Politics -   

1
Capt. Ian Penner (left) and Bombardier Trevor Johnson of Red Deer, Alta. survey the damage from NATO bombardment in Panjwaii, Afghanistan on Tuesday Sept. 12, 2006. (CP / Les Perreaux) Bibi Sagima and her son, Ghami, beg on the street in Kandahar last week. Sagima took a humiliating seat on a Kandahar street Friday, begging for the first time in her life for food for her eight-year-old son. Sagima is among some 1,500 families who fled the Panjwaii and surrounding areas to avoid fighting and intense bombardment by NATO forces backing a Canadian assault. Her husband disappeared as the fighting began. (CP PHOTO, Abdul Razaq Khan)

Afghans: civilian death toll higher than estimates

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Paul Workman on the Afghan victims
10p_hospital

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | Print Facebook   

Date: Fri. Sep. 22 2006 11:05 PM ET

KANDAHAR, Afghanistan — As they trickled back to Panjwaii district on Friday, some Afghan civilians said they will bury innocent family members who died in NATO's recent bombardment of the former Taliban stronghold.

Interviews with returning families indicate the civilian death toll in the district west of Kandahar city could be higher than the 13 acknowledged by provincial officials.

NATO says there is no way to know for sure how many innocent people caught in the fierce battles might have been killed, but the alliance has done everything possible to avoid civilian casualties.

Retired farmer Toor Jaan claimed 26 family members, including men, women and children, died in Sperwan on the western edge of the battle zone during bombing and helicopter gunship attacks.

A mass memorial service was held for his family at a mosque in Kandahar as he prepared Friday to return to Sperwan to bury the dead.

"Everybody thought the operation would remove the Taliban and security would improve," Jaan said through an interpreter.

"Instead, innocent civilians were attacked and several of my family members are still buried in rubble. This is not what we expected."

NATO officials say somewhere between 510 and 1,500 Taliban militants died in the massive air and ground assault on the area. The provincial government pegged the civilian death toll at 13.

No new civilian casualties have been confirmed, said Capt. Doug MacNair, a spokesman for NATO forces in southern Afghanistan.

MacNair added that sorting out innocent civilians from local Taliban and new recruits will be nearly impossible.

"We cannot rule out that someone stayed behind to look after crops or livestock, but it was not immediately apparent," said MacNair. "But if there were local (Taliban) hires, we don't know and we'll never know, frankly."

With the Taliban gone from Panjwaii and international forces holding the ground and promising millions in aid, few local residents are likely to admit insurgent allegiances exist in their neighbourhood.

Just a month ago, the Taliban were digging elaborate trench systems and hiding weapons among the walled compounds and grape fields in the region.

Some residents said they allowed the retrenchment under threat and intimidation, but the area was the birthplace of the Taliban and has long been known for its sympathies.

Haji Kherullah, 42, says he lost two sons and a nephew in a bombardment.

"How can this loss be replaced?" Kherullah said. "Everybody thought the operation was against the Taliban, not civilians. We were wrong."

Haji Agha Lalai, a prominent district official allied with NATO, said Friday that he could not confirm the stories of the Jaan or Kherullah families.

Two local elders, Mullah Abdur Rahim and Haji Nanai, stood by the accounts of Jaan and Kherullah, claiming 29 dead in total and denying they had any affiliation with the Taliban.

Faced with questions about civilian deaths, NATO has taken pains to point out the ample warnings area residents received to get out of the combat zone. For days, the area was scattered with leaflets and NATO forces openly warned days in advance that an attack was imminent.

"We took every step possible to minimize civilian casualties," MacNair said.

While a massive amount of bombs and artillery shells were dropped in the area, MacNair pointed out that careful targeting left most buildings standing in most villages.

In the villages around Pashmul at the very heart of the area, reporters travelling with advancing Canadian troops confirmed that most Afghans took heed of warnings to get out. Only a few bodies of suspected insurgents were found, along with scattered possessions. Most houses were empty.

U.S. and Afghan troops operated further west in Sperwan, where Jaan and Kherullah live.

Nanai, the village elder, said many civilians like Kherullah decided to stay in that area.

"My home and my business is (in Sperwan), so I thought where else could I go," said Kherullah, who says he sought refuge in Kandahar after his house was bombed.

"My sheep, my goats, my cows, my grapes. It's all gone. The major problem is that I can't go to my village again to restart my life with so much sorrow."

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV News

Soldiers with the Canadian Army's 1st Battalion Royal 22nd Regiment return to base on their final operation Thursday, June 30, 2011 in the Panjwaii district of Kandahar province, Afghanistan. (AP Photo/David Goldman)

Canada in Afghanistan

The latest news, photos and interactives from Canada's mission in Afghanistan.

Canadian Soldiers were injured when a Light Armoured Vehicle (LAV) Turret struck an on coming vehicle, outside Kandahar City, causing it to rotate 360 degrees wounding the two Canadian soldiers. (Cpl. Robin Mugridge / Department of National Defence)

Invisible Wounds

Angela Mulholland: Scope of injury toll in Afghanistan largely a mystery

Brain injuries among soldiers are often overlooked.

Blast-Induced Injuries

Brain injuries among soldiers serving in Afghanistan are often overlooked.

Doctor Louis-Philippe Palerme, right, from Gatineau, Quebec, is assisted by a Danish doctor, Captain Sacha Soelbeck, during a surgery at R3 MMU in Afghanistan.

Medical Advances

Soldiers survived injuries that, even 10 years ago, would have been fatal.

Cpl. Chris Klodt sits in a race chair. Klodt was shot in the neck July 7, 2006 during a Taliban ambush outside Kanadhar. The bullet was lodged in his spinal cord.

Soldiers Overcome Injuries

Wounded soldiers use sports to overcome injuries, adjust to their new reality.

Janis Mackey Frayer in Sperwan Ghar, Afghanistan

Kandahar Journal

Janis Mackey Frayer recounts sombre process of notifying next of kin.

Interactive

War Zone Medics

Lessons Learned

A number of the medical innovations that we now take for granted were conceived and tested during wartime.

Bios and Pictures

Casualties

Canadian Casualties

We remember those who lost their lives in Afghanistan since the mission began in 2002.

In Pictures

Canada's Last Days in Afghanistan

Concluding Combat

50 Pictures: Canadian troops conclude Afghan combat tour after a decade.

Kandahar transfer ceremony

Transfer Ceremony

In Pictures: Canada transfers control of Kandahar region to the U.S

Harper in Afghanistan

Harper in Afghanistan

25 Pictures: Stephen Harper meets with soldiers on his fourth Afghan trip.

Canada in Kandahar

Canada in Kandahar

30 Pictures: New tasks tackled as combat mission nears its end.

Operation Topak Shkar

Operation Topak Shkar

Canadian troops take on the Taliban in Operation Topak Shkar.

Today's Politics Stories

Quebec student strikes, tuition fees, Montreal, Quebec

Quebec students, government to resume talks Monday

More   27 Comments 27    4 Video(s) 4

Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Kathy Dunderdale receives applause from party members as the House of Assembly opens in St. John's on Monday, March 5, 2012. (Paul Daly /  THE CANADIAN PRESS)

EI changes unfair to N.L., Dunderdale says

More   20 Comments 20    1 Video(s) 1

In this Monday, Sept. 19, 2011 file photo, Fereidoun Abbasi Davani speaks during a news conference at the International Atomic Energy Agency in Vienna, Austria. (AP Photo/Ronald Zak)

Iran says no reason to halt 20 per cent enrichment

More   8 Comments 8  

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges