Top Stories -   

1
The experiment had students give up their phones, computers, TVs, iPods, even newspapers for 24 hours.

Students hooked on social media, study reveals

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Experts explain social media addiction
A researcher and a student subject discuss the results of a new study that sheds light on the addiction-like symptoms reported by students who gave up social media for 24 hours.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (17) Facebook   

The experiment had students give up their phones, computers, TVs, iPods, even newspapers for 24 hours.

Photos

The experiment had students give up their phones, computers, TVs, iPods, even newspapers for 24 hours.

View Larger Image

Selected Comment

The sad thing is, these same kids don't know how to relate with people on a personal level. They think they have "friends" ....what a deception!

Posh

Students hooked on social media, study reveals

talking about
Students hooked on social media, study reveals

Date: Wed. Apr. 28 2010 10:43 PM ET

Pounding headaches, drumming fingers, feelings of isolation. When 200 students were asked to stop using all forms of media for an entire day, they reported these symptoms and more, revealing addictions many didn't know they had.

The experiment, conducted by the International Center for Media and the Public Agenda (ICMPA), had students from the University of Maryland give up their phones, computers, TVs, iPods, even newspapers for 24 hours, and then describe in a university blog how they felt.

The results surprised even the researchers.

"I don't think we really expected students to react quite as strongly as they did," ICMPA director Susan Moeller told CTV's Canada AM Wednesday from Washington.

"We expected them to complain. We expected them to tell us it was hard. We didn't expect people to feel really isolated, frustrated and sort of anxious and all the physical manifestations."

Students talked about being miserable, anxious -- and bored to distraction.

"I definitely felt disconnected and out of the loop and… just lost," student Kimberly Morgan told Canada AM.

Another student wrote: "Texting and IMing my friends gives me a constant feeling of comfort. When I did not have those two luxuries, I felt quite alone and secluded from my life."

Others said they had no idea how to occupy themselves without music, the Internet or TV.

"I stared at the wall for a little bit. After doing some push-ups, I just decided to take a few Dramamine and go to sleep to put me out of my misery," one student wrote.

Moeller, who is also a professor of media and international affairs at the University's College of Journalism, says she didn't expect students to enjoy the experiment.

"We knew from the minute that we announced the assignment in class and I got booed and hissed, that students were not looking forward to this assignment," she says.

But even she was surprised to discover how addicted students were. They weren't just frustrated by being cut off from media, they reported they actually couldn't function and felt hopeless. Plenty of students admitted cheating, giving in to check their phone messages or to feed their "sports junkie" habit.

Others found that it wasn't the lost connections to friends they noticed most; it was the deafening silence of their world without TVs and music.

"It was really hard for me to go without listening to my iPod during the day because it's kind of my way to zone out of everything and everyone when I walk to class. It gets my mind right," one student wrote. "It sounds weird but music really helps to set my mood or fix my mood and without it I had to rely on other people to keep me in a good mood."

But the experiment did offer benefits for many students. Some reported they took better care of themselves during their media-free day, going to the gym, cooking full meals and enjoying more face-to-face interactions with friends.

Other students even buckled down and hit the books.

"Studying was a million times more productive without the media distracting me with texts, calls, Facebook, email, games and other random internet sites," one student wrote.

"Classes went better since I couldn't text or get on the Internet, I took better notes and was more focused," wrote another.

"I found a book I had lying around that I had not yet finished, and read for two solid hours. This turned out to be the most enjoyable part of my Sunday. I had completely forgotten how much I enjoyed reading a real book," wrote still another.

Still, while most of the students said they felt proud of themselves for making it through a whole day without using their cellphone or Internet, and some said they even learned a thing or two, most were relieved when the 24 hours were up.

According to one student: "Overall, it was a good experience to wait 24 hours to use technology, but it is something that I never want to do again!"

Comments are now closed for this story

kdinsk
said

To Jeff:Regarding your post for those of us born before the 70's & 80's and our ability or lack thereof to adapt and use today's technololgy devised. I was born in the 60's and have adapted quite well thank you very much. In fact I use these devices every day. (Computers, cell phones, ipod. etc.) What I don't do is chain myself to them. I make certain there is a balance between technological items of convenience and interacting with face to face with family, friends and community.What scares me is the grammer and spelling you used in your post. I see this trend of the written word being ravaged more and more thanks to these advances in technology. I guess my point is balance, new toys and devices are great as long as we use them as tools, not necessities to get us through our day.kd


Jaid
said

Social media is basically treated as a business that makes profit on being "connected." However, the problem isn't what was found in the research, it's the adaptation to society in general. More would have to be looked into such as the basic freedom the children of this generation have.Technology can easily be a parent's reason to keep their kids at home, because they know that they're safe rather than buying them a car and take a chance that they may be going out and drive home drunk.A longitudinal research may be required if they wish to pursue how much technology affects us. I can probably guarantee you that when these students graduate and get a job along with a car or carpool with other graduates, this type of technological "addiction" is nothing more than a farce.As of now, this research only concludes about student behaviours when disconnected from technology. Perhaps try a research of making people take public transportation instead of using a car, you'll see something very similar to what students go through. Loss of "freedom" and "connection" will lead to behaviours similar to what this research concludes.


andrew
said

i lived without my iphone, news, sports, any sort of contact of the outside world for 7 months in afganistan. It sucked but i wasn't going through withdrawl symptoms or anything.


Jeff
said

i think u guys are wrong about society becoming more anti-socialthe purpose of social networks is too strengthen relationshipsfacebook is timed generation thing (sorry but if your born before the 80's, i'll go as far as late mid to late 70's) u missed out and just ain't gonna get itif your no longer in your teens or twenties (the prime time for friends) u guys just don't get iti cannot explain the experience but once that time has passed it can't be emulatedfacebook originally and obviously wasn't intended outside the young adult demographicthe same applies with texting and all this new tech stuffit just isn't your time and is beyond the "norm" of what u grew up with


Jeff
said

really?!we needed a study to see thisgo to your local university and peer into the computer labmajority of the users are NOT doing homework but either on facebook or youtubeu don't need to be an analyst to see this trend


Pam
said

This is the generation who will be in control of our politics in 25 years. That is a nightmare waiting to happen. Anyone been on a train lately, It isn't just the children who have to have electronics but the adults who do their work with laptops, Talking on cells so that all around have to endure their loud conversations, surprisingly not to their children, but other adults, degrading fellow workers, arguing business problems, etc. This is both am and pm rush hour travel.The university and college students try to study, some just read and others use books and laptops. That generation is connected to real life. Don't blame the children it is the parents who control their life.


Dr. M
said

This study raises an important question- what is the psychological, emotional and social cost of technology? And it's not just this particular technology, which ironically is meant to facilitate communication, but in fact distorts and shrivels it. What about other forms of technology? What has TV done to the baby boom generation and those that followed? What has the pill done to gender relations? What has transportation technology done to our sense of connection? Not all of these effects are necessarily bad, but we seem to be moving into new areas of technology without any real sense of how our lives are impacted by change. To some extent, this explains the response of conservative people to the new culture that is emerging. That response is often irrational, yet somehow, rooted in a sense of nostalgia for the worlds we have lost. Obama talked about people clinging to their religion and their guns, as if they were hanging on to life preservers after a shipwreck. The trouble is, the sense of panic created by this "future shock" is likely to emerge in dangerous ways, as it did in Iran when it ousted the Shah and returned to religious fundamentalism. The same thing seems to be happening in the States, and to a lesser extent in Canada. The Tea Party movement could perhaps be understood better if we thought about the sense of panic and loss that many of these right-wingers must be feeling when they see a black president. No wonder logical arguments have so little impact on conservative people. Their resistance to change is itself becoming a problem, because it prevents us from dealing effectively with the future.


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

It has been found using positron emission tomography that the brain is designed to reward the clusters of stimuli associate with a primary reward MORE SO than the reward the brain produces for the primary need..... So then these secondary stimuli will trigger chemical rewards which exceed the primary experience providing the experience of pleasure (dopamine release etc) -- even if they are in fact fairly remote from the actual event that was the original signal for reward and are the true basis for such a reward. In some ways it is both a flaw and a "design feature" of the brain's reward systems... And it can and does lead to all kinds of negative behaviour or non-productive behaviour in the sense that it is now behaviour that really shouldn't be directly tied to the original biologically necessary function (i.e. to find a mate and reproduce etc) That is why addiction is see easily instantiated -- addiction to drugs, social networking, the Internet -- computer gaming -- and on and on.


Posh
said

The sad thing is, these same kids don't know how to relate with people on a personal level. They think they have "friends" ....what a deception!


George in Calgary
said

I have designated this social dependent generation as the "Touchie - Feelie Generation" as they must always be connected to some form of electronic gadget. This hints of the "Borg" on Star Trek where all beings are connected to a common collective and when disconnected they as "individuals" are totally lost and truly disfunctional. So from this study, crude as it might be, it seems as if the users of these gadgets are also suffering from disfunctionality. We curb the use of other addictive substances and maybe we should do the same in the case of electronic gadetry to save the youth of the world. Maybe they should all be implanted with silicon chips at birth which will rob them of true individuality and make them all just a member of a common social hoard. I am sure some political party/system would like that; oh yeah that's been tried and has failed.


Ron
said

I am a senior, and one day at the Mall, I rounded a corner and a student (about 16 or 17 ) was listening to music from her IPod (which was up quite loud I might add) and texting on her phone at the same time. She ran right into me and here was her comment "Why don't you watch where your going you FN AHO"!! You know when I was that age, we had a little more respect for adults. My how times and technology have turned us into zombies.


Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said

@ Carl, you have a point, but 3 or 4 generations of habitual behaviour could make that behaviour a necessity. Once the art of conversation is lost, it's lost. All these electronic conviences are dulling our god given senses. Getting close and personal, now means reading somebodies face book.


Alex K
said

I'm worried that social media like this is making our society more antisocial, which is bad for our own well-being. Social media, just like any form of technology, is good if it is used as a tool to develop the human person and his interactions with others, not as an end in itself. I'm a university student, and I try hard to guard myself from succumbing to an "addiction," or whatever this is, by exercising, reading (or sometimes even talking to strangers) instead of listening to an iPod on the bus, and other non-technological things like that.


island girl
said

If a person has a balanced life, it isn't so traumatic if you have to go without something. We used to have full cable, then cancelled it entirely. I took up knitting and sewing. Having lots of hobbies you can turn to rather than relying on electronics is good. It concerns me when that student said they rely on music and as a last resort, people to keep them in a good mood. Can they not generate this on their own? Seems they rely too much on external stimuli for their wellbeing instead of using creativity and self direction.


Carl
said

Rubbish! Giving up any strongly habitual behaviour for a day is likely to cause frustration, anxiety, etc. That doesn't make it an "addiction". Constant use of electronic media is not an addiction, it's just a bad habit, and perhaps for some an obsession. This is just part of a larger trend of denying personal responsibility for any uncontrolled and unhealthy behaviour. Just like every celebrity who gives in to the temptation of easy sex claims to have a "sex addiction." Pure nonsense.


Nina
said

Wow! Thats pretty sad and pathetic! No wonder they felt isolated, when normally these students dont use their time to communicate with others face to face and they might actually enjoy it and not rely on technology to keep them content.


bikerborz
said

And to think that this was how life was lived even 30 years ago...! How did we ever get by back then??


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012.  (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Charles Taylor gets 50 years for 'brutal' crimes

More   1 Comments 1    1 Video(s) 1

A police officer removes a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party headquarters in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Second package containing body part found in Ottawa

More  3 Video(s) 3

Supporters of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, hold placards and banners bearing images of him before the verdict was given in his extradition case at the Supreme Court in London, Wednesday, May 30, 2012. (AP / Matt Dunham)

Britain's top court backs extradition of WikiLeaks chief

More   1 Comments 1    2 Video(s) 2