Top Stories -   

1
This undated image taken from a Facebook page shows a woman journalists have identified as Anna Chapman, who appeared at a hearing Monday, June 28, 2010 in New York federal court. Chapman, along with 10 others, was arrested on charges of conspiracy to act as an agent of a foreign government without notifying the U.S. attorney general. (AP) The neighborhood of Marquette Road in Montclair, N.J., is seen Tuesday, June 29, 2010. (AP / Rich Schultz) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010. (AP / Elizabeth Williams) Waldomar Mariscal, son of Vicky Pelaez and Juan Lazaro who were arrested on Sunday on charges of spying for the Russians, speaks to reporters as he arrives home in Yonkers, N.Y., Tuesday, June 29, 2010. (AP / David Karp) Headquarters of the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service seen on the outskirts of Moscow, Tuesday, June 29, 2010. (AP /Mikhail Metzel) FBI agents gather in front of the two-story residence in Yonkers, N.Y. where two suspected Russian secret agents Vicky Pelaez and a man known as Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov talks at a press conference with his Israeli counterpart Avigdor Lieberman, not pictured, following their meeting in Jerusalem, Tuesday, June 29, 2010. Lavrov is on an official visit to the region. Lavrov says Moscow is waiting for a U.S. explanation on the arrests of alleged Russian spies. (AP / Tara Todras-Whitehill) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010.

Spy-ring arrests could hurt Russian ties with U.S.

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Joy Malbon on the spy ring
Both Moscow and Washington are trying to keep the latest spy scandal from poisoning relations between the two capitals, as 11 people face real and serious charges of acting as secret foreign agents in the U.S.
CTV News Channel: David Heathfield, brother
The brother of the deceased Canadian Donald Heathfield, says one of the spies who stole his late brother's identity must have gotten it through an obituary that his parents put out in 1963.
CTV News Channel: Martin Rudner, security expert
A security expert says that four out of the 11 spies used Canadian identities, because Canadians are very welcomed in the U.S. and can freely participate in meetings and government assemblies without raising suspicions.
CTV News Channel: Gordon Thomas, spy expert
An espionage expert says Canadian passports are easy to obtain and vacationers are often targets for having their passport stolen and being used by spy agents, while also saying it can take up to 3 years to get a service agent ready to go undercover.
Canada AM: Arne Kislenko, security expert
A security expert reacts to the news that the FBI has arrested a Russian spy ring whose members were posing as Canadian citizens and says he is not surprised, while explaining that this is not the first time a Russian agent was uncovered with a Canadian passport.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (34) Facebook   

This undated image taken from a Facebook page shows a woman journalists have identified as Anna Chapman, who appeared at a hearing Monday, June 28, 2010 in New York federal court. Chapman, along with 10 others, was arrested on charges of conspiracy to act as an agent of a foreign government without notifying the U.S. attorney general. (AP) The neighborhood of Marquette Road in Montclair, N.J., is seen Tuesday, June 29, 2010. (AP / Rich Schultz) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010. (AP / Elizabeth Williams) Waldomar Mariscal, son of Vicky Pelaez and Juan Lazaro who were arrested on Sunday on charges of spying for the Russians, speaks to reporters as he arrives home in Yonkers, N.Y., Tuesday, June 29, 2010. (AP / David Karp) Headquarters of the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service seen on the outskirts of Moscow, Tuesday, June 29, 2010. (AP /Mikhail Metzel) FBI agents gather in front of the two-story residence in Yonkers, N.Y. where two suspected Russian secret agents Vicky Pelaez and a man known as Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov talks at a press conference with his Israeli counterpart Avigdor Lieberman, not pictured, following their meeting in Jerusalem, Tuesday, June 29, 2010. Lavrov is on an official visit to the region. Lavrov says Moscow is waiting for a U.S. explanation on the arrests of alleged Russian spies. (AP / Tara Todras-Whitehill) In this courtroom sketch, Anna Chapman, left, Vicky Pelaez, second from left, the defendant known as 'Richard Murphy', center, the defendant known as 'Cynthia Murphy', second from right, and the defendant known as 'Juan Lazaro' are seen in Manhattan federal court in New York, Monday, June 28, 2010.

Photos

This undated image taken from a Facebook page shows a woman journalists have identified as Anna Chapman, who appeared at a hearing Monday, June 28, 2010 in New York federal court. Chapman, along with 10 others, was arrested on charges of conspiracy to act as an agent of a foreign government without notifying the U.S. attorney general. (AP)

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Jun. 29 2010 8:47 PM ET

The arrests in the U.S. of 11 alleged Russian spies -- including four who purported to be Canadians -- threaten to derail attempts to mend relations between the two former superpowers.

Ten of the suspects were arrested Monday and the 11th, Christopher Metsos, who claims to be a Canadian citizen, was arrested Tuesday at an airport in Cyprus while trying to fly to Budapest.

All of the accused were allegedly deep under cover, purporting to lead normal family lives in the U.S. northeast while also gathering and transmitting intelligence about U.S. foreign relations back to Moscow.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Farbiarz has called the arrests just "the tip of the iceberg" of a conspiracy of Russia's Foreign Intelligence Service, known by its Russian acronym SVR.

But Russia's Foreign Ministry angrily condemned the arrests, calling them without merit and suggesting the moves threaten U.S. President Barack Obama's push for a "reset" in chilly Russian-U.S. ties.

"These actions are unfounded and pursue unseemly goals," the Foreign Ministry said in a statement. "We don't understand the reasons which prompted the U.S. Department of Justice to make a public statement in the spirit of Cold War-era spy stories."

The U.S. Justice Department announced the arrests Monday, saying they came after 10 years of FBI work.

Court papers filed in the case say four of those arrested claimed to be Canadian citizens working in the U.S. They include:

  • Donald Howard Heathfield and his purported wife, Tracey Lee Ann Foley
  • Patricia Mills
  • Christopher Metsos

Another of those arrested is Anna Chapman, a 28-year-old divorcee who ran an online real estate business while also allegedly working for the Russian government.

All have been charged with acting as an agent of a foreign government, which carries a maximum of five years in jail. Nine were also charged with conspiracy to commit money laundering, which carries a maximum penalty of 20 years prison. None were charged with the more serious offence of espionage.

According to a detailed criminal complaint, Metsos was the spymaster of the group. He's alleged to have handed out orders to the other operatives, who lived in the Boston, New York and Washington areas.

The complaint alleges the spies received their orders from Moscow Center, the headquarters of the SVR, which is a successor to the Cold War-era KGB. The spies' alleged job was to develop ties in policy-making circles in the U.S. and then send intelligence back to Moscow Center.

According to messages decrypted by the FBI, the spies were told to gather information on the latest U.S. policy on Afghanistan, Iran's nuclear program, and a new weapons treaty between U.S. and Russia.

Heathfield also allegedly met with an unnamed U.S. nuclear scientist seeking information on research into top-secret nuclear warheads.

The alleged spies would then communicate their intelligence back to Moscow via steganography, which are data secretly encrypted into an image that could be posted on a publicly available website but would appear unremarkable to the naked eye. They also used radiograms, which are coded bursts of data sent by a short-wave radio transmitter.

It's unclear whether the ring actually stole any secrets of great importance.

North of the border, the family of one of the men whose identity was allegedly stolen is asking questions about the case.

Brampton, Ont., resident David Heathfield told The Canadian Press that he wants to know how the name of his deceased brother, Donald, wound up in U.S. court files.

Donald died six weeks after he was born in 1963. David Heathfield is concerned that he and his family may now have problems crossing into the U.S., but Canadian authorities have not spoken to him or commented on the case.

Arrests may chill U.S.-Russia relations

The arrests seem likely to embarrass Moscow at a time when the former superpower is trying to mend relations with Washington.

The arrests come days after Obama and his Russian counterpart, Dmitry Medvedev, shared a lunch at a Washington burger joint in a public display meant show that relations between the countries are improving. The arrests also come just a day after the two presidents met in Ontario for the G8 and G20 summits.

Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov noted the timing of the arrests was interesting.

"They haven't explained to us what this is about," Lavrov said at a news conference during a visit to Jerusalem. "I hope they will. The only thing I can say today is that the moment for doing that has been chosen with special elegance."

Oleg Gordievsky, an ex-deputy head of the KGB in London who defected in 1985, says he believes Russia may have as many as 50 deep-cover couples spying inside the United States.

He told the Associated Press that Medvedev would be aware of the precise numbers of these operatives in each target country, though wouldn't necessarily know their identities.

Arne Kislenko, an associate professor of history at Ryerson University who worked as a senior immigration officer for 12 years, noted that the arrests themselves aren't surprising.

"Foreign espionage happens fairly regularly," he told CTV's Canada AM Tuesday. What is surprising, he said, is the size of the ring and the fact that most of the alleged spies led otherwise normal lives, as married couples working regular jobs.

He also noted that Canadian passports have been used in espionage before. In 2006, for example, Canada's spy agency accused a Russian agent of using a fake Ontario birth certificate to obtain passports.

Kislenko said Canada's passports are coveted because, as a result of our multicultural society, people from any nationality can pose as a Canadian. There are also relatively few visa restrictions against Canadians, and we have a certain ease of access to the U.S.

He noted that Canadian passports are not the only ones sought by spies. "We should also note that Swedish, Norwegian and Danish passports are also very attractive," Kislenko said.

With reports from the Associated Press and The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

TB in AB
said

Somewhat ironic that arresting those whose job it is to tell our secrets and report our vulnerabilities to an economic competitor (not to mention a nation that sells weapons to unsavory characters "threaten(s) to derail attempts to mend relations between the two former superpowers." Me thinks thou dost protest too much Russian Foreign Ministry. Time to get real and take your lumps like a big boy, vice sulking in the corner like a spoiled child who got caught with a hand in the cookie jar.


Rev
said

So what are we saying? Call of Duty 2 was right?


FreakAlert
said

".....to develop ties in policy-making circles ..."Wouldn't it have been easier, and legal, if they were just lobbyists?Obviously, the story is bunk. My guess an agenda/plan is in the works for 'stasi style' laws to come to the USA


firstMickey
said

Nobody needs war and death. Smarten up people. Give constructive employment to your citizens. Stop this stupid spying stuff.


Chuck
said

Who knew! Spies are actually sexy like in the movies!


firstMickey
said

Sounds like this crop of spies is no smarter than the ones from the past. And I wish the word "Canadian" would stop being besmirched and dragged through the mud. Canadians are better and smarter than this.


firstMickey
said

Hurt what relationship? A country who sends spies is nobody's friend.


Mr.Confused
said

What do they mean by "former superpowers"?Aren't they currently both considered "superpowers"?


frank
said

cool... time for the cold war to heat up?


Cal in Ottawa
said

Here are the realities of international relations. Countries spy on each other, for a variety of reasons. Countries spy on 'friends' and 'enemies' because, in the words of Lord Palmerson "countries have neither permanent friends nor permanent enemies, just permanent interests." What it seemed these suspect were doing, from what has been reported so far, is low level information gathering. They did not have access to state secrets. Bottom line...looks like much ado about very little.


Corey
said

I am sure there are American spys in Russia... infact I am sure there are American spys everywhere... in China


ultamatt in ns
said

wow , anna is my kind of kgb agent !!!


Jim McB
said

Does this mean that all the "Khadr Lovers" will want us to bring all the accused Canadians back from the US because they are our "Citizens" ?There is no limit to left wing anti government hysteria and flawed logic. When your policy is emotion: who knows where you will go!


David
said

Considering that Russia has recently made the announcement: They are in full support of HAMAS; arrests of a singe spy ring, of an anticipated several, is only an excuse to walk away and keep everything they have stolen. The cold war is back on and has been back on for about 2 years now; President Obama simply hasn't made this publicly known.


Dougcc
said

DO not read anything that says the Americans have blamed Canada for anything. Some of these spies have claimed to be Canadian which might be true seeing as they left a country for another such as ours under false pretense, then applied to the USA for work and moved there. The only problem I will have is if they came from canada, they should be striped of their Canadian citizenship and no crying to the Federal gov. for help when they go to jail. They can seek the Russians for that not ours.


scott
said

Everyone knows but will not admit that one of the most important things you need as an international spie or criminal is a canadian passport. Think of it as a get out of jail free card. Canadian passports are among the cheapest and easiest to buy. You simply walk into a canadian embassy almost anywhere in the world other than Canada or the US, pay your "fee" and walk out. Its that simple. All the canadian government cares about is maintaining economic ties with these countries at any and all costs. As a result, canadian companies and their technology have become easy targets. Unfortunately for canadian companies, this free for all will never stop.


Gary
said

Perhaps the US is starting to justify the sides they will be picking in their future attack on North Korea. Perhaps they feared a Russian siding with NK.


Westerner
said

Interesting that people thought all spying stopped in all Countries!!! That's why they call them "Spies" and they go "Undercover" - if you have something someone else wants - you do what it takes to accomplish a goal! Then you improve it and sell it to someone who can afford to pay you - rules of the game - some people must not of studied "Commerce in relation to Free Trade".


JB
said

Sounds like something out of a James Bond film.


vince
said

Is not any strange that the US never moves quickly enough to trap or catch suspicious activities, I try to report to the INS at one time and I was treated like it did not matter what I knew about these illegal Ukrainians living in my ex uncle's in law home, they are even acting like a nurses and they have a different type of jobs, they actually drop college and now they work in a illegal status, but since I have been rejected from the INS( I ask to speak with an agent) and been treated like garbage I really do not care what the government will do, I try to pass the tip but it seems that they can live with their arrogance and pure ego, they are so unprofessional.

Comrade Bubba says so sorry, but no help here
said

No one really cares what the Russians think. We all know that the guys in charge there now are throwbacks to the Cold War. The names have changed, but the actions haven't.

Lies, Corruption, Payoffs, Bribery, Thuggery, have, and always been the tools of trade in Russia. What's new is they are getting caught.

Too bad for Canadians who helped them. We won't help you either. Get used to looking at the inside of American Prisons, cuz that's where you'll stay. Still, that's better than Siberian Jails.


The Dove is Never Free
said

Not surprising.Now what about catching Chinese spies, be they into industrial, military or political espionage?


Daniel From Toronto
said

We probally do have some in Canada but everyone does in the entire world. Their is no such thing as trust between countries anymore because it shows weakness to other opposing countries. Just show your cards and get out so we dont have to go through a WW3 anytime soon.


Jim in Ottawa
said

Well, what else was the US supposed to do? Let them continue to walk free and threaten their country? Every country has the right to defend their sovereignty whether that country is the US, Russia, or any other. The Russians are just making of meal of this because they got caught red-handed! People, be fair in your crticisms of the US.


Frank In Russia
said

Yea like the Americans have something the Russians want. If you want something all you have to do is google it. Every thing's on the WWW. )))


Ken
said

Things will be just fine. It's no different than Israel spying on the U.S. and Canada and we are all still best friends.


Acroyear
said

Canada is an immigrant country, with a very diverse population and culture. Thus it's easy to "be Canadian" as there is no single Canadian identity. Thus, so long as we remain that nation (and I for one am proud of the fact we welcome those with something to enrich to our diverse land) we will also always be a place that spies use as the fake homeland. Given that who our neighbors are, we are always going to be prime fake ID targets. MOSAD did it all the time, CIA used to do it, French Intel did it, and these are just the ones that have come to light. I would have been more surprised if none of them carried fake Canadian papers.It's up to u to control our official documents as much as we possibly can, but it's also up to other nations to check those documents as well.Hey! At least the Yanks get to blame the Beaver, rather than Moose and Squirell ;)


Plabo
said

Wow! It took ten years to uncover these people which have not even been charged with espionage. This sounds like the work of the RCMP ...


James
said

Canadian passports ARE attractive because of A) our ethnic diversity - I think every species of humanity can be found living in Canada, and B) we are fairly well respected all over the world. Its a fact of life for being "the cool people". Let's move on. I'm more concerned that the US made these busts public. In the interest of cooperation, I wouldn't have. It was bad move for the administration - unless because these are low-level spies who didn't steal anything significant the administration wasn't informed about this until after the fact...in which case the Americans have their own people working to make sure US/Russian interests never ally...makes you wonder...


rg
said

jp your right, the russians are innocent always have been always will . the yanks are guilty again.


kevin-how many in canada do you thing?
said

You can bet your frist born we have all kinds here in canada.


JP
said

YES here we go again What the USA and Americans will do for attention - When the SPOT LIGHT is NOT on them - they soem how reate incidents to bring the attention back to them.As they say in South Park - "" BLAME CANADA"""


Bill in BC
said

Awww, Russia and spying; of course they deny it. Just as the US would, of the UK or China, etc etc etc. Denying is just part of the eternal game.


Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said

Here we go again back to the "Cold War", just what we need at this time in history.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012.  (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Charles Taylor gets 50 years for 'brutal' crimes

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Second package containing body part found in Ottawa

More  3 Video(s) 3

Supporters of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, hold placards and banners bearing images of him before the verdict was given in his extradition case at the Supreme Court in London, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (AP / Matt Dunham)

Britain's top court backs extradition of WikiLeaks chief

More   2 Comments 2    2 Video(s) 2