Sci-Tech -   

1

Could floating trash become island paradise?

An artistic rendition of Ramon Knoester's Recycled island concept. (Photo courtesy of Ramon Knoester) Ramon Knoester, of the Netherlands, has been developing his Recycled island concept for the past few years. (Photo courtesy of Ramon Knoester) An artistic rendition of Ramon Knoester's Recycled island concept. (Photo courtesy of Ramon Knoester)
An artistic rendition of Ramon Knoester's Recycled island concept. (Photo courtesy of Ramon Knoester)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (26) Facebook   

Date: Sunday Mar. 6, 2011 6:30 PM ET

A Dutch engineer has a dream of collecting all the plastic refuse in the Pacific Ocean and using science to transform it into an island paradise.

From his office in the Netherlands, Ramon Knoester has been working towards building a prototype of his project, which seeks to one day use tens of millions of kilograms of plastic debris as raw building material.

Knoester, who is also a trained architect, estimates there is enough plastic floating in the Pacific to build a Hawaii-sized habitat, or an island about 10,000 square kilometres in size.

In theory, he would gather that plastic, heat it up, recycle it and use it to build his creation. To minimize the impact on the environment, Knoester would use solar power to melt down the plastic and avoid bringing in building supplies.

"The main idea at the moment is to add as little material as possible," Knoester told CTV.ca in a telephone interview from Rotterdam.

Knoester imagines that his so-called "Recycled island" would function as a totally green society, powered by solar and wind energy, living off its own agriculture and able to sustain itself at sea.

People would live there and the island would even draw tourists, as its proposed location between Hawaii and San Francisco would provide "the convenience of a location where the weather is always nice," Knoester told ABC News last summer.

But before he can go about engineering his plastic paradise, Knoester will first have to find a way of getting all that debris out of the Pacific.

"The main difficulty is how we're going to get at all these plastic bits without harming any marine life," Knoester told CTV.ca.

Knoester still has yet to put a price tag on his project and he thinks it would take years, at a minimum, to pick up all that plastic circling the globe.

After speaking to many people about his concept, Knoester said that the sheer scale of his idea "for a lot of people is really hard to handle."

Parsing the plastic problem

The plastic problem is not a new one and Knoester is not the first to try to figure it out.

Concerned environmentalists have been warning about the problem for decades, though there is some dispute about how much plastic is really out there.

Amy Fraenkel, a regional director of the United Nations Environment Programme, said the amount of plastic in the oceans "is very difficult to quantify."

Scientists have an understanding of the environmental hazards plastic causes as it breaks down and they know that people are using more plastic products as time goes on. But there is not a clear consensus on how much of that plastic is deposited in the waters around the globe.

"It's alarming that we don't have better data," Fraenkel told CTV.ca in a telephone interview from Washington.

Later this month, a group of scientists, policymakers and other experts will gather in Hawaii for the Fifth International Marine Debris Conference.

Fraenkel said the goal of the conference is to move towards "concrete solutions" on reducing the impact of harmful ocean debris, including the plastic that Knoester hopes to one day collect.

Knoester, whose island concept will be referenced at the upcoming Hawaii conference, only began thinking about the plastic problem a couple of years ago when he was reading a magazine article on the topic.

He was on board on airplane at the time and he looked down at the ocean below as he was reading.

"For about a year I started to look into the concept," said Knoester, noting that he found no project similar to his recycled island on the go during that time. Though, as noted on his website, he did take inspiration from a floating lagoon built out of recycled materials in the late 1990s, and a plastic bottle-catamaran that sailed across the Pacific Ocean last year.

After some initial exploration of the concept, Knoester launched a website to promote his project and has since done dozens of interviews about his island intentions.

He has consulted with experts and he plans to build a small prototype to prove the concept.

"I don't really have the expertise in creating these floating objects yet," he said.

Knoester said the preliminary sketches for his prototype could hit the web by the end of the month.

Comments are now closed for this story

Will
said
0 0

Stupid alert! We must be entering wacko season a little early this year. Instead of pie in the sky silliness, how about "harvesting" all that plastic and recucling it to pay for the cost of the cleanup?


doug
said
0 0

Every nation on earth should donate a certain percentage based on how much plastic that country uses. For the clean up of plastic in our oceans. Personally I feel that plastics in bottles should be totally banned. We have the technology to do better and we should start using it. And I hope we all can petition our law makers so that change can come.


Sax
said
0 0

Most of the plastic in the pacific ocean has been broken up into very small rice sized or smaller pieces, there are larger pieces and microscopic bits, but the average is small mechanically wasted pieces. In order to collect the plastic, which is a cool idea, you would have to 'filter' the water for the pieces, much like a baleen whale filter feeds small invertebrates, to avoid pumping and drying costs, wind could pump the water out to large drying pans (floating?, would have to be huge, so $$$) sun could dry the plastic, and very concentrated sun, say using a sodium collector, could melt the plastic down for reprocessing. It would be useful to separate plastics of differing molecular weight so as to specialized the re-purposed product, as there are a huge array of plastics with different properties, some would make better 'island' superstructure, and some would make better tools and technologies. I suspect that there are natural sorting processes that have taken hold of the plastic cycles now churning in the ocean, if this type of processing were to occur it would probably eventually be determined that the ocean enriches some recoverable plastic chemistries, and depletes others, either through mechanical sorting, chemical interaction, breakdown, leeching, or transformation, ultimately the ocean "could" be found to be enriching low value or low weight plastics, or altering the chemistry to a state of economic non viability. But until self sustaining forms of energy like the wind and solar you stated work in our economy as well as in self sustaining, we will not see any miraculous plastic islands forming while the ocean is cleaned up anytime soon.


Sheryl Skelley
said
0 0

I think it's a great idea, & as for Geralds comment, I live in a state & have landfill called MT. Trashmore that methane is recovered via pipes, compressed & stored & used as fuel in city vehicles, but the lake is intensly polluted !!!!


Davis
said
0 0

With all that junk plastic used to make the new island I've got the perfect name for it: "MADE IN CHINA".


HCW
said
0 0

Get George Soros, Warren Buffet, Bill Gates to build the damn island with their mega old miser cash. Old man Soros has way too much time on his hands plotting the crash of countries, their currency so this new project should get him out of hell's evil kitchen and into doing something good for the world before he croaks. Maybe it will get him to St. Peter's pearly gates if he is a good boy!


Doug ^^^ BC
said
0 0

I think "Gerald" is right about how much this would cost.Then you have to go to the nexr logical calcualtion.How much more pollution would be caused by the industry we need to grow to create the wealth that would pay for this idea? It may be that we create more of a mess than we actually clean up. This reminds me of a NASA plan to warm up Mars.They'd start with algae and fungus.Add some CO2 generators,and wait a few thousand years.The greenhouse gases would warm the planet enough to thaw the ice.The algae would absorb sunlight.Small plants would follow,which would produce more oxygen.Etc,etc,etc. All this seems theoretically possible.But I doubt the logistics and cost of actually doing it could be worked out any time soon. Sad though.How so many are so inconsiderate with the way they dispose of products that wil not decompose in a natural way.Not only are our oceans and stream a mess,anywhere you travel in the wilderness is strewn with litter from those who were there before you.Littering seems to be a tradion that goes back to a time when the planet was less populated,so there were fewer people using the wilderness,and a time before man made materials that won't decompose for centuries. Earlier on in the time of man,it was because we didn't know any better.Sadly,now,we know better,but to many people just don't care.


Steve, Halifax
said
0 0

From what I understand, plastic does break up into smaller pieces but at the molecular level it does not break down. If you were to analyze ocean water from any point on Earth, there is plastic in it.


jogc
said
0 0

Are coastal cities still hauling garbage out to sea on barges?


Ron J.
said
0 0

The answer to all of our environmental problems is simple -- Less people. For the sake of argument, if the planet had only five people, then those five could pretty much do what they want. The impact would be ridiculously low. But on the other hand, the population of the world has already doubled in my lifetime. By the time I'm old, the world's population will probably reach 12 billion. There are not enough resources (fish, forest, agricultural land etc) to support that number of people. No amount of green initiatives will make the Earth larger or double our resources. Drastically reduce the world's population, and the impact to the planet will be reduced.


six cents
said
0 0

and then come one big storm, and that new island breaks back into pieces it once came from. LOLGood luck with that Mr engineer!


mining guy Jim
said
0 0

This is a great example of how science, nature and really poor research on the parts of editors looking for a good story go together and fail in an epic fashion. The other day, someone chided me about science, so now sharpen your pencils kiddies and follow me....the story talks about TENS of millions of kilograms in the ocean (a horrible thought but) so let's assume the worst case and say it's 90 million kg. OK? What is the density of PVC? Before I lose those of you who don't care for math, I'm heading in the direction of how thick you want your foundation to be under your new eco-home on novi-hawaii. Let's assume a density of 0.4 tonnes per cubic metre...that means that by HIS calculations not mine, there may be as much as 36,000 cubic metres of discarded plastic in the pacific. Totally disgusting. Now this joker is claiming he is going to make an island 100km by 100km in area...how thin do you have to stretch 36,000 cubic metres to cover 100,000m by 100,000m? It's measured in parts of a millimetre, and I'm sure as heck not building my house there. For all the petrochemical guys out there saying, "damn man, it's not 0.4 it's 0.276" that wouldn't increase my foundation by a millimetre.5 minutes on a calculator would have told you that this was not a story.


JB in Ontario
said
0 0

What a novel idea! It is disgusting to hear of the waste that is dumped in the oceans. It is good to see someone doing something about it!


Joe Spumolio
said
0 0

I wonder what future civilizations will write about us. Will they state the obvious and write that we were basically morons who turned their habitat into a giant cess pool and choked on their own sh%t? We humans have this undeniable belief that if we can't see something, it's not there. Thus the game infants play whereby they cover their eyes and become invisible. Great for an 18 month old but why do we carry this on into adulthood? The amount of waste we've dumped into our waterways is enormous. I know the end is near when someone comes along with an idea like this. It's a sad day, even sadder when one realizes the days are running out.


Pat
said
0 0

How the hell are we supposed to screen the entire pacific ocean....Its only the size of asia...


Peter in Niagara
said
0 0

He'll have to come up with a boat that will sail around the world to collect the trash. But if there really is that much trash out there, it would be very expensive and time consuming to get it all to one location. I think he'd be better off funding a sort of travelling plazma incinerator that will dispose of the trash as you find it. That makes more sense to me, I would even donote to it. Who else?


Peter in Mb
said
0 0

It’s an interesting idea and we need more people in the world to think creatively like this. How ever I would not want to be on this island in the middle of a storm with 30 foot high waves.


Freedom Lover in NT
said
0 0

Wow, this guy's on some fabulous drugs...what utter rubbish, pardon the pun...


average joe
said
0 0

dream on


Brent
said
0 0

It is sad to see that much garbage floating around, just shows how little we care---but if someone can make something good out of something bad------GREAT


Terry in Toronto
said
0 0

Reminds me of the 'Popular Science' / 'Popular Mechanics' magazine articles that make for attention-getting 'artist rendition' cover images, but - once read - leave you feeling like you just ate cotton candy (lots of fluff and colour, but no real substance).


Gerald
said
0 0

Great idea , but the $$$$ would be huge . Who would step up with money to fund something like this? There is an old landfill that I know of that now has a lake on it and a park ...totally clean. These things are possible.


John
said
0 0

The trash we've left floating around the Pacific is something we should all feel ashamed about. I think this guy is really on to something.


Borpo
said
0 0

This should be in the fiction section.


Peter
said
0 0

If we would only use the technology we now have this could easily be solved with plasma incineration.


McFibster
said
0 0

Perhaps we, as a global society, should be using more care about recycling of all plastics and NOT dump it in the ocean to begin with. .....AND why can't we use more solar and wind power as sorces of free energy? In fact, with all the advances in filtering technology, why can't we go back to using incinerators? We could harness that energy as power as well as having far fewer emissions and less plastic thrown into the seas........................................


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Sci-Tech Stories

Models display a Samsung Galaxy S III, the latest smartphone in the company's Galaxy lineups, during its launching for media in Jakarta, Indonesia, Tuesday, May 22, 2012. Samsung said the phone, that has emerged as the biggest competitor to the iPhone, will go on sale in 145 countries with 296 phone companies, making it the company's biggest launch so far. (AP Photo/Dita Alangkara)

Samsung releases latest Galaxy smartphone in Europe

More

Cows are shown grazing on an organic dairy farm in Jordan, Minn., in a May 31, 2006 file photo. (AP / Jim Mone)

Massages and waterbeds boost milk output in cows

More

Surgery

Scientists, doctors use snake robots for surgery

More