News Sections
PMO 'lied' about Afghan prisoner transfers: Dion
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. Jan. 25 2008 8:54 PM ET
Liberal Leader Stephane Dion says he doesn't believe that the Conservative government did not know Canadian soldiers in Afghanistan had stopped transferring prisoners to Afghan authorities in early November.
That's because as opposition leader, Dion was made aware of the policy change during his visit to Afghanistan two weeks ago. He said if he knew, it's extremely doubtful that Canadian soldiers would have kept the Tory government in the dark about the issue.
On Thursday, the prime minister's communications director told CTV News that the military did not inform the Tory government of the change in policy, a statement she retracted Friday following heavy criticism from opposition parties and reportedly from top military officials.
Dion said that when he heard that Sandra Buckler had said the Tories were not informed, "I knew that was a lie."
On Friday, Buckler told CTV News she "misspoke" -- but she would not say whether the government was informed about the military's decision.
"I misspoke, I shouldn't have said it, I broke my own rule in speaking about operational matters in the military," Buckler told CTV News in a phone interview.
When asked if this meant the military had informed the government about the policy change, Buckler would not confirm that.
"I will not speak about operational matters," she repeated.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper did not address the issue during a speech to supporters in Ottawa late Friday afternoon, although he did briefly mention the Manley report, which was released this week. Among several recommendations, the report by the blue ribbon panel called for the government to be more open with Canadians about the country's involvement in Afghanistan.
Harper did not say whether or not the Conservatives will follow its recommendations, which also called on Canada to press NATO for an additional 1,000 more troops for the mission.
Other Conservatives were also silent Friday about whether or not the military informed their top ministers about the change in policy -- but the Liberals say military officials were forthright with them.
Dion said that he and deputy leader Michael Ignatieff were informed that the military was not transferring prisoners to the Afghans when the pair visited Afghanistan earlier this month. Dion made the revelation when a reporter asked him directly if the military informed him of the policy change.
"Thank you for the question," Dion told the reporter, "Because this is one of the reasons why I never believed the story that (the Conservatives) were not aware. They had been informed of that, when we were in Afghanistan, the leader of the opposition had been informed of that."
The Liberals did not go public with the information -- which has now been made public in a court case -- because it was relayed at the time in a confidential briefing.
Although the Conservatives admitted Thursday that a change in policy had in fact taken place and federal lawyers have also said so in a court case, Defence Minister Peter MacKay accused Dion of being 'irresponsible' about speaking about the issue.
Critics said Friday that they are tired of the alleged Tory tactic of doubting the patriotism of anyone who questions the Conservative policies and actions when it comes to Afghanistan. In October and November, MacKay and other Tories suggested that those who raised the issue of prisoner abuse in Afghanistan were merely echoing Taliban propaganda.
Dion accused the Tories of only being interested in putting the best spin on a story that is an important political issue for Canadians. He said there are other reasons he doesn't believe that the military never informed the Tories.
"It's not credible for many reasons, but there is one I will mention right away," he said.
"The lawyer of the justice department was aware. The lawyer disclosed the information, so if the lawyer was aware, I guess the minister of justice was aware, and the prime minister was aware, too."
Justice Department lawyers revealed in a letter to human rights groups that the military stopped transferring prisoners to Afghan custody in early November -- after finding evidence of torture in an Afghan prison.
Back in November, Foreign Affairs Minister Maxime Bernier had said Canadian officials were concerned about a Taliban prisoner who alleged that he was tortured, but he did not mention that Canada had already halted prisoner transfers.
On Thursday, the prime minister's communications director told reporters that that was because a Canadian colonel in Afghanistan made the decision and no one in the military told the government.
Critics said that was hard to believe, and blasted the Tories for misleading the House of Commons and misleading Canadians.
"I think there's been a complete lack of candour (by the Tories)," Bob Rae, the foreign affairs critic for the Liberals, told CTV Newsnet's Mike Duffy Live on Thursday.
"The government knew what the decisions were on the ground. They must have been informed about them."
Critics say it's especially difficult to believe that the military would not have told the government about the change in policy because the issue of prisoner transfers was at the centre of a political firestorm at the time.
As late as the end of October, the Conservative government had questioned and even denied news reports that some prisoners captured by Canadians and turned over to the Afghans were abused. They suggested that the reports were unsubstantiated and part of a Taliban strategy.
Opposition politicians also said the silence over the policy change is another reason the government's conduct in Afghanistan shouldn't be trusted.
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV News
Canada in Afghanistan
The latest news, photos and interactives from Canada's mission in Afghanistan.
Soldiers Overcome Injuries
Wounded soldiers use sports to overcome injuries, adjust to their new reality.
Interactive
Lessons Learned
A number of the medical innovations that we now take for granted were conceived and tested during wartime.
Bios and Pictures
Canadian Casualties
We remember those who lost their lives in Afghanistan since the mission began in 2002.
In Pictures
Quick Quotes
Government on Detainees
Quotes illustrate the government's approach to allegations of abuse of prisoners.
CTV Broadband Network
The Verdict
With the detainee crisis and Gaza struggles, the year is off to a shaky start in the Mideast.
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email








Comments are now closed for this story
Terry Hultquist
said
And what poster here that has been critical of the government, has the military experience, in the field, in Afghanistan, that has decided that the fact that the transfer of detainees was halted, was not a decision that was in the best interests of the soldiers in the field? The next time you see a Canadian soldier, do as I do...shake their hand, and thank them. I would not have lived to be a senior citizen without their sacrifice.
Mario
said
Allan - So, as a Liberalist, you needed to know these things? Explain...
Don - You don't happen to be on need-to-know basis of all operational matters, nor are the majority of Canadians.
