Top Stories -   

1
In this image taken from video provided by BP PLC at 22:19 CDT, the containment stack is shown at the site of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico Sunday, July 18, 2010. (AP /BP PLC) In this image taken from video provided by BP PLC at 12:24 CDT, a robotic arm uses a long wand-like object to clean out debris from a pipe at the site of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico Saturday, July 17, 2010. (AP / BP PLC) Vessels assisting in the capping of the Deepwater Horizon oil wellhead are seen on the Gulf of Mexico near the coast of Louisiana Sunday, July 18, 2010. (AP / Patrick Semansky)

Amid leakage concerns, feds and BP clash over well cap plans

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Paul Workman on the well
The flow of oil coming from the damaged well in the Gulf of Mexico appears to have been stopped, but government scientists are now concerned that seepage detected in the seabed near the well may be a sign of an underground leak.
CTV News Channel: Eric Smith, associate dir.
The associate director at the Tulane Energy Institute says he says if the U.S. government intends to open the well to pump oil to the surface, there is nothing BP can do to stop them.
CTV News Channel: Richard Charter, policy advisor
An energy consultant to Defenders of Wildlife and senior policy advisor says the low pressure could indicate that there could be a leak below the blowout or the oil reserve has depleted, but says he is optimistic the cap is a permanent fix.
CTV News Channel: Matt Gutman in Buras, La.
A correspondent with ABC News says the extension of the time to monitor the cap is a good indication of how well things are going, but says the U.S. government may stop them from further testing due to the upcoming hurricane season.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (15) Facebook   

In this image taken from video provided by BP PLC at 22:19 CDT, the containment stack is shown at the site of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico Sunday, July 18, 2010. (AP /BP PLC) In this image taken from video provided by BP PLC at 12:24 CDT, a robotic arm uses a long wand-like object to clean out debris from a pipe at the site of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico Saturday, July 17, 2010. (AP / BP PLC) Vessels assisting in the capping of the Deepwater Horizon oil wellhead are seen on the Gulf of Mexico near the coast of Louisiana Sunday, July 18, 2010. (AP / Patrick Semansky)

Photos

In this image taken from video provided by BP PLC at 22:19 CDT, the containment stack is shown at the site of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico Sunday, July 18, 2010. (AP /BP PLC)

View Larger Image

Date: Sun. Jul. 18 2010 10:46 PM ET

Washington's point man in the Gulf spill crisis is asking that BP submit a plan to reopen the recently-capped oil well, as concern increases that leakage is occurring beneath the ocean floor.

"I direct you to provide me with a written procedure for opening the choke valve as quickly as possible ... should hydrocarbon seepage near the well head be confirmed," retired Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen wrote in a letter Sunday.

BP had said its new sealing cap has blocked oil from gushing into the Gulf of Mexico, with early tests showing no damage to the undersea well. But those tests could be contradicted.

It now appears that the U.S. government wants to reopen the fragile well cap and begin pumping the oil to the surface. However, doing so would mean reopening the well for three days as the system is put in place.

Among concerns over seepage, bubbles near the busted oil well have been found. Officials fear that the bubbles may be the result of a methane leak.

Further complicating matters, pressure readings have been lower than expected on the well cap, which suggests that there may be another leak somewhere along the wellbore. Any such leak would be even harder to fix.

"While we are pleased that no oil is currently being released into the Gulf of Mexico and want to take all appropriate action to keep it that way, it is important that all decisions are driven by the science," Allen said.

Despite the government's plans, however, BP had said that the cap should remain sealed.

The company's chief operating officer, Doug Suttles, said earlier Sunday that the cap could remain in place until the well is permanently plugged by cement and mud.

"No one associated with this whole activity ... wants to see any more oil flow into the Gulf of Mexico," he said. "Right now we don't have a target to return the well to flow."

He added that there is no real proof that the bubbles around the wellhead are the result of a methane leak.

"We have done some simple tests to see if these bubbles come from hydrocarbons, at this point we don't believe they are," said Suttles.

When asked about the apparent contradiction between the government's stance and BP's approach, a company representative would only say: "we continue to work very closely with all government scientists on this."

One possible explanation is that BP may be trying to sidestep criticism if the well has to be reopened. If the company can paint a possible reopening as a government decision, it may help the company avoid further public embarrassment.

BP first tightened the cap on Thursday and immediately began testing whether it could withstand pressure from the gushing oil. So far, the seal has performed better than expected.

It marks the first time since April 20 that oil has stopped flowing into the Gulf.

In worst-case estimates by the U.S. government, the well pumped up to 9.5 million litres of oil into the sea every day, causing untold harm to marine life and the Gulf coastline.

The leak began after an explosion aboard the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig. The blast killed 11 people and injured dozens more.

Comments are now closed for this story

Christie
said

Something to keep in mind in terms of clean up...the most that has ever been cleaned up from any oil spill around the world is 15%!!The majority of the oil that was spilled into the Gulf of Mexico will be in the ecosystem for decades to come.


Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said

Words you'll seldom hear. I agree with Prof Pye, ( except for his usual insults ) we would be free of the oil monkey if we relied on nuclear power. This is what the Liberals are trying to do in NB. Did you know that France is spearheading Nuclear power in Europe. Over 78% of their power is nuclear, and it exports 18% to other European countries, plus the skys over France are the cleanest in Europe. I'm hoping NB gets a second plant, maybe we will become a have province and not depend on equalization payments. Just hoping.


Jake
said

Kudos Reese, you nailed it right on the head. The U.S. is a beggar nation. As for jake in miami and your comments blaming the enviromentalists for this disaster. Take a look at your waistline pal, as should all of us Americans, that says it all...over consuming pigs and oil is the biggest and baddest and is on top. So don't go blaming people who try to save this planet. If your not part of the solution then your part of the problem.


Wendy
said

I am having trouble with the word "success". Whatever the reason it happened.. the whole thing was a disaster and will be for years to come. In my opinion the word success just doesn't fit. Don't get me wrong I am glad they have managed to stop the flow.


CraigW
said

I believe them. So far their judgement and honesty have been a model for us all.


reece
said

America should forgo it's quest to remain a superpower and begin the process of sustainability. It's not only the demand for oil that is causing that nation to implode on itself, but it's now facing major water shortages. What is exactly the point in being a superpower when soverignty is yielded to rogue nations like China, and Saudi Arabia etc? That term seems to be a misnomer. There is nothing "super" about begging and bending one's principals and the "power".....who are you kidding? Self sustainabilty, and being an exporter of high technology goods and services is the future. This "weasle" word SUPERPOWER is intented to provide Americans the illusion that the elite have things under control when in fact it is some abstract word given to its masses of idiots as a substitute for the proper label BEGGAR NATION. The elite in their quest for profit sold America out and you can term this nation any word you feel comfortable with but oil spills like this are likely to come to the high Acrtic unless their govt is prepared to level with their people with the truth of their state of affairs and start to address their over-population.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

BP has now been rendered an obese and starving diabetic, stuck in a sterile white room with only a giant fudge brownie sitting upon a table. (I wonder how long it will take?) Let's not pretend that North Americans, and others in the West, are anxiously poised to abandon their de facto "addiction" to oil. Alternative energy sources are still largely a joke (spare me the foolish enthusiasm), and will remain on the sidelines for some time. Gas-sucking automobiles need to be replaced with electricity-sucking, battery-powered cars; unless industrious pointyheads can instead make sense of hydrogen. Let's get reacquainted with nuclear power, and develop safe and acceptable sources. It's time to quit being energy ostriches and apply the requisite scientific and financial resources that could/would propel us forward into energy independence and a greater regard for the environment. Time to get the show on the road.


Stu from London
said

@Jake in Florida....yes, environmentalists caused this. Overregulation caused this? I don't believe you. BP are the only ones who are responsible for this. It's their well, they didn't do their job properly. You should be thanking environmentalists.


Bevan in Winnipeg
said

Good. The remainder of the clean-up will no doubt take many months, if not years.Future exploration and extraction efforts must be accompanied by stringent regulations that also include criminal consequences for the company big-shots should there be deviation from these regulations. On-site peraons are responsible, but company big-shots are the ones who are accountable, i.e. the ones who go to jail.This will force them to ride herd on the on-site personnel, and ensure that corners are not cut, and if they are then the on-site staff gets cut. Overseers on this must be regulatory inspectors who must be on-site at all times and not just periodic forewarned visits. On-site regulators must also be rotated frequently, less they get too chummy with the on-site company persons, and subject to corruption.


Brian in Nanaimo
said

The US Gov't is to blame for allowing and encouraging this type of drilling without any kind of relief wells in place. Great job US for ruining the oceans of the world. You've done it before and you've done it again. Same company in fact, 30 years ago in the gulf and tried the same tactics that failed back then as they have now. Funny how nothing was done to change the drilling practices thirty years later. A crime of global proportions far worse than anything thus far in human history. At least you know your free.


Retired Drilling Rig Captain Dartmouth
said

Engineering has prevailed..!! While the blame game is manifesting itself at a fevered pitch... Lets not forget that the big work is about to begin. The clean up operation will be long and very painstaking. The system that was put together to have contained this catastrophe could have been put together as part of a properly deigned contingency plan. This disaster was years in the making...and incidently...years BEFORE Barak Obama was elected to the whitehouse. Note: This took 3 months to contain. That is a marked improvement from the 10 months that it took to resolve a gas blowout ere in Nova Scotia in the 1980's that nearly caused the loss of the Venture gas field. I do not know of any Regualtor anywhere who could have expeditied the conclusion any faster than what was done here. What is needed here is stronger vigilance on the part of Regulators when granting permits, a robust audit system....Trust but Verify! and no hestitation on issuing a Stop Work Order on an operator that deviates from accepted standards. The public expects nothing less!


Michelle
said

I was more concerned with the comment..."Right now we don't have a target to return the well to flow." How about you just leave it alone? I'm sure NO ONE wants to see them operating out of that area again. The damage is done. The damage will continue to ravage that area for decades to come. Just leave the well alone. It boggles my mind how much the oil and gas industry will spend on R&D, and their grand scale plans to retrieve oil in the deep seas but no one seems to want to stand up, recognize that green energy is the future and boldly move in that direction. The oil and gas industry needs some forward thinking leaders and more importantly, the government needs to start proving that they want to see more green energy and subsidizing its development. (That means in Canada too!)


Jake in Florida
said

This disaster was in large part caused by environmentalists and environmental regulations pushing offshore oil drilling into deeper and deeper waters. Unfortunately a reasonable solution will not be achieved until Barrack Hussein Obama is booted out in 2012. His push for a moratorium on drilling is an economic disaster for the people in the gulf region!


Brian
said

While the news out of the Gulf is, finally, maybe, promising. BP apparently still feels the need to retain outside assistance in handling the fallout from this oil disaster. Check out the transcript of what Steve Jobs, BP's new Chief Speaking Officer, had to say on behalf of the oil giant.

Ian
said

Good News yes, but has BP learnt anything with its CEO making comments like,"No one associated with this whole activity ... wants to see any more oil flow into the Gulf of Mexico." This should NEVER have happened to begin with. Let's hope this is the end of it, and the people whose livelihoods are in the Gulf Region can start cleaning up and getting on with their lives.

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

BP CEO Tony Hayward, wearing red tie, leaves the Rayburn House Office Building following his testimony before an Energy and Environment Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations hearing on the role of BP in the Deepwater Horizon explosion and oil spill, Thursday, June 17, 2010, on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/Haraz N. Ghanbari)

BP goes to D.C.

As BP's CEO testifies on Capitol Hill, contrasting images from the Gulf.

Booms surround Queen Bess Island as clean up operations of oil from the Deepwater Horizon spill continue in off the coast of Louisiana Tuesday, June 8, 2010. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel)

The Big Mop-Up

Boats, booms and bulldozers chase down oil spill, going in all directions.

Brown Pelicans mired in oil

Natural Disaster

Brown pelicans mired in oil -- victims of the Gulf oil leak.

University of South Florida biological oceanographer Ernst Peebles stands in front of blue screen diagram of the Deepwater Horizon's location in the Gulf of Mexico during a news conference Tuesday, June 8, 2010, in St. Petersburg, Fla. (AP / Chris O'Meara)

The Big Fix

The public is offering BP their solutions for the oil spill.

Epic Oil Disaster

Epic oil disaster

25 photos reveal the magnitude of the worst spill in U.S. history.

BP oil disaster

No way out?

No way out?

BP's big problems keep piling up.

Steven Skurka

Crime Sheet

Were oil crimes committed in the Gulf? Steven Skurka with his analysis.

Today's Top Stories

Graham James is seen exiting the courthouse in Winnipeg, Wednesday, Feb. 22. 2012.

Graham James apologizes to victims, hockey community

More  3 Video(s) 3

Public Safety Minister Vic Toews (left)and Justice Minister Rob Nicholson take part in a news conference to announce measures protecting children from internet predators, in Ottawa, Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2012. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Canadians will likely pay for online surveillance bill

More   49 Comments 49    2 Video(s) 2

Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

Journalists grieve for slain comrades in Syria

More   20 Comments 20    7 Video(s) 7