Top Stories -   

1
U.S. Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi arrives in Canada for meetings with environmentalists the premiers of energy producing of provinces, Wednesday, Sept. 8, 2010. A protester sits in front of a Canadian flag as she has molasses poured on her to simulate oil from Alberta's oilsands during a protest on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday September 8, 2010. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Approximately a dozen protesters gather on Parliament Hill to demonstrate against the Alberta oil sands in Ottawa, Wednesday, Sept. 8, 2010. Meanwhile, Nancy Pelosi, one of the most powerful lawmakers in the United States, has come to Canada's capital to chat about the oilsands with premiers and federal officials. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)   Oil sands

Pelosi to hear both sides of oilsands debate in Ottawa

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Robert Fife on Pelosi's visit
Nancy Pelosi, one of the most powerful politicians in the United States, travelled to Ottawa Wednesday night. Pelosi is meeting with key Canadian leaders to discuss Alberta's oil sands development.
CTV Edmonton: Kevin Armstrong on the meeting
Premier Ed Stelmach says he will use his time with U.S. politician Nancy Pelosi to discuss Alberta's oilsands.
CTV News Channel: Jane Taber, Globe and Mail
A correspondent with the Globe and Mail says the meeting will be an opportunity for Stelmach to make his case that the oilsands are an important source of oil that will help the sluggish U.S. economy by creating jobs in the country.
Power Play: Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall
The premier says he wants to further discuss the trading relationship with the U.S. involving the energy sector with Nancy Pelosi. He also wants to discuss investments in the technological solutions that Western Canada has created to reduce carbon footprints.
Power Play: Panel of environment experts
The executive director of Environmental Defense Rick Smith says Ed Stelmach owes Canadian an apology. The vice president of policy environment for the CAPP Tom Huffaker says Nancy Pelosi will receive a balance discussion and perspective about the oilsands.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (22) Facebook   

U.S. Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi arrives in Canada for meetings with environmentalists the premiers of energy producing of provinces, Wednesday, Sept. 8, 2010. A protester sits in front of a Canadian flag as she has molasses poured on her to simulate oil from Alberta's oilsands during a protest on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday September 8, 2010. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Approximately a dozen protesters gather on Parliament Hill to demonstrate against the Alberta oil sands in Ottawa, Wednesday, Sept. 8, 2010. Meanwhile, Nancy Pelosi, one of the most powerful lawmakers in the United States, has come to Canada's capital to chat about the oilsands with premiers and federal officials. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)   Oil sands

Photos

U.S. Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi arrives in Canada for meetings with environmentalists the premiers of energy producing of provinces, Wednesday, Sept. 8, 2010.

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Sep. 8 2010 11:00 PM ET

Speaker of the House of Representatives Nancy Pelosi is meeting with both promoters and critics of Western Canada's controversial oilsands development, during a trip to Ottawa this week.

Pelosi, who is considered one of the most powerful politicians on Capitol Hill and has a track record of voting in favour of environmentally friendly legislation, met with Canada's environment minister and the premiers of Alberta, Saskatchewan and Quebec on Wednesday evening.

Sources who attended the meeting told CTV News that Pelosi appeared knowledgeable about the oilsands and expressed serious concerns about them.

Alberta Premier Ed Stelmach said he would use his meeting to "appeal to her sense of reason, to communicate very clearly that we continue to be focused on environmental improvement in developing the oilsands," he said on Tuesday.

"Environment is the first and most important issue," Stelmach said, adding that he plans to remind Pelosi that Canada is the largest supplier of energy into the U.S.

Alberta officials have met with U.S. politicians before, and the provincial government has an office in Washington to lobby U.S. officials on the province's oil and gas industry. But Pelosi's visit marks the first time that Alberta officials will meet her.

But as the oilsands have expanded, so too has controversy about their environmental impacts and potential health effects -- something underscored by anti-oilsands protest that took place in Ottawa as the veteran Democrat arrived earlier on Wednesday.

Pelosi will meet with environmental and First Nations groups on Thursday, and they're expected to paint a less rosy picture of the oilsands.

One of those groups is Environmental Defence, whose executive director, Rick Smith, took issue with Stelmach's characterization of the oilsands, saying that the premier "owes Canadians an apology" for "pretending that there's any environmental concern in the tarsands industry within the ranks of the Alberta government."

Smith alluded to the latest in a line of reports that suggest the environmental impact of the oilsands may be much more severe than government or industry estimates indicate.

Representatives from Environmental Defence plan to tell Pelosi "that the customer is always right, that very clearly this is an industry, this is a provincial government that are not going to move on these issues unless they're pushed."

"We're very much hoping that, as the tarsands industry harbours this ambition of dramatic growth into the United States, the U.S. government takes advantage of that position to say, ‘Look, you can't continue with business as usual -- you have to seriously address dramatic reduction in your pollution levels,'" Smith said.

Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall and Quebec Premier Jean Charest also attended the Wednesday evening meeting.

Wall told CTV's Power Play that Canadian officials need to drive home that jobs in the U.S. as well as Canada are tied up in development plans for the oilsands -- including of a proposed pipeline that would feed the U.S. market.

"If the sabres of protectionism are rattled, or even heaven-forbid drawn, this has an impact on jobs in America, much as it does in Canada," he said. "This is a point we have to make."

While Saskatchewan currently has no commercial oilsands projects, Wall said that the province has about 10,000 square kilometres of land that could be exploited for that purpose.

He said he also plans to address the use of environmental technologies such as carbon sequestration to minimize the environmental affects of extracting so-called "heavy oil" when he meets with Pelosi.

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

PBW
said

If Pelosi persuades the US to boycott Alberta's oil, I guess Alberta could always fund a pipeline to a deep-water west coast port - accessible to Japanese and Chinese tankers . . .


TEA in SK
said

Pelosi - the lame duck speaker of the house with a lame duck president after only 2 years...who cares?


Ben, Edmonton
said

It is immensely aggravating to watch what is truly, truly, TRULY a carefully-executed, sustainable, environmentally responsible industry be picked apart by environmentalist (read: anti-oil industry lobbyists) and media lies. It actually blows my mind that people listen to them AT ALL.


Terry
said

Alberta needs to stop paying the transfer payments so other provinces can have a hand out. What other province in Canada has contributed more to other provinces and the economy of this country?NONE!Maybe it is time to say to the rest, if you don't support us than we will stop supporting you.


Spence in Ontario
said

We already know that there are serious issues over the oil sands that were not addressed. Beyond just the huge emissions they create and water and energy used in extraction there are quite a few other concerns that have come to light recently. The report about the improper handling of so called tar ponds and oil affecting the local watershed and the harm to birds. The government in Alberta likely has been aware of these issues for years and has not addressed them and I doubt our federal gov't will address it either, especially when both the PM and environment minister have a huge conflict of interest due to being in ridings with plenty of oil businesses.


Nolan Moore
said

Ed isnt' quite the right "spokesman" for Alberta. For those of you who think that there will be a "waste land the size of Britian" gear up on your geography. The oil sands area being used is about a third that size. The propogandists (is that a word?) were called on that error. Yes the early days of development, open pit, wasnt the best for the environment but todays technology helps to take out the bitumen with a minimal impact. The energy companies just need to put more money into reclamation. The areas will be cleaner than when they first came. Think trying to eat foot grown up there in oil soak soil, 100 years ago. 100 years from now it will be pure clean soil.


GUTSHOT!! in Thunder Bay
said

Pelosi would help the world the most if she just kept her mouth closed.


Ace
said

I cannot see one bit of good coming out of the meeting with Pelosi. She will smile and nod and then go home and carve Eddy (Alberta) a new ass. She is a dangerous back stabbing elitist without a clue and even at that 'Topsoil' is no match for her.

allan
said

Pelosi will be politically polite while here, then dump on Alberta when she gets back to her socialsit tribe. David Suzuki will probably present her with a dead duck. Get lost Pelosi!


Redneck Vic
said

Who the hell cares what she or any other American thinks? If they do not like sell it to China or any body else that wants it and there are many!


Alberta Tar Pits
said

Me thinks Eddy's gonna be doin' a whole lotta lyin'.


sarah
said

Ah, the yanks. Always complaining about ensuring energy independence but refusing to mine their own coal or build safe and efficient nuclear plants. Always yammering about ending reliance on middle east oil and saudi sheiks who wave with one hand while funding terrorists with the other, but getting upset with 'dirty' albertan oil. You are your own problem, cousins, and you are doomed to failure as a result.


anson5
said

Ed wake up. There is no way that a liberal politician from San Francisco is going to listen to what you have to say. Her was already made up about the oil sands and will not change. especially in an election year.


Mike
said

Take a look in your own back yard before making demands of others. Once your act is clean you can then preach. In the meantime you can stop buying our oil and rely on those nice suppliers like Iran, Saudi Arabia, Venezuala, etc. I.m sure we can find some new customers to replace you.


Colleen in BC
said

While the environment is indeed of huge import, everyone needs to remember our civilization is not yet ready to turf the use of oil in our everyday lives. Yes, we need to look to alternatives, but please don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. We are not there yet. The environmentalists need to get a grip and quit whining. And the US needs to learn to look after its own house before it tries to run someone else's.

Jim Kane
said

These are serious issues with serious economic implications. I trust Ed will represent the people of Alberta well. A sustainable environment for future generations must be reflected as a TOP priority by both the provincial and federal governments. The track record leaves lots of room for serious doubts and questions.


Gilbert in Ottawa
said

...and last year, our governments (US & Canada) spent billions saving the american automobile industry.... you seriously think that they will shut down their oil supply (gazoline) to feed those cars and pickup trucks drive everyday??? Reality check people, money and oil always talks louder than the environment and always will for the forseeable future.


Jon in London ON
said

Pelosi will supply platitudes to Stelmach. Her real agenda is to implement cap and trade - carbon credit trading - the failed and thoroughly discredited efforts of Al Gore and the AGW crowd.My bet........Pelosi will come out against the oilsands and expect us to drink the koolaid propaganda of the enviromental left. Remember - James Jay Lee was a follower of Al Gore. 'nuff said.


Paul
said

The yanks need to learn a lesson. They do not rule here. Everyone who is against Alberta oil, please stop driving, taking buses, using a computer or any other item that contains any plastic or runs on power. Alberta needs to look for other customers of its oil. Having one customer, the US, with such a large share is dangerous for business.


Gareth Hitchings
said

The so-called Government of Alberta is little more than a lobby group for big foreign oil these days. But a hundred years from now there will be no more money, no more jobs, just a giant stinking toxic waste land the size of Britain. May god forgive us, because our grandchildren surely won't.


Adam
said

Pelosi, keep your nose out of Alberta's business.Liberal media, stop trying to bring the economy of Alberta down with fear-mongoring. It is all about jealousy that the province is faring better than the east. Time to fight back Alberta.


Dave S Calgary
said

Eddy, try not to embarrass Albertans anymore than you already have


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

RCMP, EMS and Fire crews on the scene of a bus rollover on Hwy. 28 near Redwater, Alta., on Friday, Feb. 10, 2012. ( Bill Fortier / CTV News)

Bus filled with people rolls over on Alberta highway

More  2 Video(s) 2

Crime tape blocks the scene of a fatal shooting at the Deerfield Beach recreational vehicle park in Florida on Friday, Feb. 10, 2012.

Canadian killed in Florida campground shooting

More  3 Video(s) 3

Most Talked about Stories

I think he was pushed to take matters into his own hands. I have a teenage son and if he was involved with a drug dealer I would be furious and try anything to save him like this father did for his daughter. Why do police often say they can't do anything until it's too late? Whether it be a drug dealer or an abusive spouse, the police can't seem to do anything until something really bad happens. In this case they could have raided the drug dealers home and arrested him. The whole town knew what was going on in that house but yet the police chose to do nothing. Release this man and give him a medal for doing the right thing by his daughter. I can't wait to see the episode on W5, I will certainly be watching this one.

Shelley

W5: How far would you go to save your child?