Top Stories -   

1
A doctor treats an elderly patient.

Canadian doctors feel overworked: survey

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Dr. Calvin Gutkin, College of Physicians
DM09_docs_chat
Canada AM: Discussion of the new physician survey
CAN09_doctors

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (12)Add Comments Facebook   

Date: Wed. Jan. 9 2008 10:23 AM ET

Canadian doctors say they are feeling increasingly frustrated by their inability to properly serve their patients' health needs, a national physicians survey reports.

The National Physician Survey questioned more than 20,000 doctors and doctors-in-training from across the country about their attitudes to the current health care climate.

Seventy-five per cent reported that inadequate funding of the health-care system, an undersupply of physicians and other health professionals, paperwork and bureaucracy are cutting into the level of care they want to provide patients.

The reasons the doctors cited for their frustrations included:

  • increasing complexity of patient caseloads (80%);
  • management of patients with chronic diseases/conditions (73%);
  • increasing patient expectations (70%);
  • and the aging population (69% among all physicians, 80% among family physicians)

The survey found timely access to health care remains a serious challenge for Canadians. Despite government investments to achieve reduced wait times in priority areas such as cancer treatment and diagnostic imaging, the progress has been uneven, the survey results suggest.

The doctors also reported that access in other key areas, such as emergency services, is still poor. In fact, ratings for these services have worsened since 2004 when the survey was first conducted.

College of Family Physicians of Canada President Dr. Ruth Wilson says most of the stress that doctors - particularly family doctors - are experiencing can be traced back to the physician shortage that has plagued this country for years.

"We've been hearing for quite a while that we've got a doctor shortage. This new survey shows that although we thought we were making some progress, perhaps we're not," she told Canada AM Wednesday.

"There are 4,000 doctors likely to retire in the next two years, and we're not even able to replace them. So I think the main news is that we need a plan here. We need a Canadian plan."

She notes that part of the shortage problem is that Canada's 17 medical schools have not been training enough doctors to replace all the ageing and retiring doctors.

"Lots of young Canadians want to be doctors, and we have one of the highest ratios of Canadians applying to medical school compared to the number of spots of many countries in the world," she notes.

"But nine people apply for every spot in medical school in Canada. The number of medical school entry positions was cut a number of years ago. It takes a while for that cut to work its way through. And we're still seeing the effects."

Wilson also notes that the face of Canada's medical workforce is changing. Of all the new physicians under 35 years of age replacing baby boomer doctors, 55 per cent are female. And many of those women are choosing to have families and to take time off to be with them.

"We know that women in their child-bearing age who are physicians work fewer hours. That just makes sense," says Wilson.

"Once the children are out of the home, men and women work roughly the same number of hours, but the increasing number of women in medicine, particularly in the younger age groups, is going to affect the ability to deliver services as well."

Dr. Louise Samson, who is president of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada as well as a practicing radiologist in Montreal, notes that it's not just women who want a better work-life balance than previous generations of doctors; it's younger doctors or both genders.

She says that's what she expects to see in a second survey coming out in the spring that will ask younger doctors about what kind of career they want to have.

"It's most possible that the younger people don't want to work as hard as the baby boomer. So it's not only women in medicine, it's the whole new generation as well," she says.

Samson believes that part of the solution to the time crunch that current doctors are facing lies in having other health care professionals take over some of the duties that physicians are now asked to perform.

"We have to do a lot of secretarial work, administrative work, and in my own practice, I have to do tasks outside my expertise that somebody else could do. And then I cannot concentrate on the task I should do, that I've been trained for," she told Canada AM.

"So these are some of the obstacles between patients and physicians."

Wilson says the survey found that despite all the challenges in the health care system that were revealed by the survey, 84 per cent of physicians confirmed they are either somewhat or very satisfied with their relationships with patients.

The National Physician Survey is Canada's largest census survey of physicians and physicians-in-training. It is conducted jointly by The College of Family Physicians of Canada, the Canadian Medical Association and The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada.

1

Add New Comment ( )

Bradley Lawrence
said
0 0

I was reading about Jolan Horvath and it brought back the bone scan I had diagnosed on my left ankle. I hurt my left ankle severely Sept/03 and my family physician sent me for x-rays which showed nothing out of wack, but i couldn't perform my job, but I did for a while(jumping off the back of a garbage truck picking up big brown bags of yard waste)'till i couldn't take it anymore. Went back to my doc again,he referred me to a specialist at hospital in Oshawa,Ont. By the time I got the appointment for a bone scan and my doctor called me back for results, it was now Dec./03 (3 months after the injury) LEFT TIBIA ANKLE FRACTURE, which set in its own way due to time it took through the health care system. Now I have to live with intermitten pain for the rest of my life. I'm Canadian, pay taxes, served in Canadian Forces till medical problems honorabily discharged me from the military.


STOP THE ABUSE!
said
0 0

Seeing as we now scan our Healthcards at the doctors, there should be a rating system. At the end of the year...it shouldd be analysed and people billed/taxed accordingly..I go to the doctors once a year for my check-up and don't bother wasting anyone's time by goin in for a runny nose! If people actually saw the waste of money they caused directly on their taxes I bet they would start being responisible...

Doctor... Doctor...
said
0 0

Why do you think people fill the emergency rooms? Because family doctors don't find it necessary to work 9-5 and "after hour clinics" are only open 5-7.

What a bunch of whiners.

