Politics -   

1
NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012. NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012. NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012.

MP who refused jubilee medal says he's not worthy

Viewer

CTV News Video

Power Play: MPs return Diamond Jubilee medals
NDP MP Pierre Nantel says his decision to return his medal is a personal reason. He says he's only been in office for seven months and he doesn't believe he's earned it yet.
CTV News Channel: Was the royal return offside?
A Quebec political analyst Jean Lapierre says he is not surprised that six Quebec MPs are returning Queen's jubilee medals in protest of government spending on monarchy events.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (16) Facebook   

NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012. NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012. NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012.

Photos

NDP MP Pierre Nantel speaks with Don Martin on CTV's Power Play on Feb. 7, 2012.

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Feb. 7 2012 11:29 PM ET

A New Democrat MP from Quebec says he will return his Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee medal -- not because he is against the monarchy, but because there are residents of his riding more deserving of the honour.

Pierre Nantel, who represents Quebec's Longueuil-Pierre-Boucher riding, is one of at least six Quebec MPs who will be giving back their medals, which were awarded to all 308 Members of Parliament.

A total of 60,000 jubilee medals will be handed out to Canadians who have made significant contributions to their communities. Heritage Minister James Moore said Monday that MPs also each receive medals to award to constituents deemed deserving of the honour.

Nantel said Tuesday that after hearing about the community service work some residents of his riding have done throughout their lives, his seven months as an MP don't qualify him for a medal.

"The real reason is that we have a description of who is to be receiving such a medal. And it describes a community involved person, it describes Armed Forces people, it does not describe a seven-month MP," Nantel told CTV's Power Play.

"That's why I keep saying this is an individual response to such a thing. My impression is, my medal, I'll have it in four years if I'm re-elected. But for the moment, I think it's quite premature to put me on the same level as the people who come to me and say, ‘I would like to get this medal.'"

Nantel said that some of his colleagues in the House of Commons have been engaged in public service for long enough "that they do deserve this medal."

But he said it's been "a privilege" to meet the local residents who have put forth their applications at his office for a medal.

When asked if he should accept the medal on behalf of his constituents as their representative in Parliament, Nantel said that is exactly what he's doing in giving it back.

"It's a privilege for me to receive such people in my office," he said. "And I think it's quite representative of my riding and I think it's acknowledging all this work that's being done in my riding."

The Conservatives have set aside $7.5 million for various events and festivities surrounding Queen Elizabeth's Diamond Jubilee and the cost of the medals alone is $3.5 million.

Bloc MP Louis Plamondon called it a waste of money at a time when the federal government is talking about cuts to public pensions and department budgets.

The anti-monarchist sentiment is strong in Quebec amid the jubilee hoopla, with one nationalist group, Montreal's Societe Saint-Jean-Baptiste, announcing plans for anti-Queen celebrations.

Nantel acknowledged that while many of his constituents are not pro-monarchy, there are those who do respect the Queen, including himself.

"We have this opportunity when we arrive (in Parliametn) to pledge allegiance (to the Queen), and I think it's important for all Canadians and I'm doing all this with the utmost respect I can for everyone in Canada," he said.


Comments are now closed for this story

Veteran
said

Well Done That Man! What a breath of fresh air (as opposed to Hot Air) from this politician. While I have no liking for his political stripe, I have every respect for his principled stand on this matter. Why 100% of MP's were "awarded" this medal while only some 10% of combat veterans would receive one is beyond my comprehension. Certainly, they receive the Afghan or other theatre medal but they served, as did I, during the Queen's reign and it deserves that recognition. It reminds me of the 60 year old struggle that men who were serving in a very volatile and dangerous Egypt at the time of the Coronation were denied that medal while politicians and others at the National trough in England wear it smugly. Those men are still trying to have the medal awarded as it should have been at eh time.Incidentally, a previous correspondent should be aware that we wear our medals on our chests and not around our necks.


The right decision
said

And on February 07 2012, Jack Layton looked down and smiled, as one of them 'got it'.


Bewildered
said

Bravo for his integrity! MP's don't deserve a medal for winning an election or 2. There are hundreds in any given community more deserving. The fact that they were all awarded one takes away any significance of the medal.


Trex in BC
said

I read in the first bit of this article that the Queens 60th medal was awarded to all 308 Members of Parliament, yet only a very small portion of the proud serving military members are being awarded it. Hmmmm..... make your own opinion on this.


simone
said

Maybe he could talk to all his fellow MP's about entitlement and their pensions!!$3.5 million for these medals. Just reaffirms their idiocy and entitlement mentality.$3.5 million is insane. Could they not at least pause mentally before entering into this stupidity. Economics be damned eh boys!!GREED, GREED, ENTITLEMENT, EGOTISTIC SELF SERVING, MORONIC. There are just so many adjectives one could use.


Will
said

I may consider his politics to be misled drivel but I certainly cannot fault his avowed reason for declining the medal. There are certainly more deserving people, but for this act he deserves some respect. A class act and a gentleman.


Thomas
said

Well it is nice to see an honest and wise MP, get him away from left wing politics and he might be a keeper.


mike
said

You are certainly not worthy to collect those huge pensions or the medal. If you are not worthy then why dont you give back your pensions along with the medals.Then according to many of the comments here you would be saving even more money in this troubled economy. This is nothing but a political stunt to gain votes.


DianeD
said

I see nothing wrong with him returning the medal if he truly feels others are more deserving. Several military men and women who were in Afghanistan will not be receiving the medal as they are giving out only so many. The military are taking nominations on who should receive one, and there are those that were in other worn torn countries who likely will be overlooked, many are now retired, more recently, the Golf War, Bosinia and the Medak Pocket, etc. Many deserving Canadians will not be recognized and they fought for our freedom and the freedoms of others.


Bob fr Petawawa
said

I cannot for the life of me understand why a complete house of voted representatives would be awarded these medals. Can some out there explain this to me? Especially when some them being opposed to being part of Canada.


bpraught
said

Bravo, M. Nantel. Could you please move out west and represent us in the Wild Rose constituency?


Keights
said

Hmmn, they get to vote themselves raises AND give themselves medals!


Rae Seay
said

I applaud Mr. Pierre Nantel for recognizing that there are more deserving members in his community who should be recognized. Having said that I cannot believe that our government is wasting 3.5 million dollars on these medals. Does anyone really need a hunk of medal to hang around their neck to recognize their good deeds. Use this money for children who are going hungry in this country for goodness sake. This expenditure is appalling and I would be ashamed to be a recipient of this medal.


Senior taxpayer
said

I wonder how many of these medals will be handed out in Tony Clement's riding?


PDMinVIC
said

that's a more generous reason than the other Quebec MP's offered, and he is likely right, there are so many deserving people who don't get paid to contribute to our country!


Denis
said

Good for him. This is a sign of humility, which is nice to see in a politician.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Politics Stories

Quebec student strikes, tuition fees, Montreal, Quebec

Quebec students, government to resume talks Monday

More   27 Comments 27    4 Video(s) 4

Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Kathy Dunderdale receives applause from party members as the House of Assembly opens in St. John's on Monday, March 5, 2012. (Paul Daly /  THE CANADIAN PRESS)

EI changes unfair to N.L., Dunderdale says

More   20 Comments 20    1 Video(s) 1

In this Monday, Sept. 19, 2011 file photo, Fereidoun Abbasi Davani speaks during a news conference at the International Atomic Energy Agency in Vienna, Austria. (AP Photo/Ronald Zak)

Iran says no reason to halt 20 per cent enrichment

More   8 Comments 8  

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges