
paul from Halifax
said
PM vist to Veteran soup kitchens
said
Fair? I think not.
said
Margaret
said
NS
said
carrie macneill
said
stevo
said
smitecha
said
Mike
said
Linda in Vancouver
said
Elizabeth, Ontario
said
Not so Proud Canadian
said
This is so very apparent in the case of VAC which vacillates, obfuscates, minimises, refutes, denies, and rationalises when faced with genuine cases of need generated by the fall-out from service in the cause of this country's freedoms.
Now if only the example of the departments of open and revolving doors (ie. immigration and justice) were to be followed with benefits doled out to those who absolutely have the least call on taxpayers' money, then there would be no argument, no demonstration and no povery among our most deserving citizens.
Not insurable, on our own.
said
fd
said
Bill
said
Some true numbers
said
Outraged Vet
said
CF from Alberta
said
"I want to go and apply for hearing aids through Veterans Affairs but I hesitate because they make you feel like it is your fault that your hearing is going and unless you come crawling to them on hands and knees it is almost impossible to get help from them." Mike, I encourage you to call the local VA office and asked them to send you the application forms. I did..and with my hearing test on the way in the Army, and one on the way out (which will be on your service file VA will obtain from Archives Canada) plus afterwards, I did receive approval for hearing aid and lump sum of $13,500. But the VA service was very good, and I had no bad experience.
Protesting from home!
said
Calgary Canuck
said
BC in BC
said
DavecBC
said
Gord in Ottawa
said
Chris A Broken Sgt
said
Beetle
said
Sam in sask
said
Doug # BC
said
radha
said
Brenda a service mans wife
said
CDN SOLDIER
said
Mike S retired WO
said
Barbara Morton
said
Lisa C
said
Sam
said
Chris in Kingston
said
Ed in Albeta
said
Carl Gustov
said
Niagara George
said
Airborne trooper
said
Jim McB
said
Sapper D
said
Wayne in HRM
said
Chris
said
Parl Hill Air Head
said
Hugh pei
said
Paul, Simcoe
said
Blake Gamble, CD, Sgt (Ret'd)
said
George V.
said
Sapper Dave
said
simon
said
Pierre, Chilliwack BC
said
JR from Pointe Claire
said
island girl
said
Ron
said
Julie Page
said
Carl
said
Frank in NS
said
Capt (ret) Lance Usher
said
Molly
said