Politics -   

1

Liberal MPs lead in absences in the House

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday March 2, 2011. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld) Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla gestures as she speaks during Question Period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Friday, Nov. 26, 2010. (Pawel Dwulit /  THE CANADIAN PRESS) A screen grab of the website, HowdTheyVote.ca is shown in this image.
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday March 2, 2011. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (23) Facebook   

Date: Monday Mar. 7, 2011 10:11 PM ET

The House of Commons resumed sitting Monday, but the only way the public has of knowing if their elected representative is on the job is by watching for a glimpse of them sitting behind their parliamentary desks.

Although senators' attendance records in the upper chamber are made public, the attendance records of Members of Parliament are kept strictly confidential.

But according to the website HowdTheyVote.ca, 29 MPs missed more than 50 days of the current session of Parliament, all but nine of them Liberals.

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff was absent 135 times, the top absentee MP according to the non-partisan website, while Bloc Quebecois member Francine Lalonde missed 113 days and Liberal backbencher Keith Martin 102.

"For the leaders it's very understandable," CTV Ottawa bureau chief Robert Fife told News Channel. "The leaders have other duties than just showing up in the House for votes.

"I don't think we should certainly fault the leaders for not being there very often."

Prime Minister Stephen Harper was 11th on the list, having been absent 74 times.

Yet NDP Leader Jack Layton was 144th, with only 17 absences on his record.

Only eight of the 308 members of the House of Commons could boast perfect attendance records, seven of them Tories and one a Liberal.

Fife said the Opposition Liberals appear to be heavily over-represented on the list of MPs missing in action.

"People will have to be asked then why it's mostly Liberals who aren't there very often," he said "Is it because they don't like being on the opposition benches?"

An investigation by the Globe and Mail, published Monday, correlated the MPs' absences with votes on bills in the House and found that 17 members, most of them Liberals, have missed at least a quarter of the votes in the past two years.

Liberal backbenchers Jim Karygiannis, Keith Martin and Ruby Dhalla came close to missing half of the more than 300 votes Parliament took between November, 2008, and December, 2010, according to the newspaper.

"Is it because someone is not in Ottawa or not voting that he's not carrying his weight?" Liberal Whip Marcel Proulx wondered.

"That's a very good debate. I'm not trying to excuse members who are delinquents as far as not coming to votes. Where do you draw the line?"

Every MP is required to file a monthly statement in which they must account for any days missed by checking off one of three reasons: illness, official business, or other.

Their reasons for the absences are shielded from the public.

Fife said MPs were not eager to discuss the issue for the record. "None of them want to come on camera and talk to us," he said.

But he said one former Conservative MP, Inky Mark, offered one reason for his previous absences: "He said he didn't show up because he couldn't stand his boss, Stephen Harper."

Despite a Conservative promise in the last election campaign to lift what Harper once called the "cloak of secrecy" surrounding government, there is no sign that the long-standing tradition of secrecy over MP attendance will change anytime soon.

Asked by The Globe and Mail if the Tories would consider making the records public, party Whip Gordon O'Connor had a blunt, one-word response: "No."

The opposition parties said they are willing to open their books - but none was willing to go first and all made unanimous support a condition of transparency.

O'Connor said there are many reasons to keep the attendance and reasons for absences secret, including medical conditions or family matters that ought to be kept private.

"I am not going to have an open debate."

Heather Bradley, spokeswoman for House Speaker Peter Milliken, said the Commons works on the "honour system" and that attendance "has not been an issue."

And that holds up for most MPs. Three-quarters of the MPs were present for almost 90 per cent of the votes in the House.

Comments are now closed for this story

George V.
said

The silence is deafening from the official opposition, leading in absenteeism almost three quarters of the time and still getting paid their full stipend and their many perks. Here is a real scandal the voters can sink their teeth into instead of all the nit-picking we have had for the past few months. My hat is off to C.T.V. for exposing this out and out theft from the public purse, getting paid 100% for their work and actually doing only three quarters of it. From the party that has had for the past number of years that "holier than thou attitude". This is balanced reporting. Thank you.


Tim
said

The silence of Liberal supporters about this story is deafening.


Carl
said

No surprise here. My own Liberal MP here in Central Newfoundland has one of the worst delinquency rates. I think it's because this riding has almost always been won by Liberals, and he doesn't think he has to do anything to keep winning. I hope he gets a rude awakening next election.


John
said

The Liberals are lost and without leadership. I'm starting to wonder if they'll ever get my vote back.


Chris
said

135 days out of office?? That's almost 6 months vacation!! What does he do?? Where he's at?? And he wants to be Prime Minister?? Iggy not here for you but takes our money!!!


Judy
said

I think the money these MP's receive they should be at all meeting possible. It doesn't surprise me that Iggy missed so much, he is nothing but hotair anyway.....only shows up to cause a ripple. Proud of the MP's who are doing their jobs. This is why they should all take a cut in pay, they only attend when they want too.....


disgustedvoter
said

I'll bet there is much better attendance by representatives of the Mubarek or Ghadafi governments than there is in the Harper government. Why do Prime Ministers and Premiers have to be Dictators in this Canadian "democracy"??


NS
said

Why vote Liberal if they do not even show up to represent us? I am stuck with Liberal Mike Savage here in Halifax, and there are to many close minded stubborn liberal voters, to make a change.


Steve in Vancouver
said

Gee wiz l thought all the liberals where on the political titanic. But darn a bunch were absent for the sailing­.


4 U Marc
said

We now the proof... the Liberals are the REAL "cons".


Tad
said

I find it hilarious the neocon reformers on here whining because the liberals had business else where. This same bunch is usually saying they have nothing to offer, which is it do you want them there or not? The past 5 years there hasn't been much of a reason to be there. With Harper at the helm nothing gets done & if some thing does happen it will need to be changed back because Harper's team of inexperienced uneducated minions are incompetent. Even funnier one of the neocon reformed cheer leaders is calling for prof pye. Maybe Harper quit paying for him or he was replaced by prof go cart.


Richard L. Provencher
said

Isn't it interesting? Three of the biggest Liberal noises yammering against the Conservatives - Mr. Ignatief, Keith Martin and Ruby are the ones who missed the most dates. Yet they manage to get their names mentioned often in the news just to let people know they are still alive and kicking. So the reporter had to comment on Inky not liking our PM. Maybe the reason so many Liberals are absent feel if their boss can be away so many times, they can too. A sad affair indeed. Vote for a Conservative majority.


Sue
said

"He said he didn't show up because he couldn't stand his boss, Stephen Harper." Despite a Conservative promise in the last election campaign to lift what Harper once called the "cloak of secrecy" surrounding government, there is no sign that the long-standing tradition of secrecy over MP attendance will change anytime soon.


Johnn
said

Well, I guess if you want to be represented in Parliament, you don't vote Liberal . . . .


B in Ottawa
said

The attendance of Members of Parliament should be made public. These elected officials are elected by the public and have a responsibility to the Canadian people to actually show up for work. If they don't show up for work, they should have to provide a valid explanation, just like in any other profession. Checking off a box on a secret list doesn't cut it. At the same time, the fact that almost all of the MP's on the high-absentee list are Liberals reveals how Michael Ignatieff runs his party. Ignatieff allows MP's to miss votes and be unaccountable to their constituents. Ignatieff himself is the one who fails to show up for work the most. This is another indicator of what we've known all along: Ignatieff isn't in it for Canadians. He's just in it for himself.


Steve in Ottawa
said

Lazy Liberals. Not a suprise. They're not getting my vote.


Misen Mypie from ON
said

To get past the moderator's review, I say, absences in the House of Commons should not be tolerated. Now what I really want to say is, Prof Pye Chartt, where are you when we need you buddy? We can't fight the Leftie Lonnies all on our own ! You should be all over story.


Marc _ Toronto
said

What I voted for my Liberal MP and he decides not to show up to work? What? Is this for real? And they don't show up because they don't want to be in opposition? Who are these people?We need to deduct pay for every absence without a valid reason. Why should they be different than an other Canadian. Seems my MP still thinks he lives the life of privledge. I am embarrassed to see that the Cons attend more often on average than my Liberals.


Iggy just not there!
said

There is NO EXCUSE for this kind of delinquency. We are paying these MP's good money to be in the House of Commons not out and about doing other business. Unacceptable! Where is Ignatieff? He has almost twice the delinquency rate of the Prime Minister has who is expected to be away often !!! Where is Ignatieff?


What a Joke
said

I guess we should only pay 3/4 of our taxes and not tell the government why ...it a matter of privacy? Vote all the bums out next election


David. L. MacDonald
said

Why is this no surprise? This is the same gang of Liberals that complains at every thing the government says or does then sits on their hands or are absent when it comes time to vote on the issues. This is a poor opposition bench and arguably the worst Liberal caucus in over half a century of following politics.


B. Kelley, Ontario
said

If most of us were absent from our jobs as often as some of our elected representatives we'd be fired. I guess that they don't respect their constituents enough to represent their interests in Parliament. Our MP's should be accountable first and foremost to the citizens, not the Speaker and not their party bosses. This information should be published at least monthly so that we know if our rep is not showing up like he/she should and we can let our dissatisfaction be known. No confidential information needs to be revealed, just the raw numbers, the votes missed and the accumulated total absence. Without proper accountability theres no control.


Tungin Cheek from ON
said

Maybe the Liberals invite to participate in the House of Commons was not on the correct letterhead therefore they did not feel that they needed to attend.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

Today's Politics Stories

Quebec student strikes, tuition fees, Montreal, Quebec

Quebec students, government to resume talks Monday

More   27 Comments 27    4 Video(s) 4

Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Kathy Dunderdale receives applause from party members as the House of Assembly opens in St. John's on Monday, March 5, 2012. (Paul Daly /  THE CANADIAN PRESS)

EI changes unfair to N.L., Dunderdale says

More   20 Comments 20    1 Video(s) 1

In this Monday, Sept. 19, 2011 file photo, Fereidoun Abbasi Davani speaks during a news conference at the International Atomic Energy Agency in Vienna, Austria. (AP Photo/Ronald Zak)

Iran says no reason to halt 20 per cent enrichment

More   8 Comments 8  

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges