Top Stories -   

1
The family of Trooper Karine Blais walk up to the hearse to view her casket at CFB Trenton in Ontario on Thursday, April 16, 2009.(Frank Gunn / THE CANADIAN PRESS) The casket Trooper Karine Blais arrives at CFB Trenton, Thursday, April 16, 2009. Trooper Karine Blais is shown in a portrait when she joined the Canadian Forces. (Quebec Le Soleil / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Family and friends of Trooper Karine Blais are joined by Canadian Forces officers at CFB Trenton, Thursday, April 16, 2009. The family of Trooper Karine Blais walk up to the hearse to view her casket at CFB Trenton in Ontario on Thursday, April 16, 2009.(Frank Gunn / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Military apologizes for delay in repatriation

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Rosemary Thompson on the controversy
There was controversy over the repatriation of Trooper Karine Blais, who was killed by a roadside bomb in Afghanistan on Monday. A detour sparked a great deal of anger, which led to a high level apology.
CTV Toronto: A fallen Canadian hero is returned home in controversy
Some soldiers are upset that a change in protocol prevented them from paying their respects during the repatriation of Trooper Karine Blais. Meanwhile, GTAers were out above the Highway of Heroes to pay their respects. Rosemary Thompson and Galit Solomon report.
Power Play: Retired Colonel Michel Drapeau on Thursday's repatriation ceremony
Drapeau discusses the controversy regarding the stopover in Ottawa on the repatriation flight of fallen soldier Trooper Blais.
CTV Newsnet: Roger Smith with a military mother's concerns regarding the repartriation of Trooper Blais
One military mom said she doesn't agree that the plane carrying the body of Trooper Blais should have stopped in Ottawa to let other soldiers and cargo off before touching down at CFB Trenton.
CTV Newsnet: Roger Smith on the Blais family reaction to the young woman's death and to the mission in Afghanistan
Despite comments made to CTV News by Blais' uncle, Blais parents say the supported and believed in their daughter's work.
CTV Newsnet: Retired Col. Michel Drapeau on gender and the military
Trooper Blais is only the second female Canadian soldier to die in the NATO-led mission in Afghanistan.
Canada AM: Military aircraft carrying the body of Trooper Karine Blais to land in Ontario
The body of the second female Canadian soldier to die in Afghanistan returns home this afternoon.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (45) Facebook   

Date: Thu. Apr. 16 2009 10:50 PM ET

Canada's top military official has apologized for a decision which delayed the repatriation of a fallen soldier and reportedly prevented some of her fellow soldiers from taking part in the ceremony.

In a statement released Thursday afternoon, Gen. Walter Natynczyk, Canada's chief of defence staff, also offered the family of Trooper Karine Blais his "deepest support" during their time of grief.

"I want to offer my sincerest apologies to anyone who may have been offended by the decision to return troops to Ottawa prior to the final repatriation of our fallen comrade Trooper Karine Blais," added Natynczyk.

The comments followed a controversial -- and unusual -- decision to first drop off 117 soldiers at CFB Uplands near Ottawa before bringing Blais' remains back to Trenton for repatriation.

The 21-year-old soldier was killed in Afghanistan on Monday in a bomb blast.

"Having personally attended many Repatriation Ceremonies in Trenton, I can assure all Canadians that our goal is to treat all fallen soldiers with treated with respect, dignity and honour and it is our intention to continue to ensure this policy is followed," said Natynczyk.

Earlier in the day, the military told CTV News the flight plan was a logistical decision, due to the fact that the soldiers were also onboard as part of a troop rotation.

The military decided it would be prudent to drop the soldiers off first in Ottawa, making it easier to transport them to their various home bases, instead of landing in Trenton and then having to take a three-and-a-half-hour bus ride to the capital.

"Sure enough, the 117 soldiers got off the plane (in Ottawa) and it turns out that the flags were not lowered at the Uplands airport," reported CTV's deputy Ottawa bureau chief Rosemary Thompson on Thursday afternoon. "Many of the soldiers on board wanted to go to Trenton."

A military source told CTV News that one official had ordered the Ottawa stop because he did not want the soldiers to spend extra time in transit. Officials from the air force reportedly objected to the order but were overruled.

After the Ottawa stop, Defence Minister Peter MacKay and Gov. Gen Michaelle Jean were among those present in Trenton for the repatriation ceremony.

Still, some soldiers who spoke with CTV expressed disappointment that they would not be on the tarmac when the repatriation ceremony took place.

"Some of us talked about it on the flight last night and none of us would have minded stopping in Trenton first," one soldier told CTV.

"I think they had their flight plans in and that was what they wanted to do ... Unfortunately, as nice as it would have been to be at the ... ceremony in Trenton, we got dropped off here first -- and it's going to be a little tough coming all the way with her and not being with her when she comes off the plane."

CTV also received an email message from a soldier serving in Afghanistan complaining that Blais wasn't being treated with proper respect. Blais' coffin should have been the first thing to come off the military plane, said the soldier.

But because of the troop rotation, there would have been hundreds of pieces of baggage that would be hand-carried, and moved around and over the casket upon disembarking in Ottawa.

While some military observers told CTV it's a minor controversy that is being blown out of proportion, others who were watching the repatriation at Trenton were clearly upset at the decision -- saying if it was made to save cost and time, it was the wrong decision.

"My feeling is, they left with her from Afghanistan, I know it's a long haul -- they've been sitting there on this airplane and everything, but I think they should have come all the way with her (to Trenton)," said Kathleen Paul, a military mother whose son has been on two tours to Afghanistan.

"Blais had gotten killed over there. She was over there the same as them, and they should have come with her. Normally they all stick together," said Paul.

Retired Canadian military Col. Michel Drapeau said the detour is "a sign of huge insensitivity to the feelings of soldiers first of all, and ... more importantly, to the dead soldier and their family."

Drapeau told CTV's Power Play Thursday that the purpose of the flight was to bring home the fallen soldier and to give her family a chance to receive her with respect.

Instead, the coffin sat in Ottawa for three hours and then had a lonely flight back to Trenton, said Drapeau.

"This is not in the best tradition of the military."


Comments are now closed for this story

Steph in Oromocto
said

To all on that Flight; Ruck-up, Suck it up and Soldier on. We owe her that much.

To all civilians; You pay us to represent our country, we do it proudly and that means putting our feelings aside to accomplish the mission.


Gerry Demers
said

To the family of Karine Blais, first of all my deepest condolences, she will be missed.As a Canadian , I thank her for serving her country.
As for what happened today with bringing her home,I am disgusted.
Who in the hell made this decision ????
What lack of respect to a fallen comrade. My father was a Veteran, he would be also disgusted.And to all who think this is blown over for nothing ,you are so wrong .Some of these comments disgust me and show what little respect you have for this soldier.Wake up and be proud of all soldiers coming home dead or alive.It is all of Canda who must honor her , it is our duty and she deserved to be treated ahead of everybody.Damn the idiot who wronged her and damn this government who will not fly the flags half-mast at all times for as long as our troops are where they do not belong.We as Canadians want the press to cover these events, it is our way to honour our fallen soldiers.Great , censorship of the fallen.Nice job ,Mr.Harper you should be ashamed of such decisions.Better change it fast ,lots of lost votes on this one.
God bless you Karine.


Alex (Toronto)
said

CTV should be applauded both for their ongoing support for the military by giving these stories a high profile, and for upholding Canadian values by holding the military to the highest standard. That's what citizens and viewers expect.

One decision-maker may have made a mistake, and one or two young soldiers may have shown disrespect. One does not doubt that these soldiers are receiving proper discipline and instruction now. Canadians offer condolences to the family and respect to our fallen soldier. As we have before, as we will again. It's great that the modern media offers us the luxury of mourning every death in the field; this shows that every soldier serves with a purpose, in life and in death.


Nancy: I alwasy where Red on Friday
said

Apology Accepted.

I always were red on Friday the colour of my heart.


K Hawkins, Oshawa, Ontario
said

I think this was an insult to all Canadian soldiers-the officers on board should have had their say before the choice was made for them. Why couldn't the military have flown them back to Ottawa after the repatriation?

Welcome home soldier - God bless you and your family


LF
said

So we still have idiots running the military. Maybe they will eventually run for political office.

Apologies aren't good enough as far as I am concerned.


Trenton Repat Attendee
said

Having attended todays repatriation I can assure all - the dignity and respect displayed for Trooper Karine Blais followed the protocols afforded all Canadian soldiers repatriated at CFB Trenton.
While the stop in Ottawa is indeed unfortunate if for nothing else but to afford returning soldiers the opportunity to pay there respects to a fallen soldier, the decision was made for logistical and customs reasons I am sure. Unfortunately, the media and irresponsible citizens of this great country are taking this out of context as there were approximately 250-300 Canadian Forces members on the tarmac and another 250-300 outside the perimeter fence of this base to show support for the family and friends of this fine soldier who has paid the ultimate sacrifice.
Perhaps the retired Colonel should attend a Trenton repatriation prior to accusing the Canadian forces of callous behaviour. His comments which clearly identified the youth, gender and hometown location of Trooper Blais suggesting there is a reluctance on the part of the forces logisticians to afford the same and equally dignified return to Canadian soil offends me. Canada......the repatriation ceremony is, was and will continue to be supported with the respect and dignity these returning Canadian Forces members have earned, regardless of where they come from, how old thay were or their gender!


Trevor (soldier)
said

I agree with the comments about if the other soldiers would have had the option that they would have taken the bus ride instead of landing in Ottawa, It was probably all senior officers that are out of touch with us troops that made the decision without thinking! it happens alot.


a soldier's mom
said

Let's not forget the most important part of all this.
Today another Hero makes the trip home for the last time.
Thank you for the ultimate sacrifice--your life, the most precious gift a soldier could ever give. Thank-you again. You will not be forgotten. Rest in Peace


Ron
said

As a soldier I can tell you that this decision was based solely on finances. They may call it logistics, but the bottom line would be how much would it cost. This is very sad, but not that surprising.


dawn
said

unreal...what a crass thing for the department of defense to decide...this soldier died for her country and to be treated like this during repatriation is unacceptable....Trooper Blais my prayers and thoughts go out to your family..


karen in wl
said

..i certainly hope that the tragedy of losing another of our soldiers is not lost upon the "should they or shouldnt they have" conversation. i dont for one second believe that our fallen are treated with any disrespect and nor do i think that trooper blais would have wanted her arrival to extend the reuniting of her comrades with their families.

it is with great intent that people are trying to find controversy here however it has been explained and she is now home to be laid to rest and to let her family, friends, peers and country say goodbye.

support our troops.


Glenn
said

This is very hard to take. The first person off of that plane should have been Karine. She put her life on the line for those 117 soldiers that were LUCKY to come home to their family. The military should hang their heads in shame. Only after they shake it for a while and aske themselves the question, "WHAT WERE WE THINKING?" Shame, Shame, Shame on whoever made that call.


Linda in Vancouver
said

I don't think there was any disrespect intended here so why are we looking for a villian?? Senior officials in defense have spoken to the "faux pas".Now we should be able to count on better planning in the future.


I'm not a member of the CF,so I wouldn't presume to speak for them.But,I would find it difficult to imagine many of them objecting the the very best treatment for Trooper Blais,and deal with their own inconveniences without even the slightest hint of irritation.

I often wonder if some of the media are intentionally stirring up controversy where nor real controvery exists.And,if so,they have their own political agenda.

That said,I truly wish I had personal contacts and close friends who are now serving.At least I would knw I'm getting accurate feedback and not media spin.

I would also like to hear a real discussion about the lowering of the flag,and the protocols surrounding that procedure.I seriously doubt that those who favour leaving most of the flags in Canada flying high are saying that as a sign of disrespect.I had this discussion with my WWII veteran father.While I am guessing there would be lots of contrary opinions,he told me that he thought some flags should be lowered in some places,but that a lot of soldiers felt that they were fighting to keep that flag flying high.

One thng seems clear.We need to respect all of these people,all of the time,and quit fighting amongst ourselves every time the media,or some blowhard politician wants to create an issue for the daily news.

