Top Stories -   

1
Two glasses of water before dinner helps weight loss.

Water can flush away pounds? Perhaps, suggests study

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Avis Favaro on the study
A new study suggests that drinking two 25-millilitre glasses of water before eating a meal can help you lose weight. Over 12 weeks in a clinical trial, water drinkers lost about 15.5 pounds while non-water drinkers lost only about 11 pounds.
CTV News Channel: Meghan Telpner, nutritionist
A certified nutritionist says drinking water before you meal makes your stomach feel full, which will make you eat less.
CTV News Channel: Melissa Hershberg, The Toronto Clinic
A physician and weight loss expert says many of her patients have a hard time drinking two glasses of water before each meal, since many feel there is no point and would rather fill their stomach with food.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (21) Facebook   

Two glasses of water before dinner helps weight loss.

Photos

Two glasses of water before dinner helps weight loss.

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Aug. 23 2010 9:04 PM ET

Imagine an appetite suppressant that requires no prescription, offers no side effects, and costs almost nothing. That wonder elixir may already exist and flows freely from your taps.

Scientists have found that dieters who drink two 250-millilitre glasses of water right before their meals tend to lose more weight than those who don't drink before meals but who eat similar diets.

Most of us know that drinking a lot of water can make us feel full. But there has been little research until now on whether water can't actually help with weight loss.

Now, researchers led by Brenda Davy, with Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Va. have conducted the first randomized controlled trial on how drinking water can affect weight.

They divided 48 older adults, aged 55-75 years, into two groups: one group drank two cups of water prior to every meal, while the other did not. All of the subjects ate a low-calorie diet during the study.

Over 12 weeks, the water drinkers lost about 7 kilograms (15.5 pounds), while the non-water drinkers lost only about 5 kg (11 pounds).

The data was presented this week at the 240th National Meeting of the American Chemical Society (ACS).

Davy thinks water may help with weight loss simply because it fills the stomach and helps people feel full so they eat less calorie-containing food during their meal. The researchers found that the water drinkers ate nearly 100 fewer calories at each meal. Over time, that deficit added up to weight loss.

Water drinkers might also lose more weight because of what they're not drinking: sweetened drinks. Davy notes that drinks sweetened with sugar and corn syrup can be high in calories. A 12-ounce can of regular pop, for instance, contains about 10 teaspoons of sugar and about 150 calories. Even a 250-ml glass of milk contains 120 calories.

Davy says the water drinkers also noticed other benefits.

"Many of our participants in the water group commented they felt they were thinking a lot more clearly; their memory was better," she says.

Dr. Stanley Bernstein says he's not surprised by the study's findings. Bernstein, the founder of a chain of weight loss centres, says he has long encouraged dieters to drink lots of water not only because it relieves water retention, but because "the more you drink, the more your system can work to break down fat."

"Drinking a lot of water is a very necessary part of losing weight. Period. It's probably, from my point of view, as effective as most diet pills," he told CTV News.

With a report from CTV's medical specialist Avis Favaro and producer Elizabeth St. Philip

Comments are now closed for this story

WinnieN.S.
said
0 0

It makes sense that if you eat less you will lose weight. I don't think water makes too much of a difference, it just makes the mouth work and keeps you busy. I drink a lot of water at least 8 glasses a day or more and I still eat when I'm full,water doesn't make that much of a difference with me(of course everyones system is different as we know). I still eat when full, I love the taste of food. Simple! cut down and exercise, lose weight, lots of water or not, after 3 days of cutting down the body gets used to less food I find, but if you love food you will go back to the bad habits again unfortunately. I am 5ft 7 and 66 yrs old and weigh 150 lbs and feel overweight, have dieted all my life to lose that extra 10 or 15 lbs and if I hadn't I would be about 300llbs. I'm sure, its something you have to work at forever.


Wendy
said
0 0

Ic Health Canada doesn't recommend 8 glass of water a day because there is no medical evidence that it does anything, I almost never drink water I'm 52 & in good shape.


Stu
said
0 0

I drink probably no more than 10 glasses of water in a year & I'm thin, I've actually been trying to put weight on all my life. But it makes sense if you fill up on water it's difficult to eat too much.


Mintie
said
0 0

I've known that for a long time! I lost 50 pounds 5 years ago and drinking water before AND between meals is something I still do to this day.


Denise
said
0 0

I agree. They say also that it might be because the larger losers might be losing because they're "not drinking sweetened drinks". Wouldn't they have accounted for that in the study? If they didn't, then it's not worth the paper it's published on.


Laurel
said
0 0

Actually, drinking too much water does have side effects. It can cause hyponatremia, which is potentially fatal. This is rare, but it does happen. Staying well hydrated is a good idea, but taking this weight loss technique to the extreme could be very bad.


enigma21
said
0 0

Losing fat is a game of calories consumed vs calories burned. Burn more calories than you consume in the course of a day, you lose fat. What's so hard to understand about that? All the water they drank certainly helped their overall body health but why don't these people put more emphasis on exercise in their daily life? The formula for success is simple: eat nutrient-dense foods (in the right portion sizes) at the right times, exercise regularly, drink plenty of water, get a full night's sleep, keep stress under control and keep your life in a healthy balance. Simple, isn't it?


OK...
said
0 0

@ Dave, low calorie diets still contain calorie containing foods... and if you eat less of any type of diet you will be consuming less calories. They are saying that drinking water before the meal will make you feel fuller so that you don't eat as many calories, whatever the diet may be.


Paul
said
0 0

I do think that water is very important, it controls blood pressure, heart rate, helps in digestion and so on and so on.. That being said, I think the public should read very carefully into these findings instead of just jumping on the CTV headline bandwagon. This is just one study of 2 groups of 24 individuals, and one group losing just a few pounds more than the other. Pretty small scale. Drink water, eat healthy, EXERCISE!.


sadie
said
0 0

Common sense - moderation and exercise are the only options to "diets" - Tried the Bernstein Diet - lost lots of weight - hit my goal -looked fantastic ! now back to a "normal life" - gained the weight back and now have serious issues related to the diet ! so something wasnt right... Plus sometimes some of us are more healthy with extra weight than the skinny minny !


Frank
said
0 0

I am over weight and my concern is not the size of meal I eat but how long the effect lasts, I tried the water thing and it did not work for me...not saying it would't for others and please note they compared sugar drinks at 12 oz and milk at 250 ml making milk with more calories than soft drinks (240 my guess).


Sam
said
0 0

It said all of the subjects ate a low-calorie diet...not that they ate the same portion of food.So if they all ate steak and potatoes for a meal, then they're stating that because one group drank water prior to their meal, they ended up eating less steak and potatoes than did the group who did not drink water prior to the meal. It is a simple formula actually. The less room in your stomach, the less you'll feel like eating.


not Dave
said
0 0

Dave,

it seems you've missed the point. Yes both groups were on a "low calorie" diet but the point is that those who drank 2 cups of water prior to eating, ate less. Thus the water drinking group injested even fewer calories.


Philip
said
0 0

They obviously ate less food at each meal compared to their peers so it wouldn't matter whether or not the food had a low calorie count, the simple fact is that the water drinkers took in fewer calories because they had less room for food. It doesn't take a genius to realize that filling your stomach with fluid leaves less room for food, heck my kids do it all the time; they'll guzzle their drinks because they are hot and thirsty and then they can't finish their lunch or snack.


Karen
said
0 0

It does make sense. It does not say they ate the SAME diet, it says that both groups ate a low cal diet, and that the water group consumed about 100 less cals per meal.


danRVancouver
said
0 0

I agree with Dave. This study has apparently been misunderstood or misreported. Also, the weight-loss clinic opinion has nothing to do with the study findings: the item says nothing about water breaking down fat, just that people eat less. Finally, we will learn in a year that the people start eating more after 6 months, or something. Another fad-diet in the making.


Leigh
said
0 0

Dave, it it actually makes perfect sense. The article states clearly, "The researchers found that the water drinkers ate nearly 100 fewer calories at each meal. Over time, that deficit added up to weight loss." How is that not understandable? If you give a whole hamburger to person A and half a hamburger to person B, they're both eating the same thing, it's just that one person (or group, if you will) is eating LESS for whatever reason. Taking the case presented in this article, the reason would be that group B is already full with the water.


Andrew
said
0 0

Dave, I think you are misunderstanding a couple things here and the article doesn't necessarily make it clear of the very specifics of the study. It's probably safe to assume they were given similar meals in nutritional values as well as similar portion sizes. Those who drank water before meals would eat less of that portion, claiming to be full faster, thus not completely finishing the meal. Meanwhile, the control group would end up eating more of that same sized portion to reach the same results of satisfaction. Perhaps you should read the actual published study before claiming that it "makes no sense" instead of relying on a third party media group to relay the information. The news has a funny way of making the uncomplicated complicated sometimes.


Larry Pike
said
0 0

Dave, what "makes no sense" is your own comment. I've read and re-read your post; there is just no sense to it. The food, whether low-calorie or not, still contains calories. Drinking 16 ounces of water made the experimental group feel full sooner and need less calories from the food than the control group. It makes perfect sense.The part that makes less sense is that a scientific study was needed to figure this out.


lc
said
0 0

Don't know about water and weight but there are so many other beneficial effects of drinking water (without fluoride) it should be a habit for all.Have always been puzzled why health Canada does not educate people.Everyone should do themselves a favor and drink 8 glasses of water daily for a few weeks.Your body will be very thankful.If not that at least lay off the soft drinks full of sugar or their cousin the artificial sweetener aspartame.

Dave
said
0 0

This makes no sense. First they say: "All of the subjects ate a low-calorie diet during the study." Then they say "it fills the stomach and helps people feel full so they eat less calorie-containing food during their meal". Well if both groups ate the same low-calorie diet, then it doesn't really matter if it made them feel full or not.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Today's Top Stories

Local authorities say the incident at the Deerfield Beach recreational vehicle park began with a shooting early Thursday evening.

Canadian killed in Florida campground shooting

More  1 Video(s) 1

caterpillar, electro-motive

CAW boss accuses Caterpillar of breaking the rules

More   15 Comments 15  

Most Talked about Stories

I think he was pushed to take matters into his own hands. I have a teenage son and if he was involved with a drug dealer I would be furious and try anything to save him like this father did for his daughter. Why do police often say they can't do anything until it's too late? Whether it be a drug dealer or an abusive spouse, the police can't seem to do anything until something really bad happens. In this case they could have raided the drug dealers home and arrested him. The whole town knew what was going on in that house but yet the police chose to do nothing. Release this man and give him a medal for doing the right thing by his daughter. I can't wait to see the episode on W5, I will certainly be watching this one.

Shelley

W5: How far would you go to save your child?