Health -   

1

More family doctors needed in Canada, report urges

Hearing test
Hearing test

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (11) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday Dec. 2, 2009 4:53 PM ET

Canada should aim to ensure 95 per cent of people in every community have a family doctor by 2012, urge the Canadian Medical Association and the College of Family Physicians of Canada.

The groups, which banded together two years ago to form the Primary Care Wait Time Partnership, say in order to reach this target, the country needs to increase the number of family doctors practising in Canada while also increasing the capacity of existing family physicians.

In a report released Wednesday, entitled "The Wait Starts Here", the groups note that reports on wait times have focused mainly on access to specialty care, such as MRI diagnostics. But attention also needs to be paid to the ongoing problem of a shortage of family doctors, they say.

"Canada has seen solid effort at measuring and mitigating wait times for patients to access high-quality specialty care," Dr. Anne Doig, president of the Canadian Medical Association, said in a statement.

"We must never forget that, while patients may see many specialists for a variety of problems, family physicians play a critical role in managing and linking that care."

According to recent public opinion research the Partnership commissioned from Ipsos, 17 per cent of respondents do not have a family doctor. That works out to about 4.1 million Canadians aged 12 or older.

The survey also found 84 per cent were either very or somewhat concerned about the number of people lacking a family doctor.

Of those who do have a family doctor, about half said they were concerned about how long it can often take to get an appointment with their family doctor. Dr. Cathy MacLean, President of The College of Family Physicians of Canada, says that finding was interesting.

"The fact that about half of our patients feel confident they can get to see their doctor when they need to speaks to the fact that family physicians do all they can to provide care for their patients when they need it," she said.

To help address the issues raised by the survey and ongoing concerns over lengthy waits to see family doctors, the groups make a number of suggestions for change, including:

  • finding ways to have medical schools encourage students to choose family medicine
  • increasing training opportunities for qualified international medical graduates
  • providing incentives in physician contracts for them to take on more patients
  • finding ways for family doctors to streamline their practice so they can take on more patients, including with the use of more family practice nurses, more physician assistants and electronic health records.

"Canada must move now to increase the supply of family physicians," said Dr. Lydia Hatcher, co-chairwoman of the Primary Care Wait Time Partnership.

"If we are to address Canada's serious challenges in providing timely access to care we simply need more hands on deck."

A report released just last week from the Canadian Institute for Health Information found that the number of doctors in Canada has increased over the past five years. The physician-to-population ratio grew to 195 physicians for every 100,000 Canadians in 2008, from 189 per 100,000 in 2004.

But many of those doctors are not choosing family medicine. And Dr. Robert Ouellet, past president of the CMA, noted that more doctors does not necessarily translate into more access.

"They counted the numbers of doctors but they didn't count how many hours they put in, or calculate how well the system works," he told The Globe and Mail last week. "We need more doctors but we also need to give them the tools to practise efficiently."

Comments are now closed for this story

Helen - Ontario
said
0 0

Foreign doctors do not always have the same calibre of knowledge and when being taught in English they have a serious problem of trying to interpret the language as well as the Canadian medical procedures. I would resent the fact that these undereducated so-called medical doctors would get the same OHIP monies and privileges that our home-grown, competent, medical doctors currently have. These foreign doctors should be thoughly vetted before letting them loose on the Canadian public.


Frank Buchan
said
0 0

Regardless of native language, all doctors could use a course in basic communications. I have spoken top physicians who speak English-only and found it a challenge grasping what they have been talking about, between their reliance on jargon and what sometimes seems to be a lack of focus. When you spend 15 minutes seeing a doctor, after a half hour wait, only to have them ignore the direct answers you give to questions, then ask the same question again, you have to wonder. I know all doctors are not this way, but too many seem distracted by their technology.


james
said
0 0

yep, thats true, things are not like 45 years ago. It is a different age, and yep there should be more doctors.


GHW
said
0 0

Hey maybe if the U.S. adopts public health care the money will dry up a bit down there and our doctors will return home!


Danielle
said
0 0

The problem with encouraging people to go into family medicine in Canada is that when people finish their residency and go into practice they will take their experience to the US where they can be paid more for their services. We need to start recognizing foreign credentials and give immigrants a fair chance to use their knowledge in a clinical setting. It is the foreign trained physicians who would feel privileged to be given the chance to practice medicine here in Canada. In my personal experience, the foreign trained physicians have always given me the best experience in terms of my health care.


PeterS
said
0 0

There is a significant shortage of family physicians in Canada, and has been for decades now. anything that can be done to improve this situation should receive serious consideration. My wife and I moved from Vancouver to the interior of B.C. close to four years ago and just recently found a family physician who was accepting new patients...close to four years of looking for one here. The causes of the shortage are numerous, ranging from training spaces to demographics, etc., and the solution also has to be multiple approaches including accepting MD's from other countries once their qualifications have been vetted.


olla b
said
0 0

Jose, perhaps you should learn to understand various accents better. You live in 21st century Canada, after all. And I hope you don't want radio announcers to diagnose or treat you and your family one day. What the doctor knows, and how well he or she is trained to treat you is by far more important than how their pronounce their r's. Oh and have you ever seen a doctor's writing? In any language it is supposed to be illegible.


C. Porter in Courtice
said
0 0

Maybe we need to start accepting the credetials of other nations a bit more. I am under the impression that we are too nationalistic in what we deem as qualifications. There are many other countries out there with fantasitic medical programs....


Tono
said
0 0

Without doubt, this will add another surge of doctors from third-world countries.


Jose
said
0 0

Whoever is in charge of taking the decision of where these doctors will come from.... for heaven shake! Can you please make sure they speak English CREARLY!My first language is Spanish and English I learned it when I came to Canada. I don’t pretend to have a perfect command of the English language but then I again, I am not a Doctor. Last week I went to a walk-in clinic and I had no idea of what the doctor was saying due to his strong Indian accent, after getting frustrated trying to undersdant what he was saying, I got up and left.My girlfriend (100 % English Canadian, born and raised in Ottawa) went to another clinic yesterday and she had the same experience with a Russian/Ukranian doctor.


Mark Smith (Montreal, QC)
said
0 0

Well, good luck with that.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Health Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More