Top Stories -   

1
Sales have fallen by 25 per cent since reaching a peak at the beginning of the year as fewer buyers compete and more houses come onto the market. But Canadian home prices were up 13.6 per cent in June from a year ago in Canada's major cities, according to the Teranet-National Bank composite house price index. Housing sales in greater Vancouver and the Fraser Valley plummeted in July, down more than 45 per cent compared to the same month in 2009. Aug. 4, 2010. (CTV)

Housing bubble threat arises as prices hit new highs

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Amparo Cardenas, broker
Conflicting views in two new reports over whether the Canadian housing market has become a precarious bubble. A mortgage broker in Toronto says we are on the verge of a correction, not a bubble burst.
CTV British Columbia: Norma Reid on housing
Home sales may be slowing, but prices in six of Canada's largest housing markets are in bubble territory for the first time in 30 years, according to a report from an Ottawa-based think tank.
CTV Calgary: Kevin Rich reports on the bubble
Canada's housing market could still be in for a U.S. style correction, despite a slow down in home sales across the country.
CTV News Channel: Kelvin Mangaroo comments
The president of RateSupermarket.ca says the report seems to indicate the worst case scenario for the market is a housing bubble similar to the U.S., though the odds of that happening is fairly low.
CTV News Channel: BNN's Andrew Bell on housing
There are warnings from the Centre for Policy Alternatives for cities like Edmonton and Montreal that house prices could plummet in the coming months.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (22) Facebook   

Sales have fallen by 25 per cent since reaching a peak at the beginning of the year as fewer buyers compete and more houses come onto the market. But Canadian home prices were up 13.6 per cent in June from a year ago in Canada's major cities, according to the Teranet-National Bank composite house price index. Housing sales in greater Vancouver and the Fraser Valley plummeted in July, down more than 45 per cent compared to the same month in 2009. Aug. 4, 2010. (CTV)

Photos

Sales have fallen by 25 per cent since reaching a peak at the beginning of the year as fewer buyers compete and more houses come onto the market. But Canadian home prices were up 13.6 per cent in June from a year ago in Canada's major cities, according to the Teranet-National Bank composite house price index.

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Aug. 31 2010 6:50 AM ET

TORONTO — Home sales may be slowing, but prices in six of Canada's largest housing markets are in bubble territory for the first time in 30 years -- and a U.S.-style correction is still not out of the question, according to a report from an Ottawa-based think tank.

The report by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, to be released Tuesday, says home prices now sit at 4.7 to 11.3 times Canadians' annual income -- much higher than historical comfort levels of between three and four times income.

"To see all of the (major) markets outside of that comfort zone is very unique and concerning," said David Macdonald, a research associate who authored the report entitled "Canada's Housing Bubble: An Accident Waiting To Happen."

Sales have fallen by 25 per cent since reaching a peak at the beginning of the year as fewer buyers compete and more houses come onto the market. But Canadian home prices were up 13.6 per cent in June from a year ago in Canada's major cities, according to the Teranet-National Bank composite house price index.

June prices were up 1.5 per cent compared to May -- the largest monthly increase since last August and the 14th straight monthly increase.

The steep rise in house prices in so many cities points toward an "accident waiting to happen," Macdonald said.

In the past 30 years Canada's housing market has undergone three bubbles. Bubbles occur when housing prices increase more rapidly than inflation, household incomes and economic growth, according to the report.

Each of Canada's previous bubbles was punctured by only a one per cent rise in interest rates over two years, Macdonald warned.

It would take only a one per cent to 1.25 per cent mortgage rate increase by Canada's big banks to cause a housing crash similar to the one the U.S. is grappling with, he added.

Vancouver saw housing bubbles in 1981 and 1994 and another one burst in Toronto in 1989. In Canada's other major markets -- Calgary, Edmonton, Ottawa, and Montreal -- prices remained stable from 1980 to 2001 at around $150,000 to $220,000 in today's dollars.

"The concern today is all six major markets, not just Vancouver and Toronto, are out of that comfort zone," Macdonald said. "All six major markets now have an average price of over $300,000."

And the current cooling trend doesn't necessarily signify that the market has emerged from a bubble, he added.

Before Toronto's housing market crashed in 1989, the market saw a similar decline in sales volumes in 1987, but that marked only the halfway point before further increases led to the burst.

Douglas Porter, deputy chief economist at the Bank of Montreal, said that while the report's warnings should not be dismissed as completely improbable, it's clear that the market is backing off bubble territory as price increases subside.

"Given the rebound we've seen in employment in the last year in Canada and the fact that interest rates are still at extremely favourable levels, I can't get that pessimistic on the outlook for housing," he said.

Many economists have concluded that Canada's once overheating housing market, which began to cool in the second quarter of the year, has stopped just shy of a bubble. They credit stricter Canadian lending rules with preventing the type of dramatic crash experienced stateside, where one in 10 households is facing foreclosure.

"A lot of the fundamental differences between the Canadian and U.S. markets suggest that we're far less likely to have the kind of deep downturn that the U.S. market went through," said Porter.

However, Canada is not immune to a serious housing market correction and if prices continue to rise for a prolonged period, even as the resale market slides, that could be a danger sign, he added.

Macdonald said he sees at least a few similarities in home price index data between some American and Canadian cities. Calgary and Edmonton have seen the same price increases as some of the worst-hit U.S. cities, for example.

Canadian homes remain affordable because mortgage rates sit at record lows, but home affordability could change rapidly if rates return even partway to their historic norms, the report warns.

If that does happen, young families who have over-extended themselves and seniors relying on selling their house for retirement income would be most affected.

Macdonald said there's about a six-month to one-year window of opportunity before mortgage rates rise dramatically to "let some air out of the housing market" and help prevent the possibility of future bubbles.

Mortgage qualification changes announced in April, meant to discourage homeowners from taking out mortgages on homes they might not be able to afford down the road, didn't go far enough, Macdonald said.

He argued that the government should change the required downpayment from five per cent to ten per cent to further deter those who won't be able to afford rate increases.

But Porter said there's little point in increasing the minimum downpayment level now as the market is softening on its own.

He pointed out that the bubble bursts of the early 1990s were sparked by the Bank of Canada's decision to raise interest rates to 10 per cent above inflation, aimed at taking down the housing market.

"I don't see the Bank of Canada going on a campaign to lift interest rates to absolutely crush the housing sector. It's just not that much of an inflation concern to them this time," Porter said.

Comments are now closed for this story

WestofThe Rockies
said

@ Ben, Spoken like a true Liberal. No connection to reality. Just a bunch of random information tossed together. Connect the dots…… any dots, who cares what the result is. First the article talks about a housing bubble in a number of cities not the whole country so the assertion you can supposedly buy a house somewhere in Ontario for under a 100 or 50K means nothing. Please tell us what possible connection there is between house prices in Seattle & Ontario. Not just a different country but a completely different region & completely different economic factors. How about comparing similar regions & economies like Ontario with Michigan. “Actually” Michigan prices are lower. This is the problem with you Liberals; you snatch a bunch of bits and pieces on the same subject but with no connection to the other than the subject, throw them in the pot and come up with these ridiculous assertions. Give us the facts and figures showing how the Zero percent down incentive made the bubble. How can 1 or 2 % of all mortgages inflate the value of all housing? You may have “been saying this for months” but it’s pretty obvious why no one is paying attention. You are as irrelevant as your leader and for the same reason. No connection to reality.


SVCR
said

What would a think tank in Ottawa know about the housing market as their brains are frozen out there as none of the thinking from the east makes ANY sense now or ever.They don't live in the real world so what would they know???


Wendy
said

If you didn't see this coming you must have been living in a cave. In 2007 when the government told CMHC to drop down payments to zero, I went out, bought, jacked up the price & resold. When Whistler got the Olympic bid I noticed prices in Whistler didn't really go up. I use a group of condos as a real estate barometer, in the 80's these condos went on the market for 34,000, over the years they have been as high as 500,000. Just before the Olympics a real estate magazine was published these condos were priced at around 200,000. so I knew the housing market would soon be on it's way down. I sold everything before the Olympics, that zero down made me a pile of money over the 3 years . Now I sit & wait for prices to crash, then start the cycle again. I feel sorry for all those that will lose their homes over the next couple years. When your can buy a house for zero down it sure inflates housing prices. Fewer jobs, lower wages all the signs have been there for a long time, the blind kept buying & now they will pay the price. I was impressed with CAW for the first time ever, they recently dropped ford line workers wages by 35%, I think this one will be a recession that starts with a depress.


Dan T
said

"There may be a bubble and it may burst but if it does there will be many more houses owned by the banks. Many seem to forget that many owners have very large mortgages that the banks allowed them to have and yet these are the same institutions that will want all of it back whether you are working or not. "The banks are not on the hook. CHMC and the tax payers are on the hook. CHMC = Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac. When the US double dip sets in, the DOW hits 5000 and drags us with it the market it going to get ugly. The only reason we are in the shape we are in is because of the sudo conservative government we have. If we would not have wasted all that money on the 'Action Plan' and drastictly cut Federal Goverment spending (and related taxes) we would be in much better shape.


bubble_watcher
said

Of course there is a bubble. Interest rates are far too low, and the government is co-signing most loans. There is nothing real about this market. People will be shocked when the bubble finally pops!The USA appears to be popping yet again, and it's only a matter of time before it happens here.Don't be fooled, interest rates cannot remain this low for much longer. It's just not realistic!


Kimsum
said

Bankruptcies have been historically high for the past 3 years & it's the average working Canadian that's losing their homes. Immigration laws require many immigrants to have 800,000 in order to move to Canada. People from India & China come with bags of money & buy up property in the city which helped to inflate prices, but many of these people find they can't make money here & move back to where they came from. This helped inflate high end homes, Harper's zero down mortgages for 3 years is what created the bubble.


Denis
said

Ben,your facts are wrong. If you don't have a downpayment above 25%, you have to pay CMHC insurance on taking a morgage. Banks in Canada will normally insist that only 30% of your total net monthly income be set aside for your morgage. This limits the amount you can borrow.Home buyers are consumers making their own buying decision, nothing to do with Harper. If you buy a house for the short term or quick profit you may loose in this market but long term as always shown an increase. Live within your means and stop blaming others for your finacial failure. The number one shortfall of our society is the refusal to take responsibility for their action. Easier to blame some else than admit being wrong.


Dave S Calgary
said

Has anybody looked at the fact these Banks are still recording profits of close to 3 billion dollars, so you see where the problem starts and ends, they steal from us that are forced to use their service along with fixing numbers and stocks it is all one big ass game to these corporations


Lyne
said

@GeorgeWood floors were a poor man's flooring?! Since when? Carpets were a passing craze and the floating floors that are going into new houses and renovations today, I wouldn't even think of looking at.I renovated an older house 5 yrs ago from the '50's and put in new hardwood floors through out, not to mention gutting the kitchen and bathroom and starting from scratch. My home is now evaluated at 100k more than what it was before the renovation. Your home IS your biggest investment, you get back what you put in it. Or in your case from what I am guessing, nothing. You won't sell your house for top dollar with that attitude!


Mead
said

Nice Scam. Housing gets 'overheated', so the government jacks interest rates. If your mortgage rates go up to 10%, your house value drops $50,000. So, instead of paying $50,000 into the value of your home, you then you pay the Bank of Canada $50,000 in increased interest rates. In essence, the Bank of Canada knocks $50,000 off the value of your home and pockets it themselves with increased mortgage rates. This is a shell game and a scam, which is of no benefit. All markets correct on their own, eventually without government 'help'.


Doug
said

Why is a housing bubble such a problem?When there is a housing boom, the people that snort at the trough are bankers, lawyers, the government with land transfer taxes, phone, cable and hydro companies, movers and house flippers.Then we can add the developers and politicians that love to pack as many taxpayers into as small a new housing devolopment as is possible and there you have it.Does anyone care that these people make less money when the housing market stalls?


Kc
said

Funny how people want to stop the new housing starts just so they can retain values on their own homes. Please, people, new home starts arent being developed with YOU in mind. Your older home will simply have to adjust its prices downwards - again. And equally funny how people are demanding more immigration - just so they could create artificially high deman on their homes. Harper needs to cool the market yet again.


Max
said

The world economy is linked, a recession is a storm that hits every country. Low interest rates & zero down mortgage caused prices to inflate, giving Canada the appearance of a recovery, but it only made matters worst. The bubble is ready to burst & it's going to be messy. Harper has the economic sense of a 2 year old.


Diane from Penbrooke
said

We were smart to purchase a smaller home +10 years ago, even when the bank gave us a whole lot more to work with, but the fear of one of us losing our jobs & then our home would be gone, made more sense to purchase a smaller place. It needed some fixing up, but that was the fun of it, making it ours the way we wanted it. Now our home which we paid less than $100,000 for is worth at least 1.5 times that, and with our new deck, flooring, painting, new fence, etc. we are proud to own it. I wish people would buy what they can afford not what they want....maybe they'd be more happy, even if they get laid off, they could still pay the mortgage. Live in the real world people!


Ben
said

I've been saying this for months, in 2007 to a few months back Harper allowed zero down mortgages, everyone bought things they couldn't afford, if you have no down payment you have nothing to lose, if you can't make you payment, walk away. This did give our country the appearance of recovery, but is all it really did was inflate housing prices to ridiculous levels, now we will pay the prices. Have a look at Ontario home prices, there are lots on the market under 100,000, 2 bedroom homes for under 50,000. Actually if you compare Ontario to Seattle, Seattle prices are higher. We can't have a recovery if the rest of the world is not recovering. I laugh when they try to tell us were not in a deflationary period, in the US & some places in Canada, you can buy a house cheaper than a car. CAW recently cuts Ford line workers pay by 35%, from 30 to 19.50, these people won't be able to pay a mortgage anymore. Harper destroyed our economy trying to pull the wool over the eyes of Canadians, us liberals have been trying to tell the right wing-nuts this for almost a year, now it's starting to happen. Obviously Harper knows nothing about economics, bankruptcies have been going straight up for the past 3 years, now there going to soar & home prices will crash.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Everybody knows that we're close to a bubble. Fortunately, we're slowly backing off of it. (Those rabid anti-Conservative Liberal supporters who insist that the Canadian market is at the mercy of crappy "zero-down" mortgages are grossly ill-informed, as such instruments, in fact, account for an insignificant percentage of the overall market. Industry professionals know this.) Over the years, real estate prices have rocketed upward, outstripping income advances. Given the soft national economy, the talk several months ago of mortgage interest rates shooting back up was silly and overblown (read: alarmist). We're witnessing a rational state of cooling. No need for any hyperbole. Indeed, real estate prices in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) have been propped up by a population that continues to swell (based largely on immigration pushing the market from the ground up). Demand has certainly quieted; however, a limited supply of developable land for new homes and reasonably static "resale" opportunity should keep the overall market relatively stable, with modest price declines. (Overenthusiastic, overly-optimistic asking prices will often be met with a cold shoulder for a while, particularly on the upper end.) Non-key markets, such as a couple in central/western Canada, may well take a solid hit and notable adjustment. Anybody who didn't see this coming, and stands surprised, has been asleep for some time.


Wade Ens
said

The Market is stable. Based on current absorbtion rates no new housing is needed for 3 years. People just need to keep paying down debt. Steady as she goes,


TimT
said

I agree with what Mark said. The surrounding areas will likely see a big correction, but here in downtown Toronto, the demand for the resale homes here simply isn't going to go away. Perhaps we'll see a softening for a period of prices but it will as it always has, recover and continue to rise even further. Let's see what a nice red brick detach in downtown toronto sells for in 10 years...


River
said

Sage is got this right. I wonder how people can afford to pay for a mortage that is more than they make, then what happens when the value of the home drops so the people now own more than its worth?


Mark
said

Toronto grows on average of 100k people a year all looking for housing. The city has run out of land and is now building up. The effect of course is housing costs for homes (ie not condos or apartments) is going up quickly. Housing in TO is still cheaper than other like major cities in the world. The sky is falling mentality is silly.


Sage
said

When common sense returns to the marketplace things will come back down to reasonable levels. The cost of homes in the east are out of control also. People get into this frenzy where they say if they don't buy now they will never be able to own a home. The truth is the bank owns it unless you pay cash and because of low interest rates people will pay ridiculous and inflated prices for inferior built homes by mass project builders. Typical behaviour for the top of a cycle.


George in Calgary
said

There may be a bubble and it may burst but if it does there will be many more houses owned by the banks. Many seem to forget that many owners have very large mortgages that the banks allowed them to have and yet these are the same institutions that will want all of it back whether you are working or not. I currently have a house on the market in Calgary and yes things have stagnated. But I have also run into the young buyers that want everything and they want everything right now. My house does not have all the bells and whistles but it is a very functional house in a very sought after neighbourhood. But I am tired of those that continually come through wanting this and that at half the price. I send them out and remind them that hardwood floors were at one time considered a poor man's flooring. They have no patience and certainly no desire to purchase a home where they want to be and change it over time to the house they really desire. We who are a little older remember those times and how there was fun and satisfaction gained from a continual accomplishment. Today's "children" do not understand this; such a waste.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Police probe body parts in Ottawa, torso in Montreal

More   4 Comments 4    5 Video(s) 5

Hacking

Official claims Iran has defeated powerful 'Flame' virus

More   12 Comments 12    1 Video(s) 1

Vic Toews, Public Safety Minister, and Jason Kenney, Minister of Citizenship, make an announcement related to terrorism research funding during a press conference in the foyer of the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Ottawa pledges $1.1M to counter-terrorism research

More    Comments  

Most Talked about Stories

While Branson's comments (and activities) are arrogant in a million different ways, Clark's response was admirable. She kept her sense of humour with her joke about Branson's brand-name and his bad pick-up line, showing why humour is often the best response to arrogance.

D Austin (Fredericton)

B.C. premier rebuffs Branson's naked kitesurfing invite