Health -   

1
Ban overturned video games Pauline Chan reports on violent video games and the effect they can have on boys.

Violent video games may lead to brain changes

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Effects of violent video games
A new study on violent video games has reignited a debate on whether the games are harmful or merely harmless fun. Avis Favaro reports on the study's findings.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (23) Facebook   

Ban overturned video games Pauline Chan reports on violent video games and the effect they can have on boys.

Photos

Ban overturned

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Dec. 1 2011 12:30 PM ET

Playing violent video games produces changes in areas of the brain that help control emotion for at least a week, new research suggests.

Researchers reported their findings this week at the annual meeting of the Radiological Society of North America.

For the study, Dr. Yang Wang, a radiologist at the Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis, led a team who recruited divided 22 healthy men who were between 18 and 29 years old and not regular players of violent games.

They divided them randomly into two groups: one group was asked to play a shoot-em-up style video game for 10 hours over the course of a week and then to refrain from playing the game for a second week. The second group was instructed not to play any violent video games at all over the two weeks.

All of the study subjects underwent functional magnetic resonance imaging tests at the beginning of the study, after one week and at the end of the study.

At one week, the game players had less activation in parts of the brain associated with emotional control than they had at baseline than the control group. To test this, during the fMRI, the men completed an "emotional interference task," pressing buttons according to the colour of visually presented words. Words indicating violent actions were interspersed among nonviolent action words.

The video game group members showed less activation in the left inferior frontal lobe during the emotional task compared to both their baseline results and compared to the control group.

They also had less activation in a brain area that controls cognitive function -- the anterior cingulate cortex -- during a counting task.

Activation increased again after the second week, when the men didn't play the game.

"These findings indicate that violent video game play has a long-term effect on brain functioning," Dr. Wang concluded.

The researchers did not look at how these brain changes might affect real-world behaviour.

But Wang's colleague and study co-author Dr. Vincent P. Mathews says young adults should be concerned about the effects of these games.

"I think a lot of gamers would like to believe that these games have no effects on their brains, but I think our results show that they do and so I think they need to be concerned about that," he told CTV News.

"If they are going to make the choice to play video games, they need to be aware that they are going to have these changes in brain function and potentially may have some changes in behaviour as well," he said.

The study has not been published or subjected to peer review.

Comments are now closed for this story

Salt and Vinegar
said

You can't even allow them to watch a hockey game. You never know when a fight might break out and damage the child. And forget football games. There is so much violence with tackling and shoving We need a better bubble to keep all kids in until they turn 18.


TheOtherLowellInBC
said

Given the fact that we have had a pile of violence occurring over the ages in wars (many of them senseless and even for religious reasons), man trying to survive etc. Would we have a smarter and higher cognitive functioning population in the world if it had developed on more peaceful terms. Folks living in greater harmony.


Rick
said

So CTV publishes a report saying violent video games cause long term brain effects yet the study has not been published OR subjected to peer review? Are you kidding me?Here is my study: According to my eyes, having kids engage in video games who are autistic can actually control their emotions and give them an out instead of thrashing their parents.I'm not published or peer reviewed...so can I have a news article too please?!?!?As an avid game player for the last 25 years, who's played EVERY genre, and who has become a successful health practitioner, a husband, and a father, I somehow doubt that by playing Call of Duty i'm going to be subject to lash outs at work or my friends.Video games are NOT to blame people...it's yourself. Please subject to movies and books that are violent as well...The Hurt Locker will have a more profound effect than any video game out there now.


Paul
said

My 12 month son started to laugh like the Count on Sesame Street after watching a few episodes. How is it that a 12 month old can be affected by what they watch but 12 year old is not affected by violent "realistic" video games? I don’t get how people think it does not affect their kids when the spend hours playing games that murder innocent people for fun or the hell of it.


Remarkable
said

Spent 3yrs serving my country, seen enough senseless violence overseas, far beyond what these video games will ever have. I guess my brain has already been damaged by all the violence I've seen. I know they're only video games, but even at just the thought of having some sort of joy and thrill from killing someone isn't exactly healthy.


Opto, Calgary
said

These "brain" studies are often so flawed. Just a few weeks ago another study found violent video games did not cause any lasting changes to the brain. Problem is these personality studies cannot differentiate between cause and effect (i.e. violent games cause agression, or agression in people cause them to play violent games ). These studies try to quantify subjective traits such as personallity and feelings. They also have a lack of a proper control as life does go on for all those that participate in the study. Here is a suggestion: what about a study those that watch violent movies or shows, read specific genres of books or watch Twilight movies and see what effects they can conclude. BTW I am of the TV and Arcade generation so please pardon my total inability to think for myself.


It is what it is...
said

What about ..."Violence is evil".....do parents not understand? This Christmas parents have a choice to do what is right or to bend to the demands of their kids peer pressure.


Steve-O
said

It's safe to say all of my friends that I play on-line violent shooters with are brain-damaged to some extent. I however am completely fine.


Stu
said

@ Lame Brain Thanks for you comment, it matches your name.


Vee
said

But competetive games can produce strong emotions (Racing, Puzzles, Fighters, Sports). And then, these men might all play video games for most of their lives, so their brains may be already wired for such feedback loops. I'd bet you get a wide range of bizarre emotional latency from hardcore Sports video game players, over Shooters.


Marc
said

Key word in this headline is "may".


Chris
said

Well said JC.


Dan from Northern Ont
said

No different from taking a look at people that watch a lot of violent action movies or horror movies. People become desensitized to violence. That doesn't make them violent, it just means that the concepts are less shocking.


Dave in MB
said

This is old news, they did this ten, fifteen years ago!


Mark J.
said

Gamers will dismiss this study. But if it had showed the opposite, that there was no effect whatsoever, gamers would be referring to this study for years.


NorthenALberta
said

Has anyone ever looked at the influence of all those ultra violent movies out there??



Jenna J.
said

I could've told you that. Test anyone who's been to war. I bet they too have a dulling of their emotions when it comes to violence and death. Or test any police officer who's been to multiple motor vehicle fatalities. Do you gamers really believe there would be no dulling of emotion after all of this?


Brian
said

Regular exposure to any sort of emotion-altering activity will cause the brain to compensate and become desensitized to it. Look at other parts of the world with child soldiers, public executions, and a dog-eat-dog daily routine; the people who live in these areas are much more desensetized to violence and suffering than any first-world video gamer ever would be. You could have those same 22 men watch violent movies, UFC, or internet beheadings for 10 hours a week and you'd get the same results. I can't believe someone actually spent money on this.


JC
said

Thats the problem with these studies, it omits to mention the fact that all activities that create emotion lingers in the brain for awhile. So I have to ask, what is the point of this study? It almost sounds like somebody either has a very narrow understanding of the brain or has an anti video game bias. Take a look at the comment here posted about the gun registry....now, you have to wonder how much time this dudes brain is gonna take before it normalizes.


PA
said

EVERYTHING you do changes your brain. At the very least you change it by adding a memory. Sheesh.


Lame Brain
said

Why not create a registry for war gamers. (sic)Maybe we could use the Gun registry?


PointOfVi3w
said

Well then let me know when it has! I'm sorry, but twenty-two people is an insufficient sample size and that's why it has not been published or reviewed by their peers.I'm not trying to impugn the validity of the study, merely pointing this out. As an avid video game player, I have a vested interest in this topic, but wish to know more than speculation (which is all it is at this point.)I also wish the media would stop printing unfinished studies; however, I understand that journalists have a job to do. It's just that people will be rhyming this off as the gospel truth when they do not realize that it's an UNFINISHED STUDY.


Mq
said

Perspective folks. Before we all get upset over nothing. Message of the story, all things in moderation. And before you say violence this and children that. Think back 80 years to both world wars. The young of our lions have long since, and for every will be subjected to the violence of adults, beyond the 'Hollywood' games understanding of true violence. You want to talk about emotional detachment? You pray this never happens, but the one's not standing there in shock if the bombs every did start dropping on us, would be the 'less emotionally active' brains that got off the streets.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Health Stories

Drop the Worry Ball: How to Parent in the Age of Entitlement

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges

More   25 Comments 25  

Doctors at St. Michael's hospital in Toronto are using a device that can wash antibodies right out of a person’s blood in hopes of increasing the number of possible kidney donors.

Device could lead to more living kidney donors

More    Comments    1 Video(s) 1

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges