Health -   

1
In this Aug. 7, 2007 file photo, Todd Fuentes, 4, left, plays with Adrian Girald, 7, second from right, and Anthony Zollinger, second from left, as his father Eugene Fuentes, right, looks on in a portable pool in Brooklyn, New York. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II) Salt water pools

Portable pools can be dangerous for children: study

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Toronto Extended: Teen pulled from pool
A 15 year old girl who was pulled from the bottom of a pool at an apartment complex on McNicoll Ave. near Kennedy Rd. is brought to Toronto Grace Hospital by emergency officials.
CTV Ottawa: Ellen Mauro on the dangers
A U.S. study on children drowning in portable pools says there needs to be more consumer education and affordable protection devices to stop these occurrences.
CTV Montreal: Rob Lurie on the drowning
The drowning death of a 4-year-old in Pierrefonds and another drowning of a boy in Laval on the weekend shined the spotlight on pool safety. Rob Lurie reports.
CTV News Channel: Inflatable pool dangers
CTV News Channel correspondent Merella Fernandez says a new study shows in the U.S. between 2001 and 2009 there were 209 fatal cases of drowning involving inflatable pools. The researchers say every five days a child dies in the summer in an inflatable pool.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (10) Facebook   

In this Aug. 7, 2007 file photo, Todd Fuentes, 4, left, plays with Adrian Girald, 7, second from right, and Anthony Zollinger, second from left, as his father Eugene Fuentes, right, looks on in a portable pool in Brooklyn, New York. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II) Salt water pools

Photos

In this Aug. 7, 2007 file photo, Todd Fuentes, 4, left, plays with Adrian Girald, 7, second from right, and Anthony Zollinger, second from left, as his father Eugene Fuentes, right, looks on in a portable pool in Brooklyn, New York. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Jun. 20 2011 8:37 PM ET

A new study suggests portable or inflatable swimming pools are a greater danger to children than many parents likely realize, leading to one death every five days in the United States during warm months.

Researchers restricted their study to include wading pools less than 45 centimetres deep to inflatable and soft-sided pools measuring about one metre deep.

The study, published Monday in the journal Pediatrics, found that 209 children died in these pools between 2001 and 2009. In addition, there were 35 near-drownings reported during the same time period.

According to the study, 94 per cent of children were under age five and 56 per cent of the victims were boys. The children were also more likely to be in their own yard when the incident happened, with 73 per cent of incidents taking place there.

"The anecdotal evidence was suggesting that because portable pools are readily available in many convenience stores and malls, and they're relatively cheap, parents would pick them up, take them home, quickly assemble them, and all this would be done without a lot of forethought about the safety aspects," said senior author, Dr. Gary A. Smith, director of the Center for Injury Research and Policy at Nationwide Children's Hospital in Columbus.

The study is the first U.S. research to probe the role portable pools have played in deaths or near-drownings.

The researchers acknowledge that no single strategy can completely prevent a death or near drowning, and so advocate a multi-pronged approach. On the one hand, manufacturers should develop affordable safety devices for portable pools, including fencing, alarms and safety covers, which are common for in-ground pools.

They also say better consumer-education programs are needed to make parents aware of the pools' risks.

According to the study, children were under adult supervision in only 43 per cent of the cases.

Barbara Byers, public education director of the Lifesaving Society, says the findings are a concern in Canada, where there are fewer pool drownings each year, because there are no safety regulations for portable pools in Canada.

In-ground pools must have fencing on all four sides, while portable pools can be put anywhere on a property, she said.

Also of concern, Byers said, is that many consumers assume such pools are safer because of their smaller size.

"I think many people may think, ‘Oh well it's just a couple of inches of water,'" Byers told CTV News Channel in an interview Monday evening. "But a person, a child, can drown in a couple of inches of water very, very quickly, and very silently."

Byers said access to portable pools should be restricted to the same degree as in-ground pools, and stressed the importance of adult supervision.

"It's really important to have layers of protection to keep young children away from that pool unless you know that you are there with them and you are watching them and keeping them within arm's reach," Byers said. "Most children have no fear whatsoever. It's almost a magnetic attraction to the water. If they see it, they are going to want to go to it."

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Paul R
said
0 0

Plain and simple... Where is the parent?? There is no excuse....


Rebecca
said
0 0

I just bought an inflatable kids pool for my 15 month old. I fill it with a couple inches of water and am outside, right beside the pool watching him play. If kids are drowning in pools, where is the adult supervision? Same rule applies if you're giving your child a bath - don't leave him/her unattended. It's common sense people.


George-In-Calgary
said
0 0

Correction, there are 52 000 000 children under 12 in the US, which means 1 in 2 million chance!!


peter in BC
said
0 0

Knowing how public mentality works in the states, lawsuits will come forth and ultimately, they will call for a ban on kiddie pools. Either that, or insist that they get fenced in like in-ground pools. Bad parenting resulted in these kinds of unfortunate accidents. Nothing more, nothing less. I survived multiple pools growing up and my parents were always in the backyard watching. Well that, and they made us take swimming lessons which all parents should do.


fire
said
0 0

Though I see the point being made by Dave in Ottawa, I strongly disagree with the measures he proposes! Instead of insisting on high user / access fees, and licensing etc, I think it makes more sense to educate all parents and caregivers about what dangers such pools pose! Parents and caregivers need to be more aware and involved with where their own kids are, and more active in parenting them!! Parents should definitely have safety locks on fences around the backyard which are 6ft high, and then a smaller gate around the pool area specifically and both fences locked!! In addition, door alarms in the family home can go a long way towards alerting a caregiver if a child happens to escape their view, and attempts to open a door to the family home (and these are relatively inexpensive in my experience!). Parents might also consider sprinkler systems instead of actual pools if fences and safety mechanisms and supervision are not realistic options.I recently read an article outlining what a true drowning looks like, and was shocked to see it had nothing to do (most of the time) with people flailing about, screaming for help!! Google it -- find out what drowning really looks like!! Any parent / caregiver who reads that would be shocked, and would more be more likely to stop reading books, magazines, listening to ipods, etc while watching kids in the pool!!Also -- just because a person gets out of the water doesn't mean drowning is avoided!! Google dry drowning. Its scary!!If you're going to insist on the measures Dave suggests, you might as well ban all backyard pools altogether.


George-In-Calgary
said
0 0

Very alarming statistic. Tragic no doubt. 209 deaths over 8 years equates to 26 children per year. There are 26 000 000 million children in the US under 12 years old. Therefore this awful event is still a one in a million occurence, not nearly as alarming as 1 in 5 days, but I guess nobody would read the article if it said "1 of every 1 million children will drown in the backyard pool"


Dave, Ottawa
said
0 0

I think we should apply the same rules to these pools as we do to firearms. First, licence the owners. Make them pay a couple hundred bucks, take a safety course and pass a test. Next, register the pools themselves. If they don't come with a serial number, we'll give you a little sticker to put on them. Your licence must be renewed every 5 years. If you don't have a licence, or it expires, you can go to prison for 5 years. Inflatable pools would be deemed "ultraportable", and further restricted, requiring an authorization to transport to birthday parties, or to a dealer for repair. All pools must be emptied and stored in a locked garage when not in use, with no supply of water readily available. If you don't have a garage, you must build one at your own expense. Think of the CHILLLLDREN! No one NEEDS a portable pool! If it saves one life, it's worth it!


shelley-thunder bay
said
0 0

Children who cannot swim PROPERLY should ALWAYS wear a life jacket near ANY body of water/pools, lakes, rivers. Small sandbox-size pools should have no more than 3 to 4 inches of water. All it takes is one deep breath/gasp of water to turn matters critical! This measure does not replace CONSTANT ADULT supervision. My own adult children, also parents, follow this FAMILY LAW with my grandchildren. to turn things critical. A life jacket adds another level of safety to constant adult supervision.


Dean in Ont
said
0 0

Are you kidding me?! Correct me if I'm wrong here, but this tells me the parents (guardians, workers, etc) weren't even present for 57% of the drownings, and the other 43% weren't truly supervising at all otherwise those children would still be alive today. Whatever happened to being present, responsible parents??


Polar Den Mother
said
0 0

Mothers and fathers... it is YOUR responsibility to watch your children. Not ONE device or swimmingpool has misled you as they all DO clearly post "Do Not leave child unattended." or a derrivative of the same message. My child was not left unattended, ever, and guess what?? He's still alive. Parents, please accept responsibility and guard your children.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Health Stories

The B.C. government is pledging $8-million in funding to improve school playgrounds. Sept. 2, 2011. (CTV)

Canadian kids get failing grade for play time

More    Comments  

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More