Top Stories -   

Catholic school board to vote on HPV vaccine

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Lisa LaFlamme with the moral conflict
CTV Newsnet: Moira McQueen, Canadian Catholic Bioethics Institute

Font-size: Bigger  Smaller  Share Share Print Print Comments Comments(19)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Sep. 18 2007 11:37 PM ET

A Toronto school board is set to vote on whether to allow public health nurses to give its young students a vaccine against HPV, a common sexually transmitted disease linked to cervical cancer.

The Ontario government is offering the human papilloma virus vaccine to all Grade 8 girls, but some catholic school boards have questioned whether the program promotes sexual activity among teens.

Late Tuesday night, the Halton Catholic District School Board narrowly voted to approve use of the vaccine.

But Ontario's Huron-Superior Catholic District School Board has already instituted a ban on the program, and the Toronto District Catholic School Board is expected to vote on the issue Wednesday.

Toronto board chair Oliver Carroll said "you can't bury your head in the sand," and said the vaccines are not a green light for premarital sex.

"I will leave it to the parents and the daughter to sort out their ethics, but in the meantime I believe we have an obligation to give them the protection they may need," he said.

A letter from Ontario's conference of Bishops had urged the Halton board not to make the vaccine available to its students on religious grounds.

"Infection with HPV or other sexually transmitted diseases can occur only through sexual activity, which carries with it profound risks to a young person's spiritual, emotional, moral and physical health," they wrote.

"The Bishops note that, at best, a vaccine can only be potentially effective against one of these risks, that to physical health, and may have other unintended and unwanted consequences."

The HPV vaccine is effective against 70 per cent of cervical cancers. And according estimates by the Canadian Cancer Society, 1,350 women will be diagnosed with cervical cancer this year in Canada and 390 will die of the disease.

Health Canada estimates that up to 75 per cent of sexually active Canadians will have at least one HPV infection in their lifetime.

Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty said the Halton and Toronto board's reluctance to vaccinate its students shows an emerging ideological division in Ontario's public education system.

But he said the vaccines could still be given to students through the public health system.

"Ultimately ... we're going to deliver this through public health,'' he said Tuesday in Crosby, Ont. "I think in an ideal world, we'd rather do it through the schools because it's simpler and more convenient for parents and for kids.

"But, you know, if we run into a lot of resistance from a particular school board, we can -- we've already thought this through -- we can do it through public health."

Progressive Conservative Leader John Tory, currently campaigning against McGuinty for the October 10 election, said the school board should take advantage of the free vaccine program.

"I would like to hope all school boards will co-operate in making sure these vaccines are available and that if there is anybody who doesn't want to have the vaccine, that's a parental decision as opposed to a school board decision," he said in Belleville, Ont.

With a report by CTV's Lisa LaFlamme and files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

MJB
said

Once again the religious looking out for the health and well being of their children...

It is time for secular only education in Ontario


Steve
said

I would like to see the results of an assessment of the risks versus the benefits, conducted by an independent body. I certainly don't support refraining because of religious reasons, but I would support refraining if the benefits did not warrant the risks.


Steven Booth
said

Sure, they are debating it now but eventually they will require it despite assurances that parents can opt out. The slow creep of government control of every aspect of our lives continues.

Just another reason to homeschool your children.


Tobey St. Arnault
said

I continue to be shocked at the all or nothing attitude that some people appear to have regarding the HPV vaccine and sexual promiscuity. Just because we have the means to prevent a large number of the strains of HPV which lead to cervical cancer does not give our children carte blanche to have sex. I am writing this as a mother, a nurse, and as a woman who married into a Catholic family who is raising her children in the Catholic faith. There are a hundred reasons why we should still be teaching our children the virtues of abstinence as many dangers can still arise from premature sexual activity. Physical for one. There are still many other looming sexually transmitted diseases out there, including those strains of HPV not covered by the vaccine. There are social and psychological reasons as well. Kids that are out there having sex in their early teens are likely not mature enough to handle the emotions associated with it. And let's not forget spiritual and moral reasons which are deeply held by many faiths. I just wish many of those out there opposed to the vaccine purely on a spiritual basis can look at the issue in its entirety and realize that there are other elements to consider and that the vaccine is not a licence to have sex. It makes me wonder what would or will happen when we hopefully discover a vaccine for HIV/AIDS which is primarily transmitted via sexual intercourse and IV drug use. Are we going to experience the same backlash? The ethical question I have now is, as parents, can witholding the vaccine not be seen as a form of punishment for our children acting out in a way that we morally do not agree with. Is it ok to say that you deserve the consequences of your actions even if it means death, in a world now that has the means to prevent such a death? I could not do that to my children and it scares me that some people can.


Phil VT
said

Just say 'no'? Has anyone reading this ever witnessed the reaction of a health care practitioner when you say 'no' to a vaccine? They treat you like you are insane and attempt to heap all kinds of guilt on you for not pumping you children full of toxins. And it's not really the parents decision - students can have the vaccine administered without parental consent or knowledge.


R H
said

Well I am sure that the HPV Vaccine will NOT encourage young teenage girls, especially the Catholic Girls that all the fuss is about, to have sex early in life. I think that wearing skirts of a length an inch (maximum) above the knee would go a long way to making the girls look less like hookers and more like students. Also it would probably help to lessen the teenage sex at an early age. Just look at the girls on the news.... Most are showing their underwear almost!
Time for the School Boards to clamp down on this sort of exhibitionist attitude.


Stephanie Hartlen
said

As a student, I think it is extremely important these vaccinations are given in schools. I see what happens in my school and it is sad that so many cases could have been helped because of a simple vaccination. This does not give students the wrong idea either. If they are going to have sex they are going to do it with or without the vaccination, so the safer the better. The vaccination also makes it more real for students that these diseases exist, so they may think twice before acting.


Eric L
said

Saying the vaccine encourages kids to have sex is the same as saying the free condoms they give away at some health units promote them to have sex as well. This is a totally baseless argument and the ONLY argument should be focused around the effectiveness of this vaccine and whether the drugmaker is going to make a legislated profit. I say wait till the other developer (yes there is another HPV vaccine developer) comes to market with their product and then let the price dictate which one we buy.


Laurie
said

It's about time the Catholic clergy stands up and speak against this modern day garbage. Who knows what kind of side effects these ... vaccinations will cause later. The Church is right the best way to prevent STD's is by practicing celibacy! Why should one lower oneself by prostituting herself to so many men during her lifetime. They should wait till they're married.


Debi
said

Maybe we should record the girls who do not get the vaccine in the regions against it and send them the medical bill when these girls develop cancer. On the other hand, we could make one and only one school system with religious classes in the curriculum for any and all religions in the area. Any government up for the challenge?


bob
said

For years,mothers have made birth control available to their daughters, and if not the mothers, then the health profession. this is an admission that their children are having unprotected sex.
The vaccine gives an added protection against something that could affect these young women in their desire to hav children when they are old enough to want a family of their own.


Thomas Chan
said

I understood the religious view point from the Catholic District School, however, the vaccine is to the best health interest of the girls. Also, banning at Catholic Schools will not stop accesssing the vaccines from the public health care system. More enhanced health education on sexual transmitted diseases should be done to prevent and protect girls, rather than debating girls will abuse from vaccinations


leanne
said

The whole push for this makes me uneasy. Remember a few years ago there was a huge push by WHO to vaccinate women and girls for tetanus. Turns out that Mexico, the Philippines, and Nicaragua tested their vaccines and found that they contained hGC hormone... This is the hormone that is produced during pregnancy. when bound with the tetnus toxoid carrier it makes the body produce antbodies to hGC as well as tetnus. In light of the push here to vaccinate young girls for hpv, I think caution is in order. This is my own personal opinion, but I do not trust vaccines or the makers of them. I have a sneaky feeling that there's going to be consequences noticed in about 15 years.


Erin
said

Of course, it's always the GIRLS in those short skirts, who prostitute themselves to multiple partners before marriage, who are solely responsible for their immoral behaviour and the consequences thereof. Ummm....I doubt they're only having sex by themselves...why are their (in this case presumably male) partners not held accountable to this same moral code? Just curious.


Joanne
said

It just takes one time, at any age in a woman's life, to become infected. Opting out is a parent's choice but it is perhaps the biggest decision their daughter may have to live with for the rest of their life. Which is the lesser evil? Our children are how we raise them.


JR
said

Logic - man and woman both who have never had sex, get married, have sex - chance of getting STD of any sort - unlikely! All Christian faiths and other non-Christian faiths who belive in "marriage", not only Catholics should stand up for their faith! I would gladly give my life and hope my children would as well for eternal life vs a life of sin here on earth. Eternity vs a couple one night stands - you make the logical choice. I thought we lived in a country with a majority of Christians - no one would know...


BP from Windsor
said

This is the biggest reason why there should be only one school system without special interest influence
Here is something that has the potential to prevent a rather vicious type of cancer not to mention the results of the STD itself. If your teachings of abstaining from sexual activity will be defeated by giving the young ones the HPV vaccine and for that matter condoms then you did not do a good job of teaching therefore it makes it even more important to protect them.

kris
said

Well it appears that God lost out to common sense and the Vaccine will be offered.

We created God, why is it that we say that God created us in His image, but anyone who fails to live up to the standards set by mortals in the Catholic ruling class people are not living "right" or according to "His" teaching or some such drivel. Sex is natural, as natural as anything, self preservation is just as natural, why is it wrong to keep people from dying (Self preservation) from sex (natural, and well lets face it necessary). It's time parent's took the responsibility for raising their children away from God and those who would be so fraudulent as to assume that they speak for him, if in fact he exists at all. The argument here shouldn't be about a vaccine, it should be about parents regognizing the evolving world in which our children develop and adjusting to the new challenges they face, sex education, and simple survival techniques(emotional, physical, and social) are how we prepare our offspring for the world.
Religion is evil, and misleading. Those who assume power through the manipulation of faith are interested in no ones best interest but their own.

Gin
said

My fear is the long-term effects. No, the drug company has not spoken out on this! They can't because the simply don't know. Think of all the vaccines that have been given & have produced horrible long-term effects.

The anecdotal evidence been heard in the news, is that some young girls are experiencing some significant side effects already. Some of these have reversed themselves over several months but what if your young girl's side effects didn't.

The religious aspect has nothing to do with the issue. Why are parents, of any religion, handing over the long-term health of their daughters or granddaughter to men? (Catholic councils, or government - dominated by men). It simply astounds me!

I am a grandmother, a nurse and a Catholic but I will continue to raise my granddaughter with the good communication between us & talk about sex, emotions & what love really is. If she becomes sexually active in her later teen years, then I will stress contraception & condoms - for every occasion, until marriage.

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Facebook

Share this article with Facebook

DIGG

Share this article with Digg

Newsvine

Share this article with Newsvine

Delicious

Share this article with delicious

Email

Share this article.
Send Email

Twitter

Share this article with Twitter

StumbleUpon

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Reddit

Share this article with Reddit

Yahoo! Buzz

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

While the environment is indeed of huge import, everyone needs to remember our civilization is not yet ready to turf the use of oil in our everyday lives. Yes, we need to look to alternatives, but please don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. We are not there yet. The environmentalists need to get a grip and quit whining. And the US needs to learn to look after its own house before it tries to run someone else's.

Colleen in BC

Pelosi to hear both sides of oilsands debate in Ottawa