Top Stories -   

1

Free trade with EU would hurt Canada, study says

From left, Prime Minister Stephen Harper, European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso and European Council President Herman Van Rompuy arrive for an EU-Canada summit at the EU Council building in Brussels, Wednesday, May 5, 2010. (AP / Virginia Mayo) Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks during an EU-Canada summit at the EU Council building in Brussels, Wednesday, May 5, 2010. (AP / Virginia Mayo) Job fair
From left, Prime Minister Stephen Harper, European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso and European Council President Herman Van Rompuy arrive for an EU-Canada summit at the EU Council building in Brussels, Wednesday, May 5, 2010. (AP / Virginia Mayo)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (26) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday Oct. 27, 2010 5:23 PM ET

Canada would lose up to 150,000 jobs and see its trade deficit swell dramatically under a free-trade pact with the European Union, warns a new study by the left-leaning Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.

Canada is currently in talks with the EU to hash out the terms of a potential trade agreement.

Canada already has an annual trade deficit -- meaning it imports more from Europe than it exports to Europe -- of about $15 billion in goods and almost $4 billion in services, with the EU.

That translates to losses of about 70,000 jobs, the group said.

Canada would see greater losses under a free-trade agreement, the study says, with Canada's gross domestic product taking a hit of between .55 per cent and 3 per cent over the first few years of an agreement.

Those losses would be further exacerbated by spin-off effects in the production sector, employment and investment.

Report author Jim Stanford, a CCPA researcher and economist, gave three main reasons for his conclusions:

  • Canadian currently imports much more from the EU than it exports to the EU.
  • Canadian trade tariffs are substantially higher than EU tariffs, and therefore the loss of that income would be felt sharply.
  • The Canadian dollar has recently risen against the euro, making Canadian-made products much less competitive and overwhelming the benefits of tariff reduction on our exports.

A joint study between the European Commission and Canada showed benefits worth $12 billion for Canada under such an agreement. But the report pointed out that even that study predicted that Canada's imports from the EU would increase by twice as much as its exports, "resulting in a substantial widening of the existing bilateral trade deficit."

Stanford also points out that free-trade agreements with the U.S., Mexico, Israel and Chile have all resulted in much higher increases in imports than in exports.

Stanford said there is some merit to the idea of a free-trade pact, but the disadvantages for Canada far outweigh the benefits.

"Enhancing Canadian exports and diversifying export markets away from the U.S. are important economic policy goals for Canada," Stanford said. "But merely signing another free-trade agreement -- even with a partner as important as the EU --has no chance of achieving either goal."

Stanford modelled three different economic scenarios to project the outcome of a free-trade agreement. All three turned up the same result -- huge economic losses and job shrinkage.

He suggests alternative measures to improving Canada's European trade policies, from devaluing the loonie to offering proactive support for Canada's high-tech exports. The study points out that Canada exports mostly raw or barely processed resources, and imports mostly sophisticated, technology-intense products.

Comments are now closed for this story

bob
said

The problem as I see it is exactly the same problem I was taught in high school in the 70s. We should not be exporting raw materials, period! Everything leaving this country should have some value added to it. Whether it is milling lumber, refiining ore or oil. We should get something extra from it, not just the base price from commodities


LDL in ONT
said

Here is the first item up for discussion during free trade negotiations. Does Europe produce an electric clothes iron? Someone please tell me who produces one that is not made in China, because I can't find it. If there is one made in Bulgaria, Finland, Austria, Anywhere in Europe, I'd rather buy it from them.


lc
said

Wouldn't matter to the "free trade cultist" if Christ himself pointed out that open border policies are a disaster to all but the elitists.Even after the fools have caused the western industrial base to be exported to the 3rd world and nearly wiped out the middle class they still repeat their hollow mantras.


NS
said

Veryyyyy left leaning study. How about cheaper imports makes for cheaper products for consumers... and more competition in the market place leads to higher quality products.


Rosie
said

Canada has always exported more than it imports.There are instances where free trade agreements are good for our country,sometimes not so good.As long as we have winter in Canada we will have to import fresh produce.We certainly can't use all the potash and oil available for us,so it's sold to other countries.The reason in my opinion that manufacturing jobs leave this country is overtaxation due to out of control government spending.Also,overregulation,unions,declining productivity,Try to start a business in this country,and by the time you are through with gov't red tape you are way behind the eight ball.Then its the hydro,heating and air conditioning,payroll taxes etc.Bring down the costs of manufacturing and it will return here.


Dorris
said

The only ones benefiting from willy-nilly free trade deals are super rich and elite politicos who have the money to invest in profiting off the entire scam.People keep pitching that consumers benefit which is B.S. Those so called consumers that benefit..make minimum wage "now", they used to have decent middle-class jobs before they were sent to China. How have we benefited in this global trade transfer of wealth from Canada/USA to the 3rd world? Our own economic prosperity has eroded and the elite keep the masses from rising up by making sure they're busy in WalMart buying the newest "3D smell-vision TV". Haven't heard of that one yet? Oh you will soon!Meanwhile dinner went from a quality course meal to beans and weiners to pay for the "Made in China'" junk TV because the jobs you have now can't carry the debt of shelter, food and the WalMart shopping cart.Globalization and transfer of our wealth has benefited China immensely while putting "us" in the gutter thanks to our political and business elites who like Scrooge has nickled and dimed our economy to ruination and our ability to get ahead financially.


viral venus
said

As usual, let's attempt to sedate the howling monkeys on both sides of the political aisle for just a minute and try for an intellectual discussion. Just like when NAFTA was signed, there will losers and winners in our economy and it will take a number of years to assess the overall impact as either negative or positive. There will likely be job losses and price increases in some sectors and job gains and price reductions in others. This is always the case in any economic agreement involving two or more independent nations with their own interests at stake. Do any of you "for" howlers really think that any other country would EVER sign a deal that wasn't at least as favourable for them as for us? Do any of you "against" howlers really believe our government is so incompetent or subversive that they would sign an agreement that held NO potential pluses for our country? Each nation will be bartering using their strongest suit to get the most out of the deal. They may deliberately sacrifce weak elements of their economies to boost their strong sectors. If there is great disparity in the relative economic power of the signatory nations then the negative effects are magnified for the weaker country. Bottom line is that each nation will be taking a risk in an ATTEMPT to strengthen and grow aspects of their economies. For all signatories there will be the potential for great sucess or stunning failure that is very difficult to accurately predict. These facst can't be changed by excessive optimism, excessive pessimism or simple-minded political posturing.


Muskybuck
said

Of course this will hurt Canadians and it will hurt impoverished European countries as well.But there's nothing you or anyone else can do to stop this. Globalization has been happening for over 50 years. Little countries like Estonia will continue to be raped for their work resources, employees paid next to nothing to produce goods and consumables which is all that North Americans care about or pay attention to.We've done it to Africa, South America, the Caribbean and now we'll cement our greed for goods in Europe.And most Canadians will spend their time concerning themselves with what little they understand about local politics.Sad.


Brian
said

Gilbert in Ottawa: Yes and they were right then. We've paid a heavy cost for what Mulroney did.


CraigW
said

I would imagine there will be negotiations to hopefully account for the inequities and provide an agreement that is beneficial to all involved. Expanding as many markets as possible to become less reliant on a U.S. economy which may be in trouble for years to come cannot be a bad thing.


Jayson
said

This study fails to study any new opportunity that would come by this agreement. We would gain access to a huge market, and they would gain access to a small market. The manufacturing sector is likely to suffer a little as countries like Poland have cheep labor available. However if you look at the nature of our currently industry there, I doubt there would be a dramatic shift since most factories in Canada export to the USA and are tied to the US economy with geography playing a big role.A free trade agreement can be a big boon for us as it would reduce our reliance on the US market through diversification. Moreover it would give us major access to Europe in a way we have never had before allowing our businesses to reach their markets in a more cost effective manner.It is far more likely we would get more opportunity out of the deal. The question is how long would it take for us to take advantage of that?


Kyros
said

Haven't we all learned our lesson with the scam known as "Made in China" that has destroyed our middle class by outsourcing jobs to communist China? Chinese manufacturers "dump" hoards of dangerous sub-standard product onto our shelves at dirt cheap prices which has given birth to a "shop-a-holic" society buying up a fire sale which soon racks up the credit-cards (lending financed by China) because in socialist Canada after taxes we don't have enough "tangible" cash to pay for our costs of living plus "Made in China". To top it off the Chinese manufacturers have skillfully developed products in such a way that their "life span" is about 1/3 of what it was when "we" North Americans made the same items. That way we will have to buy 3X faster to replace the product when it dies than we did before. Clever eh? But not cheap in the long term..just the short term. We are living off a wing and a prayer anymore..paycheck to paycheck and the free trade globalization deal with countries like communist China have effectively taken your once good paying job, financed the credit cards driving you into bankruptcy and providing you with lots of 'questionable' products. Triple edge sword and it's time we collectively rise up and protect ourselves and give them the boot!


Paul ~ Kitchener
said

If the truth was really known, (the Real Benefits), to the Canadian people, one would see the benefits of a "Free Trade Agreement with the European Union.Loss of trade jobs in this country, are a result of horrendous union contracts, putting production costs out of line with the world.Canadians buy foreign goods, why, ~ $'s less from the wallets of the common folk.Entrepeneurs in Canada are growing, doing well financially, expanding their growth even to exporting.Why is this ~ they don't have "UNIONS" & never will.Canada has lots to export in the tech fields of medicine, computers, etc. they just have to be competative ~ look at R.I.M. (what made them #1 in the world and still reaching out in this universe.Go for it Mr. Prime Minister, and don't listen to the star gazzers, and soothsayers.


Stewie
said

I find it a bit scary us having this big of a trade deficit with European countries. The right thinks were in such great financial shape, but our dollar has been falling against the Euro, pound & many other currencies, it wasn't that long ago that our dollar was at 1.00 - 0.50 Australian, now it's at parity. Our dollar has even been falling to the pesos. Canada's economy won't pick up until our housing bubble pops, the inflated housing price were created by Harper's zero down mortgages, it's only a matter of time & we'll be in tough shape no matter what we do.


Mike van Lammeren
said

What does a 'trade deficit' even mean? Are there any negative consequences?Think about this for a minute. There is a huge trade deficit between me and my local Costco. I buy things from Costco all the time, but Costco never buys anything from me! This must somehow threaten my job.Lefties don't understand where wealth comes from. Wealth is not money. Wealth is created when someone pulls something valuable out of the ground, grows crops, writes a new best-seller, provides a service, etc. In short, work creates wealth. (Incidentally, this is why printing money does not increase wealth.)The fact that some countries can consistently have trade deficits with other countries over long periods of time, like my persistent trade deficit with Costco, shows that the concept of trade deficit is meaningless. Personally, I have a trade surplus with my employer, just like Canada has trade surpluses with other countries.


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

De-industrialization and the loss of processing, production and manufacturing activity has doomed North America to fall into the great divide between rich and poor. The middle class has tried to hold onto its place in the middle with borrowing and other measures like having greater participation in the the work force by women, but it has played out all the options that were available and is quickly slipping under the unavoidable tide of globalism. There is no doubt now that our children will have much less than we had during our careers. There will be the very wealthy and the unemployed and working poor. The leadership under the direction of the powerful are finding more and more ways to grant the advantaged a larger slice of the ever-shrinking economic pie. It would be far better for everyone to take a small and reasonable slice of an growing economy -- but that is not how greed works.


Mike
said

The study is a joke, it is lead by someone who works for the unions. The good thing about free trade is it leads to potentially lower prices and forces companies that rely on protection to become productive and efficient. oh ya i forgot productive and efficient are two words unions are not aware of.To Intelligent Liberal - Westerners buy foreign vehicles because they are efficient and more reliable and of much higher quality. And in most cases cost more than the equivelant domestic models. In cases such as Totota they employ as many people in Ontarion as GM and Ford does with wages that are compartive. There goes that argument


MARG MM
said

"A study by the left leaning Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives" says it all!!!!! Do they even know what terms there are in any agreements, how they would be implemented etc, or is it just because it is PM Harper that is the one in Europe meeting with EU leaders. Methinks the latter. The left leaners condemn anything that the PM and the Conservatives do. This probably came out in the news today, because yesterday Sheila Fraser gave the Government high marks for they way they handled the stimulus money. The Liberals are in shock and dismay, so immediately had to come up with something negative.


Al in Orillia
said

I think that now we need to hear from a "right leaning" study, then hopefully a " centered" study will be given some media so we can express informed opinions on the matter.


PBW
said

I have no problem with a free trade agreement with any nation - so long as it is fair trade. Simply put, we buy $1 billion from them, they buy $1 billion from us. If either party ends up with a trade surplus, it is no longer fair trade. Similarly, nations should not peg their currencies at an artificially low rate - that too is unfair trade, making goods artificially cheap. Unfortunately, some nations do not see things that way. Since we currently have a trade deficit with the EU nations - and other nations, come to that - perhaps part of any agreement should be that they increase their imports from us to a point of balance.


Luigi
said

I want a free-beer-trade agreement


Michael`
said

They said the same when it came to free trade with the US. At the moment everything is made in China.


Intelligent Liberal
said

Canada needs to stop buying from foreigners! Look what happened to thousands of high paid union jobs in Ontario because westerners kept buying Japanese imports instead of GM trucks and Ford half tons! The only way for Canada to improve financially is to stop trading with foreign countries, and the best way to stop trade is to impose tariffs on foreign goods so they will cost more. The extra cost is required in order to pay benefits for union workers trying to feed their families in Ontario.


Jackie Barrett
said

At the same time, a free trade agreement between Canada and the European Union would benefit dairy consumers as we'll pay lower prices for dairy products like yoghurt, butter, cheese, and even milk.Best of all, such a deal will also force Canada's dairy industry to eliminate its supply management system, eliminate production quotas, lower dairy prices, and force our dairy companies to be more competitive.If dairy industry free trade and deregulation works for New Zealand, a major dairy exporter to China, it can work for Canada, and such a free trade deal is a great start.


Gilbert in Ottawa
said

Here goes the fear mongering from the lefties and unions.... Didn't they say the same way back when Canada was negociating a free trade agreement with the US and later with Mexico....


Mark Smith (Montreal, PQ)
said

I can see where this study is coming from, but I'm also a bit confused. Would this agreement mean that imported goods become cheaper?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012.  (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Charles Taylor gets 50 years for 'brutal' crimes

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Police probe body parts in Ottawa, torso in Montreal

More    Comments    3 Video(s) 3

Supporters of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, hold placards and banners bearing images of him before the verdict was given in his extradition case at the Supreme Court in London, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (AP / Matt Dunham)

Britain's top court backs extradition of WikiLeaks chief

More   4 Comments 4    2 Video(s) 2