They're ALL in the top earning bracket, work ridiculously short hours, don't care about the health of patients and now complain that they're overworked?????

Before trying to get more doctors into Canada, why don't we fix the ones with already have. Teach them that being doctor is not a free pass to easy money.

ance
said
0 0

There are still too many people at the doctors office for trivial reasons.
I have a friend who goes to the doc for every little thing because "she pays for it and is entitled".
This is a bad attitude shared by many Canadians who are ill informed about just how much health care is overburdened, underfunded and understaffed.

J-F (Ottawa)
said
0 0

Anyone in Canada who complains about our Health Care system angers me to the core.
No, our system isn't perfect and alot of people do suffer from wait times and certain lack of facilities or care, but this is common to every country in the world. Please, for one moment, think what it would be like if we had a system like the U.S. where we pay out of pocket or other countries where qualified doctors are very rare.
We are very fortunate in Canada to have the Health Care system we do, be thankful! It will NEVER be perfect, appreciate what's positive about it.
We need to concentrate on paying these doctors and nurses what they deserve and perhaps encourage more students to consider health care careers. We are losing too many doctor's to the U.S. because they pay more and aren't subjected to 18 hours a day.


Albert
said
0 0

When I finished residency, I had an enormous student loan that I had to begin repaying. I took over a rural family practice and began to work very long hours. Patients would come in with lists of problems and take too much time. The waiting room got very backed up, and I would work into the evening every day to catch up. I had to do night and weekend call too. Then I started coming in on weekends to do paper work, check lab reports, dictate letters, etc. all unpaid. I would fall asleep at the wheel regularly on the way home, but luckily never crashed. Finally after three years, I burned out. The only way out was to leave the town and move away to start over. This is a common scenario. Doctors have to find a balance. Now I see fewer patients, am less stressed, and make a lot less money. My neighbours with only four years of university and average grades all have paid vacations and pension plans. I don't, except what I save out of my own pocket. Often I feel trapped and wish I had picked another career. Some of my colleagues have left clinical work for business and administration. We envy their regular hours and benefits. Family practice and other specialties can be a burnout. Shortages exist in part because conditions are undesirable. Doctors are an intelligent mobile population with families, hopes and dreams like everyone else. We are not monks sacrificing our lives, nor are we inmates to be legislated. We want to help our patients and provide good care, like any professional. Help us make our conditions desirable, and we will stay.


Jacob Bullock
said
0 0

I still find it odd that as a wealthy country we lack the medical capacity to treat our small population. When compared to some other places like the Middle East or China we have next to no doctor and I blame the system first. Many of the doctors from other countries are being turned down in Canada because they do not have a canadian medical certificate. I remember a Middle Eastern friend of mine saying that when you want down a street in the Middle East there may be 3 or 4 doctor offices in a row, all specialists who you just walk in off the street to get treatment. When there is an accident, 5 or 6 doctors will come running down the street to the scene. It's hard to imagine this when here in Canada we constantly sit in 5 hour wait times.


KATZ
said
0 0

I have been the victim of medical fraud,retaliated against, left in a critically ill condition without medical help for four months. I had a LP and my condition afterward was labelled as a mental problem to cover it up. My family was lied to. The hospital made sure no abnormal blood test results were ever given so that my family would think I was in this condition because I was depressed. I now have damage to my spine and will have to leave the county to find out the full extent of the damage to my body. The public needs to educate themselves about patient blacklisting, retaliation etc....
People who wonder why they are being refused tests need to find out it there is more going on.


Kathy
said
0 0

I am a Canadian trying to obtain acceptance into medical school. I have good grades, varied experiences, remarkable motivation, and much health care experience; I even assisted with births. However, because of med school requirements specifically the MCAT (a US based standardized test that costs over US$200 not including study materials), I have yet again not been accepted. I have a low score on the physics section and refuse to spend more money on this U.S. test. Funny, I didn't know physics was so crucial to the study of medicine! I even plan to practice family medicine in a community in N.S. I thought I would be a perfect candidate. Now I am forced to look at other career choices while I wait another year to apply. Wish me luck!


Roch
said
0 0

The socialist medicare system is broken beyond repair.


Emma Hawthorne
said
0 0

Old-fashioned doctors fought against bringing nurse practitioners and psychologists into the health care system. They opposed group practice models. And the health care system is filled with inefficiency. Hopefully modern doctors will welcome new specilties who can often provide more appropriate and less expensive care, along with greater accessibility. I think we need fewer psychiatrists who are not very good at psychotherapy and more psychologists. Many complain about wait times but make no effort to speed things up by calling specialists to ask for cancelled appointments and cancelled surgery times. Many abuse the system. For example, Toronto hospitals now instruct emergency staff NOT to advise patients about nearby walk-in clinics as the hospitals hope to shake down naive provincial officials yet again. I find the medical lobby unconvincing, although Canada is blessed with some very good medical efficiency experts who are also very pro-doctor and therefore do have credibility.


Jolan Horvath
said
0 0

I have been suffering with severe upper right abdominal pain for the past five years. Have had many ultrasounds and blood tests and even a CT scan which showed nothing. I have had a good gall bladder removed and I am positive I have difficulty with my liver genetically and cannot get an appointment with a liver specialist nor can I get a MRI to clarify any diagnoises. The claim is that the cost is too high to waste on me. I am extremely disappointed with the health care system.

Jolan Horvath


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges