Politics -
News Sections
Chiefs ask UN to weigh in on Attawapiskat
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Selected Comment
What a shock - the "solution" proposed involves yet more money. This has not resolved anything thus far, and in fact has been mismanaged terribly. Why will this time be any different?
Steve T
Consultant in Attawapiskat unacceptable: grand chief
talking about
Chiefs ask UN to weigh in on Attawapiskat
Andrea Janus, CTVNews.ca
Date: Tue. Dec. 6 2011 6:39 PM ET
The Assembly of First Nations waded into the political firestorm over Attawapiskat on Tuesday, passing a unanimous resolution to ask the United Nations to monitor the federal government's response to a housing emergency on the reserve.
The chiefs asked the UN to appoint a "special rapporteur" to examine whether the Harper government is dealing with the crisis in a way that meets its obligations under Canadian and international treaties concerning First Nations people.
The declaration, which also calls on the federal and provincial governments to respond to communities in dire need, was added to the meeting's agenda at the last minute as the controversy over Attawapiskat grows.
The resolution asks Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan to cease imposing measures, such as the third-party manager it sent to Attawapiskat.
A spokesperson for Duncan said the government is committed to working with Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence and band council members on a solution to the housing crisis. However, chiefs were unanimous in their indignation over the government's response to the crisis on the reserve.
Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo said Tuesday the only way to deal with problems such as Attawapiskat is to respect treaty rights between Ottawa and First Nations, saying natives have a reason to feel angry and betrayed.
"When I spoke with Chief Spence and leadership across the North, we discussed the urgent needs, but also that the way forward is based on respectful treaty implementation and an equitable share of resources from their land – not imposed, punitive, unilateral action," Atleo said at Tuesday's meeting.
Atleo said he stands beside the remote northern Ontario community's battle to force the federal government to deal with a housing shortage, calling it a "national disgrace."
"There is only one struggle, there is one agenda, and one goal: to build a better life for all our people based on our rights, our identity and, in fact, our very survival," Atleo said.
"And we must use every tool that we have."
Atleo is preparing for a summit of chiefs from across the country with Prime Minister Stephen Harper at the end of January.
He's suggested it may be a "moment of reckoning" between Ottawa and First Nations.
In Attawapiskat, Spence declared a state of emergency in late October stating families in her community face a winter in shacks that aren't insulated and without running water.
Last week, the federal government announced it would install a third-party manager to run the reserve's finances, something that angered Grand Chief Stan Louttit.
The manager was rejected by band councillors and left Monday.
Louttit said Tuesday that he objected to how quickly the third-party manager was sent to the community, without notice and without having a plan to help with the emergency.
"If they want to come in and be a third party manager, they would say okay community we'll work with you. Here's the plan, here's our budget, here's our schedule, here's the projects. This is how we'll do it, this is how it will be in the long term, and this is our goal in terms of making conditions in your community equal to any other Canadian in the country," Louttit said during a news conference he held with Spence.
"But no they just pop in…If they're going to come in and do something, have a plan. Where is their plan? We don't know."
Spence said the government's decision to appoint a third-party manager indicates there is more concern about the community's finances, which she said are laid bare in quarterly audits, than in the housing and health crises.
"Third party is not the solution here," Spence told reporters. "We're in crisis. And I've been saying that. We've been handling our financials within one year and we even got the deficit down. But the issue is not the deficit right now, it's the crisis. These people need health assessments right now, because a lot of them are sick."
Spence said she and the local council have been working on an emergency plan, including getting quotes and ordering materials for nearly half-a-dozen new homes.
She said she will seek legal advice, and ask her fellow chiefs, about next steps.
Former prime minister Paul Martin accused the federal government of engaging in "wedge politics" rather than face the crisis in Attawapiskat head on.
"This is discrimination and it's a failure to deal with what really is one of, if not the greatest, social problems we as a country face," Martin said Tuesday in an interview with CTV's Power Play.
He also criticized the Harper government for abandoning the $5 billion Kelowna Accord that Martin had hoped to establish between the provinces, the federal government and First Nations leaders. The accord was aimed at improving education, health care, housing, accountability and other issues.
"You're talking about human lives here. We're talking about people who, as Christmas approaches, are going to be freezing in those homes," Martin said. "As a country, and an incredibly wealthy country, we just can't allow that to happen. What is happening to these people is beyond the pale by any definition."
The NDP's Charlie Angus, whose riding includes the community, said Tuesday Ottawa is provoking a political showdown with Attawapiskat that is drawing attention away from the actual housing crisis.
Angus also questioned Duncan's claims Ottawa is sending supplies and emergency help to Attawapiskat - when the only extra supplies the Ontario MP has seen delivered were boxes of doughnuts the third-party manager brought with him when he arrived at the reserve.
Since then, the Canadian Red Cross has arrived in the community to deliver aid and to help keep people warm, properly clothed and fed. Louttit said the people living on the reserve are grateful for the assistance.
He said tens of millions of dollars are needed to build proper housing for residents of the reserve.
"The backlog of housing in our community is approximately 280 houses," he said.
"Multiply that by approximately $250,000 per house. Figure out the math."
But Mark Milke, Alberta director for the Fraser Institute, said neither discrimination nor a lack of money account for the problems in First Nations communities.
Milke said the communities are too remote to remain viable, and argues that the system to distribute funds must change.
"When you give money to the top and then ask them nicely to distribute it to the bottom, are you really surprised that it doesn't make it to the bottom? The victims are those who unfortunately sit on reserves and are subject to that sort of gamesmanship, which comes along with the way the institution is set up," Milke told Power Play. "This is an institutional flaw, and it's not going to be corrected by the way with more money, more control over natural resources."
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Tired of the freebies with no answers
said
datatect
said
Wendy
said
MikefromQuebec
said
Seeking Wolf
said
Zoe
said
D in Wpg
said
dieter from Ottawa
said
J.C.
said
Helene
said
Mars
said
N. Donna Wise
said
peter in mb
said
FCS
said
Alan
said
Kevin in Alberta
said
Mel Blake
said
Bonnie
said
Coates
said
Jen
said
Thomas
said
Prof Sine Curve
said
ArchersRequest
said
robin hood
said
brenda from Thunder Bay
said
Lisa
said
I really like that alternative!!!! If FN doesn't want 3rd party intervention, then this is a grand alternative!!!
Mea
said
Vince
said
Debbie
said
john messom creston bc
said
Gary Cerantola
said
Jim McB
said
Donald
said
BL
said
Raj
said
Proud Albertan
said
Acorn127
said
joe
said
peter in mb
said
Steve Hall
said
Dennis L. Krahn
said
no hope
said
AC in NB
said
Rob, Ontario
said
AIRCOR
said
The national disgrace is the constant pressure on the dole that is exerted on all of us to look after people who will not attempt to look after themselves. How much of our hard earned dollars, and I mean our personal tax dollar goes to support this 6% of the population who do nothing to help themselves, but ask for more, and perform civil disobedience.
I say, Six Nations, stand up for your identity, stand up for your rights, survival is for the fittest, get fit! Quit sucking us dry!
Kathy
said
CMQ
said
Helen - Ontario
said
Steve Baxter
said
This is caused by nepotism, poor money management and corruption,show the homes of the chiefs and the counselors I'll bet they are not in the same condition am not just condemning the native population but ALL corrupt officials that hold power and benefit from this power while the people they are in charge of supplying proper living conditions suffer. Show where the millions go ?? Let there be some accountability on the chiefs. My 5 years on a reservation shocked me Believe me when I say there are MANY things which can be done to improve living conditions on reservations and most of them do not involve throwing money into the chiefs budget
Harold
said
observer99
said
Mike in Quebec
said
The natives get free money.
Not true. The natives owned all the Public Domain land in Canada and agreed to give up the administration (but not the rights) to the Federal Government. In return the government was "supposed" to share the revenue and consult with the natives for distribution. The money they get is their share of the revenues, and now is a pitance of what they were supposed to get. Yes, it is a shame that 92 million for housing disappeared into somebody's pockets. Yes, there should be oversight committees for these funds, run by natives and accountable to both the Federal Government and the native community. Don't think the natives are getting "free" money.
Thomas
said
Jerry
said
Werner
said
DJ
said
MARG MM
said
KC BC
said
Andre
said
William
said
Peter in Kingsburg
said
sueann roberts
said
leo
said
Mary
said
Steve in AB
said
Ty
said
Bonnie
said
lg
said
MAE in Ontario
said
schpid
said
att man
said
Don K
said
J Stad
said
blc Ottawa
said
Why do you think they waited until October to declare an emergency for exactly what is happening right now so all the socialists would get on the air and cry these poor people, that terrible conservate Govt.
What the Band was hoping for was a rush job as winter approaches and they would get more money no questions. Backfiring this time as Canadians at large have had enough.
Give them as many millions as they want and in less than 2 years the houses will be destroyed again and same old story. Time they became self sufficient.
Zircon
said
JM
said
M
said
I've been watching the coverage of this story on TV. While they were shooting the delapatated housing several newer pickup trucks were driving back and forth down the roads in the background.
Housing budget not enough but transportation budget looks ok huh??????
Man this story makes me livid!
Helen - Ontario
said
A Koster
said
Bonnie
said
dante
said
Average Canadian in NS
said
Elmer in BC
said
John
said
basic math
said
Kevin
said
Look at the numbers
said
Erk
said
zealander
said
Just give us the money and don't ask any questions.
Dave - Portage
said
Paul in Simcoe
said
Fenton
said
andrew j
said
CarlO
said
snowcone
said
disgusted
said
J.C.
said
Les
said
Ben
said
Thom H
said
Colleen
said
what a surprise
said
Marcel
said
D-Log
said
Mike fro Calgary
said
carol
said
JanMac
said
Let's all help get them through the crisis and back on their feet, but some sort of management is needed, third party or otherwise. How else can one be sure that the the community centre will have running water and that sewage won't back up into homes, again?
Lisa
said
Hunky Dory
said
Lionel
said
PAM
said
Bob in Chatham
said
WestofTheRockies
said
Michael
said
Sandra
said
Bob,Calgary,Alberta
said
Barry Wynn
said
Sandra
said
Douglas Brown (Newmarket)
said
reidjr
said
No Hraper is not a dictator at all.
Anne
said
Sandra
said
reidjr
said
I think if there is a boiling point it will be between the different reserves you have some that are doing very well while some are in awful shape.
Kevin on PEI
said
Pat
said
Robert B
said
Scott (in Alberta Party country)
said
Anne
said
Memories
said
DCI
said
Bob in Cornwall
said
Harold
said
David Clark
said
Sandra
said
Andre Setton
said
IslandGuy
said
Pedro
said
Roam
said
DS
said
chel in the Peg
said
union joe civy
said
Had enough
said
Lets be frank
said
David Clark
said
Geoff in Lethbridge
said
Pat
said
V.I.Brad
said
joe canada
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
brian Fr Langley
said
Ted Sprague
said
Lz in Edmonton
said
Trish
said
cehnehdeh in SK
said
Jon in Burlington
said
John
said
Joann
said
Marg
said
Wow
said
Gregg C
said
brad
said
GERRY
said
TimT
said
M.M.B. Ont
said
George V.
said
Mel Bevan
said
Steve in Edmonton
said
elder
said
B.J.
said
MJ
said
joe canada
said
Saskmike
said
edCP
said
MikeW
said
Ron
said
CMQ
said
Just Saying - Ottawa
said
Proud Albertan
said
Mo Mo money
said
Attawapiskat
said
mining guy Jim
said
Lynn
said
JDF-Calgary
said
John Denson
said
stephen d.belding
said
Trish
said
Mike
said
B in Ottawa
said
CanadaEh?
said
john
said
Canadian Bob
said
House in Order
said
10-78
said
Christine
said
John
said
Wayne Rietze
said
MN_Edmonton
said
Munky
said
arthur archer
said
Paul in Newmarket
said
GUTSHOT!! in Thunder Bay
said
David
said
Sherry
said
feduptaxpayer
said
Steve T
said
Taxpayer
said
who cares
said
Paul
said
steve
said