News Sections
Axing F-35 deal would cause economic damage: Tories
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
The Canadian Press
Date: Wed. Sep. 1 2010 10:09 PM ET
OTTAWA The economic and diplomatic strings attached to Ottawa's multi-billion dollar deal to buy the F-35 stealth fighters would make it extremely painful -- if not impossible -- for a future government to unravel or cut, senior Conservatives insisted Wednesday.
Unlike the EH-101 helicopter deal axed in the mid-1990s by Jean Chretien's Liberal government, the pending agreement to purchase 65 new interceptors for the air force is a more complex arrangement that carries important risks to Canadian industry and the country's standing among allies.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper said the Opposition Liberals understand the significance and the nuances of the plans almost as much as the government.
"I don't understand why the Opposition is playing political games with this," Harper said at an aerospace announcement in Montreal.
"It was the Liberal government that in 2002 committed Canada to the development of this aircraft."
The announcement Wednesday saw the federal government pour $467 million into the country's current fleet of CF-18 jets to keep them flying until 2017.
When Chretien cancelled the $4.8-billion replacement for the air force's geriatric Sea Kings in 1994, he ripped up one contract with European Helicopter Industries Ltd, an Anglo-Italian consortium. It cost taxpayers $500 million in cancellation fees.
Tearing up -- or putting on hold -- the F-35 Lightning II plan would be far more costly.
It could endanger Canadian defence contractors, who've already won $375 million worth of work on the planes, anger allied nations already committed to buying the planes and waste hundreds of millions of dollars under existing agreements signed as far back as 1997.
The House of Commons defence committee will examine the deal later this month and the Liberals have promised to review it as well, describing the arrangement as secretive and unaccountable.
The $9 billion purchase price, with the potential of an additional $7 billion in life-time maintenance, has all opposition parties, critics and even some defence analysts suffering from sticker shock.
Harper focused his attack on the Liberals and dismissed the arguments as posturing.
"Everybody knows the Liberal party supports this," he said, his voice rising.
"Everybody understands the military will need this equipment at the end of the decade and everybody understands this is to the benefit of the Canadian aerospace sector, particularly the industry that is based here in the greater Montreal region. So the Opposition should stop playing political games with this and simply support this, which is a necessary purchase for all of us."
Critics argue handing the deal to Lockheed Martin, the world's No. 1 defence contractor with US $39 billion in sales, amounts to the sole-sourcing of one of the largest procurements in the country's history.
But Jay Paxton, a spokesman for Defence Minister Peter MacKay, argued that a competition was already run -- by the Americans.
In the late 1990s, Washington pitted Boeing and Lockheed Martin against each other to select which company would build the next generation of fighter aircraft.
Alan Williams, the former senior procurement official at the Defence Department, said Canadians should be "totally insulted" by that logic.
"Don't say you've already conducted a competition and we don't need to do one; you haven't," said Williams, who championed Canada's entry into the F-35 program in the 1990s.
"The Americans selected an aircraft between two competitors, based upon their operational requirements to meet their needs. It had nothing at all to do with Canadians needs. It's insulting to ask the average Canadian to buy that argument."
Normally when countries want to buy aircraft, they approach the contractor, cut a deal and the plane is delivered. But the F-35 was conceived and developed collectively by a number of nations, who paid for the privilege of being part of the deal.
In Ottawa's case, that's amounted to US $160 million, which allows Canadian companies access to bid on contacts associated with the project. Think of it as the federal government paying the cover charge to get into a club.
Between now and 2051, the federal government is committed to spending an additional US $551 million in order to remain part of the club.
If Canada drops out, it not only loses future access but it could be on the hook for some -- or all -- of its pending contributions, said Paxton.
"There would be costs associated with any withdrawal from the (memorandum of understanding)," he said Wednesday.
"Canada would have to complete payments on joint activities that the partnership has already contracted. The exact costs would be subject to negotiation with the other (Joint Strike Fighter) partners."
The federal government signed two agreements, in 1997 and 2006, in order to be part of the program, meaning both Liberal and Conservative governments have signed on.
The U.S. co-ordinates ordering the aircraft with Lockheed Martin every year and the withdrawal of one or more nations would drive up the price for those still in the club -- something Conservatives warned would spark a backlash among allies.
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I think he was pushed to take matters into his own hands. I have a teenage son and if he was involved with a drug dealer I would be furious and try anything to save him like this father did for his daughter. Why do police often say they can't do anything until it's too late? Whether it be a drug dealer or an abusive spouse, the police can't seem to do anything until something really bad happens. In this case they could have raided the drug dealers home and arrested him. The whole town knew what was going on in that house but yet the police chose to do nothing. Release this man and give him a medal for doing the right thing by his daughter. I can't wait to see the episode on W5, I will certainly be watching this one.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Hal
said
Mark5
said
Doug # BC
said
Not again
said
kent
said
Paul Chilliwack
said
Havelock Heavy
said
gregm
said
NS
said
Paul
said
Eric B.
said
baeto
said
tim
said
Adan
said
gilles lebrun
said
Jay
said
PBW
said
cheechcalgary
said
Sad for the world
said
Adrian from Hamilton
said
Ken
said
Jamie, Ottawa
said
Jack R
said
Born and Bred Edmontonian
said
Lee
said
CDN
said
B Bishop
said
Terry
said
Laurie
said
Bob,Calgary
said
Albertaboy111
said
Lance Usher Capt (ret)
said
Marcthefe
said
Pat in AB
said
Donaldbain
said
Earthwatcher
said
Retired Mariner Dartmouth
said
Stu
said
Van Guy
said
CraigW
said
FreakAlert
said
Michael
said
AH in Calgary
said
JFJ
said
Canadian
said
DCK
said
BrianFr Langley
said
Ex-Hornet tech in AB
said
Dave
said
Michael McMurray
said
Tim from Calgary
said
Will
said