Top Stories -   

1

Babies' pain response depends on order of shots

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (11) Facebook   

Date: Tuesday May. 5, 2009 10:35 AM ET

The order in which babies receive their scheduled vaccinations really can make a difference to how much pain they feel when they get the shots, a Canadian study has found.

Researchers from Toronto's Hospital for Sick Children found that babies who are first given the DPTaP-Hib combo vaccine (which protects against diphtheria, polio, tetanus, pertussis and Hemophilus influenza type b) followed by PCV, the pneumococcal conjugate vaccine, seem to experience less pain than those who get their shots in the opposite order.

It's common for babies to receive more than one shot at a single doctor's visit. But many pediatricians have complained that sometimes parents refuse to have a child vaccinated in because of the pain caused by multiple vaccines. Therefore, reducing that pain could increase immunization rates and prevent a resurgence of infectious diseases, the authors of this study say.

"Because some vaccines cause more pain than others, the order in which they are given may affect the overall pain experience," the authors write in the May issue of Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, a theme issue on vaccines.

Dr. Moshe Ipp at SickKids led a team that studied 120 healthy infants aged two to six months who were getting routine immunizations at a local pediatric clinic in 2006 or 2007.

Sixty infants received the PCV before the DPTaP-Hib vaccine, while 60 received the DPTaP-Hib vaccine first. All of the babies received the shots in their thighs while they were being held by one of their parents.

The procedure was videotaped and pain was assessed on a scale that considered the infant's facial expression, crying and body movements after vaccination. Parents were also asked to rate their children's pain levels on a scale of zero to 10.

The researchers found that difference in pain expression was about 25 per cent less among the babies given DPTaP-Hib first, compared to those given the PCV.

"Infants given the less painful DPTaP-Hib vaccine first followed by the more painful PCV experienced less pain overall when compared with those given the vaccines in the reverse order," the authors write, noting that "pain increased from the first to the second injection, regardless of the order of vaccine injection."

The authors speculate that giving the more painful injection first may activate the pain processing centres in the brain, which leads to a more intense pain signal in response to any shots given afterward.

They note that simply varying the order of vaccine administration is a simple, effective, and cost-freeway to reduce the baby's pain and improve the immunization experience for parents and doctors.

"On the basis of these results, we recommend that the order of vaccines be the DPTaP-Hib vaccine followed by the PCV," they conclude.

The researchers aren't sure why different shots hurt more than others, but they speculate that it may be related to the pH levels, or acidity, of the different vaccines.

They add that vaccine manufacturers should also work on making vaccine formulations that are less painful.

Comments are now closed for this story

For Crying out Loud!
said

Anyone hear of Tylenol?? You know that liquid stuff that you give to a child about 20 minutes before going for a vaccine?!?! (duh!)

To Rosemary: Not good advice for the mother of an infant who has teeth!


Andrew in NL
said

I also read about some evidence that giving the child something sweet just before the shot also reduces pain, such as the parent wetting their finger tip and dipping it in a sugar packet and lettting the child suck on it while giving the shot


Marg
said

I've been taking my granddaughter for her vaccinations because her Mom is too squeamish about needles. They gave her the DPTaP-Hib vaccine before the PCV and she barely let out a whimper both times. I think it also depends on the nurse giving the injections. Before disinfecting the area with the alcohol wipe she flicked her finger nail in the area twice, rubbed the wipe and gave the shot. The result was barely a reaction from my granddaughter.
We, as adults, all know some nurses seem to be able to give shots better than others and part of that is the answer also I am sure.

I guess I'm old school because I believe in vaccinations. Parents who don't have their children vaccinated are playing Russian Roulette with their children when it comes to their health. My parents had me get polio shots as a child. I went on to university were I met 3-4 friends who suffered polio and were severely disabled physically because of it. It could have been prevented, but unlike my parents, their parents chose not to have them vacinated when the elementary schools were vaccinating all children against polio with parental permission.


JasonInSaskatchewan
said

@OttawaFred

1 in 10 really, you honestly believe that? Anecdotal evidence shows that I don't see how that can be possible.

Between myself and my sister we have 10 children and no adverse reaction. Indeed I know, at a rough guess, directly or indirectly well over 500 children and none of them suffered more that a mild fever from any immunization. One would think that if the rate of adverse reaction was 10% I would have seen or heard of at least 1.

In fact I have heard of only 1 reaction ever and that was in a child allergic to eggs that had not had that allergy previously diagnosed. It had nothing to do with the actual vaccine.

I did lose a very young nephew to chicken pox of all things, specifically they caused pneumonia. I am happy to know I don't have to worry about such a fate for my children as they have been vaccinated.

And it's not a chemical that is being injected into the child, it's not like they are injecting the child with formaldehyde or something.

For the most part it's a small sample of essentially dead virus. Without that virus sample their body cannot create the anti-bodies required.

It's the people who don't vaccinate that put at risk the rest of our children because they can contract and pass on the disease to our kids before they are old enough to be vaccinated.


HT in SK
said

Alot of parents chose to not give their children immunizations due to the risks associated with giving them.
Just as there is a risk to not give a child immunizations there is also an associated risk with chosing to do so!
As a parent you should research both sides of the spectrum to understand fully what your child could experiance.
A very close friends child recieved her shots and suffered swelling of the brain which later caused some severe development issues.
Always look into both side of an argument when your children are involved!


OttawaRoger
said

OK OttawaFred...I think you better check your facts...the benefits far outweigh the risks when getting vaccines. When these unvaccinated kids go to school and contact a disease and pass it around to other kids...then I think the parents will have second thoughts. These vaccines are safe and parents should not think twice about getting them for their kids. Only if a doctor has a medical reason not to give it. Too anybody can be a parent. Sometimes they just don't have a clue.


Cam W
said

Ottawa Fred. Can you read? This article clearly states that pediatricians report parents refusing vaccines because of pain, not because of concern over chemicals. They did not change the formula for vaccines, merely the order in which they give them. The whole unsubstantiated parental fear over the chemical composition of vaccines is another subject all together and has nothing to do with this article.


JM
said

As a Mom, I would rather my child cry for 5 minutes, then deal with an illness that is preventable with a vaccine, a good cuddle always does the trick.


OttawaFred
said

Cam W,
Do a little research before you criticize parents. Pain isn't the main reason that most parents delay or refrain from vaccinations. It is the fact that we are injecting harmful chemicals into a developing immune system that at times isn't mature enough to deal with the injected material. Have you seen the adverse reaction rates? One in 10 have a systemic reaction. Having multiple injections only compounds that problem.


Rosemary, Ottawa
said

Research has also shown that breastfeeding while the shots are being given helps the infants cope with the pain of immunizations - and helps a mother feel better about it too! I did this with my son and he recovered quickly. Phewf!


Cam W
said

What sort of parent would sooner put their child at risk of contracting a potentially fatal disease because they didn't want them to cry over temporary pain? It is great that the medical profession figured this one out but, honestly, some parents are just plain dumb.



Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Investigators remove a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party of Canada office in Ottawa, Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Human foot was in package sent to Tory HQ: coroner

More  4 Video(s) 4

Syrian charge d'affaires Bashir Akbik speaks with CTV News outside of the Syrian embassy in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Syrian diplomat denounces expulsion from Canada

More   33 Comments 33    6 Video(s) 6