Top Stories -   

1
This photo of Omar Khadr was taken before he was imprisoned and distributed by his mother, Maha Khadr. Lt. Gen. (Ret.) Romeo Dallaire, speaks on Canada AM on Tuesday, April 1, 2008.

Dallaire accuses Canada of hypocrisy on Khadr case

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Romeo Dallaire, Liberal senator
AM0401_dallaire

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (21) Facebook   

Date: Tue. Apr. 1 2008 7:54 AM ET

Liberal Senator Romeo Dallaire is accusing Canada of hypocrisy for "abandoning" Omar Khadr after his capture by U.S. forces in 2002.

Khadr is the Canadian child soldier who was captured by the U.S. in Afghanistan when he was 15 and taken to a prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Dallaire, a UN peacekeeper in Rwanda in the 1990s, says Canada is trying to help rehabilitate and reintegrate child soldiers around the world, but has done nothing to help one of its own citizens.

"In the case of (Khadr), a Canadian child soldier in an American illegal prison ... we've backed off from taking that role and responsibility," the retired general told CTV's Canada AM on Tuesday.

Khadr, the Toronto-born son of an alleged al Qaeda financier, was captured by U.S. soldiers in July 2002 following a firefight in Afghanistan.

The teen was eventually transferred to Guantanamo Bay following allegations he threw a grenade during the firefight, killing a U.S. soldier.

Dallaire says the fact that Canada has not stepped in to help one of its own citizens may be due to the fact that Khadr's late father had alleged terrorist ties.

"(But) that is totally irrelevant of the situation. If your father is a criminal, that does not implicate you of being necessarily part of the crime. On the contrary, if you are a child who has been brought into that process, then we treat you as a juvenile and act accordingly," Dallaire said.

Lt.-Cmdr. William Kuebler, Khadr's U.S. military lawyer, has said Canada should "follow the lead of every other western country" and demand Khadr's repatriation to face justice here. Australian, French, and British citizens who were held at Guantanamo have been sent back to their home countries.

Khadr remains the sole Westerner still held at the prison, where his lawyers have alleged he has been tortured.

Human rights officials, opposition parties, and the Canadian Bar Association have called on the Conservative government to take steps to make sure Khadr is treated fairly. Since his capture, he has been in a legal limbo.

The U.S. government has had various attempts to try Khadr within its military system thwarted by the courts, which have questioned the legality of military tribunals.

Dallaire says Canada needs to step up and help one of its citizens. He says the world is watching to see if Ottawa has dropped its commitment to human rights.

"They are watching us because they don't know where Canada is going in the whole realm of human rights ... generally, this government is making it appear that human rights is not within its parameters," Dallaire said.

Comments are now closed for this story

GJ
said

A 15 year old theoretically may know right from wrong, but they are also very easily misled. The misguidedness would not have started at 15.. indoctrination isnt a light switch type of attitude.


Marty
said

STOP!!

If you've never read Mr. Dallaire's book, your comments are worth ZERO.

This man is thrown literally into "Mission Impossible" with a mere fraction of the resources required to stop a genocide.

Here is the TRUE meaning of Hero.. small town man with a pure heart.

He knows child soldiers, he knows the genocides. He also knows best, the hypocrisy of western world nations. He wanted to do good. He wasn't asking for much from the U.S. government back in the early 90s.

He is the truest of heroes.. doing the best that he can do.

He took action and actually when he met "the devil" , the actually deliberated taking his sidearm and shooting that so-called president in Rwanda.

It really bothers me people posting comments without being educated first by the man's life, ordeals and accomplishments.

He went through hell for a people which are not even his own. At least give him the hommage and respect he deserves for firm beliefs and the good he tried to accomplish.




james
said

As far as I am concerned. This 15 year old went to a war torn country and fought against our allies, in a war that Canada is activly engaged in. With that being said I believe that Omar Khadr forfeited his right to be Canadian for actively fighting with our enemy. The canadian government is doing the right thing by leaving this enemy soldier in prison where he belongs.


Sherry
said

I fully agree with Gen. Dallaire. A child soldier is a child soldier, no matter who his parents are. Khadr may have only been 15 when he was caught, but imagine the life time of brainwashing this child endured. It is embarassing that depending on where you are fighting and who your parents are determins how our government decides to care for it's child soldiers. If our justice system allows sentances to be served at home for 17 year olds that kill other kids at a party, because they are a youth, how in the world is this acceptable??


Don McKee
said

We are talking about a child. God help us if we don't do the right thing for him.


Paul
said

Some people posting here declare that they knew exactly what they were doing in every way at age 15. To those of you who claim this and are condemning Khadr into a hellish eternal limbo at Guantanamo Bay, you can bask in the altar of glowing humanity that you claim to be, and continue to live on in the perpetually fixed state of moral and philosophical enlightenment that you claim to have embraced at age 15.

Others recognize that at 15 years old, a lot of people simply don't know the full harmful extent of they are doing and deserve the possibility of a second chance when they make a grievous error. Khadr deserves the benefit of the doubt because he was so young when all of this happened. At the very least he deserves an open trial with a lawyer, and a proper sentence in a Canadian rehabilitation institution.

Unfortunately, our government and a significant vocal percentage of the Canadian populace are now striving to be in lockstep with the USA's wishes in Afghanistan and all this meaningless "War on Terror" garbage propaganda. This gets in the way of properly addressing the Khadr issue - how can our government push hard to try to get Khadr the fair hearing, representation, and open trial he deserves when they're scared it'll cause diplomatic problems with the current war mongering government to the south?

