Top Stories -   

1
A shopper watches as Prime Minister Stephen Harper addresses the country on television screens at an electronics store in Vancouver, Wednesday, Dec. 3, 2008. (Darryl Dyck / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Prime Minister Stephen Harper prepares his speech to the nation from his office on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday, Dec.3, 2008. (Tom Hanson / THE CANADIAN PRESS)   Liberal Leader Stephane Dion reads his speech in reaction to the prime minister's televised speech to the nation from his office on Parliament Hill in Ottawa Wednesday, Dec. 3, 2008. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Full text of Stephen Harper and Stephane Dion statements

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Special: Harper delivers his address
Featuring the threat of a coalition government in the midst of an economic crisis, Prime Minister Stephen Harper makes his case to the Canadian people.
CTV Newsnet: Stephane Dion delivers his address to Canadians
With Stephen Harper delivering his address to the nation, Stephane Dion responds with his economic plan and why he has requested that the GG does not prorogue parliament.
CTV News: Robert Fife on a short speech with few concessions
While some expected a longer speech with a few moments of contrition, Stephen Harper held firm in his address, saying his government has already provided economic stimulus.
CTV Newsnet: Craig Oliver with details on what the speech was lacking
With the economy continuing to stumble, Stephen Harper's abbreviated speech offerred little and is likely to stop the coalition or satisfy worried Canadians.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (295) Facebook   

Date: Wed. Dec. 3 2008 10:32 PM ET

OTTAWA The full text of Prime Minister Stephen Harper's televised address Wednesday:

Good evening.

Canadians take pride in our history as one of the world's oldest continuous democracies. During the past 141 years, political parties have emerged and disappeared, leaders have come and gone, and governments have changed.

Constant in every case, however, is the principle that Canada's government has always been chosen by the people. And following the light of this democratic tradition, Canadians have built one of the most peaceful and prosperous countries the world has ever known a land of hope and opportunity that inspires others around the globe, and has drawn millions as new immigrants to our country.

On October 14, for the 40th time since Confederation, Canadians voted in a national general election. We are honoured that you returned our government to office with a strengthened mandate to lead this great country through the most difficult global economic crisis in many decades. Canada's government is acting to deal with the crisis, right now.

Further personal and business tax reductions are coming into effect. We are doubling spending on infrastructure; we are ensuring credit for businesses and consumers by injecting liquidity into financial markets; we are helping seniors who rely on RRIR income; and securing pension plans.

We are implementing the Automotive Innovation Fund and, working with the government of Ontario, we are undertaking due diligence on any further requests for assistance from the auto industry.

We are increasing support and incentives for manufacturers, the forestry sector, and others to pursue business opportunities. We are implementing agreements with the provinces to enhance labour mobility. And, next month on January 27, we will bring in a budget which will contain additional measures to boost Canada's economy, while making sure we avoid a long term structural deficit in Canada's finances.

In preparation for that budget we are consulting widely with Canadians, meeting with premiers of our provinces and territories, and working in collaboration with our international partners in G20. The minister of finance will be consulting with the business community and interest groups.

We are consulting with, and expect to hear more from, the opposition parties in Parliament. We hope they bring forward specific proposals -- we have invited them to do so. In fact, we have already changed some of our proposals to meet their concerns.

Unfortunately, even before the government has brought forward its budget, and only seven weeks after a general election, the opposition wants to overturn the results of that election.

Instead of an immediate budget, they propose a new coalition which includes the party in Parliament whose avowed goal is to break up the country. Let me be very clear: Canada's government cannot enter into a power-sharing coalition with a separatist party. At a time of global economic instability, Canada's government must stand unequivocally for keeping the country together. At a time like this, a coalition with the separatists cannot help Canada. And the Opposition does not have the democratic right to impose a coalition with the separatists they promised voters would never happen.

The Opposition is attempting to impose this deal without your say, without your consent, and without your vote. This is no time for backroom deals with the separatists; it is the time for Canada's government to focus on the economy and specifically on measures for the upcoming budget. This is a pivotal moment in our history.

We Canadians are the inheritors of a great legacy, and it is our duty to strengthen and protect it for the generations still to come. Tonight, I pledge to you that Canada's government will use every legal means at our disposal to protect our democracy, to protect our economy, and to protect Canada.

Thank you, and goodnight. 


Full text of Liberal Leader Stephane Dion's televised address

Canada is facing the impacts of the global economic crisis. Our economy is on the verge of a recession. Canadians are worried about losing their jobs, their homes, their savings. Every economist in the country is predicting increased job losses and deficits for the next few years.

The federal government has a duty to act and help Canadians weather this storm.

Stephen Harper still refuses to propose measures to stimulate the Canadian economy. His mini-budget last week demonstrated that his priority is partisanship and settling ideological scores.

The Harper Conservatives have lost the confidence of the majority of members of the House of Commons. In our democracy, in our parliamentary system, in our Constitution, this means that they have lost the right to govern.

Canadians don't want another election, they want Parliamentarians to work together. That's our job. Canadians want their MPs to put aside partisanship and focus on the economy.

The Liberal Party and the New Democratic Party are ready to do this. Jack Layton and I have agreed to form a coalition government to address the impact of the global economic crisis. The Bloc has agreed to support this government on matters of confidence. The Green Party has also agreed to support it.

Our system of government was not born with Canada. It is ancient. There are rules that govern it and conventions that guide it. Coalitions are normal and current practice in many parts of the world and are able to work very successfully. They work with simple ingredients: consensus, goodwill and co-operation.

Consensus is a great Canadian value. In this spirit, we Liberals have joined in a coalition with the NDP. We have done so because we believe we can achieve more for Canadians through co-operation than through conflict. We believe we can better solve the challenges facing Canada through teamwork and collaboration, rather than blind partisan feuding and hostility.

Our coalition is a consensus to govern with a well-defined program to address the most important issue facing the country: the economy. It is a program to preserve and create jobs and to stimulate the economy in all regions of the country. The elements of the program need to be spelled out and this is what we will do if we are allowed to present it to the House of Commons.

We share the frustration Canadians have about a political crisis that has been allowed to take prominence over the more important economic challenges we face. Elsewhere in the world, leaders are working to cope with the recession, to bring forward the kinds of investments that will help their people and their economies. Politicians are working together. Rivals are working together.

Mr. Harper's solution is to extend that crisis by avoiding a simple vote; by suspending Parliament and continuing the confusion. We offer a better way. We say settle it now and let's get to work on the people's business. A vote is scheduled for next Monday. Let it proceed. And let us all show maturity in accepting the result with grace and the larger task of serving Canadians in mind.

Within one week, a new direction will be established, a tone and focus will be set. We will gather with leaders of industry and labour to work -- unlike the Conservatives -- in a collaborative but urgent manner to protect jobs. To stimulate the economy and create good well-paid jobs we will not only accelerate already planned investments, but invest significantly more in our country's infrastructure. Helping our cities like Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto, Montreal or Halifax build modern, efficient public transit systems. Investing in our rural communities so that cherished ways of life are protected for future generations. We can stimulate our economy through investments in clean energy, water and our gateways.

We will invest in our manufacturing, forestry and automotive sectors to protect and create jobs. We believe that in these tough economic times the government has a role to play to ensure that those who are doing their share for the prosperity of our country can continue to provide for the well-being of their families.

In times like this our compassion as a country is tested. We believe it is imperative that the government offers Canadians who have already lost their job, whether in the factories of southwestern Ontario or the forests of Eastern Quebec and British Columbia, the support they need to live in dignity and develop new skills. That is precisely what we intend to provide.

Earlier today I wrote Her Excellency the Governor General. I respectfully asked her to refuse any request by the prime minister to suspend Parliament until he has demonstrated to her that he still commands the confidence of the House. If Mr. Harper wants to suspend Parliament he must first face a vote of confidence.

In our Canada, the government is accountable for its decisions and actions in Parliament. In our Canada, the government derives its legitimacy from an elected Parliament.

Allow me to end tonight on a personal note. If I am entrusted with the role of prime minister for the next months that I have left to serve, I will work day and night to combat this economic crisis, to do what it takes to minimize its effects on Canadians, to protect jobs and to create jobs.

I will serve my country until my time to serve is at an end.

Comments are now closed for this story

Andy
said

Even though a coalition is legal and legitimate, it is a coup against our government that won the election fair and square. The Liberals lost significantly across this country. The NDP gained only a few seats and the Bloq are partisan Quebecers who don't care about Canada. This coalition is the only way Dion could ever be a prime minister! In Haldimand, most people didn't want Diane Finley but there really wasn't anyone else. It was a simpathy vote as people didn't want Dion as their Prime Minister. Ask the people of Canada if they really want Dion as their leader! I think not!! Mr. Dion, please step down now, maybe the Liberals will have a chance to lead our Parliament!


KC
said

It's no time for "backroom deals" - there never was a time, Harper. You apparently don't follow your own advice which is evidenced by the fact that a number of liberal MP's have been approached by your/your people, offering a cabinet post as reported live on CTV this morning. Influencing an MP is influence peddling. How is this remotely part of a democracy?


jim
said

How can Dion say that parliament has no confidence in the government when their agenda is essentially the same as the Conservatives. Clearly they just want power. His own party gave him non confidence by scheduling a leadership convention after the voters rejected him in the election.


CindyD
said

I would just like to know what the coalition thinks they are doing? Despite how many might not have voted for Stephen Harper, the fact remains there was a democratic election. The result of that election was that Harper won. We chose him to lead us, as we have done over the last 140+ years. I have been a staunch Liberal supporter for most of my adult life. This was the first time I didn't vote Liberal. There was a reason for it. Stephane Dion. Regardless of the person who was ultimately chosen to lead this country, the fact remains that out of the 62% that didn't vote for Harper, the next leader in votes was Dion and he received the least amount of votes for a Liberal candidate in the last 100 years. So, get over your egos boys, suck it up and realize that Canadians have spoken and Dion was definitely not who we chose to lead us.


Jason (Beachbug Ontario)
said

If the Liberals, NDP and the Bloc wanted a coalition they should have ran as a coalition in the election campain and let the people REALLY vote on it. This would have been the honest thing to do.
The government just gave an update not a budget. The coalition had to be cooking this up for a long time.

José
said

Let's face it we must find new leaders people that do their jobs in parliament. We don't lack of innovative and strong individuals but not the ones in the front panel right now. Work to a strong flourish country with sources to fulfill Canadian needs and demands for the tax contribution that citizens pay for. GET TO WORK PARLIAMENT PEOPLE for the citizens of the country. Not giving any credit to anyone on the panel right now.


Rob, Ottawa
said

I am not convinced by any of the party "leaders". This is nothing more than a power struggle, a fight over parliamentary procedure.

If you want to argue about what is democratic and what isn't, the electorate would be good to remind their MPs that the most important tenant of democracy is the these MP represent the will of the voters and not their own political career aspirations.

READ LEADERSHIP comes from being able to solve problems, not from taking a non-reconcilable, self-righteous stance. If any of the party leaders are paying attention to your voters, real leadership will be recognized when you can end this crisis without resorting to extreme measures.

Unfortunately, I don't see any real leadership coming from any of the party leaders. I welcome a new election; it's time to find some real leadership for the sake of this country.


JASON ANDERSON in Calgary
said

I decided to do some cherry picking of my own for that person who used stats to represent what number of People didn't vote for Stephen Harper.

According to stats Canada:

12,453,407 - 88.2% Did not vote Gilles Duceppe

11,315,897 - 83% did not vote for Jack Layton

10,202,982 - 75.3% did not vote for Stephan Dion

and just so we are clear on this, ZERO PEOPLE - 0% of the population voted for a coalition government as they were not a party, option or otherwise.

So yes, Stephen Harper was the least hated of all the Candidates which means he WINS. An yes it is unconstitutional and undemocratic to force a new party (coalition) into government without a vote. Nobody asked me, and I voted for one of those guys currently trying to form the coalition. I would never support a coalition. I won't make that mistake again.

LONG LIVE DEMOCRACY.


Diana
said

I support the coalition.


Bryn
said

Harper did not win a majority, which means that a coalition is fair game, clearly. Most Canadians did not vote for the conservatives, so if the MP's we voted for want to work together...why not?

Vanessa from Quebec
said

I am sick and tired of hearing that the reason why this coalition is a problem for Canada is becaused it is aligned with the seperatist BQ. I have lived in Quebec my entire life and have never been seperatist and in fact have felt very strongly against seperatism. Yet, somehow, I, and every other Quebecer is considered a seperatist because of where we live. It's simple, Harper is scared, and is looking for something to scare the rest of Canada with. This political crisis has absolutle NOTHING to do with seperatism, so why is it such a major issue amoungst all of you? This coalition is not going to break up Canada. It was done to show Harper that there is a reason why Canada voted a minority government. I am a proud Canadian and have no interest in seperating from Canada and think that the fact that Harper's every second word is "seperatist", shows that he really has no idea what he's doing.


Vic Leutschaft
said

Vic from Dryden
Harper, contrary to his words, is not prepared to protect anything but his job. Not only are the Conservatives unwilling to address the economic crisis in Canada, but now they are threatening national unity by blasting the Bloc and making nasty comments about separatists. We deserve better than PM Stephen Harper.


Dennis Maceyovski, Chatham ON
said

Stephen Harper is supposed to be an "economist" by trade? He knew the recession was coming and was advised the recession was coming and tried to seize power through a scam election. Enough is enough! Now get what you deserve - ousted from power.


Effie Gibbons
said

FE
It is in my opinion that the Liberals need to clean up their acts and focus on a choosing a new leader before Mr. Dion completely destroys their party and leave the governining to our ELECTED Prime Minister, Stephen Harper! All this talk about a coalition infuriates me and I find it to be extremely undemocratic. How dare the Liberals team up with the NDP and the Bloc, all this means is giving in to the rediculous, socialist demands,more money for Quebec, and an enormous deficit that Canadian tax payers will be on the hook for decades! Wake up Canada and put a stop to this coalition, the long term effects can be devastating on our country. Shame on them for swinging so far to the left instead of working with the current government!


Pierre Lays
said

I would be so ashamed if I was a Canadian today. Mr Dion, the world is going through a major crisis and the time has come to be all behind the elected government to support him going through this. This is not time for a "coup d'etat" !! Please also remember that Canada is a democracy .... Thank you for your consideration.


Blair S.W.Ontario
said

I don’t believe that these three parties in particular were able to arrange a collation such as this in the past several days. At best, such a coalition of differing ideologies would take months. I’m certain secret tapes, emails etc will eventually surface which demonstrate a plan, long before a ‘cause’ was found. In Canada we have a tradition of electing our government. Apparently, and unrealized by most of us, it is also legal for the opposition parties to join forces and bring down the elected government. People have compared this example of parliamentary democracy and government by coalition to much of Europe and Israel. Do these same people want the incredible instability and frequency of elections that these other countries have? Although it is legal, do we really want to go down that road? Do we really want Stephan Dion as the Prime Minister? Has Dion demonstrated, ever, that he has the backbone, political common sense and broad intellectual capacity to manage such a coalition? Harper was given a mandate to govern. It was just shy of a majority mandate and I believe that requires him to govern with a degree of sensitivity to the ideas of the opposition parties. The other parties seem to be looking for the exact same kind of economic responses as have been given by European and American governments. What no one seems to be paying attention to, except perhaps Harper, is that Canada stands very uniquely in the world as it relates to the effects of the global crisis on Canada. Our system was just not as exposed as most other countries. We were more economically sound when the crisis came, except perhaps Ontario. Such a situation requires a different response that is specific to a Canada. I would like to see the Canadian Press actually dissecting this situation in every way, instead of playing into the spin of any particular party. This political ‘crisis’ is a matter of ‘the emperor has no clothes’. There is nothing real or necessary supporting it. Problem is, now that it’s ‘out there’, it has a life of it’s own and there are going to be profound consequences no matter what happens. Things will change. The country, political parties and individual politicians will suffer. To what end?


dulak
said

Vote for me as Prime Minister, I will invest in this, and that, and the other thing.

Mr. Dion, it's a lot easier said than done.


Donna Roger
said

I'd be thrilled to have a coalition governing rather than Harper. His politics frighten me and his arrogance repels me.


Jeanette
said

Dion has proven to be more despicable than imagined. Who is he, or Layton for that matter, to decide what Canadians want? We voted for Harper and the Conservatives so let them do their job! What a great way to improve a financial crisis and solve the government issues: completely reverse focus from the issues at hand and destroy democracy instead! Pretty sure Dion offered no financial plan throughout the election campaign anyways!


Lloyd Newton
said

Lloyd Newton from North Bay Ontario
The coalalition are scared of letting the people vote again. That is why they are trying to sneak in the back door and got caught. There is no need for campaigning because they say the people support what they are doing. They know they are wrong and would pay dearly. The people already told them but they refuse to accept that Canadians do not want them governing us.


Matt
said

How can there be all these people accusing Harper of creating this mess? What are you implying? That these parties should be funded because they received a vote? That we should just senselessly dump money into a sector of the economy that is failing? No, none of these things should happen.

For anyone who knows anything about economics, all that a stimulus package is likely to do is create inflation in the long run. And even if we give out a stimulus package, it's not going to be large enough to make a real difference anyways. The Ontario auto industry is dead, let it RIP. Go get another job, Alberta doesn't owe you anything


Matthew
said

I won't dwell on the obvious, that the "three amigos", if they manage to seize power, will ruin Canada's economy for years to come.
On a larger scale, this situation highlights that our current political system is broken. Endless minority governments have become the norm and this is extremely damaging for Canada's long-term stability. The main cause of the problem - the Bloc (splitting the Quebec vote). Harper's proposal to eliminate public funding of parties would have been the first big step to eliminate this problem and it's a shame that he backed down from this initiative. The Bloc must be eliminated in order for Canada to regain political stability.


winston
said

Why are people like Bob Rae and a fossilized Ed Broadbent droning on about Harper only getting 37 percent of the vote. First, there are 5 parties, so nobody, including Cretien with his three majority victories, got much more than that anyway. Second, Broadbent can scoff at that figure, but he never garnered that much support either.

Also, the comparison this coalition agreement with what Harper was discussing back in 2005 is completely different, and I surprised no one has bothered to explain this. If, say, two years from now, it was discovered that Harper's government had secretly squandered $100 million (like what happened in the sponsorship scandal), and was refusing to face the electorate, then an argument could be made that his government had lost the moral authority to maintain power. But six weeks after an election, a egghead like Dion who was soundly rejected by the electorate and about to be sacrificed by his own party has the gall to act as though he has a mandate to become prime minister? Insane.

And to all those people who suggest that there is nothing unusual about coalitions in other countries, get real. And besides, the coalitions almost always involve the party that one the highest number of votes.

To top it all off, the Liberals expect Canadians to let a small number of idiots select Dion's replacement as though voters don't deserve a say in that either.


dulak
said

Anthony Carlucci

Take your 7 million and divide amongst 3 parties and see what number you end up with. Only 4 time since 1921 has a government received 50% or more of the popular vote, so, all of those other time there should've been a coalition government, right?


Arthur
said

Michael,
We, the majority of canadians voted against Mr.Harper. And the rules are easy, who has the majority has to form a goverment. In politics, is famous the tale "Divide and conquer..." Mr. Harper did the opposite, he forced all opposition to unite and is his time to loose.

And about the Bloc.... Finally they won't be able to criticize the goverment since they are part of it....

Harper looked like Winnie the Phoo provoking the bees hive....ha ha ha ha ha .


Colin
said

It is funny that the news media are saying that Harper runs the risk of alienating Quebec, what about Dion and Layton alienating the West, or do we not matter. Does the West have to form a Sepratist Party in order to be heard.


Alan - Chelsea, QC
said

Harper has further poven his ability to stay calm and stable under a difficult situation. Solid as a rock. Something I believe is required at this time.
His speech was organized and to the point... he's not going to fold to a group of selfish power seekers.
I only hope there's an ear in our system to let the voice of Canada be heard. It was,and now more so, obviously clear what the majority of Canadians want.

Leon
said

Mr. Harper, arrogance and vengeance has no place in politics.Instead of stimulating the economy you'd rather attack your rivals by cutting allowances.Attack. Attack. Attack is your only weapon. Now, who's frying himself in his own oil?


Tiffany and Scott Cooper, Kitchener, ON
said

Give the coalition a chance. We may not agree with all the parties involved, but they are certainly more representative of Canada as a whole than the minority Conservative government.

The Bloc are not evil, and have some worthwhile policies when one considers that they will not divide the country due to this coalition.

This situation is indicative of a need to develop proportional representation in this country: parties must learn to function in a minority state as the rule, not the exception.


Who all is in this coalition??
said

To quote Mr. Dion: "The Green Party has also agreed to support it."

How did they get in there? The Green party has elected a single MP and as far as I know, we haven't switched to proportional representation yet.

I find Bloc support offensive because they (the Bloc) are a regional interest party who didn't run candidates outside Quebec. Their vision and objectives are not national in scope so they should in no way be the critical supporting element of a national government.


Danielle Rousseau
said

As a Canadian I am appalled that Prime Minister Stephen Harper is more concerned with Liberal, NDP and Bloc coalition rather then figuring out ways to deal with the Canadian economy. This coalition issue is a direct result of Stephen Harper trying to make sure that the Conservatives are re-elected with a majority government. Shame on you Stephen Harper for putting your needs above Canadians.


Lech Ozimek
said

It takes to be a politician to write one thing and do the other one, but what Mr. Dion has said it takes a politition without any face.

Lech Ozimek
Edmonton


Tom Andrus
said

I for one would be glad to see the back of Stephen Harper's dictatorship. I am sure if there was trouble in the Tar Sands that he would give billions to the oil giants.They don't care about the jobs lost in the auto industry.



Cara
said

WE CANADIANS VOTED AND LIKE IT OR NOTE THIS IS OUR VOICE THAT IS SPEAKING! Let's not forget that it was Mr Harper's lame ideological and partisan pre budget that has resulted in the current situation and has a coalition of opposition responding to it with a united voice of non-confidence. Let us not forget, we did not as a country vote in a majority government. If we had, Mr Harper would have no problem doing or not doing anything he likes. Our voice, all of it, is speaking in this historic debate and I for one wonder if a coalition might not be a good thing for Canada. Mr Harper had his chance to deliver the goods and he didn't do it. Let's give the other side of our minority government a try


Karen Keating
said

I am so excited by the prospect of a coalition government because it will be so much more representative of the Canadian people. Just think, those in power will having the backing of a large majority of voters and consensus will have to be forged amid the conflicting ideologies. What a special and unique opportunity we have been given.


Paul (Durham)
said

We fight around the world to ensure other countries, can elect their own governments. Here we are, embarrassing ourselves on a world stage, the thought that this so called coalition, is even being considered, is treason. This is nothing but a power grab by parties that are scared of losing government funding for their campaigning, which shouldn't be allowed in the first place.

Steve in PEI
said

The coalition cannot take power soon enough to suit me. Stephen Harper and the Conservatives, by creating this crisis through sheer partisan, vicious-minded pettiness and bullying have shown they are not fit to govern. They have lost the confidence of Parliament and under our constitutional arrangement the opposition has a right to attempt to form a government with the confidence of the house if the Governor General agrees.

Let me tell you: I voted too, and I like the coalition just fine.

And let it be said that people in Quebec voted democratically, fair and square for the Bloc. Believe it or not, Quebecers pay taxes and it is their tax dollars going to support a party they voted for. Whether we like it or not, for good historical reasons separatism is considered a valid political opinion in Quebec, even by many who don't agree with it. Harper's rhetoric making separatists into a devil to whip core supporters into a frenzy is getting reported in the francophone media. All of the work to make the Conservatives the new federalist alternative in Quebec is being undone and the separatists are getting a huge boost.

Harper is what he accuses his rival of being - ruthlessly power hungry and willing to do any damage to anything to gain and keep power. Canada and the Conservative party need him out.


Carol Money
said

I am disgusted with the antics of Layton & Dion and their cavalier attitude towards the Canadian taxpayer. What is their problem? That they are not getting their $1.95 per vote!!!! That is their respect for the ordinary taxpayer!
I also feel that the press is being unduly critical of Harper & the Conservatives.
It seems that the press is slanted towards the Coalition. Are they in a feeding frenzy? The reporting is definately slanted.
Call a spade a spade press.
We had an election a short time ago at a huge cost. The people said that Harper was the person to lead during this economic crisis. When I see the antics of the Liberals & NDP it makes me upset that they are so self serving. The Bloc? Well, of course, anything they can do to destablize Canada works in their favour. Way to go Liberals & NDP. Make Canada the laughing stock of the world.


Fernando
said

It is my view that after the smoke clears, there will be so much resentment towards the LIB/NDP coalition that Mr. Harper will have the majority of public support he wanted all along. Very astute planning.


Foli Gladza
said

Mr. Harper is not an honest man and a bully. He is more power hungry than any of those other guys.
If anything Mr. Dion to me has been a coward for too long.
I vividly remember when Harper wanted to form an aligns with the bloc to topple Mr. Paul Martin.
Mr. Harper passes a legislation to prevent calling of an early election but he just did that because he thought he would win a majority. Where is the surplus left by the former liberal party? Is politics as usual you deserve what you are going to get from the three “amingos’, good luck.



Aford
said

All of you posters out there who are quibbling about democratic rules in favor of a coalition know full well that Canadian voters would have never supported an unholy agreement with the separatists, if this were publicly stated during the October election.

Dion & Layton lost that election, each by a wide margin. Now they are attempting to use parliamentary rules (never intended for the benefit of separatists) to gain power that they could not achieve thru free & fair elections only weeks ago. Then why shouldn't Harper similarly use whatever parliamentary rules available to prevent them from doing so?



m j d
said

Jeff From the Stock, It's simple. Read the history of your country. We are based on the British Parliamentary system that allows this. And yes the GG has the power to do just that. steven harpers arrogance knows no bounds. That's why we are where we are now.


B. Kennedy
said

Dion is pitiful. And the 'coalition' is a match made in hell. They're trying to grab power for power's sake - they don't give a hoot about what's good for Canada. They don't know what's good for Canada, but they sure know what's good for them! It's disgusting!


Anthony Carlucci
said

According to elections canada's website, 5,205,334 people voted for the conservatives. A total of 7,526,630 people voted for Liberal, Bloc and NDP combined. That means that a coalition government would actually represent the majority of people who voted. Most people who voted in October 2008 did NOT want Harper in power.


Rhea
said

Let me reiterate. Harper has lost the confidence of The House of Commons, due to his own arrogant assumption, that he could push forth his greedy agenda of power over the other parties, then do a 180, when they stood up to him. Let me reiterate. Harper has/is creating divisiveness across this land, pitting the east against the west, the north to the south. We need a new prime minister, who is a visionary without prejudiced views or lack of altruism, capable of simply saying, "we are one, we agree to make Confederation work".Harper's short speech this evening, defined and underlined, he has no concept of what matters most.




Bob Syeruncle
said

I hope I'm not the only one that noticed Dion's video summed up his his rant in two words.

In the top left of the picture, on the bookshelf, is a book that said it all for him. The title: HOT AIR (!)

If we could read all the titles I suspect we would find a well thumbed copy of: Hijackers Guide to The Government.

Or maybe he's saving that title for his memoirs?


Ed in AZ
said

Well, well conversations in coffEe shops and at work are not on the weather or on our national sport of hockey. What a change with all the political confusion and conflict. I plan to continue sleeping well and live normal. All this is like a bad head ache that always ends. Hope the country stays as Canada in the past.


Brenda Krawczyk
said

My opinion is they should form a coalition government as in a democracy they do represent 62% of the Canadian people. As for Dion Leading I disagree. What we have representing us now, is a power hungry unexperienced government who does not have the knowledge to deal with the state of are economy. By running televised ads it is the conservative way of using the power of suggestion to sway all the nitwits in this country into believing he is right. Your all being brainwashed snap! snap! wakeup. I myself have voted for every party in this country atleast once, except the PQ and that is only because i don't live in there province. But they are a part of Canada and in a democracy they have the right to vote the way the chose and we have to respect there vote just like they have to respect each and everyone of our votes. What I have been seeing from this government is that they are so into themselves they have completely overlooked the recession in this country and I ask myself everyday if they represent less than 50% of the people in this country what are they doing trying to lead this country and why are they more concerned with giving big corporation tax breaks than they are helping the very people that voted for them. Yes we remember the sponsorship scandal, but we also remember the Airbus Scandal oh sorry I forgot they pulled the wool over your eyes and sued you lol. Only to find addition to the story many years later. We also remember the 1980 when greed took over need and Heed shut the province of Alberta down and tried to blame it on the feds. energy program. Lovely, who suffered?


Recent Former Liberal
said

This economic crisis is not the doings of Stephen Harper, or of the Conservative Party or of Canada as a Country. It is worldwide and no one individual person, political party, or country can fix it.
I would suggest for what it matters to the coalition, that at this time , you are not doing your country any favours by attempting to overthrow your democratically elected government.


deb
said

In parliamentary democracy, all elected members form the government - a fact seemingly invisible to the Harper government. Starting with years of taxpayer funded Harper propaganda, and ending with the recent attempt to hamstring his political enemies, Harper rarely makes a move that is not for his benefit alone. The intelligent governance of Canada just isn't very high on his list. More power to the coalition I say - their actions could be our only real chance for responsible government.


Carol Wilker
said

Another election would strain the economy even further. Mr. Harper won fair and square. The other parties fail to recognize this and it seems a case of sour grapes. I believe in Stephen Harper to make the right choices and I believe Canadians do so too as eveidenced in our recent election. A coalition government appears to be a back-door approach to gaining power and not what the majority of Canadians find acceptable.



Ian Ottawa
said

The Bloc are traitor's to Canada and have "NO" rights in Canada. My Canada does not include Seperatists.


BP
said

1: To those that say it is a illegal attempt to rule, we have a parliamentary system it is allowed constitutionally. It is a fact of Parliamentary rule that the more party's you have the more likely coalitions rule will the country just look at Italy and Israel.

2: To those that say the Conservatives represent the majority of Canadians try again, they represent less Canadians then the Combined votes for the coalition.


Malcolm McRae from Smiths Falls, Ont
said

After listening to Harpers Four and a half minute speech. In which he once again has done nothing to try to solve this problem except to blame others for his arrogance. He does give a perfect example of why we should switch from a first-past-the-post to a Proportional Reppresentationn electoral system. Thanks Steve at least you did something right in three and a half years

TED
said

The percentage don't mean crap, Mr Harper got enough votes to give him more seats than the last election, sure he has made some bad mistakes, there is nobody on the face of the earth pefect.The coalition will bail out a company that has been operating for 100 years! with tax payers hard earned dollars,and they need more help? Harper wants to see a plan first.Dion is not a leader,and Duceppe will make sure Quebec gets the biggest slice, he shouldn't even have a say he is a head strong separatist, but he is smarter than the other two,I think Harper will come out of this a better leader if given a chance,they have to try and work to-gether instead of just haveing a shouting match,and leave Harper at the helm


JohnSchmuck
said

The Conservatives won 144 seats and the Liberals/NDP won about 30 less. So how can this new "coalition" lay claim to a right to govern ?
The Governor General should allow the recessing of the House to facilitate a cooling down period. Then the Tories should put forward a new budget that can be voted on in the House.
Harper does have to rein in his "mean side". Leadership does include "leading" to a consensus.


Mike from Saskatoon
said

Okay just so you all know you do not vote for a government or a party. You vote for 1 person out of 308. The only people who voted for Harper live in Calgary the rest of you couldn't have because he was not on your ballot. We each voted for 1 of 308 people so they could decided how best to represent your views. If it is their view that Harper shouldn't be PM and that insted a gopher becomes PM (they don't even have to be elected... welcome to canada) then a GOPHER becomes PM.

To the uniformed masses our there that talk about how this is against our system please learn how it works before making these comments. You waste my time and your time by acting like you know how our system works. Now let me say that this system should work different but for now atleast it doesn't.

Oh and for the record a gopher cannot become PM for a few reasons... has to be 18 a canadian citizen and be able to take the required Oaths. But the fact that the gopher is not human does not matter (which was the meat of my point).


Jean Pierre from Quebec
said

Separatist Coalition ?

May I remind to all my fellow canadian brothers that Quebec voted to stay with the Canada? The fact that we voted for the Bloc Quebecois was for the same reason you voted for the Liberals or the Conservatives: You voted for the party who represent you the best in Ottawa. Even though the Bloc is based on a "separatist" ideology, they are working in Ottawa to defend our rights, the same as the Liberals and the Conservative representatives do for their regions. I am Canadian as much as you, my vote has the same value as yours. Stephen Harper failed to achieve majority, he was pompeous and arrogant. He made the mistake of underestimate the opposition who goes back to the ABC : Anything But Conservative. They prefer to make a coalition than to work with S. Harper. At the end, he can only blame himself for failing twice..



Dave B. in London ON
said

If you want a better government then go with what was elected 2 months ago. Otherwise we will truly become a Banana Republic with snowflakes! The 3 Stooges are not the answer.


Robert
said

If Stephen Harper was more concilliatory, like John McCain who wanted to reach across the aisle to other members we would not be in this mess. Apart from the who is right in this politically challenging times, Mr. Harper's mean spiritedness is getting him into trouble. The conservatives need a leader, a statesman, who strives for the greater good and not scoring political points by demeaning his opponents


S. W.
said

Why do we all have short memories? People are saying Harper is arrogant, does what he wishes. Does anyone not remember that the Libs wasted millions of our dollars on AdScam and other questionable areas and felt they didn't have to explain themselves to us. That was under a "primadonna", Jean Chretien. All I have seen is Harper try to cut taxes and so on so we can keep OUR money. He introduced the first of what was many cuts by cutting party contributions. Is that not responsible? To start at the top? No one has even given him a chance in these tough economic times, especially the other parties.
Jack Layton said the Canadian people want Harper gone......funny thing, have any Canadians been asked? I don't see the coalition representing the voters, just themselves. Is this the time to have so much inexperience run our country? And of course they may place a politician who was soundly defeated into the senate and then give her a cabinet position.
I think Stephane, Jack, Gilles and Elizabeth are more concerned about their investment portfolios than Canadians as a whole.
Now is not the time to panic, let the PM do his job.


Daniel
said

I want Harper running the show as 37% of Canadians asked him to!

How DARE a majority of MPs, representing parties receiving a mere 63% of the vote, exercise their constitutional right to suggest that a different government could be formed?

How undemocratic! The Conservative minority MUST rule. That is how the system works, isn't it?


Terry in Halifax
said

I didn't vote for Stephen Harper, however I was against a coalition....until watching Harper's address to the nation!
Nothing has changed! He didn't mention the dire situation of the economy! Penions, life savings lost, along with jobs! He had the chance to work with the opposition, but instead acted with his own party policies rather than address our pending recession!


Derrick Allen Cambridge Ont
said

I wish that the Canadian people would wake up and realize that they need to do something other then sit on their buts and complain when they should have gone out and voted. I work hard for my money as I'm sure that all people do. And I'm sorry to say I won't be buying a new car this year. So why should my tax dollars go towards that? If I loose my job I know for a fact that no tax dollars will be put into saving my job. This is a free market economy and business either do well or sink. Sure the auto industry is big...But what about the rest of us? I trust Mr Harper.. Better him then the other two parties who will spend my tax dollars like a drunken sailor on shore leave. As far as the Quebec issue goes.. Haven't we all heard enough already... Like come on how much more can one province dictate to the other ones? If I had wanted anyone else to be the P.M. I would have voted for them.. Now people either get this worked out or lets go back to the polls and elect a Tory Majordty so at least they can do the right job for our country


Dubmonton
said

Stephane Dion actually cares about Canadians. This man should be leading us into the new year, because the 20% of the country who believe that Stephen Harper deserves to be prime minister should realize that the majority of the MP's in the House of Commons are NOT Conservatives. Why do the rich and the wealthy believe they know better than the rest of us?


Peter
said

All you people saying that 62% of you didn't vote for Harper are full of it and you know it. And naturally you don't want to mention that the last time there was need for a coalition government was 1917.
Truth is you just figure you've found a way to not lose an election if you don't want to.
And one more way to tell West they don't matter.
Well get ready for a lot of this. Any time the opposition wants to get their way get ready to see them cozy up to Quebec for another backroom "Coalition plan". If it worked for you it'll work for us.

Did you notice that? "You" and "Us"? That's what happens when cut us out and steal our money. Every GTA and Ontario poster on this board can't wait to get on here and call Westerners bigots -- which is ironically bigoted. Yep. Just keep telling us we don’t matter. Thousands of you every day move out here for work and change your tune quick.

The West ought to take a lesson from Quebec and get over our queziness about separation because apparently all you have to do is be half serious about it to get your way in this country. I've worked for and lived in Canada all my life and I've never been represented in Ottawa once.

Peter in Edmonton


Chris from Ontario
said

To use a hockey analogy here, I feel like 2 guys from the opposite team just jumped the boards and tried to goon me while I was on a breakaway after skating through their team!! It is a desperate "bush league" move after all the possible options and tactics have been exhausted. Kick the coalition off the ice!


Susan
said

There is a song, "which of these things is not like the other one" there is one obvious person who stands apart from the coalition, let him do his job, I can't believe any of the others would even be a consideration. Seriously!!


Dan
said

remember only 52% of canada voted this time it cost 310 million dollers so if the other 48% voted do you really think harper would be in power NO that's why they didn't vote cause people are fed up with the goverment cause they will still do what they want harper has done nothing as PM I still get taxed like crazy to support people on walfare canada needs a change ...wake up canada i support NDP - Liberal coalition


Rob from YVR
said

Harper's whining plea to the nation to keep his job doesn't change the fact that his anti-democratic arrogance landed us in this mess! With just over 1/3 of the popular vote he felt he could run roughshod over the Canadian people. Do the right thing Mr Harper and resign!


td
said

Why was this coalition not announced during the last election. The coalition between the Liberals and Green Party was made public. (She lost!)
I suspect if this coalition which, according to Layton, was in the works for months had been made public prior to the election things would be very different today.

Back room deals are never good. What deals were made for the support of the Bloc?
Just how much am I going to have to pay for politicians back room deals?


McCallum, Ontario
said

It's time for Canada to watch old episodes of, Curly, Larry & Moe!!


Paul - London Ontario
said

We had an election. Canadians spoke.

All of the parties need to work together to manage this Country. Collectively, they represent Canada.

We do not need a new coalition government to do so.

Precious time, money, resources and the credibility of our Nation are being wasted - at a time when the rest of the world should be (and had been) looking to Canada as an example of stability and prudent fiscal policy in a volatile environment.




melanie in calgary
said

Stephen Harpers conservatives were not returned to govern with a majority, not a majority of seats nor of the popular vote.
The joining of the 3 opposition parties represent the actual will of the majority of voters in the last election. Working together to collaborate to support our country through this crisis.
Postponing confidence votes in the house because you stand to lose them is not democratic. It more resembles the tantruming 2 year old running of to their room and slamming the door. Come out Mr Harper and face the facts. Progressive European nations work with coalition governments all the time. Look at how well their public institutions work. Leaps and bounds beyond ours.
I whole heartedly support this coalition!


Jim
said

What happened to Stephane Dion? The coalition is embarrassing: an amateurish "floating head" Dion that looked like it was filmed on my old super 8 movie camera, delivered after the major networks had gone back to there regular broadcasting. This would be funny if the TSX and Canadian dollar weren't getting the daily snot kicked out of them.


Gord
said

I think Harper is doing a great job, You just can't dish out large amounts on money at a problem and expect it to fix it self. The stimulous pack will come when they feel comfortable with all the facts and figures,and know that it will work and not just create more debt.

Dion is not fit to run our country look at what he did to the Liberal party. He also did say he was stepping down as leader did he not?

The Bloc is only in this for Quebec and does not care about any other part of Canada. Is that who you want holding the balance of power?

If they think Conservatives are not doing the job we elected them to do,lets go back to the polls.

Steven
said

What do you want for Canada Tomorrow? Uncertainty until late January, or action now?

I think it all depends on if you are worried about feeding your family now or in January.

Harper is worried about feeding his now. His reasons are selfish, the coalition's are for us, Canadians.


Bruce Starkey
said

Well, I guess it was just a matter of time. We have endured and even encouraged a party within our political structure who'se avowed mandate is succession from Canada. Now we take the final step and reduce ourselves to the stature of a bannana republic with the only thing missing the oft seen punch-ups during sessions of some laughable parliaments. what did we as Canadians do to deserve this bloodless coup.


Brian from Newmarket
said

I now know where Stephane Dion gets the text for his speeches.During his televised address, in the upper left hand corner of his bookshelf is a book called "Hot Air".
More seriously, how can we believe he could possibly save us from our Economic woes when he himself is deeply in debt to the Liberal Party, and the Liberal party has it's own financial issues????


Jean Pierre from Quebec
said

The law is the law.. Constitution is clear. Instead of protecting Stephen Harper, people should think that he failed twice. He failed to achieve majority and he failed miserably to maintain Democracy. He has been provocative to the other parties and now he got was he asked for. A minority government rules are based on the facts that he hasn't reach majority. Not so long ago, the Tories were a coalition of Greens and Blue. Coalition exists for centuries, nothing new. This one is a good lesson to Stephen Harper: he thought we was wiser than he is, he created this pan Canadian conflict.


Grace
said

Harper has been playing politics since the first day he was in politics until tonight. No any integrity. He would do anything to fight for power even at the cost of the interests of all canadians. The biggest bully in Canada. For the goodness of Canada and canadians, Harper, RESIGN!!!


Dr J in SK
said

My god, I can't believe people think that Dion should be PM...he's SO embarassing...


Peter Hardyt
said

This whole thing is turning into a three ring circus with the "proposed and self imposed" coalition the ring leader. Any wonder there is low voter turnout in Canada. After someone is elected by the PEOPLE, the opposition can just take control. They must think we are stupid!


Barb
said

Stephen Harper had the perfect opportunity to act in a responsible non-partisan manner and even convince non-conservatives that he was the man for the job. He blew it! Bring on the Coalition and let's see how our government can work cooperatively - (for the benefit of the majority of Canadians).


Danny
said

As I sit here and read about what is going on with my country, I begin to wonder what this world is coming too. Stephen Harper not only won the election but brutally defeated his opponents. Mr Dion's latest attempt to gain power only proves that he is a snake and a poor leader. If the coalition government takes power, what does that show Canadians? What will the rest of the world think? It will show that Canada is an unstable country and nobody will want trade, deal or work with a group that strong armed our current government only to finally have power and control over our country. The NDP, BLOC and liberals were defeated and defeated badly in the last election. I think this is what we call a Political Coup!!!!!! So with that being said, since I didn't vote for this so called coalition party, do I have to continue to pay taxes???? Why should I pay taxes to a party that took power by force??? I really hope that this coalition government realizes the implications of their actions. I do not and will not support this coalition government. I hope the GG makes the right decision. The fate of Canada's future and history rests on her shoulders.


Rhonda
said

We the Canadian people voted in the Conservative party.
We DO NOT WANT STEPHAN DION, JACK LAYTON AND MOST CERTAINLY NOT A SEPERATIST PARTY in control.
I am appauled at this action of the opposition parties and at this moment in time embarrassed to be Canadian not to mention ASHAMED that Stephane Dion, Jack Layton and whathisface(not worth mentioning) are Canadian!
Governor General, please respect the Canadian people.
NO TO A COALITION GOVT!!!

Bruce in Ontario
said

ABC - Anything But Coalition!!


cantuc
said

LMAO dion talk about Harper accepting the votes result with grace ? Uum didn't we just have a vote in the election in which dion was defeated ? Does anybody remember the little mans tantrum on election night ?


Manitoban
said

Recap:

Harper issued an ideological fiscal statement. Harper claims that scrapping woman's rights are good for the country. Harper claims Liberals and NDP are forming coalition with Bloc. We find out Harper tried to form a coalition with the Bloc, as did Stockwell Day. Do I hear hypocrisy spewing from Harper mouth...absolutely.

Go Coalition; Harper's petty, provocative, ideological, partisan, discriminatory method of governing may finally be over!


Iain
said

STOP, Look and Listen....it is not the Liberals or the N.D.P. that will topple the Government it will be the BLOCK because neither of the two parties can do it alone .. So the Quebec Seperatist will topple the Government and they will get the most for doing it..How Sad for Canada


Peter
said

MR Dion and Mr Layton must recall that the Canadian people VOTED in the Conservatives and not them. To try and seize power would make Canada no better than any other country who has had a coup - the only differnce is that Mr Dion and Mr Layton are not wielding guns they are wielding Quebec.
Stop this Coalition talk - please. Just do the jobs we as Canadians have asked you to do in the way we have asked you to do it.


Karla Joyce
said

Are you kidding me??? It amazes me how people eat up the garbage that Harper dishes up!

The coalition is very much the proper response - in keeping with our constitution.

Harper and his conservatives do not speak for the majority of the voters! Finally under a coalition we can have a government that actually represents what most of us want!!!

The blind following of Harper is astounding!!!


Dave I
said

I am really mad at Harper right now. It is perfectly democratic for a majority opposition to take over the house with a coalition if they can coordinate it. For him to imply that it is not democratic is a complete lie.
The Prime Minister of Canada of all people should understand how our system of parliament works. It looks like he is deliberately misleading Canadians about the legality of the Official Opposition's actions in order to further his war against the Liberals. Shame on him!


Helene in Canmore
said

The coalition is proposing a better team of economic experts to navigate us through this economic storm than what Harper has to offer. The Conservatives' bullying style evident in this week's PR campaign is as immature as it is scared.


Judith Allen
said

Mr. Harper speaks like a man who knows what to do. A man I for one am proud of when he speaks for Canada. Mr. Dion talks but says the same thing over and over without ever giving any real details of what exactly he would do in the same position. Six weeks ago the Canadian People voted for the Conservatives to do a job, and the opposition has thrown everything they can at Mr Harper to keep him from doing it. Enough, if the coalition wants to lead the country lets go back to the polls, and they can run as one party. If they are so sure they have the support of the people, they shouldn't be so afraid of this option.


Nick
said

It does not matter that Harper was elected in 7 weeks ago. The reason he called an election was because house of commons was to dysfunctional. Is it anymore functional now? The coalition only has support of the bloc, no bloc will have a seat on the cabinet if the coalition is approved.

The vote show happen next week, closing parliament to delay a non-confidence vote has never been done in Canadian history. Harper messed up, and is scurrying to survive.

And lets not forget his party agreed to form a coalition with the bloc in the 2000 election...


G. Robinson
said

The majority of voters voted for the other three parties. The coalition is the most democratic expression of the voters' wishes possible.

Harper is using Republican tactics - trying to divide Canadians by raising the spectre of 'separatists'. Shame on him. Again, shame, for his plan to dodge the will of Parliament by proroguing before the vote of non-confidence. I sincerely hope that Governor General Jean refuses his anti-democratic request.

Harper is acting in his interest rather than that of Canada. He disgusts me. The sooner he relinquishes power, the better for our country.


Steven
said

Prime Minister Harper must resign... he's working for his party only, not all Canadians, why wait to offer the Canadian people a stimulas package when the rest of the g-20 and world are in the midst of the worst global meltdown of the markets and economy since the depression? We must act now, waiting is unacceptable we must act in a pro-active fashion... As a canadian I feel democracy should prevail always, the coalition should not simply be placed in power without a vote by US Canadians ... thus a non- confidence vote is necessary now.... Hopefully the Governor General will allow all Canadians to voice their say....


Frank MONTREAL
said

Hello,
Fellow Canadians from west to east coast, remember that Mr. Harper won a minority election which means that the majority of the voters did not want him as PM, the only reason he is PM and was PM is that our country enjoys the privelege of having more than two electoral parties to choose from.. So our constitution allows us in a minority to govern in a rightfull manner to serve the best interest of all Canadians. So fellow Canadians have someone address this economic crisis as fast as possible . Even if it means entrusting the responsability to the coalition. any action is better than no action at all.

Stop feuding about the separitist there are no separatists, we are all Canadians first Bloc Liberals NDP and Green...

P.S. i was one of the many that did not vote in the last election because you see it makes no difference.


Eileen McRae
said

And how much different is what Mr. Dion proposes for the Canadian economy than what Mr. Harper already is doing? Mr. Dion's speech echoes Mr. Harper's! The only difference is Mr. Harper is trying to avoid putting Canada into a deficit position - he is being prudent in waiting for the new American government to take office. When Canadians voted, the ballot listed the party to which the candidate was affiliated. Nowhere on the ballot did I see "Coalition of the Libs/Dibs/and Bloc". When I marked my X it was not only the candidate, but, also the party. This is why so many Canadians feel betrayed by the actions of these three political parties. And it is this sense of betrayal that the Governor General needs to address. It is a betrayal to all those Canadians who did vote. In the next election, let these three parties run only one candidate against the Conservative candidate - a candidate of the coalition. You can make any numbers say what you want them to say, and you can say that this is the way that a parliamentary system is supposed to work, but none of this rhetoric will work to assuage the voters' sense of betrayal. And THAT is what is making so many angry.


jake
said

Who cares Canada is in a pickle either way.Politicians don't care about us little,honest and hardworking people,every politican only cares for his own gains which is power and money. Meanwhile us poor people are strugling to make ends meat while they can't decide anything and have these silly debates, seriously they need to start doing something for the people of Canada. On another note I say who cares let Quebec separate itself from the rest of Canada, this way we will have all that money left over we pay for them and let's re-invest that money into our economy.


Ken Sholdice, Souris. Mb
said

I am not really sure as to what Dion and Layton expect to do to stimulate the economy. How can what they say possibly do this, as this is a world wide problem and we all will weather the storm. How can building efficient public transit systems, create good well paid jobs or even the manufacturing industry help anything? They have to remember that we, all the people have to be able to purchase items to get the economy back on track. They can produce and produce and hire people they don't need, but will that make me buy something that I still can not afford, no. The coalition wants to give away to much money and be irresponsible in their actions to try and fix things in a couple of days, but what about the years to come when Canada is so far in debt we don't know which way to turn. Canada voted and the coalition lost fair and square, so Harper ,ho;d your head high and Canada will stand behind you, as for the coalition, hold your head in shame for what you are doing, and see what happens in the next election


Marg in Calgary
said

Did the ones who are for the Coalition not hear Duceppe? He said (and I quote) - "This will be good Quebec"

Not Canada - Quebec. This guy shouldn't even be allowed a say. He doesn't even have the interest of the Canadian people in mind at all, only his separatist agenda. What a joke!


C VU
said

If anyone out there felt against the coalion, you would NOT UNDERSTAND Canadian politics and how our political system should work at all

Please do not throw insults and just go back to Politics 101.

This so-called crisis must end with the coalition in power.

If GG decided otherwise, shame on her and she should take the course Politics 101 too...

Mike Wynn
said

I think if this were a few years ago and Harper had the opportunity to form a coalition he would have. I don't like the idea of Dion being prime minister, but I like it better than having a bully as one.


Joy Williams
said

I have just finished watching the speeches from Harper and Dion on CTV and the subsequent analysis. I also saw Jim Flaherty give a well thought out plan that the Conservatives have under way that shows they do have a well thought out stimules plan for this country.
It is time for all of us to step back and let rational thought not emotion rule us.
Whether you are a Conservative. Liberal of NDP supporter, never should the Bloc hold a veto power and be the definitive voice for what will and will not happen in our country and economy.
I respect Gilles Duceppe because he is totally up front and honest that all his decisions are based on what is best for Quebec....not Canada....Quebec, but he doesn't lie about it. what on earth is wrong with Layton and Dion that they give this man veto power over all decisions affecting "the rest of Canada" and they do not have the courgae to tell it like it is. I believe they do not give the people of Canada enough credit....we are smart enough to see through the game they are playing....personal power at all costs to fill the Senate, implement programs no one wants and that we can't afford now.
Beware of people who promise everyone that all their troubles will be gone with this coalition....I very much fear our problems are just beginning if this unholy alliance goes through.


Tara - Toronto
said

Overall both speeches were disappointing...

Harper's speech was too short, too much of an appeal to our anger and didn't address crucial econonmic matters. Whereas, Dion's speech was too pat, to full of the "coorperating spirit", looking to appeal to people from rural Bc to Toronto. It was well written but no real contained no real economic details.

One political analyst mentioned the reason why Harper would want to delay the budget till Jan 27 and that was too ensure our economic plan coordinated with Obama in the US. This makes sense! Consequently, what I need to know as a Canadian are the reason Dion feels our econonmy can't wait and needs econonmic stimilus now (even though Canada is the best off economically among the G7 nations. Whereas Harper needed to explain his strategy and econmic thinking.

Very disappointing the country is in policitcal and economic crisis and our leaders our treating Canadians emotional children.

This is one Canadian that is tired of the attempts at emotional manipulation and feel it is time we as Canadians be respected by our elected representatives!


Mike from the left coast
said

Sit down Stephane for PM? I don't think so. It seems to me that Dion already had many chances during the last session to provide an alternative and he chose not to. Dion doesn't even have the confidence of his own party not to mention parliament. And what was with that homemade video of his?


bcdarr
said

Just another thought here. If the conservatives are so concerned about the Bloc having a say, they can work with the new coalition government at the time to ensure that doesn't happen. Surely they'll want to work with the government for the sake of Canada like they think everyone else should do while THEY'RE the government. Or are they so petty that they'd let the Block control what happens so they can mope?


Jason Mowbray
said

This is ridiculous. I voted for the conservative party as many other Candadians did. How democratic is this? The Coalition parties were not voted in by Canada, and I don't think they should be allowed to all band together just so they have more seats than the elected party. Our country has enough problems without having a sepertist party, the NDP, and Stephen Dionne who only weeks ago was set to resign as even his own party didn't want him. If it's going to come down to this then I hope the Govenor General at least has enough sense to call an election so the Canadian people can decide. If then the Coalition is voted in then at least it is democratic and the choice of the people of Canada. Give your head a shake Coalition, this is a bad deal !!! Jason Mowbray, Abbotsford, BC


A Comment
said

The concern about the coalition is not a concern about Quebec...not at all. The concern is about furthering the agenda of separatism. Both the BQ and the PQ have boasted about this.


Wayne
said

Please hear my heart I see the coalition members expressing financial reasons for wanting to form a government to replace the elected government of a few weeks as expressed by the Canadain Public and my heart strongly feels it is an issue of social agendas and not financial postering.

Please consider the hearts of Canadians who elected the recent government as their vote of convidence of a strong minority in Mr. Harper and the Tories

May I ask this question please; shall the will of of millions of Canadians be overturned by the will of a few politicians who have for weeks plotted their hidden agenda behind closed doors and have just recently expressed their stratigically deceptively based reasoning to the Canadian public and to the media and soon to the house of parliment ?

Any Coalition that includes a seperatist party whose sole reason for existing is to break up our country, along with their ideology they bring the spirit of seperation and division, I ask you how can unity come from a source of division.

And please do not say I am Quebec bashing I was born in Quebec and still to this day remain in Quebec, it is sepertists I do not like, not Quebecers who are part of my family.



yi wang
said

According to Election Canada 2008, 37.6% of Canadians voted for CON, 26.2% for LiB, 18.2% for NDP, 10% for BQ, and 6.8% for GRN. Even without the support from BQ, the anti-Harper coalition is still supported by over half of the Canadians (51.2%).

Tony Basciano
said

TONY from TO.

The people of Canada have already voted to have Harper & the Conservative party to govern Canada.Backroom deals to gain power should never be allowed in a democratic country.This has nothing to do with the economy just greed for power at the expense of Canadian voters. Just a couple of weeks ago Dion's own Liberal party said he wasn't qualified to lead their party to victory.Now they are saying he should be PM. of Canada.A complete about face.Can you imagine Canada been ruled by Liberal party,a socialist party & a Separtist party.We as Canadians cannot let this happen.The entire world must be in shock as to what is happening.I DO believe DEMOCRACY will prevail.Go Canada Go.


Bill from Kingston
said

I'm looking at this affair as a poorly timed power grab, as opposed to a legitimate alternative coalition government. It's easy to slip into the knee jerk reaction mode when dealing with an economic catastrophe of the magnitude we're seeing, however the current measured approach has placed us in a much better position than many countries. I'd actually prefer, at this time, that a reserved approach with well thought out actions be taken... we have yet to see what the impact of presidential change in the states will bring, and this is an important event that will impact our economy. I'd prefer not to get too far out ahead of the elephant at this point, better to follow, and react when we see it drifting off the wrong way.


Wally and Diane Rawn
said

We listened to both the Prime Minister and Dion's speeches tonight. We considered the comments after the P.M.'s address to be totally negative. Perhaps they weren't intended to be but that's how it appeared. Yes, his speech was short but to the point! He is trying to defend democracy because the people of Canada voted as always encouraged to do so and assert their rights to choose our government! We do so and a month or so later the leaders, none of whom were chosen to lead the government, decide it is in the best interest of the people to form a coalition government, or coup as we see it. They feel they can do more for Canada and throw out "we will do this and that etc.etc. Why can they not wait until the budget is released to then see what the Prime Minister proposes to help the economy and other concerns.Why the big rush when parliament will break for their winter break soon anyway. Prime Minister Harper has led the country and performed his duties quite well and he will lead again in his way and his timing. He was speaking directly to the people to inform us of how he saw this attempted coalition, and how he believed he had to meet it aggressively. He spoke of his budget to be released in January and some of the issues it will cover. Mr. Dion was repetative trying to justify why he went into this coalition with the support of the Quebecois. As far as we're concerned it is purely a grab for power of leaders who lost in the election the mandate of the people of Canada.


S. Cox, White Rock.
said

Lets not give up on the Conservatives before they present their budget. It will take the same amount of time for the coalition to get their house in order as it will for the conservatives to present their plan. Better the devil you know than the New Libs on the Bloc.


Nova Scotian
said

Three points:
1. Steven Harper has not made any effort to listen to the majority of Canadians or to their elected representative (Liberals, NDP, Bloc) or indeed to those in his own party. This attitude is responsible for the situation he is in.
2. The members elected by the people of Canada determine who governs the country. To suggest that a government formed by the majority of the elected representatives, even if they are from three different parties, is undemocratic is totally senseless. However Mr Harper seems to believe that if you say something often enough it will become the truth
3. To call the proposed coalition a separatist coalition does nothing for national unity. It reflects well on Mr Duceppe that he can work with the other parties for the good of all of Canada,including Quebec. It is obviously much more than Mr Harper is willing to do.


Adis
said

Conservatives and Harper appologists need to stop speaking on my behalf. I am a Canadian and I did not elect Harper or the convervatives. I tired of hearing how Canadians chose Harper, I don't recall his name on my balot. The only reason this coalition is even able to legally come together is because MAJORITY of Canadians did not elect conservatives.


Mustang
said

It took 6 takes to get the liberal response because Stephane didn't understand the speech.....


Richard in LaSalle, QC
said

Dion's address was a complete joke. You people who still support him after he signed teh document to sell Canada off to the separatists ought to be ashamed of yourselves.


Me
said

We canadians already voted!!! What kind of gov't do we have if they make Harper resign! He is the only one fit for the job to lead our country, and that was already proven during the election. Layton, Dion and that french dude should take a hike!!! Its funny they back mouthed each other during elections and there friends? Thats kind of funny..dont you think...


Ken
said

Mr. Dion and Mr. Layton should be ashamed of themselves. They can't win an election so now they want to steal power in a country that didn't want them in an election only a few weeks ago. They both should have the courage of their supposed Canadian conviction to tear up the agreement with the Bloc and resign from Parliament immediately. And to think that I actually voted Liberal a few weeks ago. If this coalition is allowed to take power I will never vote again - and I have proudly voted in EVERY election, federal, provincial and municipal, for almost 40 years.


Lindsay
said

Layton (who is nothing but an extortionist), started planning this coup the day after the election, he is an embarassment!


HARPER GONE, BRING ON DION!
said

Harper is a joke. This country needs more than one narrow-minded, ideologically driven, minority government making decisions. His last minute attempt at including his opponents was too late. Time for a new government!

Joan (Calgary)
said

I moved to Calgary from Hamilton in 1994. I have lived and voted on both sides of the fence.

While I understand that the proposed coalition is entirely constitutional, I could never live with it.

Seeing tonight's speech by Dion, I am more firm in my resolve to never vote Liberal again.

Should the Alberta separatist party knock on my door for a donation, I will be generous.


Upset
said

Please stop mentioning the 62% voted against.....the SAME thing can be said about the other leaders. 74% or 3 out of 4 eligible Canadians said NO to Dion and the Liberals. Now they want to run the country? In my mind, they do not have the support of the majority of Canadians. This coalition, 'killing of Canada', was not a choice in the last election. If anything, let the people of this country decide, oh wait we did 7 weeks ago and voted-in the conservatives. Opposition parties, accept your defeat and quit trying to force your way into power.


Nancy
said

There are precedents in parliamentary systems for coalitions. Asking the Governor General for a stay of Parliament is an act of avoidance. If Mr. Harper believes so well in his own rhetoric then he should be prepared to stand up in Parliament and face a vote now. That is what a responsible government does; face the consequences. We are each held to the consequences of what we say or do; the same applies to Mr. Harper and his Minister of Finance. Also, we did not elect Mr. Harper to Prime Minister; the people in his riding elected him to Parliament. As head of his party he has the title of Prime Minister; not king, not president. If nothing else, this is teaching many Canadians about their system of government. Coalitions are part of that system. Parties choose a leader. And good parties work as a team, not I,I,I a small word Mr. Harper uses frequently. We vote for a member of Parliament for our own riding. One last comment, I wonder how many people who are providing comments actually voted.


Chris
said

Facts are Important.

38% of Canadians Voted for Harper, that means 62% did not.

The Bloc, has in all but actaully words dropped Separatism.

To be honest it is a power grab, but that is politics is about, POWER.

And just to point out something Stephen Harper tried to do the very same thing that he is fighting against in 2005, so don;t give me this junk about Harper was voted it, he is a just trying to stop what he failed at last time.


Jerry in Edmonton
said

I think Dion used a cell phone video.. what a sad sad performance. The hot air balloon was a nice touch though was that symbolic of all the hot air he has ?
Sorry I want someone who is intelligent running our country not a bumbler..a socialist and a separatist.
What a disgrace and utter embarrassment this fiasco is to Canada.


Andy Coates
said

Thank-you Mr. Prime Minister, and thank-you Mr. Dion and Mr. Layton. You all have had your say. I support any means by the coalition to continue the job of addressing economic issues. I oppose suspending parliament and delaying important budget measures. I support the NDP - Liberal coalition.


Shane
said

I do not support this coalition. If we as Canadians wanted a coalition we would have voted that way.

No matter who you voted for, there was a winner at the end. It’s something as Canadians that we have as a privilege to be able to pick the winner. The way the Liberals, NDP and Bloc want things to go takes away our right. This should not be allowed or at the very least another election so that as Canadian we can this time send a strict message to those three clowns and show them what we can do as Canadian and demolish those parties into has beens.
All a coalition will do is cast a black cloud over Canada and cause other countries to shy away making these economic times worse.

CANADIANS SHOULD NOT SUPPORT THIS SEPARATIST COALITION



sherry
said

This was bound to happen as 64% of Canada find Mr. Harper's policies too right wing. He is totally responsible for his own demise due to his arrogance and bullying regarding the opposition. He is not willing to work with people and in fact wants to cut public funding for his opposition. This is close to a Dictatorship as far as I'm concerned. He didn't have to diss Quebec, and he will pay for that.


J -AB
said

Also are we not forgetting....
why do we need to take it to a vote...we just had one!!!
Guess what Dion lost!!!!!!!


Sarah, Ottawa
said

The Liberals seem to be relying on the fact that they were elected to Parliament. Yes this is true - but as Liberals, not as part of a separatist/socialist coalition. I don't remember seeing a platform presented by a Liberal/NDP/Bloq coalition. Does anybody?


Bren
said

I want Harper to run Canada he is the only PM that has stayed true to his word for the most part.. If i recall the Liberals stole from hard working Canadians.. Why should we trust them.. Dion is just a sore loser and trying to get back what is not his.. Canadians voted and there it should lie..


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

This is sad. Most small town mayors would be far better able to communicate and clarify the issues. The US has a sophisticated Harvard Law grad -- we have these guys.... I wonder if you couldn't pick two better leaders at random from the local phone book.

It's PATHETIC!


Dave in Courtenay
said

Those without principle find compromise the easiest route.


Larry MacDonald
said

A perfect example of Canadian politics. One group says nothing new and the other side makes a video that any one over 6 years old would be embarrassed about. Did Dion's pathetic attempt breed confidence in the public eye. I don't believe that it did. Can't someone get him to resign immediately so that we could at least have a credible opposition leader. Please no more,I can't take the thought of Dion representing Canadians on the world stage.


Joe in Edmonton
said

Holy cow! Does this mean that a couple more Canadians have become interested in their political system? Fantastic! The coalition represents the majority of Canadians. Perfectly legal and proper, end of story.


Geoff Wallace
said

I fully support the NDP - Liberal Coalition.

Minority governments always face no-confidence motions. Asking to prorogue the parliament in order to avoid a no-confidence motion would shame our political system which is based on proportional representation. It would be a disgrace and very hypocritical for Harper to prorogue the government in order to avoid a legal vote by the members of Parliament that were legally voted in the October 14th election by the people of Canada.


bcdarr
said

Since day one, Harper has said, 'Do what I want or vote non-confidence and face the wrath of Canadians who don't understand politics (ie my supporters) and who will blame you for this situation I've caused.'
Judging by the conservative postings, I'd say he knows his fan base very well. These are the same 30% of Canadian voters who seem to think the Conservatives won a majority or that we all voted for our Prime Minister and Harper 'won'.


J
said

Well some may not like Harper, i hold far more trust in him than in Dion. Give me a break, Dion is in no way shape or form able to guide this country, he cannot even gather any consistent support from his own liberal party !!!
What could be a better coalition then the liberals, NDP and Bloc, great idea lets but a party who wants to separate from Canada in the mix, the Bloc has no plans for Canada the only issues they are concerned about is Quebec and all that pertains to it.
Harper is on the right course for this economic crisis, he will be of greater value than Dion handling the crisis.
This is already evident by the completely brutal timing of this whole event by this supposed coalition, i bet the US is just laughing this at gongshow. Let the budget be revealed and really Canadians have already been through and election this yr and the one previous were not far apart, people are tired of it and that is one reason why there are no people voting.
The liberal coalition will undoubtly screw over the west again with a NEP 2 so bring on another liberal leader who will just continue along the path that is so hated in the West, god forbid you try and gain any support out here.
Harper may not be peoples favorite leader but come on, do you seriously think Dion would be any better with the aid of the bloc....who want to leave the country sounds like a great mix for a Canadian government what a great sense of national pride....we might as well just start shipping our money and resources to Ontario and Quebec, as that is what will undoubtedly happen anyway.




Marg in Calgary
said

To PJR:

With regard to earlier "coalitions" - the big difference is that they actually formed it BEFORE the election and had it in place, and therefore, made it on the ballot. These clowns waited till AFTER, to spring and try to steal power they wouldn't otherwise obtain rightfully. They lost, and now they wreaking revenge tactics on the winners. They need to concede defeat and go home. AND, it was also the Liberals that put us in a recession before that took the Conservatives to get us out of. We need a prime minister we can actually understand. We do not need one who will resort to conviving, mudslinging, backstabbing and who has absolutely NO consideration for the voters of this country. As for all of you who say that the Conversatives only had a minority - it doesn't matter, they still won, minority or not. The others actually LOST seats. Goes to show where the confidence lies, doesn't it?


Mark
said

Solid and straight to the point speech by our Prime Minister.

The socialist power seizing Communist Liberals and NDP are overriding the will of Democratic Canadians who voted just 7 weeks ago.

The Liberals & NDP had no intention of ever trying to work with the Conservatives and this is not about the economy. It is about seizing power and overriding the will of the Canadian people in a Democratic election held just 7 weeks ago.

The Conservatives will have a budget in January with a strong stimulus package and in the House today invited the parties to provide input and work with them. Not surprisingly the Communist power grabbers led by the now communist far left wing Liberals refused because this is all is all about seizing power and not the economy and or doing whats best for Canada.

Lastly to seize power they have formed a pack with Duceppe, whose sole goal is to tear this country apart and he has been given Veto power and say against all of Canada. This alone is Treasonous.

Canadians just had an election and decided, but now the GG should call another one now that Canadians realize we have undemocratic communist parties in the Liberals and NDP and let the Democratic Canadian citizens decide who they want to see govern.





kenn
said

To see "The Three Stooges" at their table the other day demonstrating to Canadians their wonderful new found unity and desire to act for the benefit of us all was a preposterous sight. These idiots have faced the nation in an election and the results are clear. To steal power in this way is enough to get us off the couch and into the streets. Ms. Jean would be well advised to consider how angry Canadians are about this turn of events. She can put herself in the firing line next and we can call for her to resign if she supports this coup.


Craig on Gabriola Island, BC
said

I am very proud of Dion and Layton, 2 leaders who have finally shown great pride in Canada and the idea that in a truly democratic parliament there should be consensus and cross-party decision-making. Dion carefully explained his time limit and clearly outlined the coalition's plans for addressing the country's dilemmas constructively.
I am deeply ashamed and terribly saddened by Mr. Harper's anti-Quebec rhetoric and the damage he has caused--and his followers--by suggesting that only Tories are democratic and truly patriotic Canadians. That's just crap. We are all of us in the same boat, as Bob Rae once sang on MuchMusic.
I am deeply proud and glad that those who represent the other 60% of the electorate are going to unite against these demagogues who did not get elected to govern: they only got a minority. That should have led them to bridge-building and even coalition-making with the other parties.


Harvey Snyder
said

What a disgusting, outrageous scene! The 3 stooges on national television. Gilles Dusceppe smug in the knowledge that he has been handed the keys to the treasury without responsibility. Jack Layton, posturing and strutting like a latter day Mussolini, claiming to speak on behalf of the people of Canada and Stephane Dionne, giddy, babbling incoherently, almost peeing himself at the prospect of becoming prime minister.

God help us, and may the Governor General have the wisdom to reject this insult to all Canadians.

Harvey Snyder
Richmond ON


Lowell
said

Harper offered nothing new and it is totally despicable of him to try and change it into a unity crisis. By calling all of the voters who voted for the BLOC, separatists is reprehensible. His statement was that Dion has struck a deal with separatists meaning all Quebecers who voted for BLOC MP's want to break up Canada. When in fact the only thing people are worried about these days, except maybe Steve, is putting food on their tables and keeping a job. Dion made it crystally clear what the mandate of the coalition is and he served up a time frame on which they want to get started on it. They want to stimulate the economy. The liberals are fortunate enough to have people that know alot about the economy. With the cons you have Flaherty. With the coalition you will get McKenna, Martin and Manley who have all said they will be economic advisors. I say lets give the coalition a chance. So far we have zero from Steve.


Virginia
said

Funny, the conservatives made plenty of deals with the Bloc in the past....and now they say that that is the worst thing for Canada...why now?


cantuc
said

How many liberals voted for Gilles Duceppe or Layton in the last election ? How many ndp supporters voted for dion or Duceppe in the last election .Over one million liberals did't even vote for dion in the last election . The liberal party didn't want him in the last election , never mind anybody else and now he's trying to sneak in through the basement window .But then ,being a liberal , he's entitled . WHAT A LOSER!


Deb
said

Why bother voting... the people's choice does not seem to matter!!


BIll
said

Dion doesn't care because he wont be there but Layton should be afraid that when this thing backfires the NDP will be obliterated off of the electoral map.


Henry
said

Stephen Harper is my Prime Minister

I AM A VOTER AND MY VOTE COUNTS



Jim from N.S.
said

This coalition is a very bad idea. Either let Harper govern or have another election, Canadians have to have a say in this or voter turnout will be close to zero for the next election. Dion is the worst party leader I have ever seen, the Liberals should get him out of there asap. He is not only hurting Liberals, he is hurting all of Canada..


td
said

Enough already. This issue has polarized and divided the country like no other in recent times.

The only possible course of action is to call an election. If the coalition wishes to run a single candidate in each riding that is their choice.

Politicians from all parties created this problem, but the people should be the ones to decide what happens next.


SK in SK
said

Recall your MP. It is your right to recall them if they do not do what you elected them to do.


JC Kelan
said

"If I am entrusted with the role of prime minister for the next months that I have left to serve,"

One of the signatories is gone in a few months.

Where is the stability?

JC Kelan
Amherst, NS


A worried Canadian
said

People who support this coalition obviously don't believe in their own rights or democracy.. they need to give their heads a looong shake and think of what it means to be a CANADIAN!!!!!!! A country should stand as a WHOLE! and respect the decision made in the past election!

On another note.. Stephen Harper got more votes than any other party.. so when people say that many canadians voted against Harper, even MORE voted AGAINST Dion and Layton. I am ashamed of my fellow Canadians who support this crock of B.S.

GO RIDERS!!! WOOOOOOOOO


Allison Garesh, Saskatoon
said

I have been astounded by Harper's continued capacity to mislead the public (and with a straight face!) about what can and can't be done in a parliametary democracy. He clearly does not understand Canada's constitution and our system of parliamentary democracy and that alone demonstrates his lack of fitness to govern. Dion, Layton and Duceppe speak of consensus, collaboration and common sense. I sincerely hope the GG sees fit to ask the coalition to govern.


Tamara
said

Do you all not remember that the PC party "align" with the Reform party to strengthen their voting block - especially in the west? What is so different now with the Liberal-NDP "aglinment"
What about the 41% of voters that did not vote? Did anyone stop to think that maybe they felt no one was good enough to do the job, but maybe a coalition would?

This coalition, if at time of the election, would have defeated the Conservatives. This is democracy at it's best!

I see so many of you are inside-the-box thinkers. Wake up before we end up being 3rd world!


Anne
said

To C and Evan who persist in saying that 2/3rds or 62% voted against the Conservatives. We had a choice from among three parties. Let's view the votes counted for them individually because that's how a elected party gets to govern - we don't elect coalition parties. Neither the NDP nor Liberals together got more votes than the Conservatives. The Bloc Q is only relevant in Quebec so please discount them as the rest of Canada did not have a say in their election to Parliament. Quebec has approximately 26% of the Canadian population - and by right should only be assigned 26% of the seats in Parliament. For Stephane Dion to say that he has the support of the Green Party is idiotic - the Green Party does not have one seat in the House of Commons. Is Mr. Dion saying anything different to what Mr. Harper is saying? No. He is just using more words to express exactly what Mr. Harper has said in fewer words. By the way - who wrote his speech? This man is being manipulated by others. I can't believe he is so foolish as to fight the election all over again, despite losing more seats on October 14th. Canadians did not choose him and his party. And he has the nerve to say he will step down in May after a Liberal Leader is chosen? I don't think we want Dion and Layton losing their heads by throwing around billions of our dollars ad infinitum as knee-jerk reactions to every crisis. I would sooner have an election. Let's use that $31 million saved by abolishing the $1.95 per vote funded by the taxpayers.


Y. Lamarche
said

Yvon from Waub: Very disappointing speech from the Prime Minister. Mr. Harper if you have any care for the country at all you will do the right thing tomorrow and walk over to the GG tomorrow and hand in your resignation. That would give your successor Conservative Prime Minister the opportunity of meeting with the leaders of the opposition this weekend and seek their good will in averting a national crisis caused by your incompetence. No one wanted this mess you created and trust that a new conservative leader like Mr. Prentice can quickly gain the confidence of the house.


Amanda Rock
said

In this time of crisis why are we trying to undue what Canadians just voted for? With all this bickering going on we are wasting tax payers dollars and spending time on ridiculous agendas. Why can't the other parties accept that fact that Stephen Harper is doing his best to do the job that the country as a whole voted for him to have. The other parties are spending too much time whining and not enough time trying to come up with ideas of how we are going to survive this economical upheaval. Stephen is a human being, and while he is not perfect I think that he is trustworthy and will see Canadians through this difficult time. Canadians need to stand up for what we believe in and put our trust in Stephen Harper whom has been appointed this position of leading our country.


Eddie Grant
said

The SEDITION COALITION has no mandate. The Liberals and NDP ran under two divergent platforms, that both rejected coalition government. Now they have both abandoned the platforms that each of them campaigned under during the election, and have aligned themselves with the Quebec separtists to steal power. Nobody voted for this.


Jose
said

I wonder how many of the comments are written by the Conservative staff just to flood the media with pro Harper movement.


Graham McMorland
said

The combined number of parliamentary seats held by the Liberals and NDP total less than those held by the Conservatives. So the only way they will be able to command a majority is by gaining the support of the Bloc.
This means that the balance of power in parliament (the tail that wags the dog)will be held by a party with no support outside of just one province and that is committed to breaking up our Federation.
Now that bothers me -- even more than having Dion as PM and Jack Layton commanding six cabinet posts.


Annie of Winnipeg
said

Dion, your time to serve is at an end. Remember the election results! The feuding that happening was on your watch, the name calling on your watch. We've had enough, the Conservatives do have an agenda and can lead the country thru this troubled time.

Typically Liberal, you are now going to shore up the whole country with what money? And what's up with the Green Party, they have no support, worse than you.




Alan
said

All you people who say "63% of voters never voted for Harper" should remember that
100% of voters never voted for what Dion and Layton have come up with.


Lindsay
said

Isn't anyone outside Western Canada a little worried about giving a political party that wants nothing to do with this country the power of veto?


frustrated canadian
said

Harper will be damned by the coalition no matter what he comes up with as I do not believe as they say that they are for cooperation and "getting on with it" for the Canadian people. Already the strength of ordinary canadian reaction against the coalition is being blamed on conservative promotions. How foolish these men are.


David in Sarnia
said

Thanks to PM Harper for standing his ground and speaking with conviction and purpose. Finally a PM who backs up his word with action and isn't deterred by the pettiness of wannabes. A class act amidst the rants and whinings of those who want to take the power without paying the price.


Freda
said

Stephan Harper is our elected leader. If this Government is to fall there should be an Election.There is no way the Bloc should have the balance of power for all of Canada.


Bill
said

Stephen Harper just spent 30 million dollars of tax payer money without any hesitation (breaking the law he made himself!) in an election trying to get a majority which he shamelessly covets.

Now Harper is off spending huge amounts of more public money trying to save himself because he has acted so ridiculously arrogant with our democratic form of government that the other parties and most people in Canada have had enough of Harper.

Harper says everyone else is un democratic now ??? He calls the Liberals supported by the NDP seperatist ???..TOTAL POPPYCOCK ! How stupid does harper think Canadians are? He has not shown good judgement and leadership and when a PM does not show real leadership there is a mechinism to replace him. That's what the Coalition of Liberals and NDP is all about.

What Harper says now is a fiction and it is ridiculous propaganda...same old Stephen Harper. He will never change. His time is up !


What goes around comes around Stephen...even for you !



Steve Daly, Mississauga
said

Was Dion's unfocused (there's a surprise) tape designed for YouTube? It looked like it was done on a webcam in somebody's basement!

Let's face it, the delay was probably caused by having to do multiple takes because Dion didn't understand the question about when he might be Prime Minister. :)

Say NO to NLDPS, the New Liberal Democratic People's Separatist Party!


Car in BC
said

The Canadian Parliamentary system requires (and this is not negotiable) consensus among a majority. PM
Harper's divisive, dictatorial and dishonest actions have proven he is incapable of leading this country. His conflictual and arrogant style has fueled this crisis. - It is important to remember the majority of Canadians have NOT voted for this neo-conservative leader nor party. Further, he has lost the confidence of the majority of elected officials. It is one thing to disagree with the opposition parties, it is quite another to try to silence or destroy them as Harper has tried.
We need a vote of confidence. It would not only be cowardly but dangerous and undemocratic for Harper to try to avoid this vote of confidence.


Jerry in Alberta
said

Did they use a camera phone to tape Dion ?
He can not even get a video out on time and he wants to run the country? haha
Sorry I want someone intelligent that will push forward while the world and Canada are having economic troubles. Not a bumbler a socialist and a separatist. Like I heard on the news by a well known retired member of parliament "I know these guys and they could not get together and agree on what to bring to a picnic"


Joan in Saskatchewan
said

Any reason why CTV didn't post an OUT OF FOCUS picture of him from his speech along with with the picture of the book title "Hot Air" that was on the bookshelf behind him???

Also, did Craig Oliver memorize the coalition talking points before going on air? Come ON! I had to switch over to CPAC for some rational and less partisan discourse!!!


Paul
said

Where does Harper believe he has been given a mandate. He only had support of 38% of voters and couldn't form a majority based on past performance. He is continuing his mud-slinging US style political agenda. If a coalition was such a bad thing for a country, then why not remove it as an option. As has been pointed out, coalitions governments have worked.


Marci
said

The Conservatives were elected; Mr. Harper is leader of the party and our Prime Minister.

This is the first time in years I have had respect for and confidence in the Prime Minister and his government.

The people do NOT want you Mr. Dion, we do NOT want Mr. Layton and we CERTAINLY DO NOT WANT the Bloc.

Shame on the three of you; so desperate for power. Get it through your heads, we do NOT want to bail out the auto industry, we do NOT want parties with a history of wasting taxpayers money getting their greedy hands in the till again.

You, Mr. Dion, who can't even get a tape to a studio in time YOU should be trusted with running our country?? I think not.
YOU sir, and your ugly little band DO NOT represent me; PRIME MINISTER HARPER does.


Steve B.
said

Four priorities for Harper: (1) Me...me...me. (2) Stay in control no matter what. To heck with the 60%+ who did not vote for me. (3) Destroy the Liberal Party. (4) If there is time left, lets do something for the Canadian people provided the above are not compromised.


mohammad khan
said

Mr. Harper should have apologized the citizens for creating this mess in the first place. If he claims to be the Leader of the nation and having won majority of the seats compared to other parties, then he should also know what the people are going through and what actually they wanted from that statement.
A Leader who thinks he owns the country and not somebody who is given a position think of the people and do not get involved in firesome politics has no right to govern. that is my view.



PJT
said

As far as Dion's speech , I was flipping between CTV, Global, CBC, and CPAC.. all of these stations were reporting that the speech hadn't arrived yet. Eventually it did show up. Talk about lack of respect for me the voter, apparently my time means nothing to him. This man who wants to be PM can't get a simple tape out when he has 2 days notice, oh wait maybe he didn't undertandthe question and needed 3 retakes.


HEY LAW STUDENT OMG OMG
said

HEY LAW STUDENT.....

We do not have a President we have a Prime Minister. Please state your name so I know not to hire you as my lawyer in the future since you do not even know that we do not have a PRESIDENT. When you quoted "President of Canada" you lost all value to your statement.

just say goodbye to Harper, send him a letter, a Christmas Present whatever but I want my stimulous package and I wont get that with Harper


Michelle Josef
said

Unlike America where the name of the President is on the ballot, In Canada, we do NOT have a system where we directly elect our Prime Minister. We have a parliamentary system and we elect our local members to office. Then the party with the most seats is asked to form a government. The leader of that party then becomes the Prime Minister. This system is designed to prevent the concentration of power and one of the "checks and balances" is that the system works on the confidence of the parliament. Now a lot of Canadians might think that they are voting directly for the Prime Minister, but that is creeping Americanism and is actually un-Canadian. In the U.S. just about the only way to remove a president is impeachment. In Canada, our elected members of parliament can vote to remove the ruling party by a vote of non-confidence.

This entire mess is of Stephen Harper's own doing. It appears that he has lost the confidence of parliament and it is actually the duty of parliament to act accordingly. As far as portraying Gilles Duceppe as the separatist devil, we must remember that 10% of voting Canadians voted for his party in the last election. Those Canadians are entitled to having their voice represented in Parliament as well as those that voted for their Conservative candidate. Dismissing those that voted for the Bloc is cheap politics and insulting to many Quebecers.

It appears that Mr. Harper is once again pitting one region of Canada against another. When are actually going to start working together as a nation?

The coalition of the three parties to form a government is perhaps the ultimate Canadian thing-rule by committee.


Gail (Hamilton)
said

I didn't watch Dion, but read his speech here. More scare mongering sales pitch than appealing to Canadians, but this is always the tactic of the far left. There must be some Liberals who would put Canada first and would back the Conservative's position. At least their constitutents who didn't vote NDP/Bloc would probably agree since they stand for Canadian unity. Kick Dion in the butt.


Bonnie BC
said

Dion should learn from his mistakes, add that to Jacks and throw in a Rae day and voila.
Remember when B.C. was were the nuts came from?



jay selzler
said

western canada needs to rid of this old parliment system.


PM
said

63 % of Canadians rejected Mr. Harper. Canadians support the coalition.


Ugh.
said

First of all - the opposition does have every right to create a coalition, and secondly - they are not in coalition with the bloc, they merely have their promised co-operation on a vote of no confidence.


Cindy
said

Like it or not, Mr. Harper was elected by the people of this country, not the other three stooges. I am under the belief that the people that were ELECTED to run the Country should be running it, not a bunch of sore losers who need to band together in order get the power they feel they deserve.


Ted Hewlett
said

I just listened on the CTV website to Mr. Harper's speech and Mr. Dion's response. Then they were followed by two commentators who had little but criticism for Harper and no criticism of Dion's speech.

Harper rightly zeroed in on the real issue, for this is in reality a coalition with the separatists. Even though they wouldn't have a seat in the cabinet, the other two losing parties have signed a formal accord with them, which will give them a veto on important governmet measures. In most countries this would provoke even greater outrage than it has in Canada.
Ted Hewlett, Surrey, B. C.


The Hammer
said

All I can say regarding the televised speeches is.....What a waste of Television time. Overkill on Harper's make-up. He'll never be the next "Cover Girl"


Eddie Grant
said

Based on the position taken by the NDP, Liberals, and BQ, if about a dozen members of the current opposition parties and independent MPs decided to walk over to the Conservative side of the House, everybody should be okay with that.

Whenever an individual MP decides to cross the floor in the House to reassign his (or her) seat to a different party than the one he (or she) represented in the election there is always an uproar within the House, as well as the electorate. The NDP have historically been among the most vocal against this practice. This only makes it all the more outrageous to see the whole NDP party conspire to create a new political entity in cooperation with the Liberals, that abandons the policies that both of these individual parties campaigned on only 6 weeks ago. There is also no telling what role the BQ is playing behind the scenes, since there is no question that they are not committing their support to this for nothing.


Eric
said

honestly, Harper is a person who does not care about the people of Canada, he is so arrogant ans he intent is to bully people/ the opposition around to get what he wants. I am never going to vote conservative. As much as I do not like the idea of Dion as prime minister, I loath the idea of keeping Harper in. He has shown time and time again that his one track mind cannot let him understand how miserable our economy is. Harper has been so focused on having Duceppe in the coalition that he does not get to the topic of what he is going to do for the economy. His speech lacked intent and did not tell us what his plan is. He is only interested in propaganda, saying the libs are in bed with the separatists who will definitely break up our country, that he does not focus on the economy. I do not like the idea of a coalition but nor do i like the idea of Harper in that house on Sussex.


Eddie Grant
said

The Conservatives are not anti-Quebec; they are only against the Quebec separtists. The Liberals and the NDP, on the other hand, don't give a shit about any of that. They will do whatever it takes to grab power.


Gerald Sinclair
said

The fact that Harper and the Conservatives wanted to change legislation to ultimately bankrupt any opposition concerns me.

Does he really think that Canada would be better served by a 1 party system?

I think the world has seen this happen a couple of times in the last 100 years. It never turned out well.


Bruce from Calgary
said

Dion goes to bed with the seperatists, and you still don't get it... shame on you..


Patrick
said

To everyone wondering "where was the tape" - it was played back from a central feed facility and fed simultaneously to all networks.


Lois in Ont
said

I am opposed to the notion of a coalition for two reasons; it is completely dependent to succeed on the yea or nea of the separatists, who should not even be in the parliament of a country they do not respect and cherish. The second reason is that Dion will be leading the coalition. We've already said "no" to Dion. He led a terrible campaign that set his party backwards, and now we should let him run the country? He mucked up a little job so now we give him a bigger one? Where's the sense in that? We don't even know who will be heading the coalition six months from now. He's a temporary lame duck leader. I dont see what was wrong with asking the political parties (all of them) to take less from the taxpayers. It's called leading by example...and would only be asking of them, to do what all Canadians are doing, with no say in the matter. The opposition parties should suck it up and show a little "grace" like the taxpayer must, and back off.


catherine McKelvey
said

I voted for Mr Harper and am furious that my vote is now discounted by the 3 individuals that I did'nt want to see to see running the country. They are now trying to steal what they could'nt win. Go for another election Mr Harper and send those hounds back where they belong


Brian from Lotus-land
said

Get over it Canada! We have a democratic system that allows for the replacement of an minority government. It just seems to happen more to the conservative government more than the liberals. Some of us still remember Joe Who




KDR
said

I am confused as to why everyone keeps refering to Stephen Harper's cut backs on political funding a "mistake." He is trying to help the economy (which he started doing two years ago-the actions that countries are just starting now have already been done here in Canada). Out of all the possible places to cut government funding he chose to stop funding his own party.. Conservatives will lose over $10 million. Would Canadians rather start paying for education and healthcare? Get real people!!! The NDP, Bloc, and Liberals are just selfish, and upset because they will be broke without government funding


Alice - Toronto
said

I am behind Steven Harper 100% - I want an election take it to the voters - let's do it right.


Eddie Grant
said

The Quebec Separtists received only 38% of the popular vote in Quebec, and 0% of the popular vote outside of Quebec. The BQ are exclusively dedicated to the interests of Quebec and the dissolution of confederation, and could not care less about the rest of Canada.

On this basis, how can the Liberals and NDP justify abandoning the policies that they campaigned under only 6 weeks ago and aligning themselves with the BQ to form a Separtist-Socialist Coalition?

Excluding the seats held by the Quebec Separtists, the distribution of the remaining seats is as follows:

- 55.2% Conservative
- 44.0% Liberals + NDP
- 0.8% Independent

Outside of the seats held by the BQ, the Conservatives hold the majority, so it is a pathetic move by the socialists to align themselves with the Quebec separtists to steal power within the national government.


Ann
said

no appologies harper? what about a, "i am sorry for doing NOTHING to help struggling people during this economic depression" instead of haper trying to soften his tyrant image with Canadians, he continues bash the other parties for trying to take a stand. this minority government has done nothing, but stand by, as people lose their homes, jobs and as the auto sector crumbles. sorry harper you screwed up. deal with it.


Kaila-18
said

They missed all of Dion's stuttering in this typed version of his speech! He sounded like an idiot!


C. Nylander
said

So some want a coalition government where the Bloc has vito powers. The Bloc who wont take the oath of alegance and who refuse to enter the house of commons until they are done singing O Canada. And we want them to make decisions for all Canadians. Well here is a solution. Let Quebec seperate from Canada. The conservatives would have 143 seats and the Liberals and NDP would have 114 seats. Then for our economic stimulous we would have the 8.028 Billion we currently give Quebec under the equalization payments. Add to that the money saved on reducing the commons by 49 seats. Then lets not forget the billions we woul save in not having to provide services to Quebec like Justice, Employment Services, Canada Post, Transportation, Agriculture, Multiculturism, Health, Seniors Services, Tourism, ect ect ect. Seems like a lot money to stimulate our economy and even bail out the Auto industry. Just a thought


Rhett in BC
said

Harper has seriously gone mad with ego. He has no idea about finances... remember a week before the election he said the was no financial crisis; now it uses it to create fear. His attack ads are disgusting "Remember when the conservative's were working with the seperatist" a couple years ago??? Also their was a great comedy skit put on ctv featuring Harper using a baby as an ATM... Try and watch it on youtube; IT HAS BEEN BLOCKED IN OUR COUNTRY. I thought we lived in Canada not China. You can't sensor the media.

Harper does more flip flopping than Layton. Tories should do whats best for Canada and step down.


Eddie Grant
said

The power within the Separtist-Socialist Coalition will be distributed as follows:

Liberals - 77 Seats (47%)
BQ - 49 Seats (30%)
NDP - 37 Seats (23%)

Although this makes Stephane Dion the Number 1 partner in all this, the Number 2 man is the leader of the Quebec Separatists. The NDP are nothing more than the junior partner because, as many have so aptly pointed out, that's how democracy works. You might also notice that this arrangement originated in an agreement between the BQ and NDP, who together hold 53% of the voting power of this coalition. Any guess who will really be governing Canada if these clowns follow through with this?


Barry - Hamilton
said

Good Job Harper.. the Cons got their vote of confidence not more then a few weeks ago, now the LOSERS of our last election are not happy with that so they want to overthrow the government... the liberals had their chance in power with a majority government and they still messed things up, oh right they put us in debt. now they want to put us into further debt which US canadians will have to pay for. you want to grow up and try to work together for once like harpers is asking, nothing can get passed with idiots like the LIBs and NDPs opposing everything so i ask you please shut up and sit down on the opposition side


Bob Smith
said

The Libs and the ndp and the bloc. That's who you want running Canada. I'm outta here, running screaming away from the idiocy that has grabbed this country.


J.D.Wallingford
said

I listened to Duceppe tonight speak to Quebec. You would think he was Santa Clause promising the world to Quebeckers.

Guess who is going to pay for all his promises? This is an unholy alliance for sure and needs to be stopped.

How can backbencher Liberal MPS just sit there and allow their party to jump in bed with separatists? Shows me how principled the Liberals are.


Avinder Dhaliwal Brampton, ON
said

Liberal leader's speech tape was late and they have two days to deleiver it. How would he run a country and he could not perpare 5 minutes tape in two days, shame on you Mr. Dion. Anybody can do better than you. You shouod go back to KG school and learn how to be on time. You just want to grab power and want you name in the PM list. Go Harper Go Harper!!!!!!!!!1


PROUD CONSERVATIVE
said

How come Dion had a book on his shelve that said (HOT AIR) LOL. I never laughed so hard in my life. I significently laughed . Did I spell that like he kept trying to say it. LOL LOL LOL


Kathleen Walker
said

The time has come for Canada to tell Quebec to leave this Nation. It is sad, it is tragic, it will be logisticaly difficult, but we cannot let that pony keep pulling our cart to its hay bale any more.


Angela Kitchener
said

I did not vote for Liberal, Bloc or NDP and if I recall the last election, none of them were give the majority government either!

Stop being a bunch of babies and work this out. You were elected for a job, NOW DO IT!


Joey Schwartz
said

I could not believe my eyes and ears tonight. The Prime Minister, repeated the same nonsensical allegations that he made before his speech to the nation this evening.

He claims the actions of the opposition will "overturn" the election. Again, especially in light of the Westminster Rules of Parliament that we follow, not true. He did not win a majority, so which party or group of parties that is allowed to form the government is not assured. Therefore, he has to face the parliament and win confidence. If he fails, as it appears very likely his government will, then his party is no longer the government. How is that "undemocratic"? That is how our government has been run since before Confederation. Obviously the Prime Minister knows that.

Our democracy is running as it should. It does not need a "defender" as he suggested, especially him. So, I say, get rid of this anti-democratic Prime Minister, and install a government that has the support of the house: the coalition.


David from Alberta
said

Alberta whines because they voted for a loser and bully! Work together and help Canada and not destory it! I don't care who is in charge but I will never vote PC.. NEVER NEVER


Monte
said

Why is it that all these people that don't understand Canadian politics are so angry about a coalition. We do NOT elect a President for this country, but we vote for our member of parlaiment. Those members represent our concerns in the House of commons. The Prime Minister is just the leader who represents most of the members of parliament.

More constituents have members that feel that it is more important to do something about the financial crisis in a more focused way than was presented by Mr Harper. Because they agree on these things, it is their responsiblity to ensure that their constituents are represented. Anything else would be wrong.


P MacLean
said

Polly, Nova Scotia

I did not vote for Harper and the bully squad so am part of the 62% who wanted someone else. He can't go too soon for me.


Michael - Pitt Meadows
said

I want to see Steven Harper to continue what he is doing. I believe he is the best choice. We are in tough times, now is not the time for new party to say we are taking over.

What the NDP and Liberals are doing is wrong and should be considered unconstitional. Both the NDP and Liberals need to learn to act like adults and not like spoiled children.


José
said

How about stopping taking Canadian tax payers for clowns. We are in an era that we need governance and innovation to make this country still the best to live in. Let's be leaders to the world instead of followers. The legacy of Canadians and many of the cultures that emerge in the country was to work hard and reach achievement. We are responsible. Every single Canadian to the out come of the leaders that we put in parliament we pay their salaries either they create some governing in a democratic innovative and successful or let's fire them. Our money future and pride should be put in people that generate positive outcome opposed to negative and confused leaders. Nothing wrong with admitting and steeping down as a leader asking for help to govern but creating KO's in a weak and unstable economy not what we need as Canadians let's unify and create strong leaders.


Erlinda Alamay
said

This Coalition leaders can't accept their defeat.

We voted for Harper and we want him to stay.


Stuart
said

Peter, you might want to finish that thought:
82% of Canadians rejected Layton
74% rejected Dion
63% rejected Harper

It's all rejects. Like it is every time. The last leader in this country that got majority support was Mulroney in 1984 with 50.5% of the vote. So, when it comes to whom Canadian voters reject, your mileage may vary


Samantha in NS
said

While I have much respect for the issues those of Quebec have had even before I was alive and while I am not a fan of Harper and his government, I do wonder if Dion and Layton actually have a rational head upon their shoulders. We are in the midst of a economic crisis and a deal giving a party bent on dividing a country that paid in blood during the world wars but came together as a nation, seems not only insane but un-Canadian.
Democracy wouldn’t be well represented by a coalition government that in the first place, the Canadian people never voted for. The last time I checked that was one of the principle ideals of this country, a government for the people by the people. While at some point the “for the people” has been misconstrued with “for the interests of those in the government and not those who gave them their position,” it has always been our choice who we put in that seat.
This is a very trying time for Canadians and the rest of the world. We should be striving to keep the country together by any means so that we can come out of this crisis and the economic crisis still a united body. If they are unhappy with the results ask for another election and see what happens then. We the Canadian people might not like being dragged to the polls every time the opposition cries a river, at least we can prove with our vote what WE want.


Ron Barre
said

Hard to believe that these 2 leaders could sell their soul to a party whose sole intention is to break up Canada.


Andrew
said

A glimpse of History in the making... Harper on the verge of losing his power for good reason. Canadians need to give this Coalition a chance. We need Economic leadership now, and we must support elected members willing to show leadership. The Economy transcends all boundaries, and will not matter whether the Bloc Quebecious is in or not. Mr. Dion, though a shaky leader at best deserves a chance. Harper needs to face the people of Canada.


robert drew
said

Just as i expected from Harper again, Always on the attack and never trying to resolve the problem. I think this is a big power trip for harper who always has to attack and never just says i was wrong and lets try to fix this. I hope the coalition does happen and we rid of Harperville once and for all.


Justin
said

Did anyone else see the book on the book shelf behind Dion's head to his right(our left)?

title of the book: HOT AIR

Hmm... and he want's to be Prime Minister


Don
said

Put Jack in charge of the coup. He can at least right a speech in the 2 day time limit


Stuart
said

It's a bad set of choices: I don't want either guy to be my PM. Both are guys who have spent their lives theorizing in universities and think tanks instead of going out there and dealing with real people.

The real issue is: which of these incompetent fools is going to be guided by solid sane advice. Stephane Dion, at least, has the humility to be guided by the likes of Ralph Goodale, John McCallum, Roy Romanow and a host of people I DO respect. Stephen Harper will continue to be to heed the advice of no one except himself.

The advantage of coalitions is that they actually involve deliberation, debate and consensus. So, given a choice between these two clowns, I'll choose the one who at least has the sense to take some advice.


hugh grant
said

Mr. Dion is to be pitied more than anything. Here is a person who has lost the confidence of the people in an election.Went into hiding for days after and now comes out of his cave like some kind of saviour to Canadians. We already have a Prime Minister...his name is Stephen Harper. Canadians do not like sore losers. Mr.Dion,you lost fair and square and if you have one ounce of respect left, especially for Canadians..leave! If you really want to serve Canada,LEAVE!!


Cam from Canada
said

See this situation for what it is. Large unions are on the brink of disaster due to not being able to keep the gun to the struggling employer's heads during this economic crisis. Their role is to protect jobs. They are unable to do this due to the US recession which impacts us. Now they are turning to the government whose role among other things it to create a fair environment in which principles of free markets (as opposed to state controlled) are supported. Stimulus is fine as long as it has a purpose. Mr. Dion's speech sounded like he is bailing out the unions from years of irrelevancy. Compare the Honda Plants and worker rights in Canada to the Ford ones and you will see what a New Democracy and market should look like. Communism always raises the benefits and corruption to the highest levels and leaves the poor worse off in the end.


Jerry
said

Dion only on cbc eh,must have been seen by at least couple hundred and I'm guessing no more than 4 in Alberta. Dion days are like Ray days but the whole country not just Ontario gets them


sean in regina
said

Very scary times. Our vote obviously counts for nothing. It's all up to the Governer General. Sacre bleu!


SAVE OUR JOBS FROM GOING OVER SEAS
said

I cannot believe the ignorance of Canadians. Is it the baby boomers that are talking here or what? Doesn't anyone realize that our economy is in trouble. I sure the hell want a stimulous package one that Harper will not dish out. I want something back for all the taxes I have paid. Stimulate me Stimulate me!! For some reason the West does not believe the auto industry will trickle down and effect them. You wait, and then we will say I told you so, well no actually we wont, cause we will all be on the street with no place to live. GET A GRIP CANADA. LIBNDPBLOC has our best interest in mind. CANADA NEEDS MANUFACTURING.


Brian from Winnipeg
said

As a FORMER liberal supporter I am outraged with the current events going on right now. The 3 parties have no right to try and form a government. Not only were they not elected as our government, but I wonder how many votes they would lose had the public known they would form a coalition??? I am glad that Harper took a stand, he is calling it what it is. THEY were the elected government, and yes the oposition should have their opinion, but not the right to over-throw the current government. The writting is on the wall when Dion dose not want a break, he simply wants to get power one week from now and move on with out the people having their say. WATCH what will happen if there is another election. The current government would surely get a majority based on the unacceptable actions of the liberals and NDP. And why is Harper being attacked for burning bridges in Quebec??? A person from Quebec and a Sepertist are not the same thing. A sepertist is a sepertist is a sepertist


David Hutchinson
said

David
When are we all going to realize that we don't need parties anymore. Lets have an election were you elect the best person from your area and send him to Ottawa to represent you. No more parties. Lets put a group of Canadians in there and let them use some common sence. Have you ever noticed that mobs have mentalities but individuals do the senseable thing.


Laurie F
said

I'm still laughing to myself, on CBC Newsworld when Dion gives his taped speech look at the book on the top shelf of the bookshelf to the left, it is titled "HOT AIR". WOW that must be Dions' favorite book. But then again how can we expect anything more from Dion then sheer stupidity.


Miriam G. QC
said

We Canadians voted for Harper.

Period.


Mustang
said

Dion, Well!! Mr Bean could not improve on his bumbling Professor routine. Not a leader.




Donna/Vancouver
said

Does anyone remember the election debates? Think about how the 3 coaltion blockheads just kept on demorilizing anything Harper said. I was waiting for each of them to lay out their plans and showcase their party policies. Those weren't debates. That was the start of the planning of the coaltion of three. This just did not happen in the so called "four days". It started long before this and they specifically want Stephen Harper gone. What a sad, sad, man made dangerous time we are in.


Mark - Vegreville, AB
said

According to Dion:
"Every economist in the country is predicting increased job losses and deficits for the next few years."


If this is the case then would we not be better off taking a measured response to the issue than going right off the deep end and bring in a coalition of parties that up until a few days ago were enemies? How long will they make it before someone gets upset and pulls the plug at an opportune moment?

People are in a panic. They are afraid. We do not need a prime minister who is in the same boat.


Paul in Mississauga
said

Did you see the big smile on Dion's face when he was talking about being Prime Minister?

Sure the BQ will blackmail him and Parliament on every single issue, but Stephane will get to play PM!

The nine provinces had better get used to the idea of two nations; Quebec will get half, the other provinces will get the other half - otherwise Gilles (the smart fellow) will pull support and an election will have to be called. That election could destroy a Dion-led Liberal Party and return the Tories and a strong contingent of BQ members.

Gilles you're a cruel man to play hardball with grasping and naive politicians.


PJR
said

Uh when I read the comments here i wonder if i am missing something?! Wasn't Harper the one who caused this whole crisis? Wasn't Harper willing to enter into a 'separatist' coalition himself in 2004? Wasn't Stockwell Day willing to do the same in 2000? Isn't there written proof of both? I know Albertans are physically incapable of voting anything other than Conservative but come on people stop acting like sheep and try some critical thinking for once! Even if the Conservatives stay in power, Harper has shown he is not fit to lead this great country of ours. Time for him to go..


Angela
said

I had a hard time voting this year. Conservative did NOT give me a good reason to vote for them. In fact, there was NOTHING solid in their platforms.

So, it was between the Liberals and NDP. I choose the liberals merely as a strategic move. It didn't work but I may get the best of both worlds if the coalition goes through.

Yea, Harper won the election as a minority government. Doesn't mean the majority of us voted for him. In fact, record low voter turnout means, Canadians are apathetic towards the parlimentary system. They don't care anymore and can you blame them? And, Harper wants to do a prorogation? A freezing of this session? Didn't they just have the summer off? And then an election? And they just went back, and he wants to have another "time out". C'mon, this isn't a game!

Canada needs a shake-up and it's about time they join their forces and put Canada back on a path. We've been wayward for WAY too long.

Paul Martin doesn't look so bad now, does he?


Peter
said

83% of Canadians REJECTED Jack Layton.

74% of Canadians REJECTED Stephane Dion.

Stephen Harper has the SUPPORT OF THE PEOPLE.

These others leaders DO NOT HAVE THE SUPPORT OF THE PEOPLE...

WE COUNT...




Perry
said

A coalition government is a great idea. Canadians DO support this coalition. All the opposition parties members outnumber all the Conservatives--so that means that a majority of Canadians did NOT vote for Harper. Too bad we don't have proportional representation.
And Dion did not have two days to prepare this speech; Harper only said he was giving an address to the nation today, and Dion presumably learned of it when Harper decided to reveal his plans TODAY.


Paul
said

What an embarrassment Stephane Dion is!

WE CANNOT LET THIS HAPPEN.


Paul
said

What an embarrassment Stephane Dion is!

WE CANNOT LET THIS HAPPEN.


Opps Harper did it again
said

Hey Harper, why dont you start with demanding Canada give back the Farley Mowat to the Sea Shepherd CS. Lets start there.


Bonnie Plater
said

I was watching the coverage on CTV and they were certainly making a big deal about the tape not being there on time. Did someone in the CTV office miss something. I changed to the CityTV station and watched Dion give his address to the country. If this station had it, it would seem that the CTV station should have had it too. I don't know what happened to the tape but I think that you made Dion look irresponsible. It may be that your station messed up. I thought news reports were suppose to be neutral.


DSC
said

In this time of economic instability, Harper is doing the right thing by making a calm statement. Dion, on the other hand, is trying to create fear and scare us into believing that the sky is falling.

The coalition is created based on fear. Don't let it happen.


Gaetan l'Acadien du NB
said

We don't need an election yet. Enough of our money has already been spent. Let's let Harper do his job. I don't like the idea of a coalition. Where is our democraty in all this?

Mr. Harper needs to fix his mistakes and start taking action to help the people in need in our country. That's all we could ask for.Our government needs to sit down and discuss these issues. STOP THE LITTLE GAMES AND START DELIVERING!


Save the Seals HARPER WONT
said

Give me my stimulus package and dont let the door hit you on the way out Harper.

Save the baby seals from the Great Canadian Seal Hunt


Law Student
said

Parliament is Supreme ... not the Government.

The key to Canadian Government is that Parliament is Supreme. That means we elect the MPs, and the MPs make the law. Yes, the party with the largest number forms the government, but they only set the agenda, it is Parliament and the MPs that make the laws. If the majority of MPs do not like what is proposed they can vote it down and put forth their own ideas. That is Canadian System.

We did not vote for Harper to be President of Canada, he is answerable to Parliament and ALL MPs, the MPs Canada voted for.

Before saying they are illegitiment, remember if Harper stepped down and the Conservatives got a new leader, that leader was not voted in by the people of Canada, but he would still be Prime Minister.

At least the Opposition was voted in -- over 60 percent rejected Stephen Harper and his Conservatives. If they want to unite, by Parliament Supremacy, they have that right.



Lina
said

Where was Dion's tape? Looks like his wife filmed it from home, what a looser!


Chris
said

How can this "coalition" say anything about these trying times, its affecting the world. The opposition guranteed can not do anything different, either we pay for it now, like the rest of the world..or we suffer later, with the bad judgement of Stephan Dion and his accomplices'


Harold Brown
said

I watched Dion and Layton's statements on TV and I think the visual that sums it all up was the book on Dion's bookshelf titled "Hot Air". Harold ... Edmonton


Dr. D.Bamford
said

Dion looked sad tonight. He continues to have a problem relating. I was not impressed with his phoney humility about being a leader. This man scares me.

Steven Ledrew, the former Liberal party leader called Dion today "egotistical" and said to "look out" if he gets to be PM.

Canadians from coast to coast have NO CONFIDENCE in this rebel group of politicians who were handed a serious electoral defeat but refuse to accept the will of the people and instead join ranks in an unholy alliance with separatists.




Kristine
said

There is a well thought out phrase for this.

"To little to late"

Perfectly sums it up. See ya Harper


barry - ottawa.
said

Thank god they put Dion's statement, I couldn't understand a thing and I speak French!


Andrew
said



Mr. Dion has broken the rules! The Governor General is ONLY allowed to accept advise from the Prime Minister!!







FredErick White
said

Ignorant un-informed individuals will be once again misguided the misleading tatics of HARPER (AKA: BUSH II).
The new coalition government shall be formed with members of the NDP and LIBERAL parties.

Harper wants to once again pull the wool over Canadians eyes.

His time to govern is up and now he should get out of office before we the people are forced to physically remove him from the seat he warms up while in the house of commons.


Will in Calgary
said

Canadians did vote and this is the Parliament we got. You have to cooperate in a minority, and Harper (deliberately) has no friends and he has no plan. Goodbye poppet.


rodney
said

lifetime liberal supporter. simple to the point...NO LONGER


Pam in Waterloo
said

Dion can't even make a decent tape and get it to the networks on time. (apparently with 2 days notice?)

But he thinks he can run a country?

Harper is our Prime Minister. Dion is the pretender--and not a very good one at that.

The question should not be whether the PM has the confidence of the house--in a minority, no PM ever will.

The question is "Who did the people choose?" "Who has the confidence of the Canadian people?" All polls are showing Harper is still the PM of choice.

That's democracy. Dion and Layton must lose their delusions of grandeur and accept the will of the people.


Jim in NS
said

Harper stated the facts, this is what needs to be done and what we are doing as we were elected to do.
Dion sounded like he was still in election mode. HELLO,YOU LOST ALREADY GET OVER IT!!
The seperatists...well what did you expect him to say, "we will divide and conquor!! oops is the mike on?"
Layton...oh man, he's just chomping at the bit. The thought of the ndp having some significant power for the firsttime ever...he's willing to promise anything and everything just to sit at the big boys table.

The election is over, this is a wake up to Harper he has a minority, but he is still the PM! It's wrong to steal what you can't win legitimately.


THINK!!!
said

Parliment has been reduced to a group of squabbling children fighting over a juice box. Sit down and do what you are being overpaid for!


Jay Kitchener
said

The Governor General needs to call an election. The Conservative budget plan is flawed, but the Coalition won't even tip their hand a bit on what their country saving plan might be.

The bottom line is Canadians have had enough of this farce we call Ottawa. It doesn't matter which side of the fence you're on, you have to agree to that.

The reason voter turnout was so low in the election is because most of the general populace sees the leaders for what they've shown to be during this affair: power hungry. Until someone comes out of the rank and file and wows Canadians (this sound familiar yet?), you're going to see similar results.

However, put it to a vote for Canada. Ask who should be Prime Minister if another minority is elected, and also flat out ask the country on the very same ballot whether they support an industry bailout.

At least if that were done, these clowns could say "Canadians want this, they voted for it" and actually have something to back it up with.


MR. & MRS. NICHOLSON
said

We say No to this coalition !! We want our voices heard ! We want Mr. Harper to lead
with the mandate the voters gave him. We want the rest of the parties to work with him - or we want a vote on it!! We did not elect the them(the NDP or the LIB) because we do not feel they have Canada's best interest at heart and now they have proved it. Let MR. HARPER DO HIS JOB!!HE HAS OUR SUPPORT!


Jason
said

This hijacking of parliament is ridiculous! Dion's pathetic attempt at gaining power is just down right sad. What kind of delusional world does he live in? Here's to democracy!


Honesty
said

CBC had no problem broadcasting an important speech.


Diana Kinnear
said

Mr Dion, we told you in the election we don't want you or Mr Layton. If you take out your separatist Bloc supporters, the Conservatives have a majority. You ask for time to put together your budget and investigate how best to work through this economic time - then let Mr Harper, and the duly elected governing party do the same. They are working towards a reasonable budget, let them finish. During the election campaign you had no plan, you said you would need 100 days to put a plan in place. Mr Harper is working on his plan. let him do his job. Work with the party that was elected to serve us Cdns, make an effort to propose reasonable financial plans. Your actions, you and Mr Layton are blatant attempts to get power when the people have spoken and said we don't want you.


john murdoch
said

My goodness. What is Mr. Dion doing. That was a terrible clip of him. Is he being sabatoged from within.

I would prefer that Harper give a few cabinet posts to the Libs and get along. If that is not good enough for them then lets go to the polls. Jack is a windbag.



Evan
said

Speak for yourself Michael! Two thirds of us voted against Harper! We can work together; We can stimulate our economy and support the working people of this Great Country! For the first time in years the Government will represent the majority of voters!


Diane M.
said

Although Harper's speech didn't contain much meat,it has been pretty clear that no matter what he said it made no difference to the Coalition of Clowns. Mr. Dion's speech was so pitiful I almost felt sorry for him. However, I am too busy feeling sorry for our country.


Matthew - Ottawa
said

What a misleading hypocrite!
He really does not understand what a parliamentary system does, especially in his context of a minority government.
He is going against the basic principles of responsible government which were established generations ago! When the House loses confidence in its Prime Minister, it turns to the next possible choice, which in this case is a coalition. A coalition which comprises parties who have diametrically opposing views - which should speak volumes in itself. But the CONS don't get it!
To think that less than 40% of the Canadian populace voted for them...


fitzz
said

I've just watched the CTV video stream of the PM's address. Apparently, the occasion was un-important enough to draw M. DeYawn's full attention. Talk about blowing it big time!

I considered Harper's address to be masterful and urge to consideration of just what he said and how. The speech was in English only. I assume that there was a follow-up unilingual address en francais. This tactic alone was probably a good idea. The last thing some redneck in Alberta needs to hear at this point is anything French.

No olive branch was extended. I believe that the confrontation and digging in is a good idea. It's time we had someone in charge in Ottawa with something resembling gonads. Brooking no acceptance with separatists is only about 30+ years overdue. Bravo!

The Government HAS the confidence of the House of Commons. It received this following the debate on the Throne Speech. A party has confidence until it actually and specifically loses it. Clearly, that was set to happen on Monday next. Harper's likely request for a prorogation is merely a procedural means of avoiding that defeat. Reasonable tactics in power politics, non? A January date for a new session is reasonable and provides for a necessary (for the conspirators) cooling off. Remember, he could ask for up to a year.

The GG simply has no choice but to grant a requested prorogation, when it comes. Should she not do so, Harper would immediately resign and be absolved of a further burden. The can of worms would then be hers. At least Julian Byng was a well loved Commander in Chief!



Steve the Pundit
said

Harper delivered a calm, measured, reasonable speech that sought to reassure a shaken public and that he would stand up and defend the unity of the country; exactly what I would expect the Prime Minister of Canada to do.

Dion's "sky-is-falling" bleating does nothing to reassure the Canadian electorate and does nothing to back his claim that the current government isn't acting fast enough to deal with the economy.

I've been worried sick that these jokers actually had a shot at kidnapping the will of the electorate for their own selfish personal gain; based on the performance of the two principals in this drama tonight, I'm a lot less worried.


Pissed Off
said

To quote Dion: "In our Canada, the government is accountable for its decisions and actions in Parliament. In our Canada, the government derives its legitimacy from an elected Parliament." That's right, Mr. Dion - ELECTED PARLIAMENT, not a "coalition". Go back under the rock you came out from under, and take Jack Layton and Gilles Duceppe with you.


Maggy
said

I agree with you Michael. I'm upset that Mr. Dion's speech took place late. I suspect that he did his speech after he listened to Mr. Harper's. This is unacceptable to me. The coalition (all three) are now speaking out after the fact. I want Mr. Harper to stay in power. We voted him in and it should be up to the people to say whether he stays in government or not. Not three individuals who were defeated.


C
said

I never asked Stephen Harper to run this country. Neither did 62% of voters. Harper showed that he only cares about killing the opposition and pushing through his own agenda. Enough is enough!


Christine
said

Mr. Harper said it exactly right. We should get a vote on this. It angers me to think that the Liberals and the NDP feel they have the right to make up their own government without the permission of Canadian voters. In his response to Mr. Harper, Mr.Dion said that if he is given the opportunity to be the Prime Minister he would try to do a good job. My response to him is simply this: Canadians did not give you that opportunity in the last election, so you have absolutely no right to be Prime Minister unless and until Canada votes for it.


Marcel
said

All politicians are a joke. Lately it seems they are more interested in just keeping their grip on power here in Canada and not really caring what the people think.


Mark
said

Harper answered every critique from Dion and more. The coalition is making adesparate power grab adn treatign the Canadian public with utter disrespect. Eleciton now or prorogue now.


John_Downtown_TO
said

Well nothing new from Stevo. He hasn't swayed my opinion to his side one bit. Total waste of 5 minutes TV time. I found Dion much more sincere. Caught his speech on CBC. Bring on the coalition!!!


Karbin Twelve
said

What does Harper mean by "that Canada's government will use every legal means at our disposal to protect our democracy, to protect our economy, and to protect Canada."?


John in Toronto
said

Harper went on TV and attacked everyone he could think of.
Dion went on TV and told Canada what he wanted to do.
I think that says it all right there.

One of those two men is 'not a leader'
And that man is Stephen Harper


kate
said

Good man, stand your ground. And MR Dion, regarding your comment about having the grace to accept come what may - may I suggest you take your own advice and accept with good grace that we do NOT want you as Prime Minister nor do the majority of Canadians support an auto workers union bailout - not with my tax dollars. Let's help the real poor in this country not the over privelaged. And I'm sick of paying Quebec 68% more in transfer payments than any other province - it's time they stood up for themselves and paid their own way like the rest of us. Thank you.


John
said

I do not support this coalition. Harper was very convincing. Think of Canada -- say no to this coalition.


Winnipegger
said

Hazzah! A good, professional, and fair assessment of the situation.

What a change in Canadian politics...

Go Harper! The New Libs on the Bloc should be ashamed of trying to change power without an election.


ian
said

The tape of the coalition speech unavailable for how long?

These guys say they can run the country yet they can not deliver a tape to a newsroom with 2 days notice


Michael
said

I want Harper running the show as WE CANADIANS ASKED HIM TO DO!

Dion spoke as if he were running yet he seems to recall he was defeated a month ago.

Harper said today in the House repeatedly that he was more than willing to work with the opposition as long as they dropped this unholy alliance with the Bloc.

CANADIANS DO NOT SUPPORT THIS SEPARATIST COALITION.



Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV.ca Special

Coalition FAQ

Changing governments without an election. Can they do this?

Interactive

Who's who in the House of Commons: Find out where your MP sits.

CTV Video Player

Harper address

Stephen Harper's address

Watch Stephen Harper's address to the Canadian people and reaction from analysts and pollsters.

Mike Duffy Live

Mike Duffy Live - Wednesday, Dec. 3

With Governor General Michaelle Jean back in Canada, there is no shortage of reaction to the coalition.

Question period

Question period: Wednesday, Dec. 3

The economy, separatists and old deals between Harper and Duceppe take centre-stage.

Dhalla

MPs weigh in

Watch candid answers from MPs outside the House of Commons when CTV puts them in the hot seat.

A member of the media watches question period on a television in the foyer of the House of Commons in Ottawa, on Tuesday, Dec. 2, 2008. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Pulse of the nation

A bloodless coup or democratic success? The idea of a coalition has Canadians speaking out.

CTV's Question Period

CTV's Question Period

With the Tories teetering on the edge because of economic policy, Craig Oliver asks Finance Minister Jim Flaherty the tough questions.

Today's Top Stories

Investigators remove a package containing a human foot from the Conservative Party of Canada office in Ottawa, Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Human foot was in package sent to Tory HQ: coroner

More  3 Video(s) 3

Research in Motion's headquarters are seen in Waterloo, Ont. on Monday, May 28, 2012.

RIM hires J.P. Morgan, RBC to review business

More  1 Video(s) 1

Syrian charge d'affaires Bashir Akbik speaks with CTV News outside of the Syrian embassy in Ottawa on Tuesday, May 29, 2012.

Syrian diplomat denounces expulsion from Canada

More   33 Comments 33    6 Video(s) 6