Health -
News Sections
Listeriosis report to recommend more spot checks
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Mon. Jul. 20 2009 10:15 PM ET
A new report into last year's fatal listeriosis outbreak will call for more unannounced federal spot checks at meat facilities across the country and an enhanced role for the chief public health officer in managing food-borne illnesses, CTV News has learned.
The report will be made public Tuesday, but its key points were obtained by CTV News a day early.
"The inquiry cost almost $3 million and I'm told it makes about 70 recommendations," said Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife. "It makes no findings of criminal or civil liabilities; what it does is make recommendations to prevent a similar outbreak."
Among the key recommendations: food companies must report all public health threats to the government, and federal inspection reports should be published.
The probe was headed by Sheila Weatherill, a former Edmonton health care executive, as part of Ottawa's response to last year's outbreak, which left 22 people dead and hundreds more ill.
The outbreak was traced to contaminated deli meat linked to a Maple Leaf Foods plant north of Toronto.
Other recommendations in the report include:
- Meat plants must report any public safety threats to the government, not just those stemming from positive bacteria tests.
- Manufacturers must design meat processing equipment that is easy to clean and will limit the spread of bacteria.
- Canada's chief public health officer must take the lead in any future cases of food-borne illness, lessening any potential political diversions.
- Provinces need to follow more strict safety rules.
- Ottawa should review the training of federal inspectors, in addition to reviewing inspection resources.
Earlier Monday, a spokesperson for Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Weatherill's report will be released to the public in its entirety.
Liberal MP Wayne Easter, the party's agriculture critic, cast doubt on the report's efficacy.
"We have concerns about this because of the way this government has handled this matter since day one," he said in a statement.
"The report from the government's hand-picked investigator, with a limited mandate conducted in private, is not sufficient. They have road-blocked any attempts to provide more transparency about the events of last summer."
But Weatherill denied anyone had interfered with her investigation.
"I have been able to conduct my investigation independently and impartially," she said in a statement. "There has been no interference from any party whatsoever."
Weatherill and her team conducted more than 100 interviews and amassed some five million pages of information during their seven-month inquiry.
But the investigation came under some criticism because the investigators held closed-door meetings with cabinet ministers and their aides, various experts, and industry and consumer groups.
Michael Doyle, a Listeria expert who advised Weatherill while she worked on her report, said she had looked at both the outbreak and at food safety in Canada.
"What I've seen, I think, is a pretty good, balanced report," he said. "I think it does a pretty good job of addressing the issue of the day, which is listeriosis and Maple Leaf product."
University of Manitoba food safety expert Rick Holley met with Weatherill during the spring.
"I still have the impressions she's being very conscientious in exploring issues that are somewhat broader than just the specific listeriosis event," he said.
Weatherill delivered the long-awaited report to Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz Monday, four months after the original March 15 deadline.
A House of Commons sub-committee has also tabled two dissenting reports on the listeriosis crisis. In their reports, released in June, opposition MPs called for a public inquiry into the outbreak.
They also asked to see greater autonomy for the Public Health Agency of Canada, as well as for health authorities to work more closely with the United States on food-safety standards.
Maple Leaf Foods apologized for the outbreak and agreed to pay up to $27 million to settle class-action lawsuits. The company has since instituted more rigorous testing for Listeria in plants producing ready-to-eat meat.
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
If 5000 jobs can be so vital to the nation's economy, they should get what they ask for in bargaining. Simple.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Judy
0
said
0
This is not an "independent" investigator.
The report should have been released publicly. The government had no right to a 24 hour lead time to diffuse any potential politically damaging content.
Why does Harper have to insist he won't "tamper" with it...I guess his past actions indicate a tendency to deflect, delay, distort and blame.
the big gulp
0
said
0
STOP THE HATE!
When Stephen Harper and a few of his henchmen get out of politics, the HATE MAY GO!
The Conservative Party of Canada will be better off when "real conservatives" start running the party again.
my take on this
0
said
0
"The report from the government's hand-picked investigator, with a limited mandate conducted in private, is not sufficient. They have road-blocked any attempts to provide more transparency about the events of last summer."
Thankfully, Steve's days are numbered and hopefully, the Conservative Party of Canada will anoint a conservative leader with some common sense.
reidjr
0
said
0
The probleam is maple leaf food is not the only probleam.THere are many many other issues with other products.If you shut down each one your gorvery stores will have no point they will be able to sell maybe a hand full of items.
Guy Tron
0
said
0
Did you even consider that it would be appropriate for the Prime Minister and Health Minister to be clued in to what the report says so they can answer questions once it is released? If the PM and Health Minister have no idea what is in the report as once it is released, you would accuse them of not knowing what was going on.
STOP THE HATE!
MARG MM
0
said
0
As the article stated, the Conservatives will release the findings promptly without any editing or altering. Something I wouldn't trust the Liberals to do if they were the ones in power.
Barney In Trenton
0
said
0
Trevor
0
said
0
Liberals are "outraged" and having to wait 24 hours to get a report, they insist on having it before the ink dries ....
Give me a break, it's been YEARS and I'm still waiting for the Libs to tell us where the missing MILLIONS from ADSCAM are!
Ray Jacques, Glen Robertson, ON
0
said
0
It is definitely a "Big whoop" to me as so many Cnadians died (not sure if 19 or 21 ?) but this is a big deal.
Why it necessarily has to become a politial or partisan issue is beyond me.
I do not believe for a moment that the Harper Government intended that any Canadians die, but it was their de-regulation of the food uindstry which may have contributed to their deaths?
We should learn some lessons as a result, but let's see the report first:
Possibly in future, Conservative ideology should not play so large a role in regulating food inspectors ?
Partisan politics is an American invention and I would suggest that it go back there - it has no place in Canada if it does as it seems to, i.e. foster hate of Canadians by Candians whgo happen to have differing political views.
None of us should encourage this attitude. I do not thank Mr. Harper for bringing this kind of politics to Canada - it has proved to be very divisive.
Ron
0
said
0
Let me save you the time: Food producers need to keep their equipment clean. Food equipment producers need to provide proper cleaning instructions to food producers. Food inspectors overseeing the whole thing are fallible.
But I'm sure we'll hear that if we only had 1000 more fallible food inspectors we'd never have had this happen... because they have x-ray eyes. (Cause that'll be on the Liberal hiring requirements).
Buba
0
said
0
KRB
0
said
0
Raj
0
said
0
hiki
0
said
0
Good thing huh that they got rid of the workup..
Lots of things are hidden by medical professional...
Wayne
0
said
0
Samual
0
said
0
I would rather read where our tax dollars are going.
Garry in NS
0
said
0
Lillian
0
said
0
Sick of Politics
0
said
0
So before all you Harpers haters even start I’m gonna tell you to give it a rest, and stop listing to the media when they try to make a crap story sound more interesting than it really is by adding bogus lines like "But it's not known if the findings of the investigations - conducted mostly behind closed doors - will be released in their entirety to the public."
It doesn’t matter which party is in power, NOTHING DIFFERENT EVER HAPPENS.
nash
0
said
0