Top Stories -   

1
FBI agents are seen outside 35B Trowbridge Road in Cambridge, Mass., a residence owned by Donald Heathfield and Tracey Foley on Sunday, June 27, 2010. Heathfield and Foley were arrested Sunday by the FBI on allegations of being Russian spies. (AP / Richard Stanley) FBI agents gather in front of the two-story residence in Yonkers, N.Y. where two suspected Russian secret agents Vicky Pelaez and a man known as 'Juan Lazaro' were arrested on Monday June 28, 2010.  (AP / The Journal News, Shawn Cohen) This undated image taken from a Facebook page shows a woman journalists have identified as Anna Chapman, who appeared at a hearing Monday, June 28, 2010 in New York federal court. Chapman, along with 10 others, was arrested on charges of conspiracy to act as an agent of a foreign government without notifying the U.S. attorney general. (AP) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010. (AP / Elizabeth Williams) Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov talks at a press conference with his Israeli counterpart Avigdor Lieberman, not pictured, following their meeting in Jerusalem, Tuesday, June 29, 2010. Lavrov is on an official visit to the region. Lavrov says Moscow is waiting for a U.S. explanation on the arrests of alleged Russian spies. (AP / Tara Todras-Whitehill) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010.

Canadian family shocked by link to alleged spy ring

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Joy Malbon on the escape
Police are looking for the alleged ringleader of a Russian spy-ring who skipped bail and mysteriously disappeared after being arrested in Cyprus on Tuesday. Ten others linked to the ring remain in custody in the U.S.
Canada AM: Michel Juneau-Katsuya, former CSIS agent
A former RCMP officer and CSIS agent explains how a spy might steal an identity and describes the training they must undergo to pass as Canadians, while also saying the mass arrest of the Russian agents is a rare catch.
Canada AM: David Heathfield, brother's identity stolen
A man whose deceased infant brother's identity was stolen by Russian spies reacts to the news and says the family is worried that their names will be put on a no-fly list because of their connection to the spy ring.
Canada AM: CNN's Matthew Chance in Moscow
A correspondent in Moscow describes how the alleged foreign spy ring scandal is being received in Russia and discusses whether the arrests threatens to derail attempts to mend relations between the two former superpowers.
CTV News Channel: Martin Rudner, security expert
A security expert says that four out of the 11 spies used Canadian identities, because Canadians are very welcomed in the U.S. and can freely participate in meetings and government assemblies without raising suspicions.
CTV News Channel: Gordon Thomas, spy expert
An espionage expert says Canadian passports are easy to obtain and vacationers are often targets for having their passport stolen and being used by spy agents, while also saying it can take up to 3 years to get a service agent ready to go undercover.
Canada AM: Arne Kislenko, security expert
A security expert reacts to the news that the FBI has arrested a Russian spy ring whose members were posing as Canadian citizens and says he is not surprised, while explaining that this is not the first time a Russian agent was uncovered with a Canadian passport.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (16) Facebook   

FBI agents are seen outside 35B Trowbridge Road in Cambridge, Mass., a residence owned by Donald Heathfield and Tracey Foley on Sunday, June 27, 2010. Heathfield and Foley were arrested Sunday by the FBI on allegations of being Russian spies. (AP / Richard Stanley) FBI agents gather in front of the two-story residence in Yonkers, N.Y. where two suspected Russian secret agents Vicky Pelaez and a man known as 'Juan Lazaro' were arrested on Monday June 28, 2010.  (AP / The Journal News, Shawn Cohen) This undated image taken from a Facebook page shows a woman journalists have identified as Anna Chapman, who appeared at a hearing Monday, June 28, 2010 in New York federal court. Chapman, along with 10 others, was arrested on charges of conspiracy to act as an agent of a foreign government without notifying the U.S. attorney general. (AP) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010. (AP / Elizabeth Williams) Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov talks at a press conference with his Israeli counterpart Avigdor Lieberman, not pictured, following their meeting in Jerusalem, Tuesday, June 29, 2010. Lavrov is on an official visit to the region. Lavrov says Moscow is waiting for a U.S. explanation on the arrests of alleged Russian spies. (AP / Tara Todras-Whitehill) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010.

Photos

FBI agents are seen outside 35B Trowbridge Road in Cambridge, Mass., a residence owned by Donald Heathfield and Tracey Foley on Sunday, June 27, 2010. Heathfield and Foley were arrested Sunday by the FBI on allegations of being Russian spies. (AP / Richard Stanley)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Jun. 30 2010 9:59 PM ET

A Canadian family is baffled as to how an alleged Russian spy selected the name of a dead relative to use for a false identity.

The U.S. announced earlier this week that it had smashed an alleged Russian spy-ring that sought to infiltrate policy-making circles in the United States.

Four of the accused spies purported to be Canadians -- one of whom was using the name of Donald Howard Graham Heathfield, an infant who died decades ago in Montreal.

The surviving family members of the deceased Donald Heathfield are shocked by their connection to the still-developing spy drama.

David Heathfield was only four years old when his brother died as an infant 47 years ago.

"He just died of a crib death. It was very sudden," said Heathfield, telling CTV's Canada AM about his brother's death during a telephone interview from Brampton, Ont., on Wednesday morning.

It's the family's suspicion that the alleged spies picked the name up from an obituary that was placed in the paper in the past.

Heathfield said he learned about his family's connection to the spy story after a reporter phoned him asking for comment about the case.

After checking into the matter, Heathfield began to wonder "how someone could use Donald's name or my father's name, and on top of that, be a Russian spy?"

While the family is asking for answers about how this could happen, they also have concerns that their ability to travel could be in jeopardy as a result of their name being involved in the case.

"We're concerned that in our travelling plans, you know, if we're put on any no-fly lists going into the (United) States, because now we're connected to this Russian spy-thing with our surname," said Heathfield.

Heathfield said the family has not been contacted by authorities in the U.S. or Canada since the story broke.

The three other spy suspects that claim to be Canadian went by the names Patricia Mills, Christopher R. Metsos and Tracey Lee Ann Foley.

Foley is married to the arrested suspect who used Heathfield's name.

The arrested man known as Donald Heathfield worked in Boston for Global Partners Inc., a business-services firm.

He claimed to have graduated from York University in 1995 -- where a degree exists with his name on it -- and colleagues believed he was of French Canadian background.

Investigators have revealed that they have obtained a copy of an Ontario birth certificate under the name of Donald Howard Graham Heathfield. The suspicion is that it is fake.

Russian spies have long used the identities of dead individuals and former CSIS agent Michel Juneau-Katsuya says it is a "classic story" that he has worked on himself.

These spies typically take the identity of a dead child, start planning a new identity and "begin to make a new person out of the entire thing."

"The Russian spy has to undergo intensive training, in terms of language, to sort of pick up the accent of being a Canadian," Juneau-Katsuya told CTV's Canada AM from Ottawa on Wednesday morning.

"He has to understand, or she has to understand, also a little bit of Canadian history, because she or he has to assume the identity of a Canadian."

In Moscow, media are questioning the timing of the arrests of the people linked to the alleged spy ring.

CNN's Matthew Chance said there is a sense that the decades-old tensions between Moscow and Washington are rearing their head at a time when the two countries are trying to improve relations.

"This comes against the backdrop of warming relations between Moscow and Washington -- and the sense here is that there are hawks in Washington that are very uncomfortable with the idea of the Obama administration moving closer to the Kremlin and wanted to deliver this message that the Russians couldn't be entirely trusted," Chance told CTV's Canada AM during a telephone interview from Moscow on Wednesday morning.

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

anji
said

island girl, the degree is not in the name of the child who died... it's in the name of one of the three individuals.


Tom Powell
said

@fredmarcos
Passport bureaus don't have access to provincial birth certificate systems or CIC stuff. So, all they can do is check to see if the actual document is real. I worked at Passport Canada, and it's not too hard to obtain any documents/id in this country. Unless that person has a previous passport or already has one,or is on a security watch alert list, that's really the only material at our disposal to stop someone from getting a passport. Anyone can be paid off to become a guarantor.


Portes
said

Ex Coelis: I hate to tell you but when you become a member of a family you are expected to pull your weight. hence the hosting of the G8 and G20 summits. Unfortunately there are members of our society that care only about the damage they can cause and this costs a lot of money in today's world. The spy thing is quite funny in a way as Obama and the Russians are getting cosy cosy,so what do plant spies over they years. This is nothing new it is just the rehash of the cold war. I feel sorry for the family that got involved in this as they are innocent bystanders


fredmarcos
said

Why is it not possible to cross check the passport applicants with birth and death certificates. Relying on guarantors and references are obviously not effective especially if one is bent on dubious intentions.


Brian Fr Langley
said

Where is all the shrieking and gnashing of teeth. Here we have a foreign power spying on us with nary a word. Yet when Israeli's were alleged to have used foreign passports you would have thought it was 1939 and they had just invaded Poland.


Doug # BC
said

This is what spies do.The only thing I find a bit odd,is that people seem surprised.I think there are more spies still working than there ever have been.Russia has them,the USA has them,the UK and China have them,and we almost certainly do too.This is on reason,that,although we demand transparency from government,no government can be totally transparent.In spite of what "Ted" calls a game,national security and our general welfare are at stake any time we don't know what other nations are up to. I do like "island girl's" question though.I hope she will get an answer.I'd also like to know if there is a loophole that makes identity theft a little easier.The spies they are after seem to be in the USA.But trust me,if Canada becomes a suspected source of spies,our border with the USA will get even harder to cross for all of us.We all know how paranoid they can be,and an event like this could also be used as an excuse for more protectionist trade policies.Just like a non tariff trade restriction.Especially with a Congress full of Democrats. Hmmm.Curioser and curioser.


AB dude
said

Doesn't it remind you of ALIAS? Laura Bristow a.k.a. Irina Derevko.


nora garrett
said

The Russian KGB is still very much alive. These people who have their loved ones names used have my sympathy and I hope that things are cleared up for them and their loved ones. And they are treated as Canadians.


Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said

I do not know why people are surprised by this, all one has to do is walk through a cemetary check the head stones (no need to check through old death notices) the names and dates are there and the rest unfortunately is too easy. This has happened many times in the U.S.A. (identities being created in this manner) . This is not new and has been going on for years ! It is scary but true !


Martin of NS
said

I think this is a clear indication that it is too easy to get an identity from Canada. I love how the news is making this seem like a surprise that there are spies in the United States, especially Russian. Everyone spies on everyone, didn't the Prime Minister accuse the Chinese government of corporate/government espionage? Spying happens in times of war and peace.


Barry in Saskabush
said

I am not surprised. It is so easy to get a Canadian identity. Look in the newspaper for someone who just died - go and apply for a social security number (or in some provinces a birth certificate) in their name saying you are them and lost your id in the river - do the same for your medical insurance, drivers license, etc. (Be sure to give a new mailing address to have cards mailed to you.) When (not if) one such id card is issued, it can be used for your new identity to thus more easily get another id card - and then you are this person. Having been born in Canada, I am not impressed how easily other people in the world get in here illegitimately. It has been this way for years and I doubt even a spy scandal will close the doors to so easily taking on a dead Canadian's identity. Sad much. I think it is long overdue for the government to plug such holes in the system.


Ex Coelis
said

Hmmmmm, let's see... The Director(Richard Fadden) of our Canadian Security and Intelligence Services told us(June 23rd/10) that he was 'a bit worried in a couple of provinces that we have an indication that there's some political figures who have developed quite an attachment to foreign countries.' His comments were about and included Civil servants, Municipal and minister of the Crown. Mister Fadden further stated that 'At least five countries are surreptitiously recruiting future political prospects in universities, he said.' He also stated that 'Middle East countries and China are also involved.' So the fact that someone in the United States has discovered that Russia may also be involved in spying activities is a bolt from the blue? Mister Fadden went on to say that he is 'concerned that too much of the agency's resources are now focused on fighting terrorism and not counter-espionage. That concentration leaves more chances to steal Canada's sensitive technology and trade secrets, worth billions of dollars a year.'
Mister Harper; I believe your Intelligence Director is telling you that it's time to quit spending money on anti-protester fences and fake lakes and put Canadian tax dollars where they truly belong - IN DEFENSE OF CANADA!!!!


Ted
said

James Bond lives! Of course the US spies in Russia have not been caught yet. Kind of reminds me of a game I played as a kid...snakes and ladders!


island girl
said

Why does York University have a record of a degree granted to a child that dies in infancy? Did the man assume the identity and then take a whole 4 year degree just to have a record of him being there? Can't be a fake degree if the university has a record of him unless they cracked in to the records department computer and added his name. Pretty thorough.....


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

I suppose those James Bond movies were becoming tiresome in their quest for terrorists and drug smugglers, it's time to resurrect the traditional movie villains: the Russian spies.


Paul
said

That's one of the easiest ways to assume a new identity. Criminals do it too. Identity theft is standard tradecraft.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012.  (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Charles Taylor gets 50 years for 'brutal' crimes

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Second package containing body part found in Ottawa

More  3 Video(s) 3

Supporters of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, hold placards and banners bearing images of him before the verdict was given in his extradition case at the Supreme Court in London, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (AP / Matt Dunham)

Britain's top court backs extradition of WikiLeaks chief

More   2 Comments 2    2 Video(s) 2