Top Stories -   

1
Two patrons enjoy a drink of beer at a Jack Astor's restaruant in Toronto in this undated photo. Study co-author Paul Ronksley explains details of the reviews on CTV News on Wednesday, Feb. 23, 2011. Killer booze. The Cactus Club low alcohol Cohiba, a signature drink made with spearmint and soda, comes with a half shot of vodka instead of a full one ounce. (Cactus Club)

Reviews confirm it: Alcohol really is good for the heart

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Avis Favaro on the study
Researchers at the University of Calgary believe they have the definite answer to the old age debate on whether alcohol is good or bad for the heart.
CTV News Channel: Paul Ronksley, co-author
The study's co-author says two systematic reviews were conducted and they found that light to moderate alcohol consumption was cardio-protective.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (30) Facebook   

Two patrons enjoy a drink of beer at a Jack Astor's restaruant in Toronto in this undated photo. Study co-author Paul Ronksley explains details of the reviews on CTV News on Wednesday, Feb. 23, 2011. Killer booze. The Cactus Club low alcohol Cohiba, a signature drink made with spearmint and soda, comes with a half shot of vodka instead of a full one ounce. (Cactus Club)

Photos

Two patrons enjoy a drink of beer at a Jack Astor's restaruant in Toronto in this undated photo.

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Feb. 23 2011 2:31 PM ET

A drink a day really might keep heart disease at bay, new Canadian research is confirming.

Two studies from the University of Calgary have concluded that moderate alcohol consumption can cut the risk of death from heart disease and stroke by up to 25 per cent compared to people who don't drink at all.

A little bit of alcohol can also significantly increase levels of "good" cholesterol, thereby reducing the risk of heart disease.

The researchers say the key to reaping the benefits of alcohol is to keep consumption moderate -- up to one drink a day for women, and one to two drinks a day for men. They note over-consumption will erase any of alcohol's health advantages and could increase the risk of death.

The studies, which appear in the British Medical Journal, are not new research, but instead are reviews of previous studies. Both reviews were led by Dr. William Ghali of U of C's faculty of medicine.

The first study written by Dr. Paul Ronksley reviewed 84 studies that looked at the link between alcohol consumption and heart disease. The studies compared alcohol drinkers with non-drinkers and their outcomes in relation to heart disease, death from heart disease, incidences of stroke and death from stroke.

It concludes that people who drink alcohol in moderation are 14 to 25 per cent less likely to develop heart disease than those who don't drink alcohol.

The other study by Dr. Susan Brien reviewed 63 studies and found that moderate consumption of alcohol significantly increases levels of "good" cholesterol, which has a protective effect against heart disease. As well, other heart disease markers, such as inflammation and blood vessel clotting, were also lower in moderate drinkers.

Her study concludes that it is the alcohol content that provides the health benefits, not the type of alcoholic beverage, such as wine, beer or spirits.

The authors of both papers acknowledge that a number of previous studies have already concluded essentially the same thing: that moderate alcohol consumption appears to lower the risk of heart disease. But, they say there was need for a new review of the latest studies. This research is the most comprehensive to date, they say.

Dr. Ghali said in a news release from the journal's publisher that the discussion about the impact of alcohol on heart disease should now centre "on how to integrate this evidence into clinical practice and public health messages."

He adds "with respect to public health messages, there may now be an impetus to better communicate to the public that alcohol, in moderation, may have overall health benefits that outweigh the risks in selected subsets of patients… any such strategy would need to be accompanied by rigorous study and oversight of impacts."

Comments are now closed for this story

Aaron Sterlind
said
0 0

For all of you: where did a mythical diety enter into this study I wonder since I see you talking about a god and the funny thing is none of you understand anything about theology, and for the one who suggested brain cells die from alcohol use, well I suppose its a good thing we have plenty of them, I drink alot and I'm still way smarter than you are, actually scored 140 on an IQ test while blind drunk. Oh, and for the one who talked about government, well this isn't a democracy its a socialist totalitarian system and its getting worse just ask Monsanto but my rules are simple, I'll put whatever I want into my own body good or bad, I need no justification to do what I want and no permission, I'm am not a little child of big brother who needs someones acceptance and admiration, I am a free man and I need to drink to interact with a world of dumbed down mostly retarded society who enjoy their little games.


Dustin in the Yukon
said
0 0

and what would the effects of drinking alcohol once a day be on other organs just curious especially on the liver. Those who die from alcohol are usually abusing it right? People need to keep an open mind about these kinds of studies.


PV
said
0 0

And to think you posted an article on Nov 1, 2010 with the title "Alcohol more harmful than heroin, cocaine, study finds". In fact, that study found that alcohol had 3 times the score of tobacco. And people wonder why such studies are fluffed off as not credible.


Pete
said
0 0

That's like with everything else in life......It's good for You , but in moderation !


LP
said
0 0

.... but really bad for the liver.


Mitch in Kitch
said
0 0

I knew study shows that 3 out of 5 people don't care about studies which constantly show up in the news. But, they will have to do another study on that study to verify that the study was accurate to 3.1% 9 times out of 10 (WHAT DOES THAT EVEN MEAN!!)I think a new study would show that spending money on things that matter would greatly increase the benefit of the study, which would have to be studied.


Paul ~ Kitchener
said
0 0

This is "NOT NEWS", this has been known since the Egyptians invented beer 5000 years ago. My grandparents knew the heart benefits in the late 1880's (told them by their doctor) ~ WOOW !Lets stop these surveys and reports, from those who can't find real jobs ~ "IT'S NOT NEWS" !


Alyx Crawford
said
0 0

Reading the comments here, I'm wondering how many people read beyond the headline, and how many don't understand what "moderation" means?


Doug ^^^ BC
said
0 0

I always take polls and studies with a grain of salt.If the subject at hand is important enough to me,I do some follow up before I take them even a wee bit seriously. But my question to "Tom" would be about what studies he thinks should be published.Would those be studies he agrees with? SOuld we all just read studies we like,and ignore the ones we don't like? And who gets to decide? How does that further the cause of either democracy of mankind? I know it is a part of human nature to agree with people we like,and to disagree with people we don't like.But that's a poor excuse for dismissing as trivail,any idea or study that you personally don't agree with.What are your qualifications for dismissing this study "Tom"? If they are credible,I'll wait anxiously to read the details of your "study". No one should accept this study as "fact".It may well be that different people will have different reactions to alcohol use.Certainly we know using to much rarely brings about a good result for anyone.But on balance,modertate use may well be beneficial---- for some people.If you believe that not to be the case,do another study, and make your case.Otherwise,all you're doing is spitballing on a subject you have an opinion on,but show no particular expertise to make that opinion credible.At the end of the day,each of us will read several "studies",and make up our own minds.Assuming,of course,that ALL credible studies will be published. Now,if you will excuse me,I'm off to get a nice bottle of wine.A glass with dinner tonight sounds like a great idea.And healthy too.


Terry in Edmonton
said
0 0

This is welcome news! If only I could continue to bank all my daily drinks, and save them for my weekend benders once or twice a month and still get all those health benefits! Oh well, I guess I'll just have to take my drink along with my vitamins. I can't think of a better way to start my day! If anyone comments or complains, I'll just call it my doctor recommended daily health booze lol. From now on, I'll add a shot of vodka to my nutritious anti-oxidant fruit smoothies. Since men can have 2 drinks, I'll take my second stiff shot at lunch to keep the health benefits rolling all day. I think it would make work a lot more enjoyable. Cheers to medical science! I'll drink to that!


Bob
said
0 0

I'm all of a sudden thirsty after reading the article. I need a cold one!


ND
said
0 0

Too much of "anything" will be bad for you.


Mikael
said
0 0

God doesn't oppose drinking He only opposes drunkenness. It's the man made religious institutions that frown on drinking yet if you go in many of their homes they often serve alcohol to their guests!!


DANIEL H
said
0 0

And some of these remarks show that alcohol destroys brain cells. OK you bums that want any reason to pour one down, drink up and kill yourself and leave the rest of us be happy to have ONE drink.These forums are great! Where else can I go and poke fun at beer IQs.


Gerald
said
0 0

So If I have a beer mug that fits 4 frosty cold ones, is that still ok ?


No Thanks
said
0 0

The problem is, Canadians and North Americans in general don't know how to drink in moderation. We are a society of beer guzzlers and abusers who don't know how to handle our alcohol, and we pass along our dysfunction from one generation to the next. We see the devastating effects of drinking everyday... just ask a police officer or social worker what percentage of their work is alcohol-related. Maybe in some parts of Europe there is still a culture where families enjoy a glass of wine with their meal, but even in places like England the drinking problem is out of control and costing $4.5B a year in healthcare costs. It's a losing battle folks! The research is interesting, but in the end it will give our culture all the more justification to keep guzzling.


Salt and Vinegar
said
0 0

If you only have 1 drink a day, is it ok to crack open a cold beer while at the gym?


Tom
said
0 0

Studies like this shouldn't even be published, a recent British study showed alcohol to be more harmful than heroin or cocaine & the study said that alcohol damages every organ in the body. alcohol killed my father at 49 & it has killed many others I have know at much younger ages.


Nanook
said
0 0

How big can that ONE drink be???


kentingtonInOttawa
said
0 0

Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.- Benjamin Franklin


Dean Martin
said
0 0

I didn't drink from ages 1-18, so I can "catch" up now??? Just like carbon credits, right.....


Mimi2005
said
0 0

Cheers!


JP
said
0 0

Why does it matter if it is good for the heart when it is BAD for most other organs? People are so dense. I am sure cyanide is good for some organs too in small doses. You all realize there are anti-oxidants and heart-health promoting vitamins and minerals in the raw grapes the alchohol comes from right, along with all the other fruits and veggies? Oh well who cares, you all just go on and kill yourselves...makes me lots of money when you do that anyway! Drink up, serfs!


David H
said
0 0

After reading the piece on cinema popcorn being unhealthy (a study was commissioned for this??) It's good to know that I can rely on a nice cold beer. A thought: Get rid of that nasty popcorn and replace it with beer pumps :D


Darsehole
said
0 0

So, if I'm drinking alone, am I an alcoholic or a health freak?


One Beer Bill
said
0 0

This will give all the alcoholics out there some license to excuse their aberrant behaviour. For those of us who have family members or spouses who are alcoholics and refuse to acknowledge their need for help this kind of study doesn't help. Alcoholism is a serious issue which often starts with the way society condones getting drunk at parties etc. Being drunk is irresponsible, unsociable behaviour which can lead to other things including alcoholism if not stopped.


George V
said
0 0

The operative word is ONE drink a day. As long as you have the will power to stick to that.


Munro - Brampton
said
0 0

For men, two drinks is moderate ?! If you drank less then you would'nt be drinking.


Mario
said
0 0

Good for the heart - bad for the liver...what to do what to do... lol


Gerald
said
0 0

See, there is a God.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Facebook

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook

Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges