Health -   

1

Fewer Canadians than Americans obese: StatsCan

Obesity; obesity; obesity generic; obese; obese generic; fat; overweight; diet; weight; weight loss; Obesity; obesity; obesity generic; obese; obese generic; fat; overweight; diet; weight; weight loss;
Obesity; obesity; obesity generic; obese; obese generic; fat; overweight; diet; weight; weight loss;

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (17) Facebook   

Selected Comment

America = The Land of Excess. Go to any restaurant there and you will understand. Huge portions at lower costs than here in Canada will turn anyone without common sense into a 'Jabba-the-Hut'.

Steve-O

Fewer Canadians than Americans obese: StatsCan

talking about
Fewer Canadians than Americans obese: StatsCan

Date: Wednesday Mar. 2, 2011 10:54 AM ET

The obesity crisis is worse in the United States than in Canada, a new study of rates in both countries shows.

Obesity is increasing in both Canada and the U.S., the researchers found. But less than a quarter of Canadian adults (24.1 per cent) are obese, compared to more than a third (34.4 per cent) of U.S. adults.

The comparison was a joint effort from Statistics Canada and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Preventions National Center for Health Statistics and appears in the NCHS's March Data Brief.

Obesity was defined as a body mass index (BMI) of 30.0 or higher.

The researchers found that among Canadian men, 24.3 per cent are considered obese, compared with 32.6 per cent of their American counterparts.

The gap was even wider among women: 23.9 per cent of Canadian women were obese between 2007 and 2009, compared with 36.2 per cent of women in the United States.

The prevalence of obesity among men has increased over the past two decades by about 10 percentage points in Canada and 12 percentage points in the U.S. The percentage changes among women were eight and 10, respectively.

Among men, the increase in both countries has been highest among seniors, aged 60 to 74. But among women, the increase has been highest among those much younger: those in the 20 to 39 category.

The study authors point out that the ethnic mix in each country is different. The American non-white population is comprised mainly of Hispanics and blacks, they noted, who are more likely to become obese than white Americans.

In contrast, Canadian non-whites are composed primarily of East/Southeast Asians, who are less likely to become obese than white Canadians.

The researchers used data collected by the U.S. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey as well as the Canadian Health Measures Survey.

In the United States, the surveys were conducted between 1988 and 1994 and then again between 2007 and 2008. In Canada, numbers were gathered between 1986 and 1992, as well as between 2007 and 2009.

Comments are now closed for this story

Fast food is not cheap!
said
0 0

There is a lie repeated and circulated that it's cheaper to eat fast food than to buy fresh, real food at a grocery store. That is complete bunk. For me to get a burger,fry & drink combo it would cost $9 - $11 for one person, I can make a meal for two that would last three days with left overs on that budget. When I was single and didn't have time to cook every day, I would make a couple of meals a week and eat them all week. Fast food is not cheap, it's just fast. And you pay with your life and well being if you eat it regularly.Speghetti bolognese, roast chicken, apples .... those two meals and the fruit would cost about $20 and could eat for four days for two ... also, with left over roast chicken on day you've had enough of left overs, make a rice pilaf with onions and garlics and left over roast chicken.


Steve-O
said
0 0

America = The Land of Excess. Go to any restaurant there and you will understand. Huge portions at lower costs than here in Canada will turn anyone without common sense into a 'Jabba-the-Hut'.


Allow me to correct HCW
said
0 0

HCW, your comment is so ignorant and shows your level of education. It is a safe assumption that there are more obese folks in the USA because more people live there, we get that, its straight forward. The study is based on a PERCENTAGE of obese people! Read the article, get the facts right or don't comment. Ridiculous.


Monique
said
0 0

HCW--Although my math has never been good, it seems to me that you misread the article as it spoke to the PERCENTAGE of Canadians to Americans who are obese. PERCENTAGES are not impacted by numbers but demonstrate a better comparison. Also, the article uses the word "obesity" not "fat" which may be a matter of semantics to some-- but not to others.


Sahib Reginawale
said
0 0

HCW, you need to go back to elementary school. The article is talking about proportions and not absolute numbers! So, it doesn't matter whether the population count of US is more than ten times that of Canada. I am surprized that you even know how to switch on a computer!


Linda in Vancouver
said
0 0

All the modern conveniences we have invented over the years are taking a toll.Like someone said,we use cars to go 200 yards to buy a litre of milk.Previous generations of Canadians often did not have cars.What amazes me is that we've been aware iof,and discussing this very iuuse for several years.Yet I have yet to hear one word that indicates that the school systems are even ready to discuss physical fitness and health issues as mandary subjects for all students in all grades.That make me wonder about how teachers and their unions set priotities.After all,we all demand health care as a right when we get sick.What in life can be more important for children to learn,than how to take care of themselves properly? Socrates? The pyramids of Giza? Nostradamus? I think not. I'd agree with the whiner who thinks comparing ourselves to the USA only,may be a bit of a mistake.It would be a lot wiser to compare our progress to a whole lot of other nations.We are like the USA in many ways.But inmany ways we are also like Australia,the UK,etc,etc,.Why would we not want to look at them all,and use the best of what each has going for it to formulate our own plans for success? Has the progress of the human species not been built by learning from,and expanding on the knowledge of those who lived before us? If that is the case, why would we exclude anyone,or any nation.


HCW
said
0 0

Well duh! There's over 300 million Americans and perhaps 35 million Canadians (give or take a few). So of course America has more fat people! Simple math! Where's the contest?


We Can Do Better
said
0 0

We should never allow ourselves to fall behind the Americans in any area. We can do better. With more dedication to a sedentary lifestyle and prepared food, we can overcome the Americans and be the biggest people on the continent. Let's be No. 1. Go Canada Go!!


Cynical
said
0 0

'And what's with the comparison to the United States' oiufyg asks. Well . . . how about their nation forms the other part of our continent? How about the fact that we share food resources, meaning production and distribution. How about the fact that we get on very well with our neighbor and share information, like the studies that were used for comparison. Who else should we compare data with - Australia, UK, New Zealand? Please update your concept of what part of the world Canada belongs to, and preferably get rid of your anti-americanism.


Rebecca
said
0 0

It says in the article that the biggest increase for men is in seniors aged 60-74. You can't use the same BMI cutoff points for those over 65. Research shows it is safer for seniors to weigh a little more in case of illness or falls.


Canadian in the Netherlands
said
0 0

The Netherlands has a very slim and fit population. Each time that I go back to Canada, I'm shock see the large amount of Fat People. It is a mentality to use your car to drive 200 meters to get to the corner store.


Doug ^^^ BC
said
0 0

Oh Wow.Bring out the Champagne!! Winning this battle with the USA looks seriously close to the equvalent of being the best bobsledder in all of Jamaica. Now,while conceding tht there are many people with real disabilties that make it tough for them to stay fit,the rest of the population has no REAL excuse.We demand our rights and all of our liberties,but when our responsibilities come up for discussion,everyone runs for cover.It's issues like this that have me wondering if "we the people" can really handle making decisions on our own.If we go any further down that raod, the nanny state may be the only way some people can survive. Aside from our inability to make good choices on our own,I also see this as a failure of our education system.Physical education is among one of the basic life skillls that now takes a back seat in schools.It goes right along with planning a career,balancing a budget,and how to interact with people who may not agree with everything you say.We are not only less fit than our parents and grandparents,we are more in debt,less civil to each other,and have no clue how to find a compromise when complete agreements are elusive. No.I'm not saying this is a failed state.But it could easily turn into one if the citizenry can't even learn to breath without help from one level of government or another.We may have all the technology and all the toys,but as people,our ancestors put us to shame.Every time.In BC people are advocating a "fat tax".More taxes on everything you eat or drink,that someone else decides is not good for you.And you will pay that tax even if you are as skinny as a rail. And people still wonder why I detest political activists.


Earthwatcher
said
0 0

ha! see what a diet of beer, donuts and hockey games on the couch can do for a body? Besides being able to lord this minor victory over our American neighbours, this is still not good news. Fully one quarter of Canadians are obese. Think about that, one in every four cannot see their toes without a mirror. Sad days indeed.


Randy in Winnipeg
said
0 0

Has anyone ever noticed that it costs less to eat fast (ie. fat) foods than fresh vegetables and healthier choice meats and grains? And unfortunately it forces many people in lower economic groups to eat fattening foods. And then we supersize it to boot.Did you know milk on a cost per ounce is more expensive that beer?


Concerned
said
0 0

But in the states they don't clog up the hospitals, being without insurance and all.


Melissa
said
0 0

It's still a high number.To compare this rate with the States doesn't make it OK that 1/4 of our population is obese.On a side note - I'd hate to be reading a news story about obesity and be like, "hey, I'm pretty sure that's my butt in that picture."


ouifyg
said
0 0

This is horrible! A quarter of our population is obese. Why would you spin this as good news!?! And what's with the comparison to the United States. Is our only national identity comparing ourselves to them? We should try to do better no matter what the American statistics are, we are a separate nation!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Facebook

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook

Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews

Today's Health Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More