News Sections
Lawyer astounded feds won't seek client's clemency
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. Nov. 2 2007 10:34 PM ET
The lawyer for a Canadian awaiting execution in a Montana prison says he was shocked by the federal government's announcement it will no longer seek clemency for his client.
In the past, the government has requested that Canadian prisoners sentenced to death in the U.S. be allowed to serve out life sentences here, since Canada opposes the death penalty.
The apparent change of heart came as a blow to Don Vernay, lawyer for Albertan Ronald Allen Smith, who faces lethal injection for the 1982 murders of two men in Montana.
"I mean, talk about having the wind knocked out of you. I'm astounded, is all I can say," Vernay told CTV's Canada AM on Friday.
Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day announced in the House of Commons on Thursday that he will not plead for clemency for Smith, since he had been found guilty in a democratic country "that supports the rule of law."
On Friday, Prime Minister Stephen Harper confirmed Canada has no interest in wading into the debate over capital punishment, and would not be coming to Smith's aid.
"The reality in this particular case is, were we to intervene, it would quickly become a question of whether we were willing to repatriate a double murderer to Canada," Harper told reporters.
"In light of this government's strong initiatives on tackling violent crime I think that would send the wrong signal to the Canadian public."
Vernay said representatives of the federal government contacted him about a year ago and said they intended to try and bring Smith home.
"They came to us and they said we want Mr. Smith back in Canada, he's one of our citizens," Vernay said.
"We want the death penalty lifted and we are going to do whatever we can to secure his transfer to Canada and to have the governor of Montana grant clemency. And so we were pleased and we were surprised."
Vernay said he flew to Montana and met with the staff of Gov. Brian Schweitzer late this summer, and got the sense the clemency request was on the agenda.
"It was in the preliminary stages but everybody knew that this is what was on the agenda," Vernay said.
"And we had the Canadian government 100 per cent behind us and then all of a sudden out of nowhere comes this statement."
Vernay said the decision seems to fly in the face of Canada's position on the death penalty and sends a confusing message to the world.
"For your government to make a statement like that to the world internationally that you now support the execution of your own citizens -- what can I say? I mean, it's breathtaking in terms of its implications."
Smith was convicted for killing two Aboriginal men while hitchhiking through Montana in 1982. He is the only Canadian currently on death row in the U.S.
Relatives of the two men, Harvey Mad Man, 23, and Thomas Running Rabbit, 20, have pleaded with Schweitzer not to commute Smith's sentence.
Smith personally requested the death penalty, before later appealing the decision, asking for a life sentence.
Schweitzer said he is undecided about whether to commute his sentence.
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Kevin D
said
Are we next going to ask for all Canadians convicted of crimes throughout the world to be returned to Canada?
Scott H
said
Why not just go medieval and hang them at dawn after their trial? No sense in pretending killing someone isn't barbaric.
LM
said
Matt
said
Unless the courts are corrupt the Canadian government should not interfere with the internal affairs of a country.
Of course Canada should help Canadian citizens accused of crimes, but this should come short of Canada arguing they should get shorter sentences just because they happen to be Canadian.
If you don't like the laws in certain place, don't go there, and definately don't commit a crime there.
John
said
Bill
said
Andrew
said
Peter L
said
To Mr. Harper and the rest of the Conservative Government keep up the great work
against crime. We are the victims of crime not the criminals.
James
said
Would you extend the same reason to non democratic countries?
This is entirely about the death penalty and a government out of touch with the majority of Canadians.
Don D.
said
Sherry
said
Karen D
said
OR Maybe you support the death penalty in Canada!
Francine
said
We're not talking about a trumped up charge in a Chinese prison. We're talking about murder in the US. A country which has a democracy. He chose to break their laws. He should therefore be punished according to their laws.
Bob
said
Freak Alert
said
West Coast Joe
said
Why should my tax dollars be spent trying to save this guy? Nobody is suggesting he is innocent. This means he killed two people.
Bob
said
Eric
said
Barbara Halligan
said
Riley W
said
The U.S.A. is a free democracy with the rule of law.
If you go to a state with the death penalty and kill someone, you should face the concequences of your action their, and my tax dollars and Canada's resources shouldn't be wasted trying to help a cold blooded killer.
This is not about the death penalty debate at all. I am glad Stockwell Day and the Conservative government took this route.
We have no business in the U.S.A's jurisdiction and justice system