REST IN PEACE TROOPER.You will be missed.To all those serving,thank you,and take care.We love you all.


saskpool
said

Had the aircraft landed in Trenton instead of Uplands the soldiers would not have been on the ramp when the casket was removed from the aircraft. When the casket arrives at it's final destination the only person allowed off the aircraft prior to the casket being removed is the person that was designated as the official escort. There was no disrespect shown here and before people comment they should get their facts straight. It's sad enough that we have lost another young and dedicated citizen of canada without people looking for something to bitch about.


Joe from Hamilton
said

No soldier on that plane would have minded going to Trenton, it would have added a few hours more to their day.

To charter 4-5 buses and take these soldiers to Ottawa after they landed in Trenton & paid their respects would not have been a big deal. It may have helped them & the grieving family to see the respect these trained professionals have for one another.


In order to save a few bucks and make the grieving family wait is unconscionable.



Kingston
said

Well glitches happen and can be totally blown out of proportion, I would like to add a little sanity to this, the Airbuses are based out of CFB Trenton, This is a scheduled flight with a planned flight route, no doubt from it refueling stop in Europe someplace to Ottawa, unload the troops and home to Trenton for servicing and flight crew change, and reload for the next trip over to the sandbox. Was this unfortunate, totally, but I can understand how someone who was planning the flight made the error in the name of efficiency


R
said

As an Afghan combat vet, I can say that 99.9% of us would want to stay with her. This decision must have been made by a penny counting officer/admin person, who was just doing his or her job. They are directed to always find the cheapest way to move troops, in this case their should have been an exception. Hopefully this will not happen again.
Welcome home Trooper Blais, God Bless.


Troop Support
said

Such a shame to the those who made the decision to fly to Ottawa first.....Saying "sorry" isn't going to ease to pain any less to Trooper Blais family & friends. Knowing how tight knit the soldiers are, all of those on the plane will ride to "eternity" if they have to, so to bring her back home alive with them.
We salute you Trooper Blais....God Bless. You will be remembered.


Steven A
said

How fortunate that we are able to repatriate and debate the details on how to pay homage to one soldier rather than burying them by the thousands where they fall. The death of this one soldier, however, is no less tragic than the death of a million and to date was one of 117 too many.


JPF
said

Disgraceful. Karine Blais' body sits in the plane for 3 hours in Ottawa while the family waits in Trenton. Unacceptable. So is the weak apology.


John Godon
said

As a Canadian I firmly believe that a fallen soldier has priority over ALL ELSE THERE IS NO EXCEPTION. It is too easy to sit back and change the focus on the "fault pas" of some penny splitter to CTV for covering this. NO Respect-NO more volunters is possible. SAD!


Linda
said

This is such a tragic loss to the family members as well as to all the other Canadian soldiers who were killed.


The Canadian Gov't should pull troops out of Afghanistan immediately. Nobody is winning this war, if the Russians loss the war, Canada definitely will not win.


PS
Perhaps all of those sitting in the house of commons be sent over to Afghanistan to really feel pain & the loss of family members.


My "Deepest Sympathy" to the families.


Linda





Jon
said

The Canadian Forces only has 5 Airbus CC-150 transport aircraft, and they land in Ottawa all the time for troop rotations. The CF is lacking in aircraft, and if you are told to get off the plane then you get off the plane.


A death is always tragic, but perhaps her family didn't want all the crowds and media to contend with.


Welcome to the military.


goldens
said

It is a shame that such a heroic deed by a great soldier who gave it all is being marred by such petty bickering


John Wilson

Bridgetown NS


Mike from Edmonton
said

She has unfortunately joined the thousands of Candains who have lost their lives serving this great country to uphold the our distinctly Candian principles. The "News Staff" at CTV should take a moment to reflect upon who they owe their livelihood to and treat them with the respect they deserve. I expect that every "News Staff" person will be in attendance this November 11 - rain, snow or shine.


John
said

Calm down everyone. What has happened has happened we cannot change it. We are all very sorry about the death of this soldier and understand the feelings those soldiers had coming home with her. Hopefully we have learned something here.


Myself, I wonder why a coroner in Ottawa can't be used instead of Toronto. Seems to me that Ottawa or even a stop in Montreal could have happened using a corner in Montreal. Why not?


My sincere condolences to the Blais family.


Jaspf
said

Another typical poorly thought out plan. As there will always be a higher Chief in charge to make bonehead moves like this one. This is just another check in the box as to why myself and so many others have parted ways with the military. My view has nothing to due with the soldiers themselves, they themselves prove over and over they know how to get the job done when called upon, just like Trooper Blais has done. The Big Boys in Ottawa who make these calls need to wake up. Rest In Pease Trooper Blais.


John in Halifax
said

Well said Tony, you speak for me as I could not express it better


GCBurns
said

This was a very unfortunate mistake on someones part but I just have to say that the CTV news media is not giving her due respect by broadcasting this event and making a big story.


Wes
said

The most important thing is that we properly remember this young soldier and not make a huge fuss about where the plane landed.


Least we forget!


CF Member and Afghan Vet x2
said

Exactly Johan. Here is the story: Fallen Canadian Soldier returns home from Afghanistan. Family and friends there to grieve as one. I have had two tours in Afghanistan, had close friends killed, and wished I could have been there for the repatriation ceremony, but it didn't happen. So be it. She was killed, she was given a proper send off from Afghanistan, she will be given a proper burial here, family and friends will grieve. Does it matter where the plane went first? I believe not. Stay focused on the loss of another soldier who believed in the work we do every day! My condolences to her family. RIP Tpr Blais.


Jim McB
said

Canadian soldiers should be wise enough to avoid a controversy by opening their mouth inappropriately. They take the focus off the repatriation to discuss their wishes, they should be ashamed and their conduct should be examined.


The media will demean anyone at any time to get back at the government for shutting them out. The timing of this story is regrettable and it will upset the survivors of that valiant young lady.


Karine did her duty with honour and devotion and paid the ultimate sacrifice. It is too bad that those who surrounded her on her final voyage and those who covered her story could not muster up the respect to treat her well on that trip!



Garry in NS
said

@Johan, Newmarket

You are absolutely correct. This is nothing more than a minor glitch and did not detract from the repatriation ceremony in Trenton which is for the family and NOT for more than 100 or so soldiers that would have deplaned with the casket. The CTV editors need to shake their heads.


Johan, Newmarket
said

I think CTV is looking for a scoop by trying to create a controversy here. Even if there are some difference of opinion about this matter,it is unnecessary and disrespectful to report on such matters. This is no service to a family in grief, just cheap sensationmaking. Sadly enough, CTV has been doing this more and more lately.


mb
said

Jump in the friends' shoes for a brief second, I'm sure there are enough soldiers around to fill other positions if friends feel they need to be there.


John British Columbia
said

I hate to say this but bodies are routinely moved by aircraft and as far as I know they are always treated as cargo. This does not mean they coffin is treated with disrespect but the logistics of moving freight by air means that bags are routinely packed around the coffin. My dad is a baggage handler for a major airline and when his wife passed away she was transported the same way. I was there when she was loaded onto the plane. The only difference is that usually this all goes on behind the scenes. In past wars the Canadian military left its dead in military graveyards overseas. Go to northern France and you will see what I mean. I think it is a great honour that we are able to bring our war dead home regardless of how we do it. I also don’t think it demeans in anyway the great sacrifice these soldiers make.


JJ
said

The trouble is that once a decision is made, rightly or wrongly, it is made and the military like any other large and bureacratic organization cannot easily change its plans.


Veteran
said

Citizen: from a veteran, you are 100% correct. Stick to the real story, CTV, and don't mar this sad day with unwarranted "controversy".


Rick in NB
said

Updated Wed. Apr. 26 2006 12:58 PM ET


CTV.ca News Staff


"CTV.ca has been flooded with email from Canadians expressing their opinion following the Conservative government's decisions that the Peace Tower flag will not be flown at half-mast to mark the deaths of Canadian soldiers killed in Afghanistan, and that the media will be barred from attending repatriation ceremonies."




My take on ths is.If you change the way that we grieve for our fallen, than we might start forgeting what they have fallen for. Why do politicans insist on meddling in things they know nothing of?




Wise Wajid
said

That's unfortunate, but from here on in, let's show her the respect we've shown all the other Soldiers who've come home.

Condoléances à la famille Blais.


Citizen
said

CTV looking for controversy again are they. This is being blown out of proportion, soldiers don't come home directly from Afghanistan, the go to Camp Mirage, stay a few days, they go to decompression, stay a few more days, and then come home. This allows for feelings and actions to get used to no longer being in a war zone. Repatriated soldiers KIA go from Afghanistan to Mirage to Trenton, and usually there are no exceptions to this.


military girlfriend
said

This is just plain wrong. All the soldiers on the plane would understand and know the usual protocol. They all should have been given the opportunity to be there at the ramp ceremony. Cost and logistics should not come first over respect for a fallen comrade. The higher ups made a bad decision.
My thoughts and prayers are with the family during this difficult time.


JB
said

This is the second Canadian female Soldier to die in Afghanistan since 2002 and 117 CDN Soldiers in total.


This is very sad news and my thoughts and prayers are with friends and family once again.


Tony
said

As a fellow soldier, I wouldn't have gotten off in Ottawa I would have stayed on board. But it is not the soldiers' fault that this decision is made. Every soldier is special and we all feel a piece of us is gone having served with these fine individuals that give up their lives for others. Welcome Back Soldier, Stand Easy your job is done. We will remember.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

CTV News

Soldiers with the Canadian Army's 1st Battalion Royal 22nd Regiment return to base on their final operation Thursday, June 30, 2011 in the Panjwaii district of Kandahar province, Afghanistan. (AP Photo/David Goldman)

Canada in Afghanistan

The latest news, photos and interactives from Canada's mission in Afghanistan.

Canadian Soldiers were injured when a Light Armoured Vehicle (LAV) Turret struck an on coming vehicle, outside Kandahar City, causing it to rotate 360 degrees wounding the two Canadian soldiers. (Cpl. Robin Mugridge / Department of National Defence)

Invisible Wounds

Angela Mulholland: Scope of injury toll in Afghanistan largely a mystery

Brain injuries among soldiers are often overlooked.

Blast-Induced Injuries

Brain injuries among soldiers serving in Afghanistan are often overlooked.

Doctor Louis-Philippe Palerme, right, from Gatineau, Quebec, is assisted by a Danish doctor, Captain Sacha Soelbeck, during a surgery at R3 MMU in Afghanistan.

Medical Advances

Soldiers survived injuries that, even 10 years ago, would have been fatal.

Cpl. Chris Klodt sits in a race chair. Klodt was shot in the neck July 7, 2006 during a Taliban ambush outside Kanadhar. The bullet was lodged in his spinal cord.

Soldiers Overcome Injuries

Wounded soldiers use sports to overcome injuries, adjust to their new reality.

Janis Mackey Frayer in Sperwan Ghar, Afghanistan

Kandahar Journal

Janis Mackey Frayer recounts sombre process of notifying next of kin.

Interactive

War Zone Medics

Lessons Learned

A number of the medical innovations that we now take for granted were conceived and tested during wartime.

Bios and Pictures

Casualties

Canadian Casualties

We remember those who lost their lives in Afghanistan since the mission began in 2002.

In Pictures

Canada's Last Days in Afghanistan

Concluding Combat

50 Pictures: Canadian troops conclude Afghan combat tour after a decade.

Kandahar transfer ceremony

Transfer Ceremony

In Pictures: Canada transfers control of Kandahar region to the U.S

Harper in Afghanistan

Harper in Afghanistan

25 Pictures: Stephen Harper meets with soldiers on his fourth Afghan trip.

Canada in Kandahar

Canada in Kandahar

30 Pictures: New tasks tackled as combat mission nears its end.

Operation Topak Shkar

Operation Topak Shkar

Canadian troops take on the Taliban in Operation Topak Shkar.

Today's Top Stories

Red stains are seen on a bed in Luka Rocco Magnotta's Montreal apartment, which is the scene of a murder investigation, on Thursday, May 31, 2012.

Dismembered victim was Chinese student Jun Lin: Police

More   10 Comments 10    8 Video(s) 8

quebec tuition protest classe

Talks between Quebec gov't, students collapse

More  3 Video(s) 3