Top Stories -   

1

Harper says proroguing best for 'important work'

Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks to reporters during a wrap up press conference following the 2009 United Nations Climate Change conference in Copenhagen, Denmark on Friday, Dec. 18, 2009. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks to reporters during a wrap up press conference following the 2009 United Nations Climate Change conference in Copenhagen, Denmark on Friday, Dec. 18, 2009. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (33) Facebook   

Date: Monday Jan. 11, 2010 10:30 PM ET

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper is offering a new wrinkle on his reasons for suspending Parliament -- the government can do more important work without MPs sitting in the Commons.

In an interview with Business News Network, the prime minister flatly rejected the notion that proroguing Parliament has left the country open to criticism it is not a stable democracy.

In fact, it is Parliament in a minority situation that is perceived by markets as unstable, said Harper.

"The games begin when Parliament returns," he explained. "The government can take our time now to do the important work to prepare the economic agenda ahead.

"That said, as soon as Parliament comes back . . . the first thing that happens is a vote of confidence and there'll be votes of confidence and election speculation for every single week after that for the rest of the year. That's the kind of instability markets are actually worried about."

The argument opens a new front in the rationale the Conservative government has provided for the controversial pre-New Year's decision to suspend Parliament until March 3, even though doing so kills a number of bills the government had been eager to pass.

Harper had previously cited a need to recalibrate the government's agenda as the economy moves from recession into recovery.

Harper repeated that argument Monday, but is now adding the instability of a minority government and the ability to avoid "the games" of Parliament as additional talking points.

The controversial decision has been criticized by commentators and newspaper editorials, and even drew a sharp rebuke from the respected British newsmagazine The Economist. It accused Harper of stopping inquiries into allegations of torture of Afghan prisoners and suggested he was guilty of "naked self interest."

Parliament had been set to return Jan. 25 but instead will remain dark until after the Winter Olympics in Vancouver, returning Mar. 3.

Recent polls have also suggested that Conservative party standing in public opinion has dropped a few percentage points since the announcement.

In the interview, Harper said the government will not be introducing major new spending programs in the Mar. 4 budget because the economy has stabilized and will likely grow going forward.

As such, he said the government's $46-billion stimulus package will be phased out on schedule at the end of the next fiscal year, which ends March 31, 2011.

"We are not today looking at a second stimulus package," he said.

"We are looking at recalibrating, making some decisions on the existing stimulus package, but we are thinking beyond that -- the exit strategies and the next economic agenda."

Harper said the government is examining what measures are needed to grow the economy and create employment without massive infusions of public cash.

Although the stimulus spending, and lower revenues caused by the recession, has caused the government to fall into record deficits -- $56 billion this year alone -- Harper said he is not worried Ottawa is creating a structural deficit.

He said if the economy continues to grow and the government does what it has pledged to do in ending the stimulus and controlling spending, "the possibility today of getting in a debt-interest payment trap is in my judgement not high."

Nor he is overly concerned with deficits in the U.S., which by his estimate are four times higher than Canada's. Harper said the U.S. economy is extremely resilient and that international markets will likely continue to lend it the money it needs to finance debt.

Harper expressed some disappointment the economy has not recovered as strongly as it might have, particularly on the employment front. He blamed low international demand for Canadian exports and the strength of the Canadian dollar, which has made Canadian goods less competitive, for dampening growth.

Comments are now closed for this story

Intelligent Liberal, PhD, from da bar
said

The current (but changing) headline says:"Harper says proroguing best for 'important work'" 'important work'" = "secret agenda" WHAT kind of important work might that be? Going on VACATION?!? This is supposed to be our PRIME Minister, he's not even a flank steak


Patsplace
said

A Federal Government is responsible for the protection and development of Canada. Both in brand enhancement as well as brand protection.The nonsense in Copenhagen was a case in point. We didn't get sucked into the Great Thin Air rip-off. The Arctic Ice has increased 27% since 2007. Nothing in the MSM about this. No apologies from the Global Warming Crowd. Jim Prentice looked after our interests in spite of the foaming at the mouth Canada Haters that wanted to do as much harm to the Canadian economy as possibleThe Afghans treatment of Prisoners that were turned over under policy created by the Liberals and found to be flawed and re-drafted by the Conservatives. Prisoners that slaughtered women and children, tortured people in the most horrible of ways and when they were turned over to the Afghans, the Afghans slapped a few of them around and hit a few with shoes (major insult in Afghanistan) Big bloody deal and good on the Canadians that they rode herd on the Afghani's to stop them from just killing these vermin on the spot.The point of all this is that the Liberals are attacking Canada's brand, and all in the attempt to gain points in the polls. Not out of any sense of need for fair play or to defend anyone. The only Canadian Politician that has spent any time with the troops in Afstan is PMSH, guarded by Canada's finest, JTF2. And you expect him to enable the attack on Canada's military? When Pigs fly. I think this is going to come back at the liberals in a very harsh way.


Ryan P.
said

CTV you forgot to include "authorized by the official agent of The Liberal Party of Canada" at the bottom of this one sided article. "A new wrinkle" in why he suspended parliament, did you folks hire Iggy staffers recently? Pathetic journalism-though I doubt you will publish this comment.


Dayton
said

One year ago last fall Harper was elected with the mandate to govern. He was also burdened with the recession created by the American housing crisis. He took on the challenge and may have lead us to believe things weren't all that bad while the opposition screamed like hell the sky is falling do something. Panic was working against the American's but here calmer waters prevailed. Did Harper mislead us? Did he shutdown the opposition not once but twice for no good reason? Today we enjoy the lowest interest rates in history, consumers are still spending on cars and homes increasing every ones viability. So for what good reason would you not give Harper another mandate?


Intelligent Liberal, PhD
said

i read comments here everyday and write some as well. I used to be a member of the progressive conservative party and I can honestly tell you there is a giant rift inside the conservative party. The old PC party brass do not like Harper one bit. If he doesn't get a majority the next time around he is out and many in the party are waiting for it, and yes there are a few people lining up for the job. I hated Dion, but must say Iggy seems alot better than Harper right now, he just needs to show more of it.As for the people who constantly post across media sites which have blog posts such as this one, realize you are part of a propaganda machine, which uses deceitful and opportunistic messages to push their rationalized message to hold on to power. I am sure political students are having a blast writing up reports about this situation.Democracy has been attacked, it's not the actual act of prorogation that makes me believe that statement, it's the timing of it. Harper has done this too many times in the past few years, where he times things to hide from Canadians. Canadians are passive by nature, but i hope they will show up on Jan 23rd to protest, not to support any particular party, but to stand up for the blood lost by all our soldiers through all our history, they all died for democracy and I can honestly say that Harper has diminished their sacrifice for our freedoms and liberty!!!!In case no one noticed, I won't be voting for him ever again!!!!!


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

It's funny to witness Liberal weenies still lovingly using the whole "CON" thing in their comments; as if it's not Liberals that are known to be the most desperately pandering, ideologically challenged, say-whatever-you-must-to-get-elected collection of partisan hacks on the political scene. Liberal PM Chretien CONNED Canadians into believing a number of things (ie. GST elimination) that turned out to be a bold-face lie. Liberal Premier Dalton McGuinty CONNED Ontarians into believing that we weren't going to suffer more taxes, and would enjoy an improved and more efficient provincial healthcare system. Nope. Lies. Nobody CONS like the shameless. self-entitled Liberals. They wrote the definitive book, "How To Be a Political Weasel And Get Elected."


Boring - anything new?
said

ZZZzzzzzz ! This is already a worn out, much spun, Liberanos subject....what else is new?


TVic
said

The PM continues to offer bafflegab in an attempt to hide his undemocratic ways. He and his advisors must have closeted themselves away for hours and this is the best that they could come up with - pretty lame excuse on top of all the other excuses he has already offered. Get back to work in parliament where you belong and take the heat that you deserve.


Paul Y
said

The Liberals and New DemocRATS are desperate for attention because they have no policies of their own to talk about! Harper is doing a good job piloting the ship of state through treacherous waters while the opposition parties behave like swarms of seaguls and crows surrounding the ship and squaking their heads off as the ship sails by on a steady course.


Barb Chase Bull Lake
said

I Like to know why Iggy and his so called liberal's are upset with Mr. Harper proroguing Parliament . most of them hasn't been in their seats in Question period most of 2009 I know because I watch it every day , They remind me like blood sucking leaches, and so do the media. out for blood. I know this won't be printed because I tell it like I see it. and CTV . don' like it when you tell the truth.


Toby
said

What a pile of crap. Bring on an election and let's get rid of this clown.


Miriam in Muskoka
said

Note to Harper: You are the leader of a MINORITY government - always have been, always will be - and your illusions of grandeur are not attractive!


Susann
said

CTV is wrong to cite The Economist as the source of the anti-Harper proroguing Parliament.It was a CBC Online journalist, referred to as a online correspondent submitting to the Economist. It was not an Economist editorial or staff writer doing the article CTV mentions.The history of her other online writings puts to rest the notion that she or the Economist is a right slanted magazine. Simply absurd to say so.


Conrad from Calgary
said

" the government can do more important work without MPs sitting in the Commons."For a government in our parliamentary system there is NOTHING more important than MPs sitting in the commons.


james
said

maybe 53% disagree with prorogation, but this may surprise you. a recent agnus reid poll on jan 9, 2010 showed support for harper, leaving iggy in the dust when it came to leadership, the economy, and who canadians thought who was best to lead the country. ever ndp jack was better, he came second.


Marg Alberta
said

I'm very happy about the proroguing, everyone should be happy!!! The conservatives are doing a great job of pushing their poll numbers down in the range of opposition territory. Yahoo!!!


Greg from SK
said

Very well said Mr. (Scott) Johnson. It is nice to read comments such as yours. I would like to read more of what you have to say on issues such as these.


Westcoaster
said

I think Canadians have acquired a genuine taste for proroguings. Many Canadians were first introduced to them during the Chretien years, when they were much more common -- the current PM, Stephen Harper, has only served them up twice. Like everything else about this PM, he does his proroguings smarter and much more strategically. Personally, my all time favourites are still my Mom's cottage cheese "proroguings."


Wayne in HRM
said

Wow the government can get more done without sitting MP's. This guy is a joke. He has no respect for democracy or the opinion of Canadians other than conservatives. He reeks of the lies of his government and no doubt needs the time off not to help Canadians or the economy but to help himself and in extension his party. He needs the time off to revamp the Tory sleaze book of political tactics to give his troops a fresh patch of deceit, lies and sleaze to spread over the Canadian political landscape. Spreading his lies and BS is like spraying a field with manure, only in this case they over do it and kill everything on the field including decency, respect and honesty.


Mark from MB
said

As a tax payer, I believe that we should have every reason to be outraged by the fact that our Prime Minister thinks we are stupid enough to buy this s__t. We pay his wage and I only wish that I had the power to fire him right now, but don't worry mr. Harper because next election I will have that power. I hope people start to realize that you are abusing your power and running from the elected chamber of our government to hide from the opposition.


montrealer
said

found this:"When a government starts trying to cancel dissent or avoid dissent is frankly when... it's rapidly losing its moral authority to govern " Stephen Harper Canadian Press, April 18, 2005" HARPERCRITE!!!!


dawn
said

the chief CON is a liar.....


Chris in te 'Toon
said

I fail to see how parliment shutting down for a couple weeks is undemocratic. It's no different than a compan getting readyfor the yar end review saying that staff meetings will be cancelled for the next little while why the board of directors meet to discuss the planned direction of the company. The opposition doesn't get to be part of that anyways until it is presented to parliment so who cares. Politicians are still working, but now they actually have to work not just sit in the House of Commons. Its up to you to make sure yor own MP is working for you during this time. We are in a fragile world economy where we have fared quite well in retrospect to others. Let Iggy say his party is not taking Holidays (then depart for a National field trip to Universities) its not like the Conservatives aren't busy preparing the budget.


JFJ
said

It's constitutional.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

This reason. That reason. Who cares?! The bottom line is that His Royal Highness, Michael Ignatieff, along with his "Three Stooges" counterparts, Layton and Duceppe, have exhibited no interest in acting in the best interests of the country. Period. Throughout this past recession they have brought absolutely NOTHING to the country's table, and have continually shown that their own stubborn political self-interests are most important to them. Polls clearly show that Canadians don't view Iggy as a sound alternative to PM Harper. Period. Ultimately, Parliament is but a big "game" to the Opposition, and PM Harper calling a "timeout" frustrates their worthless "game plan." Prorogation is a bountiful GIFT to all Canadians who expect meaningful cooperation in the House of Commons. For too long, the Opposition has operated under the twisted and backwards notion that a minority government means that you get to drive the official parliamentary bus at your demand. It doesn't; and you don't. By victorious democratic election, it's a Conservative PM, a Conservative ministerial cabinet, and the Conservatives are the official representatives of Canada's government. Period. Liberals need to suck it up, once and for all, and finally put their entitlement egos on the shelf, for the benefit of Canadians. Win an election, my little red-ties, and you'll get to call the shots...just like Chretien did when he prorogued, four times.


montrealer
said

i read comments here everyday and write some as well. I used to be a member of the progressive conservative party and I can honestly tell you there is a giant rift inside the conservative party. The old PC party brass do not like Harper one bit. If he doesn't get a majority the next time around he is out and many in the party are waiting for it, and yes there are a few people lining up for the job. I hated Dion, but must say Iggy seems alot better than Harper right now, he just needs to show more of it.As for the people who constantly post across media sites which have blog posts such as this one, realize you are part of a propaganda machine, which uses deceitful and opportunistic messages to push their rationalized message to hold on to power. I am sure political students are having a blast writing up reports about this situation.Democracy has been attacked, it's not the actual act of prorogation that makes me believe that statement, it's the timing of it. Harper has done this too many times in the past few years, where he times things to hide from Canadians. Canadians are passive by nature, but i hope they will show up on Jan 23rd to protest, not to support any particular party, but to stand up for the blood lost by all our soldiers through all our history, they all died for democracy and I can honestly say that Harper has diminished their sacrifice for our freedoms and liberty!!!!In case no one noticed, I won't be voting for him ever again!!!!!


cjajbell
said

This is part Canadian government process. The irony is that the Liberals suspended government this way 4 times while they were in government (but who wants to talk about that!). It is the process that is flawed, not the governments. Both sides play the game. It's time to change the game. Lets go with fixed election terms and restrict the ability to suspend government to very rigid times of emergency.


Ry in the Hammer
said

Complete Baloney! I don't support this clear affront to democracy. Parliament never should have been prorogued. It was clearly to keep things from embarrassing the Government during the Olympics (i.e., the torture issue, environment, a confidence vote on the budget).


Scott Johnson
said

This is not as controversial as commontators and news outlets are suggesting. Parlament will miss about 2 weeks of sitting above what was collectively agreed upon. Parlament sits more days per year with this minority government than when parlament was under the stewardship of the the three previous Liberal leaders. The primeminister will retain his credibility in spite of the news media's wishes, and the government will continue to govern. Unfortunately, the more Mr. Ignatief make significant claims of parlamentary abuses by the governing Tories, the more he illuminates his own government's history. He in fact did inherit the legacy left by his predecessors and the more he says, the more elitist he appears. Government will return, and he will have his opportunity to take us to the polls. We will let him know how we feel about our Prime Minister then.


Dayton
said

Can't help but wonder how P.M. Dion and his Coalition of the Left would have handled the situation. And you think Harper is scary!!!


Coq Kid
said

I think this is a positive move by the prime minister. We don't need the opposition foaming at the mouth about Afghan detainees when we all know that they are only interested in scoring political points on the government. If the prime minister is a "dictator" as the opposition and the msm are screaming, then I'm sure that we'll see a no confidence vote when the house sits again in early March (after 17 days when the house would have been sitting). The faux outrage by the opposition and enabled by the msm is breathtaking. Where was the outrage when Chretien prorogued parliament for 4 months in the past? Oh silly me. He was a liberal so that was OK.


Will
said

Just come out and say it, Mr. Harper. Democracy is getting in your way. The only problem is that Canadians value democracy.


montrealer
said

This guy forgets he is in a minority and by shutting down parliament he says we don't care about your opinion and the 2/3 of Canadians you represent! i can't believe he actually would utter such words. I will give him credit for changing the party name from progressive conservative to conservative, as there is nothing about this man that is progressive. REGRESSIVE CONSERVATIVE sounds much more like reality! Harpercrite!

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Jun Lin, the Concordia University student who was murder and dismemberment in Montreal, is seen in this undated handout photo.

Police ID murder victim, say suspect has fled to Europe

More   21 Comments 21    10 Video(s) 10

Mohammad Mahjoub is shown in this undated handout photo. Suspected terrorist Mahjoub has been ordered released from custody by a Federal Court judge pending a review of his case. (THE CANADIAN PRESS / HO)

11 lawyers, clerks ordered off national security case

More   4 Comments 4  

A Canadian Pacific Railway employee walks along the track at a marshalling yard in Calgary, Wednesday, May 16, 2012. (Jeff McIntosh / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

CP Rail service returning to normal, officials say

More    Comments