Top Stories -   

1
Newfoundland and Labrador Fisheries Minister Tom Hedderson speaks on Canada AM from CTV's studios in Ottawa, Tuesday, March 31, 2009. Newfoundland and Labrador Fisheries Minister Tom Hedderson speaks on Canada AM from CTV's studios in Ottawa, Tuesday, March 31, 2009. A seal.

N.L. minister meeting EU members over sealing ban

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Tom Hedderson, N.L. fisheries minister
Newfoundland and Labrador fisheries minister explains why he is in Ottawa this week to make his case to representatives of the European Union against a proposed EU ban on seal products.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (42) Facebook   

Date: Tue. Mar. 31 2009 8:41 AM ET

The European Union should reconsider its plan to go ahead with a ban on the import of seal products, says Newfoundland and Labrador Fisheries Minister Tom Hedderson.

Hedderson is in Ottawa this week to hold discussions with EU representatives, to urge them to reconsider the sealing ban.

Nordic EU countries such as Denmark, Sweden and Finland oppose the ban but a European Parliament committee recently endorsed a bill that that would prevent member countries from importing seal products.

The proposed ban would only allow for some exemptions, including products from Inuit or other indigenous communities who practise small-scale, easily monitored hunts in Alaska, Canada, Greenland and Siberia.

To become law, the bill will still need the approval of the entire EU assembly and EU governments. That could come as soon as April 21.

Hedderson says time is of the essence if Canada is going to convince the Union to scrap the bill.

Premier Danny Williams has already written to the ambassadors of EU member countries to make them aware of the province's support for the sealing industry., but Hedderson says Ottawa needs to step up its efforts too.

"We feel strongly that we need a stronger presence from the federal government," Hedderson told Canada AM Tuesday. "We are in the 11th hour, we want them to pull out all the stops."

Hedderson says if the bill is passed, the onus will be on our federal government to begin actions to challenge the ban before the World Trade Organization.

"We've been asking them for the last couple of years to make sure they are ready to go forward with WTO action. We feel that this is the only leverage we have left. It's time now for them to do it," Hedderson says.

Newfoundland and Labrador says the proposed ban is a serious threat to the province's 6,000 sealers and their families who depend on the province's $30-million sealing industry. The economic downturn is already hurting the Canadian seal industry and if the EU ban goes ahead, it could decimate it.

"But there is a bigger picture here and that is that not only are we looking at the viability of the commercial hunt, we have to look at marine resources and the effect that seals have if we let them go unchecked and the devastation it would cause to other stocks," Hedderson added.

As for opposition from animal welfare groups that the hunt is cruel and that the hunting methods are "inherently inhumane," as some groups have maintained, Hedderson says he's confident that all regulations are in place to ensure a humane hunt.

"That's been done and we're satisfied. And we would hope that the opponents would be satisfied as well."

Canada's seal hunt is the largest of its kind in the world. For this year's hunt, the federal government set a quota of 280,000 harp seals, out of a herd of more than 5.5 million. About 30 per cent of the quota is taken in the Gulf of St. Lawrence, while the rest comes from the major hunt off Newfoundland's northern coast, known as the Front.

Comments are now closed for this story

Al
said

When it comes to Spain, Portugal, France, Italy, or Germany, the only thing on my shopping list that would say "Made in ..." would be the wines. If they boycott our products then we should boycott the wines and any other product that comes out of those countries. There are lots of good alternatives to European wines.


Lisa
said

Ban the hunt are you crazy? People are not thinking about the effect it will have on the rest of the ocean. Do you know how much destruction one seal can do? Why is this such a big deal, what about all the chickens and cows that are killed everyday? You have to kill the seals to keep population down to protect other marine animals. Period.


Get a Real Job
said

It is apparent the rest of the world is becoming civilized and it is time Danny Williams (well, that's a lost cause) and Newfoundland did too. The Ottawa that governs me doesn't need to waste it's precious time stepping up it's efforts on this issue.

Anyone who wants to justify clubbing seals and skinning them alive will have to produce some out-of-this-world mind-blowing figures to show people demanding flippers and carcass on their plates before they can compare what they do to the beef industry.


Gail (Hamilton)
said

The EU is just dictating what Canada should do as regards the seal hunt. They seem to be taking a greater role on the world stage with regards to the IMF (run by Europe) at the G20 versus the World Bank. All Canadians should stand behind NL in their efforts to export seal products, instead of sounding like the EU and condemning.


Xeniya
said

All the people who are against the seal bans are cruel, unconciensious and unethical people. How woul you react if this happened to your children ?

LISTEN UP: MAJORITY OF CANADIANS ARE AGAINST THE SEAL HUNT AND SEAL HUNT IS A CRIME.

Clare in Nepean is an ignorant heartless individual who can't see past her nose.

I for one will continue boycott NL until this cruel practice stops. Not only that I will continue to spread anti-NL propaganda to everyone I know to ruin their tourism.


Shannon
said

To John in Calgary:

Sorry man, but the whole argument of controlling the seal population for the good of the eco-system is actually pathetic. If you think about it, there are 6.6 billion humans on this planet and we have done nothing but destroy our eco-systems. So, following your logic, a few billion of us should be clubbed to death... you know, just to protect the eco-systems.

Get over yourselves. Just because a certain industry has existed for a hundred years or more does not make it good and fine. I am sure when the slave trade got banned hundreds of years ago, there were quite of people out of work. But it was done because that particular industry was wrong on so many levels. So, may be the 6000 families should try their hands at something else....


Dan C in Halifax
said

Here's a thought. Those putting their efforts forward to thwart the seal hunt should concentrate and lobby for the protection of the ocean's sharks.

The shark population is on the downward spiral, and fast. Killed in record numbers for their fins to please an asian appetite that cares not about the population decline.

I'm telling you, concentrate on protecting the world's sharks and the seal population will be kept in check, but I guess that makes entirely too much sense.


George
said

Dear Bridget Curran,

If you say the majority of Canadians are against the seal hunt, please provide at least 4 sources (surveys, reports, etc.) to substantiate this claim. Making up numbers to validate your opinion is not exactly reliable


not a dumb urbanite - olds
said

Man, so much misinformation in comments here. First, anyone that works with animals beyond dogs and cats knows that animals dont perceive that human sense of freedom. They care about being warm enough, fed, space to walk around depending on species, and after that they're good. Second, we'd have a lot less chemicals and byproducts in this world if we used more environmentally friendly, endlessly renewable resources like... fur. What's in Gortex? I dunno but I dont want to eat it that's for sure. And while there is no argument that we get things out of whack lots, we have always been part of the food chain and we can't just wash our hands of it. Like the people in Alberta that want to get rid of all the cattle on public lands even though the loss of of the buffalo (our fault as a species to be sure)dictates that something needs to put grazing pressure on the land to maintain the ecosystem's balance.

The great thing about humanity is that we have the gift of seeing the irony and sadness that accompanys natural processes sometimes, but that doesn't make them wrong. If an animal lives a comfortable life and dies within minutes, thats a good day in the animal kingdom. Come to the countryside where I live and watch an old coyote or a deer clearly in it's last days. Starvation from being to weak to hunt or move to better grazing is generally part of the package. If it was your pet you'd put it down, but the whiners always think animals should live "natural lives."

In short, killing seals quickly and in numbers that correspond to the ecosystem is not bad. It's just not pretty, but that's the universe for you - Live how you want, let others be.


Nancy- Danny Williams bashed Paul McCartney
said

Premier Danny Williams of NL bashing the favorite son of Europe Sir Paul McCartney former Beetle, was the dumberst thing ever and he wonder why they ban the seals. Thnk goodness he never bashed the Queen too.


GTK
said

Economics is not a valid argument here. Seals should be culled to prevent disease and starvation from overpopulation.
The Federal Government needs to properly manage it though. If left to their own devices, Newfoundlanders would hunt anything to extinction for the sake of money(then blame someone else). There are very few replanted clearcuts, I have seen one live Moose in four years and I can get fresh seafood and fish year round regardless of season or ban. These people will poach and eradicate anything that makes them money and there is no reasoning with them.


Steve in PEI
said

Killing seals is the same as killing any other animal. Canadians who oppose the killing of these celebrity animals and still eat meat and wear leather should think twice. Seals are a wedge, and once they've been used to establish a precedent that harvesting animals is "wrong", your own lifestyle will be squarely in the crosshairs. Because let me tell you, there's NO DIFFERENCE between what goes on out on the ice and what happens in order to provide you with nice, juicy hamburgers, except that in the former case the animals were free-range.


Bill in BC
said

Seals are not cute & cuddly. They are ravenous predators that no longer have a predator above them except humans. We are the onlyl thing that keeps their numbers in check.

Ever see what a seal eats? Only the belly of the fish, wasting the rest.

Maintain the hunt.


