News Sections
'Ashley died because no one in Canada cares'
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Mar. 4 2009 1:47 PM ET
The mother of Ashley Smith, a teen who committed suicide in a federal prison while correctional guards watched on, vowed to keep pushing the government until "faceless" jail officials were held accountable.
During a news conference Wednesday morning, Coralee Smith fought to keep her voice steady as she told reporters she wants the names of the guards who watched her 19-year-old daughter strangle herself to death.
She said she was outraged at a recent report into the death that found the guards did nothing to help the girl because of specific orders from their supervisors not to intervene if the teen attempted suicide.
"As a family we think Ashley died because no one in Canada cares. No one," Smith said fighting back tears. "Not the guards who watched her asphyxiate, not the people who gave the orders, not the bureaucrats who knew our daughter needed help but did nothing but transfer her 17 times in 11 months."
Ashley, a troubled teen from Moncton, N.B. who was assessed by child psychologists several times in her youth, and was in constant trouble with the law.
When she was 13, she was sent to a New Brunswick psychiatric facility after she started shoving people on the street. She was sent home after 21 days of the 30-day evaluation because staff couldn't handle her, Coralee Smith said.
Two years later, Ashley got into trouble for throwing crabapples at a postal worker. Her mother said when she went to visit her in custody, she noticed several scars along her forearm from various suicide attempts. She said Ashley never tried to hurt herself before she was placed in custody.
When she was 16, Ashley was released but was arrested again a short time later for stealing a CD and pulling a fire alarm. She returned to a youth facility but after assaulting several guards, she was transferred to Ontario Grand Valley Institution, a federal prison, when she was 18.
In the 12 months that she was incarcerated, she continued to attempt suicide several times before finally succeeding on Oct. 19, 2007.
Ashley's death 'preventable'
Howard Sapers, Correctional Investigator of Canada, publicly released a report on Tuesday of his investigation into the matter. His report concluded that Ashley's death was "preventable" and that senior officials violated laws in regards to how the teen was treated while she was imprisoned. The violations include, "inappropriate use of institutional transfers, administrative segregation, and interventions involving force," the report says.
He told reporters on Tuesday that Smith had tied ligatures around her neck on several occasions prior to her death and staff had been successful in negotiating with her to remove it or forcibly removing it themselves.
According to court transcripts, seven guards watched as Smith choked herself to death because they had been instructed not to intervene.
"When staff finally did remove the ligature they exited the cell without providing any sort of medical intervention and then subsequently went back into the cell a second time where they began attempts to preserve life," Sapers said at yesterday's news conference.
"Eventually paramedics showed up, transported Ashley to an outside hospital, where she was pronounced dead."
Sapers concluded in the report that her death marked a "disturbing and well-documented pattern of deaths in custody" and was indicative of the "lack of coordination and cohesiveness among federal, provincial and territorial mental health and correctional systems."
Minister urged to act
At Wednesday's news conference, the family's lawyer Julian Falconer read a letter the Smiths have written to Peter Van Loan, Canada's public safety minister, appealing for him to identify the public officials who broke the law by letting Ashley die.
"The family is requesting you direct the correctional investigator to complete his work," he read from the letter. "Currently all we know is that a group of faceless bureaucrats violated the law and let Ashley Smith die alone in utterly deplorable circumstances.
"It makes a mockery of public accountability to identify law breaking but fail to identify the lawbreakers," he said.
Mark Holland, an Ontario MP who serves as the Opposition Critic for public safety, said it's imperative that an action plan be put into place to prevent a similar tragedy from occurring.
He said the minister's response to the matter has been "inadequate."
"It's imperative that there be an immediate action plan and specific dates be put into place to deal with what has been some very long-standing issues," he said.
He quoted the report's findings that Ashley's death was partly the result of "ill-functioning and under resourced correctional and mental health systems."
He said the government has worked to improve the laws around punishment but have fallen short on implementing a strategy that would deal with prevention, particularly with people who suffer from mental disorders.
"It was through mistake after mistake after mistake that (Ashley's) death eventually resulted. It's something that should have never been allowed to occur," he told reporters at the news conference.
Coralee Smith said her family spoke to Ashley days before she killed herself but that her daughter almost never spoke of the conditions of her confinement.
She commended Sapers for his "splendid report" but repeated the family's request that the government name the people that were investigated in her daughter's death.
"We are heartbroken," she said. "I promise Canadians that I won't stop looking for answers until we can be sure that this won't happen again to a youth in this country."
User Tools
Related Stories
Related Websites
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
But they probably get straight As for computer games and TV.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
SAZ in Ottawa
0
said
0
Peter from Kanata
0
said
0
WestofTheRockies
0
said
0
No normal person stands by & watches anyone die. That's it period.
By defending these people, you are as pathetic as these people.
I'll bet their families are proud of them for thinking only of them while standing by while a helpless person died.
Missopi
0
said
0
Tania Edmonton
0
said
0
Michelle Ottawa
0
said
0
EdwardMean
0
said
0
It is the system that has failed. Those in a position to help are handcuffed due to human rights issues.
As somebody who has dealt with a mentally ill mother for many years, I have seen firsthand the difficulty in getting someone help. A person must voluntarily admit themselves into care unless there is a direct threat to themselves or others. This is a human right. The problem with this is that, in general, people with mental illness do not realize that they are mentally ill. And that is why the system needs to change. Families need to be able to help their loved ones but simply cannot.
I feel for this woman, but given the current laws we have I think the outcome was probably inevitable. We need to change things in this country. We need to help those that are unable to help themselves and mental illness prevents these people from helping themselves.
WestofTheRockies
0
said
0
This is the same pathetic defence mounted by most of the Nazi's tried at the Nuremburg trials.
This young person was very difficult to handle according to another official. Another pathetic excuse. Blame the victim, is now the mantra of law & order personnel in Canada
How anyone, regardless of what they were told by anyone could stand by and actually watch anyone die is completely beyond the capacity of any normal person to understand. Too bad a helpless young woman is dying, I have my job & family to consider.
One would hope that this would haunt these people for the rest of their lives, but anyone so hard hearted that with the ability to stop it who then stands by and lets this happen will probably not loose a wink of sleep.
We wonder how the horrors of WW II, Bosnia, Rawanda, etc happen. This is how, this is the thin edge of the wedge.
Pathetic!
Dave A from Ottawa
0
said
0
Somebody needs to be held accountable.
Don Crone
0
said
0
If our people really cared then enough hell would be raised that the guards and their boss would all face criminal charges
seval
0
said
0
Ted
0
said
0
Craig
0
said
0
Wayne
0
said
0
Thanks for your well written comments.
Kojak
0
said
0
Its Very Sad, Ottawa
0
said
0
The correctional officers, in their world of fear, abuse, and unbelievable stress that would cripple the rest of us, will have to live with what they did not do, but Ashley is gone because she was determined to strike out at both society and herself from an early age.
I feel sorry for all of them - every person who is mentally ill and uncared for, every victim of that mentally ill person and every family member who has to deal with such grief.
Such sadness in this world...
Ontario CO
0
said
0
Karen Sk
0
said
0
Dave Alberta
0
said
0
Victoria
0
said
0
Maureen
0
said
0
Caroline
0
said
0
Cody Sponaugle
0
said
0
Hold NoPunches
0
said
0
Cindy Woodcock
0
said
0
This is truly a tragic story, and my heartfelt sympathy goes out to the family of this young girl.
I am a mother of a 15 year old boy who is quite troubled. I have had many interactions with law over the last three years -- some positive and some extremely negative. I'm appalled at Canada'a youth justice system.
Chris in Ontariariari-Oh!
0
said
0
I still have a hard time understanding why the guard's would still leave that girl in that situation.I would rather take a disciplinary action than risk what happened to that girl.As far as the manager's in charge of the facility are concerned there need's to be an investigation into their role and what punitive action need's to be taken.This whole affair need's to be reviewed to find out why the system failed this girl and to draft the necessary protocol's to deal with and ensure that this will never happen again.This girl has been bounced through the system from an early childhood to a young adult and has not gotten the help she needed maybe if she had been properly diagnosed at an earlier age this may have been avoided.Our law's make it difficult to treat the mentally ill and many tend to fall through the crack's unfortunately ending up in the justice system.Let's hope something good come's out of this for anyone else who may find themselve's in this position.
beverly - lethbridge
0
said
0
What a horrifying story for any parent of an obviously mentally ill child - or the parent of ANY child at all.
Coralee Smith is right. NO ONE cared enough to even get psychiatric help for an obviously disturbed youth.
Shame on all of us for not crying out in protest and shame on the government officials and staff who perpetrated this crime on a young life.
Retired Soldier in Kingston, ON
0
said
0
The SS and the garden variety Nazi's in WW2 pleaded as much when confronted by Allied prosecutors with their collective crimes!
Now, speaking as a life long Conservative, if the current government does'nt act immediately, investigate and prosecute these sub-human individuals then the Conservatives are no better than the guards who stood by and watched them die.
Consequently, if no action is taken, I'll have to hold my nose and vote Communist in the next election as no party is currently worthy of high office!!
Peter Van Loan; are you listening?? Imprsion and then fire these shmucks and, as a society, lets show public support for Ashleys mother, and ensure this never happens again!!
Pro Patria
Laura
0
said
0
Clearly the system is flawed and is in need of additional funding and bureaucratic changes, but remember that our system is based on rehabilitation not punishment, and that should apply to the guards as well. Perhaps they need better training or supervision? If you care enough to write an emotional and outraged comment, care enough to write a well thought out letter to your MP. We can't get a life back, but we can prevent issues in the future.
Brittany
0
said
0
AD
0
said
0
"Get real - there aren't enough guards to constantly watch and intervene every time an inmate threatens suicide."
I suppose seven guards watching this happen weren't enough to prevent this suicide?
willy...
0
said
0
Well yours truly was a Jail Guard.
Yours Truly had his face kicked in....
Yours Truly had feces and urine and spit "occurrences".
Yours Truly was taken Hostage, albeit for a short time...by the elite of whom you show sorrow for.
'till you walked the cell block or dormitory hallways folks...take a hike.
Andrea
0
said
0
Mike from Ajax
0
said
0
In the case of strangling themselves it is all they can do, as they have no weapons or anything else.
Most people are not capable of strangling themselves, as they pass out before life slips away.
I was responsible for watching this happen as well. We were told to watch them attempt to strangle themselves, as it is (was) an attempt to gain attention, and not a real suicide attempt. (This sad story is the first I have heard where someone succeeded in strangling themselves).
Some of the kids were violent and would use a suicide attempt to get a guard inside the lock up so they could attack them. So occasionally this is for the safety of the guards (which is top priority).
Granted, in this situation, there comes a time when we must step in... but the only way to truly prevent such things would be to restrain any suicidal kids/prisoners just so they can't kill themseves...
Suicide attempts are a very regular occurence in youth jails, this is a 1 in a million case where the youth succeeded.
My solution? She should have been restrained completely, hands and feet. But as I said, this is SO common, especially strangling attempts, that this could have easily happened at any youth prison.
The ONLY options are completely restrain all suicidal prisoners, or allow them to kill themselves. Obviously they cannot keep all suicidal prisoners strapped down 24/7 so these cases are bound to happen.
Preventable? perhaps... but these are the details everyone should be aware of before passing judgements on a faulty system...
There is room for change, but this is not an obvious 'shame on Canada' situation.
Mel
0
said
0
Josh
0
said
0
My thoughts and sympathy go out to the family.
-Josh from Ohio, United States
David from Edmonton
0
said
0
Charles
0
said
0
Zand
0
said
0
Diana Parker
0
said
0
Put a vulnerable young woman in solitary confinement for days upon days and what ould you expect? heck a very storng, mature person might have thoughts of taking their life.
How on earth could the guards watch a person choke themselves to death and not intervene. Sickening.
Canada- what is happening to us? Where is the compassionate society I was so proud of gone?
Do something NOW government.
Again to the family-your pain is imeasurable but know that many of us DO care. take care of yourselves.
EA
0
said
0
LaLa
0
said
0
Health Care Worker
0
said
0
Paul in Mississauga
0
said
0
D in SK
0
said
0
darico
0
said
0
Psych Nurse
0
said
0
kyra
0
said
0
George Lawrence Thunder Bay ON
0
said
0
Dr John Smythe
0
said
0
ALL Police and Peace officers should be liable to at least 3 times the sentence of anyone else because these people are supposed to uphold and enforce the law.
Frank
0
said
0
Caroline
0
said
0
KLK
0
said
0
Corrections staff deal day in and day out with people and situations that most of us don't even like to think exist and they do it for very little pay and very little recognition. If every once in a while something goes bad, I'm willing to cut them some slack. As someone said yesterday, there wouldn't be all this fuss if it was some child molester we were talking about, but then again, we don't even know why she was in the system.
Roby-D
0
said
0
From what I understand, the guards are members of a union, and therefore would have had assistance to fight any insubordination disciplenary actions that may have resulted from intervening, not that I would stop long enough to think of such a fact in an emergency.
Have a heart, Canada.
0
said
0
NB
0
said
0
All those guards, supervisors and bureaucrats must be identified and charged. I have lost all respect for our correctional and police forces. After the tasering death of the Polish immigrant in Vancouver and now this, Canada needs to get off her high horse and we must clean up our act!
Christina
0
said
0
Sandy- Belleville
0
said
0
ReyC - Toronto
0
said
0
Julebran
0
said
0
Ian
0
said
0
ian Stant-karma
0
said
0
George from saskatoon
0
said
0
Argue all you want I commend these people on following through with their orders.
Art
0
said
0
Not that this isn't a tragity or a shame, but you will only be able to stop someone so many times before they succeed. Everyone seems to be talking like this was a sudden and unexpected event with her, becasue it wasn't.
sandy
0
said
0
Barb
0
said
0
nc
0
said
0
If this is true. Even on a most basic human level one of those guards should have intervened. If someone higher up ordered guards to not to intervene. This person must be tried for some criminal act. I have little respect for this present federal govt.
Donna
0
said
0
Roger T
0
said
0
All talks but no actions in our country!
Barry in Ottawa
0
said
0
AllYouNeedIsLove
0
said
0
Perhaps the Minister of Public Safety is not told everything.
Perhaps CSC is conveniently keeping some secrets...
Both hypothesis are of great concern. Canadians deserve to know and secrecy has to stop! Lifes are at stake here...
simon
0
said
0
What a shame!
I would like to see drastic, and immediate actions to correct this.
Some heads should roll.....
Todd Hagar
0
said
0
Dave P.
0
said
0
Elaine, Cranbrook
0
said
0
Anne
0
said
0
Larry
0
said
0
In my opinion, the officers involved as well as the warden and and all in the chain of command, that gave the order to not act, should be charged with assisting a suicide, second degree murder. The facility should be shut down, and the charged officials behind bars.
Dave
0
said
0
Dean
0
said
0
Rhona Bennett
0
said
0
Sandra from Montreal
0
said
0
what on earth
0
said
0
FreakAlert
0
said
0
Fatman
0
said
0
All concerned, guards, supervisors, the warden and all other faceless bureaucrats who played a part in this tragedy should be held fully accountable and pay an appropriate price for their participation. I hold that termination of employment and jail time would fall into the catagory of "appropriate price".
My condolences to the Smith family and the deceased friends for the pain they endure due to the lack of compassion and common sense that should have been, but wasn't, demonstrated in this case by those in positions of responsibility and authority.
Jarrod in Victoria
0
said
0
B
0
said
0
Wayne Butt
0
said
0