Paul Hansen - Bingo
Freedom Lover - Get a grip on reality.
Dave - And the way that Dion is handling this shows his complete ineptitude with all things political.
Curt - Radical Right Wingers? Give up the fear mongering.
Now that I've vented with some of the most absured comments, I am glad that the majority of the posters seem to be logical Canadians that understand how the world works, and that in times of war, certain discretions are needed. I for one am glad that every single detail of what we are doing isn't broadcasted for two reasons: The enemy doesn't know what we are up to, and the morons in the Liberal party have minimal "ammo" with which to attack our own troops.
Curt
said
André Bérubé
said
Moe
said
Ottawa soldier
said
To all the armchair generals, stop telling everyone what we need. Once you have walked a mile in our shoes, maybe, just maybe, you can tell everyone what we need. In the Forces we have a saying, Opinions are like a**holes, everyone's got one, but that doesn't mean I want to hear from yours!
DDJ
said
dale worsfold
said
i support what our troops are trying to accomplish and they have it tough enough as is. stephane dion is an opportunist and will make stephen harper look bad at any cost.
RP
said
retired soldier
said
How much do people really believe in a mission if the most they are willing to do to "support" it is put a yellow ribbon magnet on their bumper and puff out their chests and look tough when someone thinks that we shouldn't send our youth to kill and be killed. If you really support the troops - shut up or sign up!
Dave
said
Wayne
said
Simon Ladell
said
CP (former Canadian soldier)
said
Chris
said
DCR-Toronto
said
Stop thinking you have the right to know what a General in Afghanistan says to his boss, or his soldiers. Pathetic snivvlers! And yes..I have military in my family and friends.
freedom lover
said
When will the Harper government stop playing political games that endanger Canadian lives?
When will Harper stop hiding behind the troops and instead protect the troops from becoming complicit in violations of the Geneva Conventions regarding treatment of prisoners?
When will Harper show some courage?
Will the Harper government ever act in defense of Canadian values and interests?
Cheery Albertan
said
Paul Hansen
said
Let the military run the mission.....
said
"The government will not provide any comment on operational matters," said a PMO statement released Thursday.
Do we really want the media telling our government how to run a war? Do we want politicians running a war instead of the military?
I don't know about you but I've had it with this politically correct BS at every turn....we need a revolution in Canada to wake up the politically complacent and brainwashed so we can take back our country from the socialists who haven't a clue what they are doing other than making trouble.
Don
said
If Stephen Harper told me the sun came up in the East I would get a second opinion.
Dave in Surrey
said
You may feel ok with lowering our standards to their level, but most Canadians do not...
Ray
said
What's the hulaballo about?
Sounds like the more political chaff is thrown by opponents to the war occurs the more it ultimately plays into the Taliban's hands.
I see this "revelation" as cheap politicking on the backs of the soldiers who have made the supreme sacrifice.
You ought to be ashamed of yourselves!
Observerer
said
raj
said
I think most of these things, they are media driven. sadly, this is true. The media get a hold of one story, and they don't let it go. Dion knew before he went. But if telling all puts our soldiers in any danger at all, I say , keep quiet We don't need to know everything.
Mike from Canada
said
" Who in their right mind would believe that Canadians, let alone the Canadian government, would commit torture or allow the torture of prisoners?"
I hate to say it...but we already committed torture...in Somolia...
Edward in Vancouver
said
Paul out West
said
Mike from Canada
said
Len
said
Surely, how we handle prisoners is not something we are so ashamed of, that we won't tell anyone about it.
Shane Prpich
said
Kevin
said
For the first time in 22 years I feel that I have a PM that actually cares about me as a military member.
The NDP was mad that JTF took prisoner in 2002, and MR Dion was in government when we were sent to war, with out protesting about being sent into combat,in fact he was speaking out saying it must be done.
Do I agree with all the decisions of the current PM, not at all. But we are allowed to at least this one does not make me sick.
Ken
said
Dave in Surrey
said
Mr Dion, please end this soon...
Allan Eizinas
said
Perhaps they can now blame Dion and Iggy (and maybe Layton and Gilles) for not disclosing that information when they became aware.
It will be interesting to see if Harper will do this next Fred Astaire tap dance or send out one of his minions to be sacrificed.
MRM
said
Roger T
said
Didn't our PM tell other nations they need to be transparent on Human Rights issue? So what happened to our Gov't?
James
said
A CF Memeber
said
Pat - Vancouver (ex-soldier)
said
Mich
said
they should remember they were voted in by the people and for the people. Same issues---all sneaky like for North American union meetings too between Mexico Canada and USA. Same for letter they supposedly 'did not' get from Karlheinz Shrieber. I see a pattern here.
Lets have an honest and open government instead of a secretive angry one.
Bob
said
Mr. Layton's constituency would be a good place to start.
The other option is a no prisoners taken policy, oops can't do that either it goes against Mr. Layton's image of our armed forces as peace keepers.
It's time for Mr. Layton and a few dozen of these deskjockys peace activists to come out from behind their desks if only for a week and see what is really happens in Afghanistan, and I don't mean sitting inside the wire go for a walk outside spend a couple of days with the people.
Chris Rumbold
said
Jim
said
Craig
said
Oh I'm sorry, most Liberals are not in their right mind at all.
Before this get's blown out of proportion, let's all use a little common sense.
Justin
said
I don't understand, we wanted them to stop the transfers. Shouldn't we be pleased about this?
Sean
said
steve I. C.
said
Waldo
said
Dick Varley
said
K Blake
said
Charles
said
Derek
said
Instead, "Angry Mr. Harper" decided to accuse his fellow Members of Parliament of supporting the taliban.
I'm not surprised the Ice Queen of the PMO Buckler continues to mislead Canadians.
Jason
said