Top Stories -   

1
Terri-Jean Bedford, middle, and law professor Alan Young, third from left, react to a decision by an Ontario court that has struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Osgoode Hall law professor Alan young appears on CTV's Power Play from Toronto, on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Dominatrix Terri-Jean Bedford appears on CTV's Power Play from Toronto, on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Dominatrix Terri-Jean Bedford is calling it emancipation day for sex trade workers after an Ontario court struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Terri-Jean Bedford smiles to a decision by an Ontario court that has struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010.

Ontario court strikes down anti-prostitution laws

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Robert Fife on the law
The Ontario Superior Court ruled some sections of the criminal code are unconstitutional as they put sex trade workers in danger, and struck down those sections that make it a criminal offence for a person to operate a common bawdy house.
CTV National News: Jill Macyshon on the reaction
Many of the most vulnerable sex workers, especially those who work the streets, will remain at high risk, but not everyone agrees with the ruling on prostitution law.
CTV News: Austin Delaney on the ruling
An Ontario Superior Court of Justice judge has struck down several portions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, saying they increase the danger to sex-trade workers.
CTV News Channel: Ron Marzel, lawyer
A lawyer says the ruling over the key provisions of the prostitution law is all about sex workers' safety. He suggests sex workers should also take precautions to protect their own safety. The decision is expected to be appealed.
CTV Calgary: Kari Eyles on the court ruling
It will be legal for bawdy houses to exist unless the federal government steps in. What the new prostition ruling means for Calgarians.
CTV Winnipeg: Caroline Barghout on the law
An Ontario provincial court made the ruling on Tuesday striking down provisions of anti-prostitution laws. Women in the sex workers are concerned for their health and safety.
Power Play: Alan Young, law professor
A law professor says changes are essential to rationalize a law which has been contradictory for 30 years. He says it is not about whether prostitution is morally correct, this is about the safety for those who can legally sell sex.
Power Play: Terri-Jean Bedford, dominatrix
A dominatrix says it is important that women in the sex trade are safe. She hopes these women will be treated with decency and respect and that they will be given the same rights as other citizens in Canada.
Power Play: MPs on the prostitution law
Liberal MP Marlene Jennings says she believes the Tories will appeal the decision relating to the prostitution law. NDP MP Libby Davies says this decision will break down the myths that this law actually protects sex workers.
CTV News Channel: Allan Young, law professor
Law professor Allan Young reacts to a decision by an Ontario court which has struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, saying they contribute to the danger faced by sex-trade workers. Professor Young says this is a resounding victory for women that prostitution is becoming 'even more legal.'

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (101) Facebook   

Terri-Jean Bedford, middle, and law professor Alan Young, third from left, react to a decision by an Ontario court that has struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Osgoode Hall law professor Alan young appears on CTV's Power Play from Toronto, on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Dominatrix Terri-Jean Bedford appears on CTV's Power Play from Toronto, on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Dominatrix Terri-Jean Bedford is calling it emancipation day for sex trade workers after an Ontario court struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010. Terri-Jean Bedford smiles to a decision by an Ontario court that has struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010.

Photos

Terri-Jean Bedford, middle, and law professor Alan Young, third from left, react to a decision by an Ontario court that has struck down key provisions of Canada's anti-prostitution laws, in Toronto Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2010.

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Sep. 28 2010 9:30 PM ET

An Ontario court has struck down several key provisions in Canada's anti-prostitution laws, saying they are dangerous to sex-trade workers.

A ruling by the Ontario Superior Court of Justice said the laws against keeping a common bawdy house, communicating for the purposes of prostitution and living on the avails of the trade "are not in accord with the principles of fundamental justice."

"These laws, individually and together, force prostitutes to choose between their liberty interest and their right to security of the person as protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms," Justice Susan Himel wrote her in 131-page decision, which struck down those provisions.

"I find that the danger faced by prostitutes greatly outweighs any harm which may be faced by the public."

Dominatrix Terri-Jean Bedford and two other sex-trade workers went to Ontario's Superior Court of Justice to ask the court to rule on the Criminal Code laws relating to prostitution.

In an afternoon press conference Bedford said Tuesday was like emancipation day for sex-trade workers.

"It's important that women have safety and security in this business," Bedford said later Tuesday on CTV's Power Play. "It is legal, and like with any other legal business in Canada there are health and safety laws that go along with it."

Prostitution is not illegal in Canada, but nearly everything related to it is.

The struck-down provisions deal with adult prostitution. Prostitution laws dealing with those under the age of 18 remain unaffected.

Lawyer Alan Young, who represented the women, said the ruling "means the sex trade is changing in Canada."

"Whether Canadians like prostitution and think it's morally valuable or a moral vice really is not important," Young told Power Play. "This was a safety issue to ensure that people who are legally allowed to sell sex can do it in an environment that doesn't put them in harm's way."

Young said the case was based on the fact that the provisions the court struck down compromised the safety of sex workers. For instance, the prohibition on communicating for the purpose of prostitution prevented sex workers from screening their clients, while the provision against operating a bawdy house prevented them from moving their business off the streets, where it is more dangerous.

In her ruling, Himel said Parliament had to "fashion corrective action" to put new laws in place.

"It is my view that in the meantime these unconstitutional provisions should be of no force and effect, particularly given the seriousness of the charter violations," Himel wrote.

"However, I also recognize that a consequence of this decision may be that unlicensed brothels may be operated, and in a way that may not be in the public interest."

The Christian Legal Fellowship, which was granted intervenor status, argued that prostitution "offends the conscience of ordinary Canadians."

The government argued removing the prohibitions without replacing them with new laws would "pose a danger to the public."

The decision is subjected to a 30-day stay and the federal government can seek an extension of that period.

The federal government has previously argued that prostitution is inherently dangerous, no matter where it is carried out.

It has also argued that striking down the laws would make Canada a sex tourism destination.

Rona Ambrose, the minister of state for the status of women, told reporters Tuesday the government is "concerned with the decision and we are seriously considering appealing it at this time."

Deputy NDP Leader Libby Davies said Tuesday's ruling "breaks down the myth that these laws were actually protecting sex workers and local communities, because not only were they not protecting sex workers, they were actually harmful."

Davies said she has often heard from her constituents in Vancouver's downtown eastside who say the provisions prevented them from reporting violence or exploitation.

"We need to distinguish between what is consenting between two adults and what is exploitative, coercive and violent and focus the law-enforcement on those aspects," Davies said.

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Jeff
said

When did prostitution become a profession. ? Is this a Univ. course.?


Gord
said

In the words of the great George Carlin"I could never understand why it is illegal to sell something that is perfectly legal to give away."


B.C. resident
said

If sex is legal, and selling is legal, then why shouldn't selling sex be legal?


kestral
said

suzanne,marijuana has been decriminalized, not legalized. find out the difference before you spout your hollier than thou attitude.also, bawdy houses have been around far far longer than same sex marriages. the one did not led to the other.pulling away from right wing church nuts running countries and moving towards using our brains has led to these things.


Richard in New Brunswick
said

As I read through these comments I don't know whether to laugh or cry. So many people "beaking off" about something they know so little about.Reminds me of the situation in Old England when the authorities banned bear baiting, not because the practise abused the bears but because watching the abuse gave so much pleasure to the onlookers.Prostitution is a legal business. It is a testament to the gutlessness and incompetence of our legislators that appropriate laws have never been formulated to regulate it as is the case with thousands of other businesses. If there's any shame attached to this entire issue it should be shame on the hypocrits we hire to run our country.


KT
said

I cannot believe how many religious whackos this has brought out. The sex trade will NEVER go away no matter what you do. Some people have already commented on how it is like trying to win the war on drugs. Lets all come back from LALA Land cause we know that will never happen. This judge has guts because I am sure that this was a tough decision but the laws surrounding prostitution in this country were totally idiotic. We have so many bigger issues to deal with in this country rather than busting hookers and johns.


Damon
said

All the against comments seem to miss the fact that the problems they are mentioning are all due to the fact that it is done underground and illegally.It can't be forced or its sexual assault. Under 18 is still completely illegal and anyone interested in legitimate prostitution wouldn't touch it. No legit pornographer deals in child pornography, it would be the same for prostitution.Also, this will definitely hurt the pimps more than help them. For protection, prostitutes can higher security guards / firms now, no pimp needed for that. They can also call the police if they are a victim of a crime without worrying about repercussions.


Scott ON
said

still all the comments about most of them don't choose to do this. Are you people deluded? Sure there are some forced into it but most do so by conscious decision. Welcome to the real world, these women have a product and are capitalizing on it. Not every prostitute has a pimp, stop watching so much friggin' TV. Regulating it would make the illegal stuff so much easier to ferret out and enforce


suzanne - Waterloo Ontario
said

I agree it should be legal, they should be taxed and forced to undergo health checks.I do question who would pay to do anything with either of the defendants however.


Tim
said

EmAB: "I wouldn't want my daughter working in a slaughterhouse either but that doesn't mean it should be illegal.Comparing a slaughterhouse and prostitution? A good comparison as both cattle and prostitutes are treated as meat by many. Sheesh!


Jagu
said

Job description and daily routine of Police officers revolves alot around the law enforcement on this issue of prostitution as they have undercover officers who also fights drugs. This will cause police job cuts for most municipalities - Recession


MJ
said

What a shame. Next they will be teaching how to be a lady of the night in our school systems. Can't wait to see who gets elected next as premier......


John
said

The problem that I have with this is that one judge [ who may or may not have a personal interest] is able to change our laws. Aren't they supposed to interpret and uphold our laws, not change and cancel laws? I think our justice system really needs to be looked at.


Frank
said

Legalize prostitution regulate it and tax the proceeds. It has always existed, and will continue to exist. It is not up to the state to impose morality through the legal system.


Brad
said

One thing the court have failed to do here is to look at the moral fibre of the soul!!! of the girls been exposed to this indecenscy. It is a grave move that impairs the alternative choices of future or growing girls. Now that the economy is pretty bad, wives, daughters, ladies, female students declaring "prostitution" as an alternative part-time income is going to rise!


Jade
said

I am ashamed to be a Canadian today. While it takes years to attempt to pass a bill on minimum sentencing to human trafficking in Canada, we arbitrarily condone prostituting. This is only exacerbating the issue in the wrong direction.


vick
said

For migsvers 2.0 Please remember your statement when McQuinty tries to pass the Shiria law again.


Tom
said

I would not want my daughter (if I had one) to be in the sex trade. I feel sorry for those that are forced in to the trade. For the most part these mothers ,daughters ,sisters are "kid"napped,runaways,down on their luck etc... They are then drugged and abused. Most do not wish to be doing this.


Rob in Waterloo
said

It's a free country. Just because you don't like prostitution dosen't give you the right to tell adults they can't have sex.... @ Candace lots of people hate their jobs and yes being a prostitute isn't the best career choice but what if a child came to you and said they want to be a walmart gretter or pump gas when they grow up? you'd be pretty upset, Candace there are lots of bad career choices in life.They've obviously had troubles in their lives and made bad choices but who are you to tell them they can't make a living. Everyone has to survive somehow, whether that be flipping burgers or selling themselves. In the end neither you or the government have any right to tell other people how to live their lives


Lady in Van
said

It seems quite a few people making comments on this story missed that Prostitution is legal in Canada and it already was. This court proceeding was not to legalize Prostitution it was to bring the Laws related to prostitution in line so there are safe options available for Prostitutes to conduct their business. This is a fantastic step forward! I applaud this decision.


EmAB
said

@Joel Cross and @Tim
I wouldn't want my daughter working in a slaughterhouse either but that doesn't mean it should be illegal.


Not a John
said

So, criminals (eg: prostitutes) are in danger due to their criminal activity, therefore we decriminalise their acts because it's against their human rights to not commit crimes? I'm sorry, but WTF?


Rob Canadian
said

As Canadians we think we are so far ahead of other countries but the sad part is we are still in the dark ages. Some of the people who made some of these comments shoild really get their heads out of the sand. Travel outside of North America and get up to speed on where the rest of the world is at. Such a sheltered life they live.


TLC
said

Reading some of these comments makes me sick. Why? Because I had a friend who ended up on the streets at 14. I never heard from her until they announced her body was discovered in a dumpster, naked. I was stunned. She would have been 19 that June. Turns out she was trying to get out of the "industry" and was moving on when a guy at a local bar decided to take her home. He choked her to death to the point that she threw up. Then he tried to vacuum the puke. The he put her naked body into the bathtub to scalled the body with hot water. Then he took her body and dumped it, naked, in a dumpster. I'll never forget going to the trial. He was a rich boy, with no remorse. She'd be 40. And you people want to legalize this?
As for "no religion", well, don't open that can of worms! Are you mental? Where do you think the first laws began, look up Exodus 20. Then ask yourself, okay, no "religion" ... cool... whose conscience will you use as a guide, because obviously we all see things different, what a mess. Stupid comment.
Lastly, let's say Mr. and Mrs. Smith are happily married, he loses his job, can't find one for months. Neither can she. "Hey, honey, the only way I see for us to make rent this month is if you go to the new brothol." The wife, reluctantly agrees because it seems like the only legal option she's got...do we really want to encourage this life style? It's not gonna be any safer, don't fool yourselves.
I could go on but...


Richard D
said

Should the government fail in their appeal of this, I have a suspicion that prostitution will be declared illegal all across the board. It'll still be in keeping with the Constitution, after all. Be careful what you wish for, people. Harper is not known for his forgiving nature.


Jason
said

The question should be, "Would it please you if your child became a 'legal' prostitute when they came of age?" Does this mean, once regulated, that unregulated prostitutes would be illegal? Will prostitution become more prevalent, and will that cause it's associated negative consequences (drugs, STDs, etc)to increase as well? Can we hope that prices level out, since prostitution is ridiculously expensive and requires minimal skills? These folks should really be making no more than $40.00 per hour, I say!


Stan the Man
said

I think we should start something to give a little protection to the girls. We could call it " The institude for destitude prostitudes " They need something to be on their side


Rob P
said

Most of these comments clearly show that most have not even read the article they are commenting on!

Simply put, and I quote from the article above "Prostitution is not illegal in Canada, but nearly everything related to it is. "

Therefore the issue here is not that prostitution is Now Legal, instead the issue here is that all the laws surrounding prostitution have been struck down. For example, "living off the avails of a sex worker" is one of these stupid laws that was just struck down by this very logical and open minded Judge. This is such a stupid law because it states that a sex worker cannot use her income to provide for her family since that family would be "living off the avails" of this sex worker.

Do you see now why these stupid laws have been struck down. It is about time! Justice finally has shown its beautiful face.


Sorry
said

Prostitution is human trafficking. Today wasn't "emancipation" day for hookers in Canada, today pimps and those who buy and sell human beings got a big break. If we are going to make it easier to traffic in humans we might as well bring back slavery.


zm
said

After exporting all geniune jobs to China and similar countries has our wonderful government decided to create more jobs by legalizing prostitution in Canada? How nice really.


Ken P.
said

The Charter of Rights and Freedoms works both ways folks....like it or not, we are stuck with Trudeau's screw up.


Scott ON
said

A couple questions. How is it that everyone knows so much about why people become prostitutes? Do you really think that they are all forced and coerced. Or are all drug addicts? I'm sorry but I went to university with a few girls who sold themselves on a regular basis. And you know what, we've got a doctor and a lawyer in that group. People need to get off their high horse. You people say you wouldn't want your daughter doing it. Neither would I, but I wouldn't want mine working at McDonalds either. And how many of you know how many sexual partners your daughter has. Promiscuity isn't much different than prostitution, you're just not getting paid.


Scott ON
said

@ Candace... 95% of prostitutes want out? Really, you know many? I'm sorry but sites like craigslist and whatnot are filled with ads from people that post them on their own. Give me a break


Ed
said

It is known as the oldest profession the world over; it is time that we accepted it and ensured that proper laws are in place regarding health and work issues like any other profession. Also, it is impossible to legislate human behaviour. Most European countries have a logical approach to the issue.


John in Nepean
said

Prostitutes will be thanking Trudeau and the Liberal Party by offering a free ride to any card-carrying Liberal. Some conditions apply.


Scott ON
said

@ Carl - You do realize that being forced into something prostitution ( it was never illegal ) doesn't change the fact that you can go to the police. Being held against your own will is another type of crime altogether. Give me a break


Jb
said

Don't charge the prostitutes.. charge the johns... if the users of the service are charged... then demand may lower.. which will decrease the sex trade, pimps, and human trafficking


syko
said

A lot of wives are going to find out there husbands have a taste for the now legal product.


Suzanne
said

This is a place to start asking the cops to disobey the law and continue bursting those bawdy houses out of moral concience. It is like daylight abomination. We saw this coming when Marijuanna was legalized, when homo sexual marriages was approved, it just keeps coming. Guard your hearts


Josh in High Prairie
said

Going to prove the courts are full of idiots. Stop protecting the trade and make it fully criminal. The prostitutes would be safer not doing it by far than any provisions will make the job for them.


Bubba says legalize it. Protect the victims.
said

We should legalize it, and make rules for health testing, and keeping the criminal element out. WOmen should not have to go out on the streets to get business. They should be able to practice in a safe environment.

There is really no direct victim here, and no reason for the legal system to be involved.

I would never use these services, even if they were legalized, but if some people wish to use it, they should not be subject to abuse by the pimps, or police.

Frank
said

I think it would be appropriate to start requesting HIV/STD, Drug test certification. The embarassing thing is no one not even the government can measure or regulate what type of service is been provided, even involving Better Business Bureau for a disatisfied customer is really embarassing.


Rob
said

Legalize it,clean it up collect taxes and cut mine. Its been around thousands of years and its not going to change.


Michael (Ottawa)
said

Pathetic !! ...Truly pathetic.


Tim
said

For those who are defending this idiotic judgment, would you want your daughter to work as a prostitute if the prostitution industry is so legit? No? I didn't think so.


BigDS
said

Some stated "Religion has no place in making our laws"Well then let us drop all our laws, thay all came originally from religion!What is next, all laws toward women made nul and void. Let them kill thier husbands after they visit a brothel. We can give them all medals! Prostetion is a crime should remain a crime and the women who choose that career should be locked up and reeducated! But lying on thier back is easier and higher paying than a real job!


Joel Cross
said

I'm dumbfounded to hear that people are willing to allow their daughters to become prostitutes just to make an easy buck. Don't you want to encourage girls to have more respect for themselves. Its funny when people say that drugs, gambling and prostitution doesn't hurt anybody. If you believe that you must have a very unbalanced lifestyle. Because, anybody that I know going through these addictions are probably hurting people. Does anybody have a moral compass anymore?


Gilbert in Ottawa
said

Just an other example that Canada is NOT a democracy, but rather an Authocracy (An autocracy is a form of government in which one person possesses unlimited power). In this case the court (non elected judges) stike down laws passed by elected governments. By the way, our neibours to the south are also an authocracy... Intereting society we live in. Where judges and courts are not about justice, but rather points of law and who can find a loop-hole wins...


Steve
said

Prostitution is the oldest profession in the world and its not going to go away... ignoring it, covering it up or hiding it isnt going to help either. Its time we legalize it, tax it and control it!! Im jealous of prostitutes, insofar as being able to perform services, get paid for it and not have to pay a dime of income tax!! Worse still are the John's that get punished but not the prostitutes!! Yet the prostitutes have access to all of the benefits availed to those of us that do pay income tax! As for the prostitution services itself, its time we grow up and bring the country out of the closet and into the real world! Imagine the court system being freed up not too mention police services that could better service the public in serving and protecting us from real crimes against humanity... put it to a referendum... I have no doubt it will be an overwhelming in favour for!


MT
said

There is the inherent supposition by many here that the sex trade in and of itself does not harm women (the idea that if it's legal and protected, sex trade workers are safer); while the reality shows sex trade workers are usually coerced, abused, and suffer from a variety of addictions and illnesses such as depression and anxiety. Many have histories of child abuse. So back up the train - before we consider if legalization makes it safer, shouldn't we be looking at the fact that for most prostitutes, the very trade hurts them? JB talks about an "ideal world" - we base laws on striving for the ideal, not on the fact that the world isn't ideal. Otherwise we would legalize every crime on the basis we don't live in an "ideal world."


melted time
said

It's time to take religiously based morality out of governance completely. This is an excellent first step. People should have the right to do with their bodies as they see fit. A crime should have to have a victim, it should be essential to the definition of a crime. There is no victim in prostitution, nor in drug use, nor in gambling. It is beyond time that we recognize the basic human right to make bad decisions. Let's focus on real crime, those of property, life and the infringement on another human beings rights.


Cam
said

I've never paid for sex & probably never will, but see no wrong if that's what someone wants to do. Legal sex might even reduce the number of rapes. I don't believe in forcing my opinion on anyone. Now take the right wing-nuts that's their main agenda is forcing their opinion on everyone around them. The gun nuts for instance want to be able to walk around with unregistered guns but they also want it law that I can't smoke pot. The more the government & other people stay out of other peoples lives, the better off this world is.


daryn
said

Ok now the law is gone (oh and Guy I agree with you fully) Let's start making regulations to limit these bawdy houses. Make sure that the prostitutes are not being paid well and there is regular health care involved.


Captain Sarcasm
said

Great decision. We should also strike down laws against robbing banks, because those laws create a danger for liquidity-liberating workers. I mean, all they're trying to do is making a living and the police might end up shooting them while they try to carry out their trade!


Sam C
said

@ MiggsVer2.0 and RealityCzech... uh, most of our laws COME FROM "Religion." Does "Thou Shalt Not Steal" sound familiar?


shawbrooke
said

And who wants to live next door to a brothel? A lack of, and unenforced, regulation was tried in Canada in the twenties and it was awful. Read James Gray's book Red Lights on the Prairies. As a result of constant trouble, the cities herded brothels into specific areas and things got worse. Then as now, prostitutes get through their lives by using drugs and alcohol, and johns threaten other women. Maybe there should be stiff fines for paying for sex, that may lead more johns to be discreet and leave other women alone. I know of not one woman who wants to be accosted, the judges have made life less safe for all other women. Wait till a brothel move in next to their toney residences.


Tricia
said

@Eric - I completely agree @RealityCzech - Any time something of controversy comes up, religious folks have their muddy paws all over it. The article even states "The Christian Legal Fellowship, which was granted intervenor status, argued that prostitution "offends the conscience of ordinary Canadians." I'm not interested in having the church speak for me. I have to agree with MiggsVer2.0 that religion has no place in the way we make our laws. As for all of these people claiming it's abuse - well ya when there is no one there to protect them because they are doing it in an unsafe place to avoid being caught. There are legal brothels in other areas of the world that are successful CLEAN businesses. I was watching a documentary on it one night and some of the workers have regulars that they actually enjoy seeing. Not everyone is an abused victim.


James
said

Here's hoping that the government will create some intelligent laws relating to prostituion. We need productive laws that regulate and tax prostitution, not silly laws that compound the negative issues without creating and positive one.

Linda
said

Wayne - do you really think that there aren't any male prostitutes, or that other women and couples don't avail themselves of female prostitutes? Really???


Candace
said

To those who say prostitution is just another career choice:

That means your child could come to you and say they want a career in the sex trade.

Does that change your feeling about it at all?

As to 'needs' being met...the need to control a person; by simply paying money, the johns can get whatever they want.

95% of prostitutes want out. The 5% who made this a 'choice' came from families and backgrounds where they were repeatedly told they were no good and of no value.

Some choice.

W in the GTA
said

Since the courts are preoccupied with the "bizare" situation concerning the legality of prostitution in Canada an obvious response is to outlaw it.If prostitiution is now illegal there is no right to security of person during the commission of an offence under the criminal code.Prostitution could be made illegal as a means of protecting those who may be forced into the trade as well as to attempt to curb the transmission of STD/STI. A prohibition on prostitution would further the governmnets agenda of protecting Canadian society and would be a reasonable limit on an individuals personal liberty.Similarly, a firm mandatory sentence of 12 years for those found guilty of "pimping" or human trafficing may give the government a useful tool to combat the victimization of women and children.Lastly if an individual wants to live in a country with red light districts and where the tax payer foots the bill for sex trade related healthcare costs and testing then happy trails!


Daniel
said

Some people are saying this is a moral issue. It is not. Everyone has a different set of morals based on how they were raised, their religion, and times in which we live. Many things that were once considered morally justified, are now morally repugnant, and vice versa.This is about the rights of sex-trade workers to be able ply their trade without fear. As prostitution itself was never illegal, these laws were ridiculous anyway


Julian
said

I love how the man haters come out of the woodwork every time an issue like this comes up.

Women use these services too ladies.
So you can drop the "men this" and "men that" redirect.

I've never used these types of services, but I see no reason why they should be illegal.
Who are you people to dictate what two consenting adults can or cannot do with each other behind closed doors?

And for those talking about the abuse of women, not only are many of your comments discriminatory against men, but you completely miss the fact that a regulated system would be far safer for all adults involved, and help to reduce levels of violence and child prostitution as well.

Just because it makes you uncomfortable, doesn't mean it should be illegal.


Terry
said

Does this mean McGuinty and company havent heard of prostituition in Ontario, OH my he will be getting out his calculator, here's another tax coming.


Amberin Sask....
said

I think it is time that safety and police aid are regulated among these women....It is a choice that they have made (one way or another) and deserves the credibility and equality that all other 'legal" jobs have. emplyment insurance and Pregnancy leave are still something to be worked out.....This occupation has been around since Mary Magdelene....And she was not condemned!! I think instilling a safety policy is a smart move and congratulations Ladies!....Now to make sure all the women also get regular screening, and can the customer get the same as well??


Tony
said

Turning Ontario to Nevada? is that the new conspiracy?


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

"a sex tourism destination" you say.... I see a really interesting vacation ad campaign looking for a STIMULUS grant.....


Jagu
said

This is highly inappropriate ruling. If we have lost our moral fibre that is when this type of ruling goes on. When will parliament re-enact this law??I dont mind the cycle if re-enacted as it will take another 12 yrs before another judge stkes it down


Wayne
said

The very idea that a man can "BUY" a woman is itself demeaning and dehumanizing. So much for protecting gender equality. Where are all the wacko feminists when you need them?


steve in wildrose country
said

the old laws "force prostitutes to choose between their liberty interest and their right to security". Nonsense! Nobody ever has to be a prostitute ( I am not talking about human trafficking ). For a judge to loosen the laws against prostitution and thus encouraging it as a social norm is sick and wrong. Nobody should ever be treated as an object to be used and then discarded by their fellow human.


laureen
said

to coolmankenStop using women! They are people not objects for selfish pleasures.


Rick in NB, Ste marie
said

@ coolmanken, you and your friends should invest some time in discovering self worth. My guess is, you are searchijng for a beautiful looking person, not a beautiful person.


Carl
said

Some people say you should decriminalize prostitution because it will never be eliminated by criminal sanctions. The same argument is often made about drug use, but it does not make sense in either case. Criminal sanctions will never eliminate rape or theft or murder either, but that is no argument for decriminalizing those activities. We should be focusing on whether criminal sanctions against prostitution are good public policy. By striking down the laws against operating brothels, the Judge has made it impossible for those who are forced into prostitution to seek the intervention of police against their pimps. Truly tragic.


Albertaboy111
said

Now lets put some real regulation in place on where they can keep them, cleanliness of the workers, as well as mandatory STI testing, and make them pay taxes!


Anne
said

Such a pathetic "occupation". If men wouldn't use them (and it is the lowest form of the word "use"), we wouldn't have prostitutes. A world of delusion, paying someone to pretend to like you for sex. It should remain as a crime, the last thing we need is some kind of legitimacy to the abuse of women.


russ
said

Free of choice! Plain and simple.


Adam
said

The degradation of women and sexual abuse of minors. For shame! Citizens of Ontario....stand up and fight against this for the sake of your women and children who are victims of this abuse,


Bruce from Alberta
said

I like laws that protect people from other people, murder, theft, drinking driving etcNever been a huge fan of laws that protect people from them selves. Drugs, seat belts and this issue.If your not hurting anyone else by your actions it should not be illigal. But it should be controlled as not to influence people.


scott
said

Time for "holier than thou" canadians to come down from their high horse. Prostitution has been "legal" in this country for a long time. Every one knows that these so called escort agencies and massage parlors are nothing more than fronts for prostitution but as long as their activities are kept out of sight then neither the federal or provincial governments give a damn. Given that the government is actually collecting tax from prostitution, their stand against it is absurd to say the least. It is common knowledge that not only the corporate elite but members of our own government use these "services" routinely and need I remind you that is our tax dollars that they are using to pay for it.


Kevin in Vancouver
said

The main problem here is that now it will be perfectly legal for adults to proposition anyone 18 years or older for sex. And you thought catcalls and leers were distasteful....hey baby $100.00 if you..........


Jenni
said

Anyone know how many prostitutes are first introduced to the sex trade before they turn 18? 75% was the last stat I heard. The average sex trade worker starts at age 15. Now add the layer of addictions and coercion that so often exist within the sex trade. It would appear to me that though 'sex between two consenting adults' is a good idea, the reality is that underage people (sometimes males, more often females) are lured into or coerced into a trade that is difficult to escape when they reach the age of majority. If we are going to make it easier to get into the sex trade, we had best take responsibility for also making it easier to get OUT. I fear that this court ruling takes into account only one tip of the ice berg.


macpriest
said

Logical as it may seem..............I still can't carry a pistol to protect myself; from the criminals. But the courts can once again re-define a country based on a illegal activity. Who the #$%^ is in charge anyways?


Sunny West Coast Again
said

It's about time someone stepped forward to understand protitution is a business and should be formally legalized so women and men can safely conduct their business off the streets and in safe places of business where their medical and other needs can be properly be addressed. Thank you Canada's legal system. Obviously the pure conservatives will be outraged once again about the "sins of the flesh." We are human animals, not a species above all others; we are unique as are other species but we all share the same needs.


Toronto
said

You want to seal the "cracks in the morals" of society? Start by banning spending on military hardware - things intended purely to kill and terrorize. Or how about actually enforcing green house gas laws, in order to preserve the planet we live on? Or how about actually punishing people who commit corporate crime and fraud instead of just fining them a pittance that they can pay in a single stroke of the pen?If you're worried about the degradation of morals in our society, you shouldn't look at drugs, prostitution, or queers. You only need to look at corporations, the military-industrial complex, and our plundering and pillaging of the earth.


Cobra
said

heres the problem....Ya cant legalize it because ya cant tax it. If it was legal and being taxed, what stops women or men from haveing back door sex or making the cash under the table so to speak? Its always going to have a fraud problem attached to it. And on top of it all...who do you think is going to foot the bill for the medical checkups on these prostitutes on a regular basis? We are, the tax payers. I see nothing wrong with getting paid for a job well done...however, leave this one alone, your stirring the pot!


RealityCzech
said

Miggs Ver2.0 said: "Religion has no place when it comes to making our laws." 'Scuse me? What does this have to do with religion?


viral venus
said

Sex for sale is a business like any other and should be conducted as such. The basic rules of supply and demand and all other business functions can be appled (ie licensing, regulation, health standards, worker protections including not allowing children as workers) so it is only our moral squemishness at the "product" being sold that stands in the way of sex workers being business people instead of criminals. Many European nations figured this out long ago and have an infrastructure in place that protects both sex workers and their clients from disease and violence. As long as men have penises and some are too immature or lazy to get their sexual gratification from partners willing to service them without an outlay of cash, there will be sex for sale and it may as well be safe and regulated. A common sense ruling that will be decried by some in our sexually repressed society.


DON
said

When you get married your paying for sex to.So where does the law stop.When the CANADIAN GOVERNMENT don't make any money.


CraigW
said

I am always amused when people who prevail in making it easier to become prostitutes think they are better off. I can't think of a better example of "Be careful what you wish for".


coolmanken
said

All I know for men in my situation -- single, poor, no women in this city willing go out with me. The only way for me to have a bit of sex are from the prostitutes. Some of my married friends are also using their services, since their spouses are not always in the mood.


Ron from Georgetown
said

So people committing a crime in Canada have a constitutional right to security. Only in Canada you say.


BC boy
said

The next step that lowlife officials in Ontario will take is failure to properly oppose the slave trade. Prostitution is also legal in Israel and the slave trade is hardly opposed.


Nolan Moore
said

Typical left wing judges. While it may be some cases "force" them to the streets. Thats' a farce. There will still be those on the streets. The houses exist and are illegal. Just one more crack in the morals of our society.


MiggsVer2.0
said

Religion has no place when it comes to making our laws.


spaz
said

After Dalton McGuinty gave the green light to mixed martial arts, he will be giving the green light here as well. Besides.......look at all the HST money he will rake in.......customers will be able to "charge it" on their next trip to the bawdy house.Just wondering.........could I get "air miles" as well ???


10-78
said

Everybody has sex. If an agreement is struck for cash between two consenting adults, what business is it of ours? The only crime I see is the failure to claim income. I say license it and tax it. The government should provide safe places to conduct business, provide health care for the prostitutes and monopolize the industry. A legal brothel would mean taxes for the government, CPP and old age pension for the prostitutes and increase community safety by eliminating illegal brothels.


Guy
said

If you pay someone to have sex it is prostitution and illegal. If you pay someone to have sex but video tape it is porn and legal. Stupid.


Roger in Courtice
said

"However, I also recognize that a consequence of this decision may be that unlicensed brothels may be operated, and in a way that may not be in the public interest."

You think???


JB in Ontario
said

In a perfect world there would be no prostitution. In a perfect world people's needs would be met.


Someone
said

I recommend we also strike down laws against thievery! They're actively contributing towards the danger faced by thieves!

Eric
said

Gotta say, I don't disagree. You aren't going to get rid of prostitutes, it's like trying to achieve a 100 per cent victory in the war on drugs. It isn't going to happen. That being said, why not give 'em somewhere safe to be? It's no worse than safe-injection sites and at least these women are working for their money.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Police confirm body parts sent to Ottawa from Montreal

More   4 Comments 4    5 Video(s) 5

Hacking

Official claims Iran has defeated powerful 'Flame' virus

More   13 Comments 13    1 Video(s) 1

Vic Toews, Public Safety Minister, and Jason Kenney, Minister of Citizenship, make an announcement related to terrorism research funding during a press conference in the foyer of the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Ottawa pledges $1.1M to counter-terrorism research

More   1 Comments 1  

Most Talked about Stories

While Branson's comments (and activities) are arrogant in a million different ways, Clark's response was admirable. She kept her sense of humour with her joke about Branson's brand-name and his bad pick-up line, showing why humour is often the best response to arrogance.

D Austin (Fredericton)

B.C. premier rebuffs Branson's naked kitesurfing invite