Top Stories -   

1
Minister of National Defence and Minister for the Atlantic Gateway Peter MacKay speaks with the media following Question Period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday Oct.7, 2009. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Military Police Complaints Commission chair Peter A. Tinsley listens to remarks during the Public Interest Hearings into the allegations regarding Afghan Detainees in Gatineau, Que. Wednesday October 7, 2009. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick) NDP MP for St.John's-East Jack Harris holds up a copy of an affidavit filed by diplomat Richard Colvin with the Military Police Complaints Commission during a news conference in Ottawa, Thursday October 15, 2009. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

MacKay denies knowing about Afghan torture

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Freya Kristjanson, Military Police Complaints Commission
While the government says it is cooperating with the Military Complaints Commission, it has failed to deliver documents requested by the panel as far back as 2008.
CTV News Channel: Roger Smith on prisoners
In an affidavit presented Wednesday, an official said he sent memos to Ottawa regarding abuse in Afghanistan dating back to 2006.
Power Play: Afghan detainee probe shut down
A commission investigating the alleged torture of Afghan prisoners after Canadian soldiers handed them over to Afghan authorites has been shut down. The commission counsel explains.
CTV News Channel: Tom Clark on crucial documents
The inquiry into the Canadian military's handling of Afghan detainees has been postponed since the government has been slow to produce the necessary documents.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (13) Facebook   

Minister of National Defence and Minister for the Atlantic Gateway Peter MacKay speaks with the media following Question Period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday Oct.7, 2009. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Military Police Complaints Commission chair Peter A. Tinsley listens to remarks during the Public Interest Hearings into the allegations regarding Afghan Detainees in Gatineau, Que. Wednesday October 7, 2009. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick) NDP MP for St.John's-East Jack Harris holds up a copy of an affidavit filed by diplomat Richard Colvin with the Military Police Complaints Commission during a news conference in Ottawa, Thursday October 15, 2009. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Photos

Minister of National Defence and Minister for the Atlantic Gateway Peter MacKay speaks with the media following Question Period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday Oct.7, 2009. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Selected Comment

This inquiry isn't about judges and commissions want to make Canadian policy and laws, it's about bringing the truth to light so Canadians can make an informed voting choice in the next election. No Canadian government of any political stripe should be able to conceal their behavior on any issue behind a self proclaimed "National Security" issue, regardless of whether or not it may be embaressing. A commitment to be transparent and accountable by any politician or party forming a government may be what the people want to hear, however past and present practise has sown doubts on any credibility in that mission statement.

howard

Military commission blasts feds for withholding info

talking about
MacKay denies knowing about Afghan torture

Date: Thu. Oct. 15 2009 5:31 PM ET

Defence Minister Peter MacKay says he wasn't aware of warnings authored by a Canadian diplomat that prisoners in Afghanistan faced the risk of being tortured if transferred to local authorities.

"I have not seen those reports in either my capacity as minister of National Defence or previously as minister of Foreign Affairs," he told The Canadian Press.

MacKay was responding to an affidavit that diplomat Richard Colvin filed to the Military Police Complaints Commission on Wednesday, which said that government officials knew of the risks because he personally warned them in writing in 2006.

Colvin -- who is now an intelligence officer with the Foreign Affairs department -- said in his written statement that he filed two reports in 2006 that examined potential problems with the handover of prisoners by the Canadian military to the local authorities.

"Judging these problems regarding Afghan detainees to be serious, imminent and alarming, I made investigations and detailed my findings formally in my reporting from the PRT," he wrote in the affidavit.

His statement contradicts earlier assurances by Prime Minister Stephen Harper and other high-ranking officials that they had not received any credible reports from Canadian officials about prisoner abuse.

Cabinet ministers had also assured the public that the opposition was misled by Taliban propaganda, and that in fact, the government has not received a credible allegation of prisoner abuse.

That revelation has resulted in opposition calls for an official public inquiry into issue.

However, the Canadian government said that when the allegations came to light in the spring of 2007 that they had never received any prior warning about the risk of torture.

The content of the first report is still covered by national security. Colvin said the second report gave specific findings that "dealt with two issues, one of which concerned the risk of torture and/or actual torture of Afghan detainees."

But opposition MPs say the government may be hiding something.

"Peter Mackay and the prime minister must come forward and tell Canadians exactly what they knew, and when they knew it. That is the clearest, fastest, and most honest way to proceed," said NDP defence critic Jack Harris on Thursday.

The NDP is now calling for a public inquiry into the issue.

The Liberals echoed those concerns and said that the government is attempting to "muzzle" one of its own diplomats.

"The government is obstructing justice by not co-operating with the Military Police Complaints Commission's request to hear from Canadian diplomat Richard Colvin," said Liberal Defence Critic Ujjal Dosanjh in a media release.

"As a result of their stonewalling, the commission's investigation is now shut down for at least six months."

