News Sections
Tories blame Ignatieff for losing bid for UN seat
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Tue. Oct. 12 2010 9:02 PM ET
After losing its bid for a coveted seat on the UN Security Council to Portugal on Tuesday, the Conservative government responded by defending its campaign and blaming Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff.
"I do not think that this is a repudiation of Canada's foreign policy," Foreign Minister Lawrence Cannon told reporters Tuesday afternoon. "Canada ran a campaign based on principle; we ran a strong campaign. Unfortunately, back home in Canada, the leader of the opposition determined that Canada does not speak with one voice.
"In my view, (Ignatieff's statements) were used as an issue to prevent Canada from succeeding to the Security Council."
Ignatieff had accused the Harper government of ignoring the UN during its four years in office.
"This is a government that for four years has basically ignored the United Nations and now is suddenly showing up saying, ‘Hey, put us on the council,'" Ignatieff said in September.
Ignatieff responded Tuesday afternoon by saying it was a "sad day" for Canada and the international community has sent the Conservatives a message.
"This is the first time in sixty years we've failed to secure a seat on an institution that this country helped found," he told reporters, noting the roles in the UN played by former prime ministers Lester Pearson and Brian Mulroney. "This is a pretty depressing story about the government's performance on foreign policy."
Ignatieff called the blame the Tories laid at his feet "ridiculous."
"The responsibility of this lies squarely and exclusively with the Harper government," he said. "Any other proposition is just too ridiculous to entertain. The ‘blame game' is the sign of a government that is unwilling to absorb the lesson of defeat."
Paul Heinbecker, a foreign policy analyst and former Canadian ambassador to the UN, dismissed Cannon's blaming of Ignatieff.
"If they're selling policies that the international community is not sympathetic to, it isn't going to be because the leader of the opposition was for or against those policies," he told CTV News Channel's Power Play.
Heinbecker said Canada likely didn't get enough votes because it had failed to commit to its Kyoto obligations, and shifted foreign aid away from the Middle East and Africa to Latin America.
"We have a series of policies that, whatever their merits are internally, are not vote-getters," he said.
"We followed policies that are frankly and strongly in support of the government of Israel. And again, whatever you think of the merits of the policy -- and I happen to think we're not as fair as they should have been -- they're not vote-getters. There are 57 votes in the Arab and Islamic community."
NDP foreign affairs critic Paul Dewar said the defeat was "devastating for our country's reputation.
"We've lost our credibility, we've lost our reach. If you're on the Security Council you can actually influence the agenda of the United Nations . . . on climate change, employment change, peace and security," he told reporters.
Stephen Staples, president of the Ottawa-based defence think-tank Rideau Institute, called the losing bid Canada's "Hindenburg moment."
"Prime Minister Stephen Harper may regret snubbing the UN for so long. Now we know if you ignore the world long enough – it will eventually notice," he said in a statement.
The withdrawal
Canada withdrew its candidacy for the final seat available on the UN Security Council after it appeared Portugal was on track to win the last spot after the second vote. It was the first time Canada lost a bid for a Security Council seat.
Canada's UN Ambassador John McNee made the abrupt announcement after Canada received only 78 votes to Portugal's 113 in the second round of voting for a spot on the Security Council.
Initially, Germany, Portugal and Canada were vying for two non-permanent seats available to pro-Western nations, but Germany got the required two-thirds majority to secure a seat in the first round of voting Tuesday.
Germany received 128 votes, Portugal took 122 and Canada finished with 114 in the first round of voting.
Cannon said he never saw the opposition leaders in those countries speak against their own candidacy.
Shortly after withdrawing, the Tories began to blame Ignatieff.
"I would say a big deciding factor was the fact that Canada's bid did not have unity because we had Mr. Ignatieff questioning and opposing Canada's bid," Dimitri Soudas, Harper's communications director, told The Canadian Press.
"That was a factor that played ultimately against Canada because people outside of Canada were saying, 'Well, Germany and Portugal have a united front, their opposition and their governments seem to be fully, 100 per cent behind this bid.'
"Canada did not have that required advantage. We had an opposition leader that opposed Canada and clearly was not in it for Canada on this one."
When asked if Canada's strengthened support of Israel under the Tory government may had played a role, Soudas said Canada's democratic values were not up for bartering.
Three other countries were elected to the UN Security Council Tuesday -- South Africa, India and Colombia. All were running for uncontested spots.
Second snub
It was the second international snub for Canada in two days. On Monday, a military plane carrying Defence Minister Peter MacKay and Chief of Defence Staff Gen. Walt Natynczyk was not allowed to land in the United Arab Emirates, the result of a dispute over aviation links.
The dispute means Canada will be forced to withdraw from its formerly secret military base near Dubai.
Canada's surprise announcement was in stark contrast to Cannon's statements in the morning, in which he said he was confident Canada would rejoin the council.
He said Canada's campaign had "gone well."
Canada was believed to be in a good position because it was facing two European competitors.
"There is concern that the Council would be too European-weighed if both Germany and Portugal were to prevail," Michelle Fanzo of the World Policy Institute told CTV News Channel on Tuesday before Canada withdrew its candidacy.
If Canada was successful in its bid for membership, it would have started a two-year term on the Security Council in January. It would have been the seventh time that Canada has served since 1948.
There are 15 members of the Security Council in total.
Five nations have permanent membership: China, France, the Russian Federation, the United States and the United Kingdom.
The remaining 10 seats are non-permanent and are assigned to nations for two-year terms.
With files from The Canadian Press
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
While Branson's comments (and activities) are arrogant in a million different ways, Clark's response was admirable. She kept her sense of humour with her joke about Branson's brand-name and his bad pick-up line, showing why humour is often the best response to arrogance.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Understanding the UN
said
Laurie
said
BCDarr
said
Wilson
said
TerryR from Lethbridge
said
HArry
said
Luc from Carp
said
Obsserverman
said
Independently Minded
said
Kim
said
Mandosa
said
Scott (in Wild Rose Alliance Country)
said
jean from Ottawa
said
Richard L. Provencher
said
kestral
said
A different Paul
said
Martin in Ottawa
said
Doug
said
Margaret
said
Richard L Provencher
said
Max
said
Andrew in NB
said
simon
said
Kelly Richmond
said
PissedCanuack
said
Jack Neilson
said
renaldo
said
JohnQPublicQc
said
Ed Vella
said
Andrea in Ottawa
said
Damon
said
Debbie
said
Gary
said
Personally I think it would be great for Canada to be on the UN seat in one way because it means that Canada can help influence the decisions to help the world.
On the other hand we would look like the bad guy in our decisions such as sheer hatred of us if we imposed sanctions for whatever reason.
MIKE
said
CF
said
Collin
said
jeffrey martin
said
victoria trudeau
said
Steve in Manotick
said
mary
said
willowway
said
Mac
said
Joe_from_Winnipeg
said
The Harperites let Canada down again. Toss 'em out in the next election.
Bob
said
Golf Company Grunt
said
Randy Moldowan
said
Jason Daniel Baker, Toronto
said
John
said
Hunter Elliott
said
Thinking this through
said
machiavelli
said
Sask Voter
said
JD
said
Mike
said
manner
said
Dan
said
John Ozols
said
Tim from Calgary
said
Gerry
said
Zi Pep
said
Spence in Ontario
said
KJ in Kingston Ontario
said
sickandtired
said
Inga
said
BMP
said
Sam C
said
Steve AB
said
Non political guy
said
Rob Meadows
said
It's a poor man that can't own up to his own mistakes and shoulder the blame. When you try and move the blame over to someone else, it makes you even more of a failure.
Mike R.
said
Former conservative
said
Jessica from Toronto
said
Vincent
said
Brian
said
Bradford
said
Al in Orillia
said
MHB
said
JayRoc
said
Michael (Ottawa)
said
jen
said
Ab red neck in the know
said
viral venus
said
David
said
dustyrusty
said
John Calgary
said
Windex
said
Brent
said
CharlieG
said
Simonae
said
The Sky Is Falling!
said
Ronald
said
Pat
said
James (AB)
said
charlie
said
Hal
said
Jason In Edmonton
said
Linda in Vancouver
said
We can, and always will have our differences, and we should all welcome sane and useful debate about those issues. But when it comes to our country, all of us need to stand together to defend our country.
In this case, while Harper has to wear this, we have lost little. The biggest loss is the reality that the "coalition of the three morons" is willing, for its own self interest, to diss our nation.
Like the debate regarding Afghanistan,their objective is all about defeating a PM that they don't like.I see no reasons to believe any of them,particularly the separatists,have much concern about the country itself. No elected MP should publicy announce that Canada doesn't deserve this seat.Ignatieff lost what little respect I had for him when he went down that road.His words were almost treason. Certainly not words I want to hear from a man who wants to be our PM. Despite our differences,we must all remain loyal to Canada.Not a political party of any stripe.
Mars
said
fatboy
said
OttawaOutsider
said
Embarrased Canadian
said
Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said
George
said
AH in Calgary
said
Albert Ballentine
said
Jim in Calgary
said
mahanna ali
said
Gregoryd
said
Anne from Ottawa
said
Jan-Michael
said
And the higher deficeit is Ontario and BC going HST as Harper Conservatives wanted???
When you are the Government or boss, it is your responsibility.
But Harper and team just blame someone,anyone!
Face the mirror, you won't like what you see and neither do I.
Paul Vancouver Island
said
Benny
said
WE DONT! Being apart of the UN has only proven one thing for canada, a lack of rights and freedomes, time and time again the UN pressures Canada to change and re arrange laws behind the backs of Candian citizens, this is no hidden fact.
Boo to the UN it does us NO good!
I will be voting Liberal.
Ken - Calgary
said
Chuck
said
Steve in Manotick
said
Jiwan Singh
said
Jeff Wilkinson
said
James
said
Big Mo
said
But the real issues are likely our position on Israel (USA lite), the shift of aid to latin america, and of course our dismal environmental record. We don't exactly cooperate if it doesn't work for us. Portugal is far more progressive and rational than our dysfunctional government could ever hope to be right now.
Mar
said
Allan Eizinas
said
Steve in Ottawa
said
Dave in Qc.
said
Jim Mintz
said
Former Liberal
said
ron777
said
Dave in Calgary
said
Double Double
said
KB in W'burg, ON
said
all the way from Calgary
said
Dan in Quebec
said
Gregg
said
Tonya
said
Mark
said
Jackie Barrett
said
James (AB)
said
Magnus
said
David - Ottawa
said
Tim from Calgary
said
CD from AB
said
Rick @ Ottawa
said
MARG MM
said
golflouis
said
Will
said
Albertaboy111
said
rmd
said
James
said
Albertaboy111
said
Michel Di Lullo
said
I am afraid that many comments regarding the usefulness of the UN are very accurate, it's time has come and gone.
L
said
Leo
said
Surebye
said
rhea smeltzer
said
Cameron252
said
steve in wildrose country
said
Fun City, SK
said
Jay
said
After having hosted the Olympics, the G20 and G8 Summits and sending troops to Afghanistan, Canada has shown it is quite capable of successful representation on the world stage.
Rick
said
Maybe next time you could spend MORE OF OUR money on a bigger beer party, to get us a seat.
Zhimmy
said
al
said
Havelock Heavy
said
It's your fault!
said
Point Break
said
Denise
said
valorie
said
Rob
said
James in Ottawa
said
Mark
said
Miggs
said
Robin
said
Jamie, Ottawa
said
bill from Winnipeg
said
Mike in Mississauga
said
Sheila
said
Richard in New Brunswick
said
Al - Ottawa
said
Amar
said
Kevin B
said
PO'ed in Canada
said
Intelligent Liberal
said
MKR
said
Carl
said
Willi
said
James
said
Kay
said
What is this all about?
said
George
said
5th Generation Canadian
said
Just Cynical
said
Wendy
said
Peter in MB
said
allan
said
Dick Chapman
said
Get rid of two organizations and we wouldn't have a deficit in Canada! Th U.N. and the CBC!!!
LDL in ONT
said
Lane
said
Al in Orillia
said
Paul Vancouver Island
said
Carl
said
Helen-Jean - London
said
Renaldo
said
OBSSERVERMAN
said
Allan Eizinas
said
Allan - Angus, Ont
said
Jim in Ontario
said
Dave S
said
They have out lived there usefulness anyway
Bob,Calgary
said
James (AB)
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Tod
said
Bryn
said
Cam
said
Kelly
said
Ken Durham
said
CMQ
said
BMACK
said
Ron
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Tom
said
Cliff
said
Fiscally Left
said
Will
said
Ian Ottawa
said
Anne
said
paulfrottawa
said
BMACK
said
paulb
said
JP
said
Stave
said