News Sections
Lipsticks and lead: The rankings
By: CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. Oct. 12 2007 5:37 PM ET
The Campaign for Safe Cosmetics had 33 brand-name lipsticks tested by an independent laboratory. The lipsticks were purchased in Boston, Ma., Hartford, Conn., San Francisco, Ca. and Minneapolis, Mn.
The group includes this text as part of its "buyer beware" list:
"The lipsticks tested for this report may or may not be representative of the entire lipstick market. The lead levels could vary widely for other shades, and as the results below demonstrate, levels are not consistent by brand, shade or state of purchase," it says.
"This list should not be used to decide which brands are safe or unsafe. Instead it highlights two important findings: First, there is lead in some lipsticks and consumers cannot determine which those are from the ingredients, the price or the brand. Second, there are lipsticks containing no detectable levels of lead at every price level."
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has said it would examine the findings, but warned that similar claims had not been confirmed in the past.
| Lipsticks with less than 0.02 parts per million (ppm) lead | |||||
| Brand | Product Name/Shade |
Lead | Parent Company |
State | Purchase Date |
| Avon | Ultra Color Rich Cherry Jubilee |
<0.02 | Avon | MA* | 08/27/07 |
| Body Shop | Lip Colour Garnet | <0.02 | L'Oreal | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Body Shop | Lip Colour Garnet | <0.02 | L'Oreal | CA | 08/27/07 |
| Clinique | Long Last Lipstick Merlot |
<0.02 | Estee Lauder | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Dior | Replenishing Lipcolor Red Premiere |
<0.02 | LVMH | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Estee Lauder | Maraschino | <0.02 | Estee Lauder | MN | 08/26/07 |
| MAC | Matte Lipstick Viva Glam 1 |
<0.02 | Estee Lauder | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Revlon | Superlustrous Love That Red |
<0.02 | Revlon | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Revlon | Superlustrous Bed of Roses |
<0.02 | Revlon | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Revlon | Colorstay Lipcolor Red Velvet |
<0.02 | Revlon | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Tarte | Inside Out Vitamin Lipstick |
<0.02 | Tarte | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Wet N Wild | Wild Mega Colors Cherry Blossom |
<0.02 | Markwins | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Wet N Wild | Wild Mega Colors Cherry Blossom |
<0.02 | Markwins | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Lipsticks with detectable levels of lead but less than 0.1 ppm lead (the FDA-recommended limit for candy) | |||||
| MAC | Matte Lipstick Viva Glam |
0.03 | Estee Lauder | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Revlon | Love That Red | 0.03 | Revlon | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Cover Girl | Queen Collection Ruby Remix |
0.03 | P & G | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Clinique | Long Last Paprika | 0.03 | Estee Lauder | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Dior | Replenishing Lipcolor Red Premiere |
0.04 | LVMH | CA | 08/26/07 |
| Body Shop | Garnet | 0.06 | L'Oreal | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Wet N Wild | Cherry Frost | 0.06 | Markwins | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Clinique | Red | 0.09 | Estee Lauder | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Burt's Bees | Lip Shimmer Merlot | 0.09 | Burt's Bees | MA | 08/29/07 |
| Lipsticks with lead levels higher than 0.1 ppm | |||||
| Maybelline | NY Moisture Extreme Scarlet Simmer |
0.11 | L'Oreal | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Cover Girl | Incredifull Lipcolor Maximum Red |
0.12 | P & G | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Peacekeeper | Paint Me Compassionate |
0.12 | Peacekeeper | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Maybelline | NY Moisture Extreme Midnight Red |
0.18 | L'Oreal | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Maybelline | NY Moisture Extreme Cocoa Plum |
0.19 | L'Oreal | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Dior | Addict Positive Red | 0.21 | LVMH | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Cover Girl | Continuous Color Cherry Brandy |
0.28 | P & G | CA | 08/23/07 |
| L'Oreal | Colour Riche True Red |
0.50 | L'Oreal | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Cover Girl | Incredifull Lipcolor Maximum Red |
0.56 | P & G | MN | 08/26/07 |
| L'Oreal | Colour Riche Classic Wine |
0.58 | L'Oreal | CT | 08/27/07 |
| L'Oreal | Colour Riche True Red |
0.65 | L'Oreal | CA | 08/23/07 |
User Tools
Related Stories
Related Websites
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
Perhaps they should look at reducing duties resellers must pay for products coming from the US to Canada in order to level the field? Then it would be prudent for the resellers to offer competitive pricing and good service to maintain a loyal customer base.
Email