Health -   

1

Deal reached on labels for genetically modified food

Sodium list on a food label Sodium list on a food label
Sodium list on a food label

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (16) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday Jul. 6, 2011 8:53 PM ET

Regulators from more than 100 countries have agreed to new guidelines that will make it easier for food makers to say on their labels whether their products contain genetically-modified ingredients. But consumers in Canada are unlikely to see any changes here.

The Codex Alimentarius Commission, a group of more than 100 of the world's food safety regulatory agencies, agreed to the guidelines on Tuesday, after years of debate.

Until now, the U.S. had objected to such labels. But during the annual Codex summit in Geneva this week, the U.S. delegation surprised many by deciding to drop its opposition.

The new Codex agreement means that any country that wants to bring in new food labels that would identify genetically modified ingredients will no longer risk running afoul of international free trade laws or facing a legal fight in front of the World Trade Organization.

The new guidelines are voluntary only. But Consumers International, a large international group representing consumer groups, said it's pleased with the deal.

"While the agreement falls short of the consumer movement's long-held demand for endorsement of mandatory GM (genetically modified) food labelling, this is still a significant milestone for consumer rights," Consumers International President Samuel Ochieng said in a statement.

"This guidance is extremely good news for the worlds' consumers who want to know what is in the foods on their plates."

In Canada, about 70 per cent of food sold includes genetically modified ingredients from such common crops as corn, soy, and canola.

While many other countries now have mandatory GM labelling rules in place, Canada does not.

Health Canada, which shares responsibility with the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) for food labelling policies, does allow food makers to voluntarily mention whether their foods contain GM ingredients. But Eric Darier, who heads the anti-GMO (genetically modified organisms) campaign for Greenpeace Canada, says such standards aren't effective.

"I challenge your readers to find one label in Canada that mentions whether the food contains GE ingredients," Darier told CTV.ca in an interview.

"Voluntary labelling doesn't work."

Darier says while food labels in Canada won't change because of this agreement, but it does allow other countries to enact their own mandatory labelling standards without fear of reprisals from big GM-crop producers like the U.S. and Canada.

Health Canada has long contended that there are no known health risks from eating GM foods.

"Every new GM food product must undergo a rigorous pre-market safety assessment before it is allowed to be sold in Canada," the department says on its website.

"No GM food is allowed on the market in Canada unless Health Canada's scientists are satisfied that the food is safe and nutritious."

But Darier says many Canadians are not comfortable with genetic modification. Poll after poll has shown that most Canadians want to know whether their food includes engineered ingredients.

Health Canada says it won't call for mandatory labelling until it receives information that there's a health concern.

"But that's a bit of a silly argument," says Darier. "A lot of what already appears on food labels isn't about health or safety. Products can mention if they're organic or they're Kosher or whether they were made in Canada. That's not about health."

The bottom line, he says, is that consumers should be allowed to be fully informed about their choices.

"Consumers have a fundamental right to know how their food is produced," he says.

Comments are now closed for this story

MarcO
said
0 0

The good things about genetically-modified foods (I prefer the term 'gengineered', but that's semantics), is that the product is often more nutritious and may grow better in less optimal environments than the unmodified progenitors.The bad things about these foods is the likelihood of cross-contamination and the possibility of supplanting the native species.While the debate on the merits and lack thereof of gengineered foods will likely last years from now, what the article is concerned about is the LABELING of GM foods. While I agree to the labeling of said foods, I am concerned about unreported food-borne allergies that such foods may carry. If my tomato sauce contains a tomato-peanut hybrid, does it warrant a "peanut allergy" label? That's my big concern. These new foods may generate some presently-unclassified and untested allergies in people... and then there's the risk of cross-contamination of crops, which may lead to unchecked mutations in the food crops. What if they make it to market, unlabelled and potentially allergenic?Playing God has a price; are we willing to pay it?


Dori
said
0 0

Yes genetically modified foods have been around for a few years but around the same time the cancer rate also started to climb rapidly. Why doesn't anyone put two and two together?.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

I don't have a problem with genetically modified people; therefore, I don't have a problem with genetically modified food...unless, of course, it's proven unhealthy. Make sense? No? Okay.


Gomtor
said
0 0

Time to come clean with honesty on food labels. We should have the right to know what we eat.


Pierre D, in Montreal
said
0 0

Why is it that smart people that work in agri-business eat mostly organic; smart people that work in asbestos mines not live in houses with asbestos; smart tobacco workers not smoke cigarette and management at hydro refuses to live under power-lines? Because they know the truth about was is killing us. In the future, historians will shake their heads at our stupidity and gullibility. Banish obedience!


Prairie dweller
said
0 0

Don't confuse the two issues. It's not either GMO or organic; you can grow "natural" seed without using organic practices. The real question is...how exactly do you expect to stop the bees from cross-pollinating that GMO crop with the natural one across the road? Eventually, "natural" won't exist anymore.


Ian Ottawa
said
0 0

Now lets get rid of Trans Fats for good.


GMO poll
said
0 0

This is all about choice and Health Canada is falling short of providing us with that choice. As a government agency, you are falling short of the people's call for GMO labels on all consumer products. Food is a necessary component to life. We have a right to know what crap the government is allowing growers to push down our throats. Let us do our own poll right here, right now.......Regardless whether you agree with my comment or not, vote "thumbs up" if you want GMO labels and vote "thumbs down" if you don't. Let us see what the people want from Health Canada.


MarcO
said
0 0

Here's an idea: every label that has genetically-modified food should have a friendly Frankenstein's Monster's head imprinted on it. That way, people will know it's a "franken-food" and if the picture is really, really cute, even the parents will look for it!I'm sure the companies that market these products will no doubt do anything they can to make GM foods as appealing as possible, and to them I say: "Frankenstein Heads as GM Labels" is MY idea!


Pip
said
0 0

Karla seems to forget that GM foods have been around a couple of decades - most of the time under a Liberal government, which also did nothing vis a vis GM labelling. As another poster noted, the product code tells the story: if it doesn't start with "8" it's not GM. Education helps more than specific labelling. Education would also reveal that most fruits and vegetables have been engineered for centuries, by means of selective breeding, which is also a method of tinkering with a plant's genes. The only disadvantage I see to GM fruits and vegetables is that they tend to displace the centuries-old varieties that are the source of today's varieties. However, I'm sure there are organic gardeners and farmers throughout the world who are maintaining those seed stocks, not to mention the Doomsday Vault in Svalbard.


getreal
said
0 0

GM foods taste a hell of alot better then Organic and are consistent. Organic foods get fertilized with human waste, so you hippies have fun eating my excrement.


jane
said
0 0

Health Canada is falling very short of providing Canadian consumers with the type of information required to make informed purchasing choices. It's time Canada got on board with the EU to make it mandatory for companies to list any and all GM grains/products which are included in their processed food. At least let the people have the right to make their own choice. With higher and higher health issues in Canada, how can Health Canada say there is no impact on humans? Someone is making a lot of money off these GM products.


Raj
said
0 0

Everyone has the right to know what they are consuming. So much emphasis is placed on individuals being responsible for their own health... well... how is that possible unless the government legislates that we have a right to know. I hope someone in this Harper government takes a lead on this. The fact is, organic food is still well out of the range of affordability for most Canadians, so this won't affect much in the market place immediately. Hopefully the labelling will create a greater demand for organic foods in the long-run, shifting production to non-gmo foods. We can still go back.


KARLA
said
0 0

While many other countries now have mandatory GM labelling rules in place, Canada does not. And WHEN are we going to see some REAL CHANGES On our labels??? Don't hold your breath ... not going to happen here any time soon... Our Government has been bought and paid for by BIG BUSINESS and they say what is going to be done ... Profits before peoples health and welfare!!!


DF
said
0 0

If you want to find out if a fruit or vegetable sold in a store is GMO, just read the code. All foods have a PLU or UPC code on them in the supermarket. Vegetables are no different. If the vegetable is sold individually, look for the sticker on the vegetable itself. If the five digit number starts with an "8", it is genetically engineered.


Amar H
said
0 0

Good, I hope Canada takes the lead and identifies all GMO ingredients.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Health Stories

The B.C. government is pledging $8-million in funding to improve school playgrounds. Sept. 2, 2011. (CTV)

Canadian kids get failing grade for play time

More    Comments  

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More