One can only hope that the upcoming new leadership in the USA will be forward thinking enough to close Guantanamo Bay and raze it to the ground...

Last, I'd like to say to those that seem to believe that a special legal system and the ripping up of the Geneva convention is needed in the context of terrorism. Was any special reworking of anything required to ensure that Timothy McVeigh got what he deserved for his act of terror?


Khalid Quraishi
said

Thank you Mr. Dallaire for speaking out. Khadr remains the only westerner in the illegal Guantanamo facility. As a Canadian citizen, the Canadian Government should bring him back home and he should then be tried in the Canadian Legal system


Ron
said

Why the fuss? All politicians are just a bunch of hypocrites. the Conservatives are just showing their true colors in this matter and have done so since being elected. They only react in apositive manner if if benefits thier right wing agenda


Rene
said

While I agree that there is a miscarriage of justice here regarding this case, and that Canada has done nothing to help this person, I would also like to point out that the Conservatives have not been in power for five years. Where was the previous Liberal Government on this matter when they were in power. Please don't misunderstand. I'm not a fan of Stephen Harper and his Conservative ideology, nor his governing record, but I don't believe in all fairness that we can only blame his Government. Had the Liberals done what they are insisting the Conservatives should have done, this discussion would not be taking place.





Gary - London
said

Liberal Senator Romeo Dallaire has witnessed human acts of cruelty that
he has to live with for the rest of his life.I sympathize with this man.
However,his sense of logic may now be impaired by his own history. This teenager knew right from wrong.

Ray Hogan
said

I agree with Senator Dallaire, we should do what we can to rehabilitate child soldiers where ever they are. However, when one performs acts of terrorism that mains or kills a person or persons and then there are some who wish to wrap him in the Canadian Flag and say poor kid, this is where I disagree. If you willingly involve yourself in acts of terrorism, then you shouldn't expect Canadians to come to your defense.


Ed Penheiro
said

Canada has shown reluctance in interceding for Canadians incarcerated in other countries, why should we do differently in this case? In view of Khadr's family background and in particular the comments made by his mother and sister during that notorious TV interview, Canadians may not be too supportive of an offer of help.


hilary
said

I must disagree with Mr. Daillaire on this one. A 15 year old knows right from wrong. The U.S. has every right to hold this individual for what he did to one of their own. In my opinion leave this "child" there and let him deal with the consequences of his actions.

Shamaro
said

I tend to agree and disagree at the same time with the General. First of all, the boy's father did not have alleged terrorist ties, he was a terrorist and had many ties high up with people like Bin Laden. The thing I do agree with, is this young man (who then was a boy) had been indocterinated by his terrorist father and being a minor and under the care of his father, was taken overseas, trained as a terrorist. It is his father who should be held accountable, not the boy. The Canadian government does have an obligation to help this young Canadian Citizen, regardless of the charge against him, however upon his release from the Americans, should be brought home to Canada, have his passport stripped of him and should remain in Canadian Custody.


JKL
said

No one forced this young
boy to go to Afganistan!!Although he was born Canadian he chose to be with Al Qeada.I was a boy soldier 16 With the Canadian Army and I knew right from wrong.Senator/General Dallaire has my respect but to waste Canadian taxpayers money over this family is not acceptable.


Ian - Milton
said

Mr. Dallaire - there is nothing 'alleged' about the Khadr family invovement in terrorism - films and documents show they were - so please stop your rhetoric about this 'child-soldier'and the influence of his father. He certainly was influenced by his father but in a negative way but he himself ultimately chose his own destiny.

Yes, he should receive fair justice and preferably back home but knowing Canadian 'justice' - we as a society will not be the best for it if he is brought back and given a mere hand-slap, if that.




AM
said

Thank you Romeo Dallaire for speaking out! It's hard to understand why the Canadian Government chooses not to help Khadr. It seems to me that the gov. helps when there is public outcry... I am disappointed that fellow Canadians say they care about Human Rights... just not in their own back yard! We should be ashamed really... the only western country that has not help our citizen. It's time to bring him back to stand trial if need be and help him re-integrate into Canadian society.


JDS
said

Senator Dallaire speaks for many of us who have been silenced by the "War on Terror/Support the Troops" xenophobia that has gripped this nation.


Kira
said

Canada has an obligation to act, one need only know that Khadr was only 15 at the time of his arrest, held for 27months with no access to counsel or lawyers, held for 5 yrs in custody with no charges (until recently). Anywhere else Canada would not stand for this treatment of one of its own. All other citizens in the western world have been returned to their country; even Russia got their citizens back. Canada standing by and doing nothing is the equivalent of condoning the US's behavior. If (and it is a big if) Khadr is guilty let him be tried here. - I highly recommend all Canadian Citizen becomes failure with the facts of the case before judging Khadr's guilt. I recommend the paper written by Univ of Ottawa on Repatriating Omar Khadar.


Ron
said

I would think that Senator Dallaire would know better than anyone what a "child soldier" is capable of.


Bob h fr Petawawa
said

I agree to an extent regarding this fellow. However. He has been in their prison system for so long now. Do we know if his mind has been brainwashed to coincide with the terrorists views now? I would hope not, but........ It is sad that anyone would do this to children to begin with, very sad indeed. No doubt the Gen has seen much in that regard in his time. If Canada is to do something, can they rehabilitate him? I would like to say yes. Then I agree let's see what Canada can do. But after so long, it remains to be seen. Good luck!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges