Health -   

1
11-year-old Cosmo practices boxing at the Cabbagetown Boxing Club in Toronto in this undated photo. Dr. Claire LeBlanc, from the Canadian Paediatric Society, appears on Canada AM, Tuesday, Aug. 30, 2011. Shyraya Sullivan, 12, works out at Palooka's Boxing Club in Halifax on Monday, March 21, 2011. (Andrew Vaughan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Libby Norris helps demonstrate some boxing moves on Canada AM, Monday, Jan. 18, 2009.

Keep kids out of the boxing ring, doctors urge

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Avis Favaro on kids and boxing
The Canadian Paediatric Society and the American Academy of Pediatrics issued a joint statement Monday saying boxing is not a good choice for young people because repeated blows to the head, can cause brain injuries and concussions.
CTV Winnipeg: Josh Crabb on the recommendation
Brain injuries in professional and amateur sports have been the focus of a lot of debate lately. Canadian pediatricians are urging children and teenagers to stay out of the boxing ring.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (25) Facebook   

11-year-old Cosmo practices boxing at the Cabbagetown Boxing Club in Toronto in this undated photo. Dr. Claire LeBlanc, from the Canadian Paediatric Society, appears on Canada AM, Tuesday, Aug. 30, 2011. Shyraya Sullivan, 12, works out at Palooka's Boxing Club in Halifax on Monday, March 21, 2011. (Andrew Vaughan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Libby Norris helps demonstrate some boxing moves on Canada AM, Monday, Jan. 18, 2009.

Photos

11-year-old Cosmo practices boxing at the Cabbagetown Boxing Club in Toronto in this undated photo.

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Aug. 29 2011 9:24 PM ET

With increased focus on the dangers of brain injuries in kids, Canadian and American pediatricians are banding together to warn of yet another sport that endangers kids and teens: boxing.

Amateur boxing has long been a popular sport in both countries and many boxing-title holders say they began training when they were still in elementary school. But the Canadian Paediatric Society and the American Academy of Pediatrics say children and teen athletes should not be allowed into the ring at all until after age 18, to protect their brains from injury.

"Because of the risk of head and facial injuries, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Canadian Paediatric Society oppose boxing as a sport for children and adolescents," the groups write in a joint position paper issued Monday.

"These organizations recommend that physicians vigorously oppose boxing in youth and encourage patients to participate in alternative sports in which intentional head blows are not central to the sport."

Dr. Claire LeBlanc, co-author of the new position statement and chair of the CPS Healthy Active Living and Sports Medicine Committee, notes in a press release that while most sports have some risk of injury, boxing is especially dangerous.

She says that's because athletes are rewarded for deliberate hits to their opponent's head.

The groups note that children's brains are more vulnerable to concussion, and recovery takes longer than it does for adults.

"Though amateur boxers wear safety gear, there is no evidence to show that head guards actually reduce the incidence of concussions," the groups say.

The CPS and AAP are urging pediatricians and other health professionals to strongly discourage their patients from participating in boxing.

The warning comes as evidence mounts that repeated head injuries and concussions can lead to a degenerative brain condition called chronic traumatic encephalopathy. The condition causes permanent changes to the brain and leads to personality changes and symptoms similar to dementia.

The condition has been noted among boxers for decades and was once called "dementia pugilistica" because of its prevalence among professional boxers.

According to Boxing Canada, the organization representing amateur boxers, the minimum age to fight in a boxing competition is 11. About 2,000 kids between the ages of 11 and 16 are registered to compete, its records show. About a quarter are girls.

Boxing enthusiasts insist the sport is no more dangerous than other sports that can lead to head injuries, such as hockey, football, skiing or other martial arts.

Dr. David Venturi, the medical advisor to Boxing Ontario, says amateur boxing is "an extremely regulated combative sport."

"Injuries do occur in boxing as in any other sport, but significant head injuries are a rare event in amateur boxing," he said in an email to CTV News.

"Boxing Ontario executives, coaches, chief officials, referees and ringside physicians work diligently together to protect their athletes from significant injury by watching every punch thrown during every fight. These experienced eyes at any time will stop a fight," he said.

In comments made to The Canadian Press, Robert Crete, the executive director of Boxing Canada, notes that amateur boxers spend the bulk of their time punching bags, not each other.

"It's not like playing hockey, where every weekend, the kid is competing," he told CP. "If they compete twice a year, it's considered very often."

The CPS and AAP acknowledge that the overall risk of injury in amateur boxing seems to be lower than in some other collision sports such as football, hockey, wrestling, and soccer.

"However, unlike these other collision sports, boxing encourages and rewards direct blows to the head and face," they note in their paper.

The pediatricians' paper says it's unclear how many children and teens get injured while boxing, since few studies separate data by age group.

But they note that data has been collected by the Canadian Hospitals Injury Reporting and Prevention Program, which collects data from 15 hospitals across the country, including 10 children's hospitals. That database found some 273 boxers reported injuries between 1990 and 2007 and among them, nearly 70 per cent were 18 and under.

Most of those injuries occurred during sparring or competitions.

The Canadian Medical Association has pushed to make boxing off-limits to youth and even advocates that the sport be banned entirely. The American Medical Association recommends that until all boxing is banned, head blows should be prohibited.

Peter Wylie, a former boxer and coach who has trained such notable Canadian boxers as Shawn O'Sullivan, Johnny Kalbhenn and John Raftery, says boxing is not only an excellent form of exercise, it's also one of the few sports readily available to underprivileged youth.

"Boxing clubs and boxing youth programs are typically located and function in inner-city communities, where teenagers in the critical 11-to-18-years age range frequently come from low-income and single-parent households, often lack proper guidance and are therefore at high risk of becoming involved in gang activities," he said in a statement to CTV News.

He says boxing builds self-confidence, helps to channel aggression into a constructive outlet, and helps to develop a respect for rules, discipline and good health.

"Therefore, the function of youth boxing cannot be narrowly viewed only from the purely sport-related technical skills, but must be evaluated also from its social community building role," he says.

Comments are now closed for this story

Jason
said
0 0

What a joke. Lets take a bunch of untrained 18yr olds with more power and throw them in there and let them duke it out instead of teaching people from when they're young to fight. No wonder our country gets beat at the Olympics in this sport all the time. I've been involved in this sport for the past 15 yrs and yes people can get hurt (it is a fight let's not kid ourselves here.) but most young kids don't have the punching power to seriously knock someone out cold. That comes when you get a bit older, hockey and football have way more head injuries than boxing does. And I'd still let my kids play either of those sports too if they wanted.


Bill East
said
0 0

While I understand that to some it seem obvious that youth should be protected. We are headed to a to a world were all risk is controlled by laws and special interest groups. If my daughter wanted to box I'd make her wait but let her do non contact work outs or karate. I made that decision with my wife and not my Dr. or the legal system.I bet all Doctors don't feel this way but that's not my point. This group have good motives but they aren't my kids parents. That is my job. Thanks for the advise and I'll consider it and make sure my child is safe but banning and laws a step too far in my opinion.


Para
said
0 0

Realist, WRONG. I've been a parachutist for over 30 years and I know the risks. You obviously do not, sport "license" aside.


DK
said
0 0

Boxing is heavily regulated. Each athlete gets checked by a doctor before and after the bout, during the bout you have minimum 6 people watching the two in the ring, it’s a very safe sport. There is a reason society is raising "wimps" today they are scared to let youth take a risk and get a minor scratch. What’s next paper that can't give paper cuts?


C. Mortensen
said
0 0

Sorry but I'd rather my daughter know how to protect herself from all the sick bastards that the news is usually reporting. I believe that watching the evening news is damaging more brains than boxing! I'm not even going to touch on hockey and the damage and deaths that that great sport causes.

Go back to reporting about how bad video games are for kids!


Jane Marek
said
0 0

It does not even take a brain to know repeated blows to the head will cause damage. It is only common sense.


Sally
said
0 0

I was going to say it doesn't take a genius to figure out boxing can cause brain damage regardless how much protection is worn... until I read some of the replies here... I used to take martial art and muay thai boxing as a kid and we were NEVER allowed to punch or kick the head. You need to get your head checked if you think it's safe for kids (or anyone at any age) to have their noggins knocked around.


Arjun
said
0 0

Although it seems excessive, its the medical community has a responsibility to make recommendations against things they believe are dangerous, especially when it involves children. They would not be fulfilling their responsibilities very well if they didn't advise against children getting punched in the head now would they.


Raif
said
0 0

And while you're at it, make sure to wrap them in bubble wrap when you send them out the door, what a load of crap!


jason heit
said
0 0

Cycling deaths in Canada =78 average per year, drowning deaths per year in Canada = 400+, MMA and boxing deaths in Canada a year = 0. Thanks for your advice Dr. Tator, but I will stick with MMA and boxing that are proven safer than the sports you just recommended.


Mike Ong
said
0 0

Eliminating head punches will prevent head related injuries.

Karate practioners know of the dangers of long term head trauma. As such many karate clubs do not permit head strikes during practice and competition.

Perhaps youth boxing can evolve.


Judy
said
0 0

I believe that vibrations off the floor during loud concerts can cause concussion in susceptible individuals, too.



Clinton Hudson
said
0 0

Good afternoon all, good article which picks up on some interesting points. But this fails to identify why people take up boxing in the first place. I coach boxing to children and adults alike and I was taught by the legendary trainer Brendan Ingle of Sheffield, England. One poster reads on the gym wall, "boxing can seriously damage your health, but will instill discipline, determination and confidence! Where drink and drugs JUST damage your health"! Please don't see boxing just as a sport, but as a lifestyle, best regards coach Clinton.


C Church
said
0 0

Boxing is a sport enjoyed by many people and has been for a long long time. If that is the sport children want to learn, let them. How is it different from any form of martial arts? It teaches discipline self confidence and the ability to defend ones self should the need arise... sounds great to me.


Shaun Nickerson
said
0 0

On paper a lot of people would assume that this would lead to boxing being safer. Kids stay out of the ring and don't get involved in the serious contact until they are older. That is exactly the problem. They don't get involved until they are older. In boxing, it is very easy to learn how to throw a serious punch. Where the true skill lays is AVOIDING those punches. So we are going to end up throwing a bunch of 18 year olds in with each other who have less experience defending themselves, more natural power and we think that is going to be SAFER? Am I missing something here?


Ben
said
0 0

I'm on the fence on this one, I suppose we should take more care to keep our kids out of the ring, but I also think of hockey in which the age of which we permit body checking is going up and up, and I cannot help but thinks this parallels the serious injuries players are sustaining from all these cheap shots. Will boxing injuries follow suit and become worse as we increase the "legal age" to box? I really don't know...


realist
said
0 0

@PyeChartt: I'm a licensed skydiver and I can assure you that it is FAR safer than you think, believe it or not. I would definitely prefer that my kid take up skydiving instead of boxing.


Can't fix Stupid
said
0 0

Box is barbaric at any age. time to get rid of it period.


Jon in London ON
said
0 0

Mr. McGuire: "I just want to say one word to you. Just one word". Ben: "Yes, sir". Mr. McGuire: "Are you listening"? Ben: "Yes, I am". McGuire: "Bubblewrap". Ben: "Exactly how do you mean"? McGuire: "There's a great future in bubblewrap. Think about it. Protecting children. The Nanny State. Will you think about it"? Ben: "Yes I will". McGuire: "Shh, enough said. That's a deal". Scene from the upcoming 2011 remake of the Graduate.


Ian in N.B.
said
0 0

So when they do it in a gym with coaches watching it's called boxing and they might get a trophy for it. When they do it in the parking lot with a bunch of students watching, it's fighting and they'll probably get suspended for it. I've got to be missing something here.


Jaid in Toronto
said
0 0

Boxing doesn't necessarily encourage going to the head, however, it is considered the most effective to pummel your opponent's face in to ensure you win the fight. Going to the body is another way to box, not the best method though. Boxing is there to enhance reflexes and it is an incredibly easy way to get your cardio going, not to mention cheap. There's a reason why you have helmets in boxing too, to protect you like the many other sports out there.


allan
said
0 0

..and no more hockey, football, gymnastics. . . .Amazing how some so-called educated people are totally stuck on stupid. Humans have been physically competing throughout history, and hopefully this will not change. some people should just stay in their own little dream world and leave normal people alone!


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

Okay; fine. I won't let my kids box. (My young daughter has really been itching to punch people in the head, for sport, and exercise.) Oh, well. I'll make it up to them with skydiving lessons, and try to get them hooked on extreme thrill sports. They'll love me for it, and I'll surely win the battle against my wife to be the most popular parent.


Munro - Brampton
said
0 0

Any parents that allow their kid to box already has brain damage. There is still lots we don't know about how our brains work, the brain may still be developing in the early teen years and maybe blows to the head are not a good idea, duh.


Evil03
said
0 0

taking blows to the head is not good for your health who would have known ?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Facebook

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook

Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews

Today's Health Stories

The B.C. government is pledging $8-million in funding to improve school playgrounds. Sept. 2, 2011. (CTV)

Canadian kids get failing grade for play time

More    Comments  

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More