Meg J from Chatham
said

Bridget Curran: "All life is important & where cruelty is present, cruelty must be abolished. It doesn't matter if it is human or non-human."

That you think and would state publicly that human and animal life are equal to each other shows how people like yourself, and others opposed to the seal hunt, are on the extreme fringes of Canadian society.

I'll join other people on here in saying that I will boycott French and other EU wines and products if this ban goes through. Time to hurt them in their pocketbooks if they try to hurt us.


J.C.
said

Yes it is necessary for the human race to kill for food just as it is for other species to do so. The problem as I see it is not the matter of killing for food but rather the killing for fur only! According to the government the young white coats are not allowed to be killed anymore, however I wonder how many of them die because their mother is killed for her fur? I'm sorry but I cannot agree with the killing of any animal other than what is necessary to survive and this means not for fur or sport!!! Also if man stays out of the multitudes slaughtered the fish environment would naturally adjust as is the case with nature until man's interference creates upsets in the natural environment.



John in Calgary
said

Stop this ridiculous talk about banning the seal hunt. The seals need to be managed or the eco system goes out of whack. The EU is unwise to restrict the importation of seal pelts to everyone. What about those that want the pelts? Is the EU our conscience? Hardly.

Does this restrictive action help the economy? Not at all.


Michelle
said

The answer to the "cute factor" ethical problem is to stop eating ugly chickens, pigs and cows. Eat legumes and support a farmer. They make more money growing crops than they do on livestock. It is virtually impossible to make a profit on livestock these days unless you go into factory warehousing of animals which is really cruel. I will say this much, at least the seals got to spend some of their lives living in freedom.


Bridget Curran, Halifax, NS
said

The people banging on about slaughterhouses & nobody caring about the "ugly" animals need to seriously change the record. It got old a long time ago.

If you actually gave the matter some investigation you would discover that the organizations campaigning against the seal hunt also run campaigns against factory farming, fois gras, veal, etc. The media does not give it the same coverage as it gives this issue.

The idea that we should condone the cruelty of the seal hunt simply because there are other cruel practices is ludicrous. You cannot excuse one evil simply because there are other evils.

Stop assuming that everyone opposing the seal hunt wears leather and eats meat. Many of the people opposing the seal hunt are vegan. Illogically, the argument is used that unless you're vegan you don't have the right to oppose the seal hunt, while at the same time if you ARE vegan, you are a tree-hugging freak who is trying to tell everyone to live their lives, etc. etc.

Equally ludicrous is the suggestion that people involved in the anti-sealing campaign should involve themselves in more "worthy" causes like human rights violations. Those involved in animal causes would never tell someone "Forget about the starving children of Africa; the seals are more important!". All life is important & where cruelty is present, cruelty must be abolished. It doesn't matter if it is human or non-human.

To RobP who suggested that we go learn about the real seal hunt, I have done just that. I spent the past few years researching the "real seal hunt" & have observed the killing of harp seals in the northern & southern Gulf of St. Lawrence, the killing of grey seals in Nova Scotia & can confirm that it's horrendously cruel & must be abolished.


LR
said

Bridget:
"If sealers want to be able to remain stuck in the dark ages with their clubs to continue killing seals,"

Didn't you get the MEMO?
Sealers use guns now, not clubs. Amazing isn't it?

"I repeat - the majority of Canadians oppose the commercial seal hunt"

Since when do YOU speak for the majority of Canadians. The last time I looked, my passport said Canada. I DO support the seal hunt, as do thousands of other hard working and educated Canadians!

I repeat, I DO support the seal hunt! ;)


John Clax
said

Bridget, the majority of mainstream Canadians do NOT oppose the seal hunt. And Trish, "slaughter of innocents"? They're ANIMALS, no different than cows, pigs, lambs, or chickens, which we all happily eat, and wear leather from.

I agree with Clare from Nepean - boycott or ban European wines and other EU products, if they continue with their actions against the seal hunt.


Jim in Calgary
said

Stop the slaughter! 6000 fishermen ruin the reputation of 30 million. Fish stocks are down due to the previous uncontrolled slaughter not because of seals. Ottawa should invest money into new jobs for the region not for coast guards to protect this disaster.


kt e
said

I remember how warm and waterproof my seal skin boots were when I was a child (over half a century ago). i sure wish I could get something that quality today to get me through these long cold winters. I certainly believe that in the scheme of things, as long as the product is used ie; clothing, food, shelter we have control over the natural resources, and they should be used accordingly. Sure beats chemical manufacture of synthetic clothing.
kt e


Bridget Curran
said

The federal government should respect the wishes of the majority of Canadians, abolish the cruel commercial seal hunt and implement a license buyback program.


I'm fed up with my tax dollars being used to subsidize this annual atrocity. It is our tax dollars that pay for:


1. Coast Guard planes that spot seals and radio coordinates to sealers;


2. icebreakers that clear paths in the ice allowing sealers to reach seals and tow non-iceworthy sealing vessels that are stuck or damaged by ice due to sealers' stupidity and greed;


3. Marketing initiatives, trying to find new buyers for seal products while markets dwindle and prices plummet;


4. All-expenses paid trips to Europe for sealers, Inuit and government officials to defend something to which the majority of Canadians object;


If sealers want to be able to remain stuck in the dark ages with their clubs to continue killing seals, let them fund it themselves. Remove the subsidies. Need ice broken? Pay for the icebreaker yourselves. Need to know where your victims are? Pay for the spotter planes yourselves. Need rescuing because you got stuck in ice? Pay for it yourselves. Need to find new markets? Find them yourselves. Want to go to Europe to cry on the shoulders of MEPs? Pay for it yourselves. Want to fly journalists over to have sealers paraded in front of them? Fund it yourselves. Want an EU ban challenged at WTO? Pay for it yourselves.


End the subsidies; make the sealers pay for the seal hunt. We'll see how long it lasts then.


I repeat - the majority of Canadians oppose the commercial seal hunt. The federal government should stop using our tax dollars to prop up and defend this appallingly cruel industry, abolish the commercial seal hunt and implement non-lethal alternatives.


Christian, NL
said

For those people who have pictures of the whitecoat seals, know this...Newfoundlanders do not hunt them anymore, since roughly 20 years ago. So stop bringing up the whitecoat seals.


Christian, NL
said

When the "Green" people came to Newfoundland to protest the sealhunt, the woman from MASH came with a group of people spraying the baby seals with green paint...when the seals came back to their mothers, the mothers disowned them because the scent of spray paint covered the baby seals own scent. Hundreds of baby seals died on the ice because of Starvation, so who is the seal killers?


Chris in Ottawa
said

In my opinion, the annual east coast seal hunt only garners the attention it does for two reasons:

1. It's done in public, not behind closed doors in a slaughterhouse.

2. Whitecoat harp seals are considered 'cute' in the same way a teddy bear is considered cute.

Veal is made from calfs ('baby' cows), but the hub-bub about their slaughter is strangely quiet. Why? Probably because there's zero fund-raising potential in it.

And don't give me that crap about wearing furs (i.e. animal hide with the hair left on), because that belt, purse, shoes, and leather jacket make your arguments ring hollow.

Animal slaughter is messy work, regardless of the animal. You're a human and are equipped with pointy teeth and a short intestine -- get over it.

My only caveat on this is to only take what you need, and don't kill for sport. These sealers aren't killing seals for the sport of it.


SJC
said

seal meat is high in protein and a bunch of other stuff like omega 3, DHA.

seal leather is supple, warm, lightweight and the only naturally waterproof leather there is.

seal oil(dubbin) is salt resistant and the best for waterproofing boots, shoes and other stuff for winter.

no one really complains about any other animal that is similarly or completely consumed. cows, pigs and chickens dont make the general public's list of 'cute and fuzzy' animals. that is the only real argument that can be made, in light of the real facts. of course, most nay-sayers only use selective parts in order to make their case.

i have a BA in natural resource management and lived in NL for 10 years. i have heard just about every argument for and against the hunt.



Terry - Calgary
said

It really blows my mind that due to the cute factor and celebrity endorcement the lively hoods of good, hard working people is put on the line. Animals are killed by the thousands every hour from chickens to cows to horses. The seal hunt has been a part of the culture and backbone of many Newfoundland homes since 1723. I ask, why is it now a crime?


Trish, ON
said

Millions of dollars are squandered by the Canadian government on the cruel uneconomical and dysfunctional sealing industry. Millions are spent every year trying to counter bans on the importation of seal products. The DFO, since at least 2003, has been flying high-level delegations to Europe to argue against the bans.

It seems that a whole industry of government spending is supported by the slaughter of seals. But who does it benefit? Not the people of Newfoundland. These people have been colonized all over again; this time not by merchant traders but by a government bureaucracy - and, all for 7 votes in Newfoundland!
Wouldn't the money wasted on subsidies for the sealing industry be better invested in the safety of our soldiers in Afghanistan, whose lives are further endangered by lack of proper equipment and support?

Where are our priorities? Martin Luther King once said, “Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter.” Every Canadian who doesn't speak out against this inhumane "slaughter of innocents" is guilty by association!


Rick in NB
said

To CYL are you willing to use your tax dollars to subsidize the seal hunting population. Or would you have them starve?
Remember this France is known for its pate' foi gras. Google the process for making foi gras, then you will have more people in jail. If you eat meat than you should be jailed due to slaughter houses. Google it than maybe your narrow misled comment will change, if not then i suspect you just wanted the first comment.



Oscar in Ottawa
said

Why is it always the cute animals that get the world's attention?

The same people who shame the seal hunt condone the common practices involved in the farming of cattle, pigs, poultry etc which makes their comments hypocritical and in reality, laughable.

The hacapic (sp?) is as humane as some of the other mass euthanizing methods used in other animal rendering facilities, like it or not.

Let's not forget the culling of the seal heard, flock or whatever they're called is also to elevate spin off issues such as the volume of fish the seal's consume and ring worms in fish. To stop the cull could tip the balance in the eco system and cause over seal population and future issues such as disease and starvation of the heard (then who will they blame?)

In the end, I like my steak medium rare and in the words of Denis Leary “you’re a baseball mitt now get on the truck”



duck
said

THe seal hunt is no different than any other harvest. We harvest to provide income, food and shelter. I have yet to see the "antis" step up to the plate and offer alternative solutions to the people that harvest to sustain their families. Perhaps governments should listen more closely to the silent majority than to the vocal well financed minority with a narrow agenda to save the animals--- at what cost---


Lorne
said

CYL: Your comments are nothing short of ignorant and extremist.

"The people who kill these animals should be put in prison, like any other killing crime."

By your words, we would have to call home all our troops, call up all our reserves, pull our entire RCMP force and just about all provincial police just to manage and guard the hundreds of new prisons that we will need to contain the thousands of hard working fisherman, sealers, cattle ranchers, pig farmers, chicken farmers, the entire Maple Leaf Foods Co. etc. that you would have imprisoned. GOOD JOB CYL!! GOOD JOB!! ;)


BB
said

Unbelievable, hundreds of thousands of people are being laid-off in the automotive, education, health, steel, etc sectors, and we are supposed to spend hundreds of millions saving the livelihoods of 6000 sealers who insist on living in the Dark Ages?

The ignorance of all DFO officials and fishermen has depleted fish stocks and destroyed the oceans. There is NO SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE that reducing the seal population will help fish stocks recover (it is even mentioned on the DFO website!), yet these morons still say they have to keep the seals in check. Seals are being used as scapegoats and it is time the real culprits paid for their crimes.

I am praying the EU won't listen to the government propaganda and ban all seal products sooner rather than later. It is time for this industry to simply die.


J. Blough
said

CYL: So how 100's of 1000's of slaughterhouse workers and any animal industry workers are going to have to go to prison? Your logic, well, lacks any.


Tom A from Toronto
said

CYL: "The people who kill these animals should be put in prison, like any other killing crime."

CYL, are you equating killing animals with killing humans? It's nutjob animal right extremist statements like those that give these so-called animal welfare organizations absolutely zero credibility amongst the mainstream public.


Clare from Nepean
said

Canada should tell the EU that if they put in this ban, we will counter it with a ban on wine imports from the EU. I'm sure that would get them paying attention (they export far more wine to Canada than they import of seal products), and stop all this banning discussion fairly quickly.


Colin
said

Good idea CYL, and put another 6,000 people out of a job.

Just because the animal is cute doesn't make it a crime to kill them.


Rob P
said

CYL:
Why not go learn about the real seal hunt before you get all defensive. I really wish someone would put you uneducated fools in school and teach you how seal hunting is no where near as bad as what they do with cattle, pigs and chickens. Go use your energies for something more constructive like helping poverty stricken children.


Ken Young
said

CYL
Ban the killing, and the import. The people who kill these animals should be put in prison, like any other killing crime.

************
Said the population of the world as they march off hand in hand to MacDonalds.


Nick
said

Ban the hunt, and then watch the rest of the marine life be decimated. Not to mention the 6,000 or so more folks collecting welfare and other support incomes. Good plan.


CYL
said

Ban the killing, and the import. The people who kill these animals should be put in prison, like any other killing crime.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges