News Sections
Parties reach deal to avert Homolka pardon
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Selected Comment
Why don't they temporarily suspend all pardons until the Bill is in place and running?
dahren
MPs look for ways to derail Homolka pardon bid
talking about
Parties reach deal to avert Homolka pardon
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Jun. 16 2010 11:05 PM ET
The government and opposition parties have reached a deal to keep convicted sex killer Karla Homolka from receiving a criminal pardon.
Homolka would have been eligible to apply for a pardon as early as July 5, and MPs have been scrambling to find a way to keep her potential application from being granted.
At a news conference on Wednesday evening, Public Safety Minister Vic Toews said the Tories and the opposition parties had reached a last-minute agreement to push pardon reforms through before the Commons closes for the summer on Thursday.
"We essentially have a deal with the Bloc and the New Democrats," he said. "The Liberals are looking at a couple of details but I think on the essential components of an agreement, we will proceed forward with a bill."
Toews said he could not provide specific information on the new legislation, but he described it as a "compromise effort" to pass pardon-reform legislation before the House is adjourned for the summer.
Responding to a question, Toews said he believes that a person convicted of offenses such as Homolka's would not likely qualify for a pardon, if the proposed bill is passed.
"This is an issue that is much greater than one person," he said.
The proposed bill would prevent people convicted of certain crimes from applying for a pardon for a specified number of years, Toews said. It would also give the National Parole Board discretion to deny a pardon request.
Under the agreement, Toews said MPs would vote on a piece of legislation that has been "split off" from Bill C-23, which was introduced by the Tories in May and would bar those convicted of serious violent or sexual crimes from applying for a pardon.
The NDP and Bloc Quebecois oppose some of the measures included in Bill C-23.
"Like a lot of the government's legislation, it mowed down everything in its wake," NDP public safety critic Don Davies said on CTV's Power Play.
As an example, he said Bill C-23 proposed that anyone who has more than three indictable offenses would be barred from receiving a pardon.
"That's the old American three-strikes-you're-out approach that even American states are rejecting now because it works injustices," he said.
Bill C-23 will now be taken up by the House in the fall, Toews said.
Meanwhile, MPs are expected to vote on the new pardons bill on Thursday.
Homolka received a 12-year manslaughter sentence in a plea-bargain deal for taking part in the rape-murders of teens Leslie Mahaffy and Kristen French. Videotapes found after the sentencing showed her to be a more active participant.
Her release from jail in 2005 sparked nationwide outrage.
Tim Danson, the lawyer for the Mahaffy and French families, said news that Homolka may have been ready to seek a pardon for her horrific crimes was disturbing.
"On a personal level, it's very emotional the words Karla Homolka and pardon come up in the same sentence," he said for the families. "They are pretty anxious about what's going on."
Danson said the families are pragmatic about the government trying to speed up the passage of their bill in response to Homolka.
"They accept you don't make public policy based on one individual," he said. "This is something that requires careful debate."
With files from The Canadian Press
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is high time to replace Air Canada with a no-frills airline that can slash prices and still be profitable.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
garybrogan
said
Gary
said
A no brainer and a step in the right direction
Mikey
said
Paul
said
Rob
said
ian
said
ian
said
Jo
said
Rhonda Gribbins
said
Ella
said
Ian
said
Syl
said
Interesting commentary here
said
Jason P
said
KingstonGuy
said
WDK
said
Jim - CGY
said
Now we pay the price, if she is entitlied, she should be allowed to apply.
If she actually gets a pardon then she should be placed on Parliment Hill working with the other Politicians that are above the Laws of this Great Land.
Pay her well, she is a public figure !!!! Doh !!!!!
Nella in Pickering
said
Mark
said
simon in Montreal
said
gizahgin
said
Alan Alfred
said
Sharon in North York
said
Extemd Parlament.
said
Mac
said
Steph
said
Mel Blake
said
Adam
said
Wendy
said
Paul
said
Observer
said
Pat in Mississauga
said
MR - Yellowknife
said
Samual
said
Sandra Stewart
said
Whitehorse Will
said
keitht
said
Anne M
said
Marg Alberta
said
Golfgal7
said
Rebly
said
Corrie AB
said
sandy NS
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Isabelle Watson
said
Save Canada
said
Old Ted
said
Rick
said
Richard in Ontario
said
Jim in the West
said
julie
said
BABE
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
beverly - alberta
said
Catherine Amesbury
said
AL
said
shane
said
M.M.B. Ont
said
Bill in BC
said
Catwoman 37
said
Lianne
said
Elizabeth, Ontario
said
Diana
said
Anne Crozier
said
Graeme
said
Tim
said
DaveB
said
MAL of TO
said
Doug # BC
said
Secondly, pardons may well be granted in a process similar to parole. We chide parole boards for their decisions frequently. But those boards are often forced,by regulations,to make decisions they don't like. In fact,they often tell us they have no choice but to grant parole,and,at the same time,warn us they are paroling a person who is a serious threat to re-offend.
ALL of these regulations need fixing..And everyone except people like "reece" seems to know that.Attack Vic Toews if it makes you feel better. But,the system we have now is almost entirely the LIBERAL system. We have had it since Trudeau was PM,and it doesn't work for anyone except the criminals and the lawyers.The victims and their families,and society as a whole have been poorly served.While I do not advocate for and extreme right wing system,there can be no denying we need change.Given the Liberal tendency to side with the rights of those who commit crimes,the only way we get change is if we let someone else do it.If they go to far,let the Liberals correct the errors when,or if they get re-elected.Unless,of course,they take an unprecedented step,and actually take part in a process to remedy the mistakes they made during their terms in power.A Conservative minority cannot do anything about this if they are fiercely opposed by all the left wing loonies on the opposition side of the house.
reece
said
American conservatives have bankrupted America because they thrive on peoples anger and thirst for revenge. When you have a nation of unemployed people who lost their pensions, homes, social security, and medical plans, these politicians will deflect the anger onto some criminal and have you vent in that direction....on your dime. They sale off into the sunset financially secure. You are still left steaming in your boots as your taxes increase to cover the warehousing of these criminals. You then bow down to China to pay for the infastructure and you must do as they say...don´t be criticizing them too much or our big communist sugar daddy may not show us any more loving and then what? Do you release the prisoners out on the streets? Do you cut the police officers pay check? I hate to see your credit card bill because your passion is buying things you can´t afford. Its ok to be angry, but to get carried away and demand people be locked up forever is only gonna make you poorer and more angry. Try to take up another perspective rather than the old 2 demensional thinking the politicians count on you to adopt on everything.
Chris
said
Jean Hayley
said
Cam Scott
said
Are the people who rubber stamp these applications not looking at the facts?
BritinCanada
said
It's equally despicable to see the federal government use this horrible crime as a wedge issue to polarize voters (something its become expert in doing) by creating issues to keep the media on their "tough on crime agenda" rather than their economic fallacies or obfuscations to social and health policies.Are Canadians that inept they can't see through this? Crime is at its lowest in years, and continues to drop, yet we are constantly mired by the Government's [U.S. republican style] "tough on crime agenda". Are the Conservatives trying to create a prison industry like the US, where the whole judicial system is an economic driver for the country?Reforms are probably needed to the pardon system, I'm sure of that. But knee-jerk reactions will not solve anything. This seems to be the Government trying to show its tough on crime, rather than providing Canadians with the best, well thought policy for their protection of their safety, and their rights.
Mona Heagle
said
Dr. M
said
Bill in Ottawa
said
Nathan
said
I don't think Karla Homolka will be granted much opportunity to work. What other benefits could she get? The ability to travel? Again, I don't think so, the US doesn't recognize pardons and if she wants to travel legally I doubt she will be granted that luxury! So come on, you can pardon her file, but the reputation she created for herself is the real security measure for the public.
dahren
said
back and to the left
said
Joanne from Barrie
said
Niagara George
said
Sandra D
said
No bill- no more tax payers money being spent. Just say no.
reidjr
said
IT could be but it won't.Last year something like 40,000 were granted pardons while 800 were rejected.
Jim - North Saanich, BC
said
Art in Alberta
said
laura chatreau
said
bstark
said
terry
said
LAC
said
John Daintree
said
Jim in Ottawa
said
reece
said
In the USA the conservatives there and their 3 strikes you´re out policy has bankrupted many states. It was a huge failure and it cost them to yield soverignty to the Chinese who bankroll their infrastructure. Sure, you can heed the cry´s of crime victims and I´m certain I would also cry for blood if anything happened to me or my family, but are you willing to sacrifice our national security for it? To give people a second chance is not a sign of weakness, it gives ex cons a second chance, and at the same time it guards are security.