Top Stories -   

1
Tanya Bloomfield, a transgendered woman, speaks in Halifax, N.S. on Thursday, july 29, 2010.

Transgendered woman seeks refugee status in Canada

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Atlantic: Rick Grant on the deportation
A transgendered woman in the middle of undergoing sex change procedures who is living in Nova Scotia faces possible deportation, but she fears she'll face discrimination if she returns to Great Britain.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (25) Facebook   

Tanya Bloomfield, a transgendered woman, speaks in Halifax, N.S. on Thursday, july 29, 2010.

Photos

Tanya Bloomfield, a transgendered woman, speaks in Halifax, N.S. on Thursday, july 29, 2010.

View Larger Image

Date: Fri. Jul. 30 2010 10:42 AM ET

A transgendered Nova Scotia resident facing possible deportation from Canada says she could become the victim of hate crimes if she's sent back to Ireland.

Tanya Bloomfield, a transgendered female, came to Canada from the United Kingdom as Tim Bloomfield.

Shortly after arriving in the fall of 2006, Bloomfield and a female partner got married. But three years later, their relationship was on the rocks.

"We got married in Nova Scotia, and in January of 2009 that relationship broke down. Along with it, my spousal sponsorship application also became invalid," Bloomfield told CTV News.

Bloomfield, an Irish national, says that she applied for a temporary residence permit and a temporary work permit, but was denied both.

Tanya doesn't know why she was rejected, other than not meeting the criteria.

When Bloomfield and her lawyer, Lee Cohen, sought clarification from Citizenship and Immigration Canada, they were asked to sign a voluntary departure order to leave the country by the end of August.

"Tanya has refused to sign the voluntary departure order and has indicated her intentions to claim refugee status in Canada, primarily on the grounds of seeking protection as a transgendered person," Lee said.

Bloomfield, 40, says she started the process of transitioning from a man to a woman when she was just 24. But it wasn't until she and her ex-partner arrived in Canada that she became entirely comfortable with the idea.

Now, she fears for her safety if she's forced to return to her former home in Northern Ireland.

"There are statistics which show there's increasing hate crime within the European Union," Bloomfield said.

If Bloomfield can prove her case, establishing a legitimate refugee claim could mean at least another 18 months in Canada. As a refugee, Bloomfield would then be able to apply for permanent residency.

If her application is rejected, however, a deportation order could be issued in a matter of days.

Bloomfield's lack of legal status hasn't stopped her from establishing roots in Nova Scotia.

Besides owning and operating a small computer business, Bloomfield gained prominence in May when she ran a Halifax road race barefoot to raise money for a local organization serving gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered people.

With files from CTV Atlantic's Rick Grant in Halifax

Comments are now closed for this story

Nova What?
said

@ Ryan James Neufeld: Nova Scotia is a beautiful place to visit and Canada is first and foremost a liberal country and nation of origin..Well that gives high marks in my crayon book! What does that have to do with anything in anyone's life? What is a nation of origin? The closest thing to that is, NS is a place of destination. p.s. Ryan, get out of NS. You might be Liberal, but certainly not all Canadians.


JJ
said

Send him back, and let in properly screened refugees.


Color Me Redneck
said

Tanya doesn't know why she was rejected, other than not meeting the criteria. Hmm, Tanya, could it be for not meeting the criteria?Does Canada have a shortage of skilled transgender people?Lastly, what is the social / physiological factor whereby we must always refer to color, gender, sexual preference etc? Can we ever get an article that simply states: When asked, little Johnny stated he had no sexual preference and didn't have a favorite color.


John Meron
said

"Tanya doesn't know why she was rejected, other than not meeting the criteria". Well Tanya that's what not meeting the criteria means. You have not met the criteria to apply. Perhaps you could look up the word in the dictionary. Other than having what I'm sure is a charming accent you do not qualify as a refugee from hate crimes. In any case I'm sure you will receive the same degree of acceptance in Ireland as you have received here.


samantha young
said

What a bunch of hogwash!! Being a Canadian citizen, but born in Ireland I can assure you she WILL NOT be persecuted anymore than she is now. But blabbing and demanding to stay in Canada, the bleeding hearts will probably let her/him stay! Knowing our justice system this will go on forever,so she probably will be here for a few more years!


MD
said

Refugee status for he/she would just be another daily example of the ongoing cultural marxism in Canada. Our most treasured values have been turned upside down in a diabolical [i.e. showing the cunning or ingenuity or wickedness typical of a devil], “behind-the-curtain,” marxist orchestration that has taken over our schools, churches, movies, publishers and media. Canada has for the past 60 years slowly wandered off the trail of success, all under the guise of social egalatarianism. George Orwell's book 1984 also explains today's world quite accurately(“Ignorance is Strength, Slavery is Freedom”). Give Canadians a break, no refugee status for he/she!


Jason
said

This person has 27 countries in which to live as an EU national. If this person's claims about Ireland are true, then this person has 26 more kicks at the bucket. Claiming ref status here is simply asylum shopping and this person needs to be deported immediately!


Dahren
said

Can't she go to Vegas for the Weekend, and come back and ask for another 6 month visa? I know a few friends from the States that do that, as long as they leave the country and are not deported, they can come back after 24 hours and apply for a new 6 month work visa.


mandosa
said

In the immortal words of Barney Gumble: "Go back to Russia!"


Matthew
said

@Northern Princess For less than $250 you register and open your own business. In fact, I have a business registered in my name but that doesn't mean the business can support me or even makes a cent of profit. She can own/operate a business all she wants but if it's not profitable and can't support her then maybe that's why her application was denied.


Sal
said

Tanya doesn't know why she was rejected, other than not meeting the criteria. ummmmmm? not meeting the criteria would probably be the reason for being rejected. Not rocket science


Northern Princess
said

@Matthew ... did you not read this .. and all who say 'if she could prove she can support herself/himself ... duhhhh! Reread the article before commenting.; Besides owning and operating a small computer business, Bloomfield ... 'This transgendered 'it' hasn't a leg to stand on, or at least I hope not. Her claim was refused and I hope that Immigration will stand by their decision and not think that they have to be politically correct. As far as I'm concerned, Ireland would not chastise her unless she blabs to everyone what she is over there. I even think that they would just raise their shoulders and walk on if she told them. So, to claim refugee is a laugh! What people will do for attention!

Acroyear
said

I don't know anything about the refugee laws, so can't comment on legal aspect, but while I agree Ireland is a Catholic stronghold and she wouldn't be very welcome, I don't think there could be a strong basis for being called a refugee. Having said THAT, it seems to me s/he is running a local business, contributing to taxes and went about everything in a completely legal manor. Why not grant some sort of injunction that allows for application for citizenship? I don't give a fig about her sexuality or gender, one way or the other, only that as an immigrant s/he is contributing to our country and not being a drain on it. Seems to me it's the former.

RYAN JAMES NEUFELD
said

the provincial government of Nova Scotia and the federal government of Canada should let her stay no matter what!Nova Scotia is a beautiful place to visit and Canada is first and foremost a liberal country and nation of origin...re: so let us keep it that way!she has done nothing wrong in regards to and versus what the average person faces as to the reason for deportation!


Matthew
said

As the story states the woman applied and based on her application did not meet the criteria. So rather than accepting that and attempting to meet the criteria ( secure work, savings balance, etc... ) she is preparing a refugee claim?What were the reasons for her application being denied? There is no mention of that. Again does she have a job, savings, or any means to support herself? Regardless if the individual is transgendered, or bisexual, or straight, etc... if you can't support yourself why should you be allowed to stay and be placed on one of our social systems?Also it will be interesting to see how her lawyer argues the dangers of being transgendered in the EU are any great than here in Canada. In conclusion this story should probably be re-titled, 'Upset Foreigner Fails Immigration Critiera, Files Refugee Claim' but then again that wouldn't be news right?


D. E. Smith, Langley, BC
said

A no-brainer, send this one back ASAP. He/she should have thought of this prior to having the change. Under no conditions should refugee status even be considered!


Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said

I'd be hard pressed to explain how Ireland is more anti-transgendered than Canada. Ireland, the land of pixies, leprechauns and fairys sounds like a place that wouldn't have issues with she/ he. But, if she/he wants to stay in Canada, she/he should try using the truth, not a lawyer.


Denise
said

Yes, everyone knows how intolerant those Europeans are of alternative lifestyles...rolls eyes


Matt in NS
said

Better keep her here, NS needs all the tax dollars we can get.


G.Boudreau
said

I thought refugee status was granted to people who came from unstable countries, not N.Ireland. It seems to me this person is just trying to stay in Canada because she has made some ties. This has nothing to do with refugee status. But then again here in Canada we let anyone in.


slipperyslope
said

Why is it that everyone wants to be treated equally, but as soon as things don't go their way they pull out the race card or the gender card or whatever card works to their advantage?


RealityCzech
said

Sadly, one is as likely to face hate crime in Canada as you are in the EU. Therefore, not a valid claim.


Lou
said

"Tanya doesn't know why she was rejected, other than she does not meet the criteria." ??
Seems pretty self-explanatory to me. Of course this will turn into a political thing, claiming her rejection has to do with being stigmatized for her sexuality. Lots of hot buttons for the media. The country she is seeking refugee status from (Ireland) indeed has problems with violence, but then, Montreal could fit that profile too. Sorry, I'm against granting refugee status on par with say, some one from Darfur or true war-torn countries who need our help desperately.


Linda
said

Interesting case, and one where we can safely say that the political issue will be more important than the individual considerations. The EU doesn't want any acknowledgement of the hate crimes issue, and conservatives here won't be looking to support a transgendered person... I feel for her, but I think the road she's on is about to significantly more rocky.


Frank Buchan
said

This is the kind of abuse of the immigration system that saddens me, because it will turn people against the very idea of refugee status being valid. I feel for this woman, but realistically the kind of hate she is using to lever a stay is present in pockets everywhere.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Commuters wait for the first train after a five-hour work stoppage by urban rail workers, as all other public transport employees are on a 48-hour strike, in Athens on Friday, Feb. 10, 2012. (AP Photo/Thanassis Stavrakis)

Greek unions launch two-day strike, bailout in limbo

More    Comments  

Sub.-Lt. Jeffrey Paul Delisle is escorted from provincial court in Halifax on Tuesday, Jan. 17, 2012.

Entirety of Moscow spy allegations may never be known

More  2 Video(s) 2