Top Stories -   

1
The Deepwater Horizon oil rig is seen burning in this aerial photo taken in the Gulf of Mexico, southeast of Venice, La. on  April 21, 2010. (AP / Gerald Herbert) Oil containment boom is seen with fresh oil near Comfort Island, in Yscloskey, La. Saturday, July 31, 2010. (AP / Judi Bottoni) In a photo made from video provided by BP PLC, oil emerges from the damage wellhead in the Gulf of Mexico on Wednesday, July 14, 2010. In a photo made from video provided by BP PLC, oil emerges from the damage wellhead in the Gulf of Mexico on Wednesday, July 14, 2010.

'Multiple companies' contributed to oil spill, says BP

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: BNN's Michael Kane on BP
BP has released a report on the Gulf oil spill saying they were partially responsible, but also noting there's enough blame to go around.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (11) Facebook   

The Deepwater Horizon oil rig is seen burning in this aerial photo taken in the Gulf of Mexico, southeast of Venice, La. on  April 21, 2010. (AP / Gerald Herbert) Oil containment boom is seen with fresh oil near Comfort Island, in Yscloskey, La. Saturday, July 31, 2010. (AP / Judi Bottoni) In a photo made from video provided by BP PLC, oil emerges from the damage wellhead in the Gulf of Mexico on Wednesday, July 14, 2010. In a photo made from video provided by BP PLC, oil emerges from the damage wellhead in the Gulf of Mexico on Wednesday, July 14, 2010.

Photos

The Deepwater Horizon oil rig is seen burning in this aerial photo taken in the Gulf of Mexico, southeast of Venice, La. on  April 21, 2010. (AP / Gerald Herbert)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Sep. 8 2010 12:42 PM ET

Oil giant BP isn't the only company to blame for the massive oil spill that has polluted waters off the Gulf of Mexico, according to an investigation by the organization.

Instead "multiple companies" are to blame for a sequence of failures that involve failed human judgement, engineering design, mechanical failures and operational implementation, the 193-paged report says.

The report was commissioned after a sea floor oil rig exploded on April 20, 2010, causing the largest accidental spill in history. About 4.9 million barrels of crude oil were released into the gulf before it was capped on July 15.

Eleven platform workers were killed in the explosion and 17 others were injured.

The report, which was made public on Wednesday, noted a chain reaction of failed incidents that led to the explosion and continued after the fire had been set.

"Even after explosion and fire had disabled its crew-operated controls, the rig's blow-out preventer on the sea-bed should have activated automatically to seal the well," the report says. "But it failed to operate, probably because critical components were not working."

BP's outgoing CEO Tony Hayward explained in an internal memo that the design of the Maconda well was not flawed.

"To put it simply, there was a bad cement job and a failure of the shoe track barrier at the bottom of the well, which let hydrocarbons from the reservoir into the production casing. The negative pressure test was accepted when it should not have been, there were failures in well control procedures and in the blow-out preventer; and the rig's fire and gas system did not prevent ignition.

"Based on the report, it would appear unlikely that the well design contributed to the incident, as the investigation found that the hydrocarbons flowed up the production casing through the bottom of the well," he continued.

BP's findings sparked some criticism from U.S. officials.

Congressman Edward Markey (D-Mass.) issued a statement Wednesday from Ottawa where he is visiting, saying he was skeptical about BP-funded investigation.

"This report is not BP's mea culpa," he said. "Of their own eight key findings, they only explicitly take responsibility for half of one. BP is happy to slice up the blame, as long as they get the smallest piece."

Markey said BP is right to say that the blame should be shared but that the problems started decades ago and stretch across the entire oil industry.

He blamed the oil industry for giving assurances that this massive of an oil spill wouldn't happen and could be contained if it did. He also noted the "overly-cozy relationships established between the oil industry and regulators."

Markey said the truth will come out with further investigation.

"I look forward to seeing the final results of the multiple other investigations not funded by BP or the other companies involved in this disaster," he said. "Those are the reports that will tell the real story of this disaster, and give us the lessons we need to create laws that will prevent this type of accident from happening again."

BP's report did include 25 recommendations that would help prevent a similar occurrence in the future. The recommendations suggest cement testing, rig audits and strengthening assurance on blow-out preventers, well control and pressure testing. There is also a recommendation to review personnel competence.

The BP investigation is one of multiple ongoing probes into the disaster. Departments within the U.S. government -- including the justice department, Coast Guard and Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement -- are conducting their own investigations.

