Canada in Afghanistan -   

1

Canada should debate Afghanistan: committee

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | Print Facebook   

Date: Monday Jun. 18, 2007 10:49 PM ET

OTTAWA — The House of Commons defence committee says the conflict in Afghanistan will likely go on well past 2009 and Parliament should hold a debate halfway through next year to decide whether to extend Canada's mission in the war-torn country.

The all-party committee's long-awaited reported was tabled on Monday. "If we leave, someone else will have to carry the load," it said. A recent poll found a majority of Canadians wanted to see the army's combat mission end on schedule in February 2009.

The survey by Decima Research, released to The Canadian Press on June 12, found two-thirds of those polled said they would not support an extension.

Only 26 per cent said the military mission should be extended "if that is necessary to complete our goals there."

The Commons committee study, which has been months in the making, said the army's role in fighting the Taliban-led insurgency in the southern region of Afghanistan is largely misunderstood by the Canadian public.

"Critics of the mission have said it is unbalanced and that more diplomatic and development effort is required - and less combat operations," said the committee's report.

"Nearly everyone we met, including military commanders, said more development was needed, but they pointed out that until an adequate degree of security existed, development aid could not flow to the degree desired."

Both the New Democrats and Liberals have made the argument that the existing mission in Kandahar, which began in February 2006, was more about war-fighting than nation-building.

Both the Bloc Quebecois and the New Democrats wrote dissenting reports, with the NDP arguing for an immediate withdrawl of troops from combat operations.

Development aid was slow in arriving following last fall's major Canadian-led offensive - dubbed Operation Medusa - but the committee's report suggested that the Canadian International Development Agency now has a better handle on the situation.

The recent scandal over the alleged abuse of Taliban prisoners captured by Canadians but turned over to Afghan authorities has also further tarnished the views of people back home, the 174 page report concluded.

The committee held hearings in Ottawa, visited military bases in Canada and made a high-profile trip to Kandahar in January. However, the Members of Parliament were not allowed to venture outside of the heavily fortified airfield that NATO uses as its main base in southern Afghanistan.

The committee received most of its briefings from Canadian military and development officials without visiting aid projects - or even speaking to local Afghan officials.

The report noted Afghan "displeasure" with the rising number of civilian deaths, but said that many of the unfortunate cases involved air strikes and that Canada had no combat planes operating in theatre.

As many as 2,400 people, most of them insurgents, have died this year in fighting. A recent Human Rights Watch report said NATO and U.S. military operations killed at least 230 civilians in 2006, but most of the 900 civilian combat fatalities last year were from insurgent attacks.

There has been a lot of critcism and friction over the reluctance of some NATO allies - most notably Germany, Italy and France - to allow their troops in Afghanistan to join the U.S., Canada, Britain and the Netherlands in combat operations in the south.

"We end on a note of humility, acknowledging that many of our close and traditional allies are indeed sharing the burden of combat," the report said.

"Many of them have lost national blood and treasure as Canada has. While we might encourage others to do more, there is no more effective way to bring others along than to continue to play a meaningful role ourselves."

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV News

Soldiers with the Canadian Army's 1st Battalion Royal 22nd Regiment return to base on their final operation Thursday, June 30, 2011 in the Panjwaii district of Kandahar province, Afghanistan. (AP Photo/David Goldman)

Canada in Afghanistan

The latest news, photos and interactives from Canada's mission in Afghanistan.

Canadian Soldiers were injured when a Light Armoured Vehicle (LAV) Turret struck an on coming vehicle, outside Kandahar City, causing it to rotate 360 degrees wounding the two Canadian soldiers. (Cpl. Robin Mugridge / Department of National Defence)

Invisible Wounds

Angela Mulholland: Scope of injury toll in Afghanistan largely a mystery

Brain injuries among soldiers are often overlooked.

Blast-Induced Injuries

Brain injuries among soldiers serving in Afghanistan are often overlooked.

Doctor Louis-Philippe Palerme, right, from Gatineau, Quebec, is assisted by a Danish doctor, Captain Sacha Soelbeck, during a surgery at R3 MMU in Afghanistan.

Medical Advances

Soldiers survived injuries that, even 10 years ago, would have been fatal.

Cpl. Chris Klodt sits in a race chair. Klodt was shot in the neck July 7, 2006 during a Taliban ambush outside Kanadhar. The bullet was lodged in his spinal cord.

Soldiers Overcome Injuries

Wounded soldiers use sports to overcome injuries, adjust to their new reality.

Janis Mackey Frayer in Sperwan Ghar, Afghanistan

Kandahar Journal

Janis Mackey Frayer recounts sombre process of notifying next of kin.

Interactive

War Zone Medics

Lessons Learned

A number of the medical innovations that we now take for granted were conceived and tested during wartime.

Bios and Pictures

Casualties

Canadian Casualties

We remember those who lost their lives in Afghanistan since the mission began in 2002.

In Pictures

Canada's Last Days in Afghanistan

Concluding Combat

50 Pictures: Canadian troops conclude Afghan combat tour after a decade.

Kandahar transfer ceremony

Transfer Ceremony

In Pictures: Canada transfers control of Kandahar region to the U.S

Harper in Afghanistan

Harper in Afghanistan

25 Pictures: Stephen Harper meets with soldiers on his fourth Afghan trip.

Canada in Kandahar

Canada in Kandahar

30 Pictures: New tasks tackled as combat mission nears its end.

Operation Topak Shkar

Operation Topak Shkar

Canadian troops take on the Taliban in Operation Topak Shkar.

Today's Top Stories

Luka Rocco Magnotta, the subject of a Canada-wide search warrant, is shown during an audition for the reality TV show 'Cover Guy' in 2007.

Murder suspect auditioned for reality TV show

More   48 Comments 48    20 Video(s) 20

Gabriel Nadeau Dubois of the CLASSE, centre right, responds to reporters questions after negotiations came to a dead-end with Quebec's minister of education at the legislature in Quebec City on Thursday, May 31, 2012. (Jacques Boissinot / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Talks between Quebec gov't, students collapse

More  4 Video(s) 4