Health -   

1
Independent investigator Sheila Weatherill speaks during a press conference in Ottawa on Tuesday, July 21, 2009. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)  Independent investigator Sheila Weatherill speaks during a press conference in Ottawa on Tuesday, July 21, 2009. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)  Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz speaks at a press conference in Ottawa on Tuesday, July 21, 2009 in response to the report of the independent investigator. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Michael McCain, the president and CEO of Maple Leaf Foods, responds to the the listeriosis outbreak findings during a press conference in Toronto, on Tuesday, July 21, 2009.

Leadership 'void' led to listeriosis outbreak

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Robert Fife on the repercussions
Sheila Weatherill spent six months investigating last year's listeria outbreak and came up with 57 recommendations to avoid future outbreaks. But she stopped short of calling out those responsible.
CTV News Channel: Bob Kingston, president of the Agriculture Union, on the need for more inspectors
Bob Kingston, a former CFIA inspector and the current head of the Agriculture Union says that from the first day of the crisis, they have been trying to point out the fact there aren't enough inspectors in the agency. This is a claim also brought up in the report.
CTV News Channel: Carolyn Bennett, Liberal health critic, on the findings
Says it's a good blue print for going forward. The inquiry didn't go far enough to examine the role of the Chief Officer of Public Health.
CTV News Channel: Gloria Galloway, Globe and Mail
Maple Leaf Foods has had to go back and take a very serious look at its food safety protocol and procedures. Despite the many changes they have made, the head of the company pointed out that no food processing plant can ever guarantee that bacteria will not find its way into the system.
CTV News Channel: Michael McCain, president and CEO of Maple Leaf Foods, responds to the findings
The president of Maple Leaf Foods says the report is a 'painful reminder of the factors that culminated int he tragedy of last year.' The company, he explains, accepts full responsibility, and has and will continue to make changes to its food safety program.
CTV News Channel: Investigator releases findings
A new report on last summer's listeriosis outbreak says manufacturers should be required to design easy-to-clean meat-processing equipment that limits the spread of bacteria.
CTV News Channel: Rick Holley, food science professor, on his recommendations for the report
Holley says one of the troubling things that comes from the study of the food safety system in Canada is the issue of shared responsibility among the various jurisdictions.
Canada AM: Rick Holley, professor at the University of Manitoba, on the listeriosis report
Microbiologist Rick Holley says the report was a waste of time and taxpayer money since it didn't look at the bigger picture.
CTV News Channel: Sharon Shepherd, Kelowna Mayor, on how the forest fires have affected the community
Sharon Shepherd says people have learned a lot from the forest fires of 2003 and now know how to better deal with this fire.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (22) Facebook   

Date: Tue. Jul. 21 2009 9:46 PM ET

The listeriosis outbreak that killed 22 people last year was not taken seriously enough in its early days, concludes a report that offers 57 recommendations for preventing future outbreaks.

"What we found is that last summer, our food safety system did not work as perfectly as it needed to," investigator Sheila Weatherill told a news conference Tuesday morning.

"The investigation has made clear that much more could have been done to prevent this from happening in the first place and more to that point, much more must be done to make sure it doesn't happen again."

Weatherill's report found the Maple Leaf Foods plant that was the source of the outbreak failed to notice its problem with Listeria contamination on its meat-slicing machines. Over-extended government meat inspectors also failed to identify the problem.

Once reports of illnesses began to mount, the outbreak was not considered a severe food-borne emergency, as it should have been.

"This led to a void in leadership in managing the crisis," the report alleges. "It took close to three weeks before senior executives in all key organizations became fully engaged in the event."

There were also failures in communicating the crisis to the public and to those in institutional food services, which received most of the contaminated meat product.

"Federal communications to the public were slow off the mark, and were not sustained for a sufficient period of time. In addition, there was no designated communications coordinator, which resulted in a fragmented approach and seemingly inconsistent messaging," the report notes.

While Maple Leaf Foods president Michael McCain welcomed the findings as rigorous and comprehensive, he said that there are "no guarantees" that a similar outbreak won't happen again.

"Our job is to produce safe food ... that never means the hardened word of guarantee," he said Tuesday.

Still, McCain said that the systems for food safety are a huge improvement over the ones in place last year.

"Had (they) been in place then, we believe we would have saved 22 lives," he told a news conference.

"We have learned our lesson."

Key findings

As CTV News reported Monday, Weatherill's report calls for a number of changes including:

  • More unannounced federal spot checks at meat facilities. Currently, meat plants are given 72 hours to 30 days notice ahead of inspections.
  • Ensuring that food companies alert public officials as soon as they suspect a health threat, rather than wait until they have a positive lab tests.
  • Having Canada's chief public health officer take the lead role in a food-borne illness crisis, not government officials.
  • Requiring meat processing equipment manufacturers to design equipment that is easy to clean.

The report is the result of a six-month probe headed by Weatherill, a former Edmonton health care executive, who conducted more than 100 interviews and amassed some five million pages of information.

Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz told reporters Tuesday he accepts Weatherill's report and noted that some of her recommendations have already been implemented, while others can be implemented quickly.

"We now have a critical mass of research and recommendations," Ritz told a Parliament Hill news conference.

"...All of these reviews have clearly identified opportunities for improvement. This is a turning point. The reports are in. We will continue to resources, regulations and legislation where required to strengthen our food safety system."

However, Ritz said that Ottawa won't compensate the victims' families.

Liberal MP Carolyn Bennett said Weatherill's report was "a good blueprint for going forward."

But the Liberal party health critic also said the report did not go far enough in uncovering the reasons why Canada's chief public health officer did not take the lead role during the listeriosis outbreak -- a responsibility that is already part of his job description.

"We are very upset that the mandate of her inquiry couldn't go far enough to find out what on Earth happened that the chief public health officer for Canada was not front and centre in the outbreak last year," Bennett told CTV News Channel during an interview on Tuesday evening.

Maple Leaf Foods apologized shortly after last summer's outbreak and agreed to pay up to $27 million to settle class-action lawsuits. The company has since instituted more rigorous testing for Listeria in plants producing ready-to-eat meat.

Comments are now closed for this story

Barry from Regina
said
0 0

If a listeriosis outbreak never happens again where will Ritz get his material for his jokes? I find it repugnant that a minister can joke about such a serious illness and then get reelected. Only in Saskatchewan!


Bill in BC
said
0 0

This has been dealt with. No need to try to rake up muke, it's OVER.


Brian in TO
said
0 0

What boggles my mind is the fact that this thing was all over the media front and center last year. Everyday I would turn on CTV News and they'd be talking about cold cuts for 10 minutes. Then I'd open the paper and they'd have a 5 page section about cold cuts, then on the radio...cold cuts! You couldn't escape it.

Yet people kept getting sick AFTER all these warnings were out there. Were these people living under a rock? Did they not believe it? Why didn't they get the message not to eat the meat?


Mattman in Ottawa
said
0 0

Do we STILL want the industry to police itself?


Michael. Cambridge Ont.
said
0 0

Of course with remark made by Minister Gerry is tasteless and it does indicated that he and his employer doesn't care enough about listeriosis outbreak.

Shame on you Ritz... You should've been fired since day you made that remark.

You are minister of Ministry for sake!!!!! Set a example for your own kids!


allan
said
0 0

How much do we pay these "investigators" like Weatherill? These "recommendations" are a joke and are already in practice for the most part. Just a case of more beaurocrats coming up with words to look like they have accomplished something. It was an accident, period, and will happen again no matter what beaurocrats b.s. about.



Dale Hefalumpenwosels from Nanticoke
said
0 0

I am more worried about this than swine flu. I wish money would be put to help these problems and not other meaningless ones.


Rick in NB
said
0 0

David Poelzer,
Don't get me wrong i'm a card carrying grit. The government should never have allowed the reductiuon of inspectors and we were on a downward spiral as far as safety goes.
That was a problem both governments never addressed. But i believe that this report and regulations that have been implemented are a good fix.
Again i have to say Wayne Easter is on a fishing trip. Harper uses personal attach ads. The grits question every action the tories make. Six of one half a dozen of the other.


THE Fatman
said
0 0

Hindsight......20/20!


Norma Graham
said
0 0

Get a clue, everyone: go vegetarian, which will keep you safer, healthier, less prone to heart disease and colon cancer, and will meaningfully decrease your carbon footprint. I have been a vegetarian for 30 years and am fit, healthy, happy - and haven't gotten ill from food poisoning since 1976! Meat kills.


my take on this
said
0 0

Steve, could you please pass a law that says card carrying conservatives do not have to pay income taxes of any kind and conservatives will also be allowed to tell us non-conservatives how to lead our lives.
Thanks


Don Fierro
said
0 0

As a retired Occupational Health and Safety in the Canadian manufacturing industry I can honestly attest to the fact that for most executives safety is seen as a pain in the ...

By far and large there is a total lack of commitment in the part of owners and senior management towards implementing a safe workplace and the listeria outbreak is a child of this corporate way of thinking.
Ontario has a very strong Occupational Health & Safety Act and yet, few companies take it seriously and if they do, is in the most basic form, lip service as it is known.

That a poorly designed piece of equipment was allowed to be installed, pressed into daily production despite is flagrant flaw and that the products processed by it were allowed to reach the public is a disgrace, more than that, is a criminal act, negligence causing death but nobody has been charged. It is a sad state of affairs but no level of government accross Canada is willing to do something about it, safety costs money and that gives executives,board members and, shareholders indigestion so it is easier to toss it out of the window rather than do the right thing.


Phipps
said
0 0

Rick you are incorrect that it was a machine design that was hard to clean correctly, it was the companies lack of attention to detail and reading the manual to insure the equipment was operated and cleaned properly. It was a lack of training on their part to ensure that proper protocols were being followed. In my eyes if a company refits its plants with new equipment they must follow the proper protocols but it is the responsibility of the government to ensure that this happens.

And why were the companies ever informed of an upcoming inspection, to me this sounds counterintuitive.


Martin in Edmonton
said
0 0

Harper would never have allowed this to be released directly to the public unless he had previously vetted the content (partly by handpicking Weatherill). What a surprise that the recommendations are practically all floor level issues and not critical of leadership.

Have unannounced inspections? How profound. Require prereports of possible issues? This has been common practice for corporate environmental reporting for years. Make machines easier to clean? How many decades has there been meat cutting equipment requiring cleaning - and now this is a key finding? Come on now.


Liz
said
0 0

Has anyone checked all the slicers in every store or deli?

I just don't buy any deli meat anymore. I haven't seen Metro or anyone else show any sign it even knows about the issue.

Liz


Laura
said
0 0

Over the past few years, government officials and "experts" in the food & health industries in this country have become complacent, dismissive and even downright incompetent. I have worked in healthcare for 20 years and in academics for 10 with a focus on microbiology and epidemiology. People in charge of safekeeping our food/water systems, health systems, etc are grossly ill-equipped, both intellectually and financially. Just look at our past 10 years - municipal water systems that kill residents with severe E. coli contamination, extensive Salmonella and Listeria contamination in the food system, flu outbreaks that could easily be managed if the complacent attitude of "won't happen to us" wasn't so prevalent, inspectors that don't even know how (or didn't care) to practice the basic techniques of infection control when entering the pig barns in Alberta (now have come down with swine flu) - if these are the kind of "experts" in charge of our country's well-being, then we'll be seeing a lot more "reports" after the fact for a long time. The knowledge is out there - nobody has the will to properly use it.


David Poelzer
said
0 0

Rick, It wasn't the cutting machine that caused the death of 22 people. It was neglect,sloppy workmanship, and inaction from all levels of government that caused Mass Murder. Plain and Simple.

David in Ottawa


zwinky
said
0 0

The current Conservative government admits it wanted to move towards looser regulation and less oversight of Canada's food industry in the months leading up to this terrible and uneccessary loss of life.

While this outbreak was initially caused by faulty equipment it was vastly exacerbated due to the government having reduced the number of inspectors and their mandate to oversee food safety.

Industry will not properly voluntarily regulate itself because it is expensive and cuts into profits.

Safety will never be put ahead of the bottom line unless the government enforces the standards.

Let's get Canada's food supply back to being one of the safest by restoring food inspector's power and ability to protect our citizen's.


Roger T
said
0 0

Good to know that checks weren't even enforced by our law. No wonder our health system is poor and tax paying citizens are getting sick from contaminated process foods.

Our Gov't is quick to critize other countries on safety or health standards just to deflect attention back home only to turn a blind eye on Canadians health!


Raj
said
0 0

Wayne is doing his job.He really would have liked to have heard that somehow our PM was in trouble.He isnt! the food experts for months have said listeriosis is everywhere, even in our fridges.We want safe food, so how many more inspectors would we have to hire? Go to your local food chain or deli, and we take a chance.
She took 6 months to say, this is a tough problem, we all know that, but she also said everybody did all they could.


Francesco
said
0 0

Whenever I hear the words "behind closed doors", I know that someone has something to hide. Also, we, the taxpaying public, has every right to know the whole story and not some vetted version pabulum fed to the electorate. To our CONservative government , I say, "stop exercising the political strategies" relayed to the knowledge that people will soon forget bad governance.


Rick in NB
said
0 0

I think Wayne Easter is beating a dead dog. The outbreak was caused by a machine designed to make it very hard to clean properly. Safety and protocol have been reviewed and improved. What is Easter's problem?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

Today's Health Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More