BP's study took four months to complete. It was led by Mark Bly, the company's head of safety operations but included a team of more than 50 specialists drawn from inside and outside the BP organization.

The report noted that "additional relevant information may be forthcoming, for example, when Halliburton's samples of the cement used in the well are released for testing and when the rig's blow-out preventer is fully examined now that it has been recovered from the sea-bed."

Comments are now closed for this story

DanK
said

I haven't had a chance to look at the report yet, but BP had a horrific and totally preventable explosion at a Texas oil refinery in 2005 that killed, I think, 15 people and injured scores of other contractors.The report into that Texas incident" totally blamed BP's management and culture of apathy for the terrible accident.I think Sir John Browne was at the helm of BP at that time, just before he got tossed for cheating on his company expense reports for his live-in boyfriend-assistant.It really is about priorities when it comes to safety and it is obvious to me that BP has its priorities messed-up. Sad for all the dead and injured victims who pay the ultimate price for all this apathy and greed.


JB in Ontario
said

If multiple companies are responsible for the oil spill in the Gulf, then multiple companies should pay for the clean-up until it is all cleaned up. It would be interesting to read recommendations from outside sources investigating the oil spill.


Havelock Heavy
said

I'm sure the lawyers for all these companies are lining up their arguments as to why it was the other guy's fault. Too bad we will never know how much will now be spent on Lawyers fees versus how much was spent on cleanup versus how much could have been saved in human, environmental and capital cost if they all had done it right in the first place.


Julian
said

Of course it isn't solely BP's fault.

They're just the biggest and easiest target for the uneducated masses (in regards to the petroleum industry at least) to pick on and point fingers at.

To their credit, BP has put a lot of time and money into fixing their mistake.
I don't blame them a bit for wanting a few of the other culprits to step up to the plate.


Darin
said

We use oil and gas products every second of every day. We are all to blame. And there is no reasoning our way of of it. Period.


Gary
said

Blame blame blame

Take responsibility and earn your millions by finding a way to make sure it never happens again and get it cleaned up that's all that matters.


jason Avramenko
said

That sounds like what my 4 year old says (It wasn't my fault, I didn't do it!). I sure hope the relief well they were drilling was shut down the second their leak was finally plugged. But then it was somebody elses fault.


Dennis L. Krahn
said

Having worked on rigs and after accessing on line information about the mechanics of drilling that blown out well there appears to be enough bad calls to go around. BP certainly is not alone in generating that disaster.


Will
said

Exactly, Sam. And don't forget to add the government regulators who approved the drilling and the others who forced BP to move into extreme depths instead of allowing "shallow water" drilling


PaulAB
said

Its about time other companies are identified as having some responsibility in the spill. Typically there are several service companies involved in the completion or servicing of oil and gas wells. Its not unlike a homeowner building a new house, where normally several contractors are hired to perform different tasks, framing,engineering, roofing, gasfitting, plumbing, electrical etc. Although the owner may carry the ultimate responsibility of the project certainly a trade or service that contributes to a fault in the project is also has a level of liability. If the roof blows off your house and crashes into the neighbors I would think you would be looking into who did that work as well! I dont see why anyone should expect less from BP.


Sam C
said

No doubt there will be those who say this is just BP's attempt to deflect blame, but I suspect the other investigations will have similar findings. This should not let BP off the hook in any way -- rather, there should be others on the hook along with BP.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

A new home for the community of Attawapiskat is seen 300 km away from its destination.

Homes finally headed to Attawapiskat

More

RCMP, EMS and Fire crews on the scene of a bus rollover on Hwy. 28 near Redwater, Alta., on Friday, Feb. 10, 2012. ( Bill Fortier / CTV News)

Bus filled with people rolls over on Alberta highway

More  2 Video(s) 2

Crime tape blocks the scene of a fatal shooting at the Deerfield Beach recreational vehicle park in Florida on Friday, Feb. 10, 2012.

Canadian killed in Florida campground shooting

More  3 Video(s) 3

Most Talked about Stories

I think he was pushed to take matters into his own hands. I have a teenage son and if he was involved with a drug dealer I would be furious and try anything to save him like this father did for his daughter. Why do police often say they can't do anything until it's too late? Whether it be a drug dealer or an abusive spouse, the police can't seem to do anything until something really bad happens. In this case they could have raided the drug dealers home and arrested him. The whole town knew what was going on in that house but yet the police chose to do nothing. Release this man and give him a medal for doing the right thing by his daughter. I can't wait to see the episode on W5, I will certainly be watching this one.

Shelley

W5: How far would you go to save your child?