Commissioner Peter Tinsley agreed to adjourn the hearing but blasted the Canadian government for stonewalling the inquiry by withholding the requested documents.

Government officials say they are in the midst of censoring documents about the issue for national security, but critics say they're taking too long to get the job done.

Meanwhile, Freya Kristjanson, a lawyer with the Canadian Military Complaints Commission, told Canada AM that while the government has said it's co-operating with the commission, it has not turned in any documents since March, 2008.

"This commission has not received a single new document (sic) despite repeated assurances that the government would be producing the documents both in the House and by their lawyers directly to the commission," she said in an interview from Ottawa. "The government has simply failed to deliver any documents."

"If the government co-operates with a body established by Parliament within its mandate and gives the commission documents and access to witnesses then Canadians will know what happened," she added.

"The commission absolutely will protect valid national security claims but the problem is the government is not co-operating or expediting the vetting of those national documents so that we can proceed with this hearing," she said.

The lawyer's comments come a day after the commission was adjourned for at least six months to deal with arguments over the inquiry's jurisdiction.


Comments are now closed for this story

M. Cameron
said

It's no surprise the Conservative government is, once again, caught hiding information they should have made public.


Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said

David in D, The skinning and beheading are the things that separate the civilized world from these animals. If you stoop their idea of what a human life is worth, than you are no different than they are. Killing for any reason is wrong. Torture is inhuman.


simon
said

All the commission wants to know is whether the government knew that the returned captives were going to be tortured by the Afghan government. A simple YES or a simple NO will do.What's with all this 36 months censorship?The only explanation is that they want to answer with a simple NO. But they need to cover up a whole load of evidence.Because otherwise they would have to answer with a simple YES


howard
said

This inquiry isn't about judges and commissions want to make Canadian policy and laws, it's about bringing the truth to light so Canadians can make an informed voting choice in the next election. No Canadian government of any political stripe should be able to conceal their behavior on any issue behind a self proclaimed "National Security" issue, regardless of whether or not it may be embaressing. A commitment to be transparent and accountable by any politician or party forming a government may be what the people want to hear, however past and present practise has sown doubts on any credibility in that mission statement.


Red X
said

Wade; this is happening under the Conservatives who promised accountability and transparency. They are covering up the Truth by delaying the inevitable...


Samual
said

Quit wasting my tax dollars on a war that has nothing to do with Canada.The USA started these wars let them finish them.


David in Dartmouth
said

What in the wild world of sports is going on here!??And people wonder why the Afghan mission is failing??Message to all of you academic do gooders.... you are the best friends that the Taliban could ever want by systematically undercutting our troops. Your efforts are more effective than any IED's or gunfire!Do you think for one minute that our advesary Mr. Tallie would give any of our troops equal consideration???....NOT!!!!Just ask the family of the Navy Seal member that fell from the back of a Chinnok Helicopter a few years ago during an engagement, though gravely injured, the just took his gun vest off, stood him against a rock, and blew his brains out in front of of his comerades.Add to that don't forget about, skinning people alive, beheading people with shovels, and oh yeah.. throwing acid in school girls faces.A serious double standard here!!At the point where these do gooders force us to leave..and they will.. Mr. Tallie will most ceratinly go on a rampage seeking out and brutally kill any Afghan that tried to work with us....PITY!!!


Wade Ens
said

After Ignatieff co-authored the essay a Lesser Evil published in the New York Times where he wrote “We must traffic in evil to fight evil including coercive interrogation, assassination and pre-emptive war” he is likely to want to accuse Canada of torture and then say he fought it. Opposition parties need to start defending our country and not attacking it. Being a Canadian is a full time job in or out of power. We have to follow the rules of national security and I support our troops who practice the highest standards in the world. It more important to stand up for Canada that try an remake some failing politician’s image.


Kel in Victoria
said

Federal Conservatives... you talked about bringing transparency and accountability, we are still waiting...


simon
said

quote""""Government officials say they are in the midst of sensoring the documents for national security but Kristjanson said they're taking too long to get the job done. """" unquote.

They have been at it since March 2008.They are now in the midst of this enormous sensorship effort.18 months have elapsed.They will complete this 18 months from today in April 2011 !!!Activities like these makes one feel pretty skeptical about what is goung on.And when you add all these things up ( from the military to the stimulus. from tax payers money to H1N1 etc. etc. ) you find that :.These guys cannot be trusted to do anything


Tim
said

Funny how some people are more concerned about the Taliban who murder innocent Afghan civilians than they are about the Afghan people themselves. A certain civil liberties group comes to mind.


happy
said

This must be what the Regressive Conservatives mean by transparency and accountability. Their refusal to cooperate and follow through with their promises to provide the documents makes it look as though they've got a lot of dirt to hide.


Bill from Winnipeg
said

If all of these judges and commissions want to make Canadian policy and laws then they should run for political office otherwise keep out of the rablerousing media.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest