Top Stories -   

1
Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz attends a news conference at the National Press Theatre in Ottawa on Wednesday Aug. 27, 2008. (Sean Kilpatrick  / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Paul Mayers of the Public Health Agency listens to media questions during a news conference at the National Press Theatre in Ottawa on Wednesday, Aug. 27, 2008. (Sean Kilpatrick  / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A sign at a Metro store advising customers that Maple Leaf products found on their shelves are not part of the recall is seen in Montreal Wednesday, Aug. 27, 2008. A sign at a Metro store is seen in Montreal (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS) To determine if a Maple Leaf Foods product is affected by the recall, look for either a Crown Seal with the establishment number 97B or an inkjet imprint of Est97B (shown here) near the Best Before Date associated with the recall. (Maple Leaf Foods Inc. / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz attends a news conference at the National Press Theatre in Ottawa on Wednesday Aug. 27, 2008. (Sean Kilpatrick  / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Agriculture minister defends food inspection process

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Chief Health Officer Dr. Butler-Jones
A discussion about whether Canada's food inspection is to be blamed for the massive nationwide outbreak of listeriosis that has been linked to at least 15 deaths.
CTV National News: Rob Brown on the human toll in the outbreak
Officially the death toll is low from the listeriosis, but many people are sick. Others are wondering if the meat supply is safe.
CTV National News: Rosemary Thompson covers Maple Leaf Meats problems
With the outbreak of listeriosis claiming more lives across the country, the company at the centre of the crisis is taking full responsibility.
CTV Newsnet: Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and heath officials update the listeria investigation, part one
Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and a number of heath officials hold a press conference to update the public about the investigation into the listeria outbreak
CTV Newsnet: Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and heath officials update the listeria investigation, part two
Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and a number of heath officials answer questions about the investigation into the listeria outbreak.
CTV Newsnet: Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and heath officials update the listeria investigation, part three
Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and a number of heath officials answer questions about the investigation into the listeria outbreak.
CTV Newsnet: Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and heath officials update the listeria investigation, part four
Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz and a number of heath officials answer questions about the investigation into the listeria outbreak.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (5)Add Comments Facebook   

Date: Thu. Aug. 28 2008 5:54 PM ET

The number of deaths in Canada being blamed on a nationwide outbreak of listeriosis has grown from five to eight.

All three of the latest victims are from Ontario, Mark Razienne of the Public Health Agency of Canada said at Thursday's press conference. Their cases had previously been on a list of deaths under investigation.

At the same press conference, Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz continued his defence of Canada's food inspection system but backtracked on an earlier claim that inspectors spend half their time at meat-processing plants.

The inspectors' union challenged that claim, and now Ritz says the 50-50 split between paperwork inspections and floor inspections is the way the system is designed -- but not necessarily the way it actually works.

Paul Mayers, of The Canadian Food Inspection Agency, said the criticism that inspectors spent most of their time doing paperwork is a "derogatory" way of describing their work. He said the paperwork side of the job is just as important as work on the plant floor.

Earlier in the day, Ritz told Canada AM the country has a world-class food inspection process, but more resources are being added to boost its effectiveness.

"There's a lot of mixed messages," Ritz said. "The opposition parties are screaming that we're cutting funding. Nothing could be further from the truth. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to add up the numbers and see there's 113 million new dollars going into the system."

Ritz denied reports based on a leaked government memo that suggested anticipated changes to the federal food inspection system may have already been in use at the Toronto plant.

Ritz said the memo actually dealt with slaughtering processes, not processing guidelines, and wasn't relevant to the listeria outbreak.

Adding to the list

The announcement of further deaths confirmed with the outbreak came as more products were added to the growing recall list of potentially tainted foods.

Cooked ham and salami sandwiches sold in Sobeys, Foodland and IGA stores in Ontario may contain listeria monocytogenes, the bacteria that has been linked to 15 deaths.

The sandwiches are made with both whole wheat and white bread and were in 900, 450 and 220-gram packages and are marked as having been packed as recently as Aug. 24, 2008.

The Canadian Food Inspection Agency also added certain Kirkland Signature platters to its list of products that could contain listeria.

Kirkland Signature brand croissant and meat-and-cheese platters -- which carry best-before dates up to and including Aug. 28 and 29, respectively -- may contain meat products already recalled by Maple Leaf Foods. The platters were sold at Costco outlets across Canada.

The products were added to a list that now includes more than 220 food items manufactured at the Toronto Maple Leaf foods plant at the centre of the outbreak.

A family mourns

Meanwhile, an Ontario family prepared for the funeral of the 89-year-old great-grandmother they say died from listeriosis and as

The funeral for Frances Clark, of Madoc, Ont. was held Thursday.

She was described by her daughter as an active and healthy octogenarian who made the "best raspberry pie in the world" before she suddenly fell ill last week, then died on Monday.

It has not been confirmed whether Clark was infected by the same strain in the outbreak that originated at the Toronto plant.

Her daughter Karen Clark said her mother began feeling ill on Wednesday night. By Thursday she had a headache, and by Friday when she was taken to hospital her eyes were fixed and staring, and she was non-verbal.

On Sunday, a doctor confirmed a blood sample was positive for listeria, By Monday, she was dead.

"It hit so fast and so furious and so cruel, I mean one minute you have her and the next you don't," Karen Clark told CTV's Canada AM.

"Somewhere along the line something happened. We can't even get to the grief stage yet because we don't even know what to think, where to begin."

Clark leaves behind two children, four grandchildren and four great-grandchildren, her daughter said.

Full responsibility

On Wednesday, president of Maple Leaf Foods, Michael McCain, took full responsibility for the outbreak.

"We have an unwavering commitment to keep our food safe, and we have excellent systems and processes in place. But this week it's our best efforts that failed, not the regulators or the Canadian food safety system," said McCain at a press conference in Toronto.

According to the Public Health Agency of Canada there are 29 confirmed cases of the outbreak strain in the country, resulting in 15 deaths -- 12 in Ontario, and one each in Saskatchewan, B.C. and Quebec.

With files from the Canadian Press

1

Add New Comment ( )

Norm in Ontario
said
0 0

What is it with Conservatives and inspectors. With these reports of inspectors doing things other than inspecting, here in Ontario it harkens us back to Walkerton in 2000. The strange thing is many of the same faces are in charge.


AWL
said
0 0

The government cannot say the system failed because it will raise questions about the ideology of deregulation and 'free markets'. They must have a proactive public message to protect one of their main agendas; privatization and deregulation. Public debate must be steered away from any such topics.

Also note the 'international standards' referenced, which of course means the US-FDA. The US Supreme Court has recently cited the FDA as 'neglecting its regulatory duties and acting as an agent for the industry its meant to regulate.' And our governments plan to 'improve' the Canadian system by making it more like the US system. Lucky us.


Mr. Graham Stanners
said
0 0

Ritz said: "Canada has one of the most stringent food safety systems in the world, but it can always be better...That's why we are investing $113 million in Canada's food and consumer action plan and [hiring] 200 more inspectors".

Im glad to hear that they are reacting to the problem, but where was this investment and the inspectors before the outbreak. It is assuring, even though there is a PR undertone, to hear Mr. McCain of Maple Leaf Foods shoulder the blame, but clearly he is taking responsibility to ensure that this doesn't happen again. Yet, Mr. Ritz, the Conservative Agriculture Minister is more concerned about an election and doesn't want the voting public to read the tea leaves and understand that his gov't dropped the ball on this problem and wasn't doing a sufficient job of providing adequate resources for CFIA.

Mr. Harper and the Conservatives must share blame (not equally, but to a certain degree) in this problem, they oversee CFIA, and they must ensure that front-line inspectors have required training and expertise to do their job, but also to ensure that there is a swift response, not mounting deaths in Canada.


Bedore
said
0 0

I watched this new conference and each one emphasized how good our food inspection was. I was in awe. fifteen people have died. I think there is a problem.


Doug
said
0 0

This:

"Canada has one of the most stringent food safety systems in the world..."

is much the same sort of thing that they were saying when Mad Cow first cropped up in Canada.

The truth in that case was that the Canadian system was far from being a world leader in food safety.

That a minister can come out and say, roughly, that 'the system works' in spite of a number of deaths is incredible.

I wonder why it's not possible to be honest and frank, instead, and say "This is a terrible tragedy and the system failed. We will fix it."


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest
Recalled Meat

Recalled Meat

Here is the full list of recalled meat products.

listeria bacterium

Listeria Q&A

What you need to know, and how you can protect yourself.

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges