Top Stories -   

1
A woman's body lies under a tarp as a fireman surveys the scene where a slab of concrete fell from a downtown hotel killing a woman and injuring her husband in Montreal Thursday, July 16, 2009. (Ryan Remiorz / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Lea Guilbeault, 33, who was killed when a slab of concrete fell from a hotel in Montreal, is seen in this undated image. (Courtesy Caisse Desjardins Cite-du-Nord de Montreal) A firefighter surveys the scene where a slab of concrete fell from the 18th floor of a downtown hotel killing a woman and injuring her fiance in Montreal Thursday, July 16, 2009. (Ryan Remiorz / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Passerbys look up at the scene where a slab of concrete fell from a downtown hotel killing a woman and injuring her fiance in Montreal Thursday, July 16, 2009. (Ryan Remiorz / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Dinner turns tragic as concrete slab kills woman

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Caroline Van Vlaardingen on the accident
A young Montreal couple out on the town celebrating a birthday were in the wrong place at the wrong time, when a giant slab of concrete fell from the upper floor of a Montreal hotel, killing 33-year-old Lea Guilbeault instantly. But what caused the piece of concrete to fall?
CTV Montreal: Annie DeMelt on the tragic accident
Quebec's Construction board says it last checked the Marriott hotel in 2000, nine years before a concrete slab fell off the façade and killed a 33-year-old woman. Annie Demelt reports.
CTV Montreal: Remembering Lea Guilbeault
Caroline Van Vlaardingen talks to friends of Guilbeault and Hani Beitinjaneh, the victims of Thursday's bizarre accident downtown.
CTV Montreal: How concerned should we be?
Todd van der Heyden talks with civil engineer Dr. Adel Hanna about structural inspections.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (32) Facebook   

Date: Fri. Jul. 17 2009 5:47 PM ET

A woman enjoying a romantic dinner at a Montreal hotel was killed Thursday when a piece of concrete fell off an upper floor of the building that was last inspected in 2000.

Lea Guilbeault and her husband Hani Beitinjaneh were eating dinner Thursday night at the Mikasa Sushi Bar on Peel St. in the downtown core, when the decorative slab fell from the Mariott Residence Inn.

The slab crashed through the atrium window of the restaurant, located on the ground floor of the hotel, from 17 floors above.

Guilbeault, 33, was pronounced dead at the scene by police and paramedics.

Montreal Const. Olivier Lapointe said Beitinjaneh, also 33, lost some fingers on his right hand and was treated for severe shock.

The slab of decorative concrete was between 700 and 800 pounds, said CTV Montreal's Annie DeMelt.

"The question is what caused this to come down," DeMelt said. "Was it corrosion? That's what we have been hearing from some of the engineers we've been speaking to this morning. Another is why was this was not noticed, and could it have been prevented?"

The agency responsible for monitoring structures in Quebec said the 42-year-old building was last inspected in 2000.

According to Regie du batiment spokeswoman Christin Grant, no complaints had been filed about the building or its façade.

"We don't look at number of years anymore, we look at the risks certain types of buildings may represent," Grant told The Canadian Press.

Witnesses at the scene said Beitinjaneh was in a state of shock after his wife, who was sitting just a few feet away, was killed.

"I saw him getting in the ambulance and he was totally devastated. He was yelling at everybody and crying," witness Justine Lafond told CTV Montreal.

"It hit the woman right on the head, and her head was smashed," an emotional witness, Kali Subramanian, told CTV Montreal.

"It's sad...it's a sad way to die. Somebody eating at a restaurant, and it happens like that."

It's not clear what caused the slab, about one metre by one-and-a-half metres, to come off the side of the building, Lapointe said.

"For us at this moment, it looks accidental. There was no one who played with the block of concrete trying to make it fall," Lapointe added.

Lapointe said a section of Peel Street was expected to remain closed for several hours as a precaution while the fire department inspected the building.

With files from Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Amanda
said

Have you seen the picture where the piece of concrete fell off! it looks like nothing was holding it in place.

Also the middle slabs of concrete looks like it's just being held in place by caulking.

My heart goes out to the Husband and their familys.


Big Bear
said

OK I want to make something clear. I meant no disrespect to the family of this tragic event. I am not heartless. It's just that when someone dies from a truly random event that it is referred as an "FD" moment. When it's your time...it's your time.


Dwight
said

My heart and prayers go out to the family at time


Mr Dano
said

The Fisher King. Robin Williams./ Brings it home.


Sin
said

a minute to pray, a second to die..
Godspeed..


Stephanie
said

This seems like something straight out of "Dead Like Me". It's so hard to believe that something like this can be real. I hope the husband recieves monetary compensation but the turmoil that he'll be put through will never be healed.


Peter BC
said

Unfortunately, this is not the first time that something tragic like this has happened. Sadly, it is unlikely to be the last..

The Romans were masters of concrete 2,000 years ago and many of those structures are still standing. Why can't we, with today's technology, do better, much better?



Alex D
said

I agree with you RD. This restaurant is my favorite restaurant and I used to go there at least once a week and I sat multiple times where the couple was sitting.

I was supposed to go there yesterday later in the evening though, but my friend could not come, so we cancelled. I think this should make us appreciate every single moment of life because it can be taken away from us in a heartbeat.


Lucy
said

Montreal needs to pay more attention to its crumbling city and less attention to English signs on the windows.


Justin's Thoughts
said

How sad! The poor lady and the poor man who not only lost his wife but also his right hand.


Ian
said

What a tragic accident. To big bear, how can you have the nerve to compare this to a movie. A poor innocent young woman has had her live taken, her husband seriously injured, both physically and emotionally scarred for life. All the workers and patrons in the restaurant as well as any people close by can only live through this horrific accident.

Our thoughts and prayers go out to all concerned and may the cause of this tragic accident be found and rectified quickly.


Mattman in Ottawa
said

What a nightmare!


JF
said

This is sad enough as it is. Why does there always need to be someone made responsible? It's an accident, a horrible one, but an accident. Was anyone made responsible when the bridge fell in Lacordaire?
There doesn't always need to be someone blamed for everything that happens in life. Life is life, and it is difficult at best of times.


"CTV #1 FAN"
said

Wow! That's an image of his last supper with his fiance that will surely give that poor guy nightmares for a lifetime. Just goes to show you that you've got to make every minute count because you never know when you're time comes.

Sometimes it doesn't make a difference how you take care of yourself in life with the right diet, exercise etc. Any freak accident can bring the Grim Reaper to your door with a big surprise. God Bless the poor girl.


CrackerJackLee
said

is this not happening more often? even in Toronto, skyscrapers have lost sections from the upper stories (downtown BMO and Eaton's Centre). the glass windows of the Montreal library periodically blow out over pedestrians below. it's especially egregious when this tragedy is cause by some decorative motif! it's a crime against society to erect a building and then forget about it. in the old days of massive stone architecture, gravity was less of a problem. today they use economical methods to assemble buildings that require periodic inspection and preventive maintenance. building owners must all have to pay into a governmental building inspection regime. obviously none presently exist. and we'll all sit by and wait for the next tragic death to occur. insurance can't replace loved ones. talk about Canadian Roulette...


Brad
said

Rest in Peace Lea

I will always remember that smile of yours.
This woman was filled with joy and happiness, she will be remembered.


Keith
said

Actually Roger I think the Final Destination comparison is appropriate, since in those movies it is freak situations like that which are the basse of the movie.

Of course my heart also goes to the family in such a difficult time.


Mario, Hearst ON
said

Is anyone really surprised by this? It happened in Quebec, the province known for it's crumbling infrastructure. Makes you wonder where all the handouts are really going.


FA ottawa
said

Roger...i agree with u completely. There needs to be more inspections on our infrastracture so these types of tragedies can be prevented. My heart goes out to her husband. What a horror!!!


Mark Pauls
said

OMG what a tragedy. Sitting eating dinner and wham. This poor guy saw his wife crushed to death. She is gone. I would sue this hotel into the ground. My heart goes out to them.


BB in B.C.
said

Now what? Sit by and wait for another piece of that building to fall? I for one hope the survivor sues the hotel and its contractors until they hurt like he does. What a senseless tragedy.


kt
said

Is it me or does Montreal have a concrete curse? Everything from various bridges collapsing, mass cracks & pot holes in certain areas of the streets to now this, concrete on hotels falling. this was a preventable tragedy. My heart and prayers to Hani Beitinjaneh & their families.


al
said

I have to question why Québec construction companies have so many problems with concrete. There was the 50 ton slab that fell from the big o in 1986, the slab that collapsed the bridge a few years back and now this. Time to review concrete composites for construction.


Vern---AAFU Oshawa spokesman
said

A terrible terrible tradegy. One has to ask, what is with the concrete structures in Montreal?? The big O, a few years back an over pass collapsed, and now this...Do the contractors down there have the mix right on the concrete?? Are building codes or inspections a little lax?? My sympathies go out to the families of this young man and woman...


Nina
said

My condolences to her family and her husband. I hope he has the strength to deal with this very difficult tragedy.


"CTV #1 FAN"
said

Wow! That's an image of his last supper with his fiance that will surely give that poor guy nightmares for a lifetime. Just goes to show you that you've got to make every minute count because you never know when you're time comes.

Sometimes it doesn't make a difference how you take care of yourself in life with the right diet, exercise etc. Any freak accident can bring the Grim Reaper to your door with a big surprise. God Bless the poor girl.


D.A
said

Roger;
I assume what Big Bear was implying was simply " when it's your time... it's your time. " because I thought the very same thing.


Roger
said

Big Bear - Comparing this tragedy to a lame movie is in extremely poor taste.

My prayers go out to the family. Someone needs to be made accountable for this, to set an example, and in turn, improve public safety.


RD
said

What a sad and tragic way to die. My heart goes out to the poor girl. Just to show you, we worry about many stupid things in life, you never know what can happen in 1 minute!!!


Mike in ON
said

How horrific, to witness what this man did: the grisly death of your loved one, as well as the involuntary amputation of several of his own digits. I can only imagine that he'll be needing MUCH counseling in the years ahead. No lawsuit could ever make up for what he's lost. Sympathies to him, and both families.


Big Bear
said

It is truly a shocking and sad "Final Destination" moment. My prayers go out to the family at this time.


Leah A
said

What a horrible tragedy! My heart goes out to the family.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Investigators remove a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party of Canada office in Ottawa, Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Human foot was in package sent to Tory HQ: coroner

More  4 Video(s) 4

Syrian charge d'affaires Bashir Akbik speaks with CTV News outside of the Syrian embassy in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Syrian diplomat denounces expulsion from Canada

More   33 Comments 33    6 Video(s) 6