Health -   

1
Newfoundland and Labrador Health Minister Ross Wiseman discusses the findings of the Cameron inquiry from St. John's, N.L. on Tuesday, Mar. 3, 2009. Newfoundland and Labrador Health Minister Ross Wiseman discusses the findings of the Cameron inquiry from St. John's, N.L. on Tuesday, Mar. 3, 2009. Louise Sellars, who received incorrect test results, speaks on Canada AM from CTV's studios in St. John's, Tuesday, Mar. 3, 2009.

N.L. cancer tests inquiry finds failure at all levels

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: John Vennavally-Rao on the report
Relatives of cancer patients in Newfoundland and Labrador finally received some answers after the release of the Cameron inquiry report. Now they are left wondering how the health system could have failed their loved ones so badly.
NTV News: Correspondents on the Cameron report and the lack of quality control in the N.L. health system
Patients and the public in Newfoundland and Labrador finally received some answers about why nearly 400 breast cancer patients were denied potentially life saving drugs because of faulty laboratory tests results.
CTV Newsnet: Beverly Green discusses how being given incorrect test results impacted her treatment and her long-term health
A woman who was given incorrect breast cancer test results discusses how this misinformation impacted her treatment and her long-term health.
CTV Newsnet: Judy Jones, who received wrong test results, discusses whether individuals or the system should be blamed
A woman who received the wrong breast cancer test results reacts to an inquiry which found that a failure of accountability and oversight 'at all level' led the inaccurate test results.
CTV Newsnet: Dr. Jagdish Butany, Canadian Association of Pathologists, reviews the inquiry report
The 60 recommendations from the Cameron inquiry all appear to be good ideas, but the government will need to follow through to ensure that they are all implemented.
CTV Newsnet: Ross Wiseman, N.L. health minister, with the final report
A comprehensive inquiry report on the botched breast cancer tests has been released, which looks at whether the errors could have been detected earlier and whether best practices were being used.
CTV Newsnet: N.L. Health Minister Ross Wiseman takes media questions on the report
The report of the Cameron inquiry into botched hormone receptor tests for breast cancer has made 60 recommendations.
CTV Newsnet: Peter Dawe, Canadian Cancer Society, on what to expect from the report
The report into botched cancer tests in N.L. is expected to cover what went wrong in the lab itself and the communications disaster that followed discovery of the problems.
CTV Newsnet: Myrtle Lewis, wrongly diagnosed with cancer, on the inquiry results
One woman who underwent unnecessary treatment after being wrongly diagnosed with cancer, is hoping for answers about what went wrong and how it happened.
Canada AM: Louise Sellars, received incorrect pathology results
After four years of waiting, N.L. breast cancer patients and advocates are going to get some answers. One woman who received incorrect tests hopes the inquiry will lay out guidelines for better communication and disclosure.
Canada AM: Norman White, breast cancer survivor, on how something positive can come from the report
The report into the breast cancer test scandal in N.L. will be released Tuesday, and at least one survivor is hoping for something positive to come from the report.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (7) Facebook   

Date: Tue. Mar. 3 2009 4:45 PM ET

A failure of accountability and oversight "at all levels" led to hundreds of breast cancer patients in Newfoundland and Labrador being given inaccurate test results, a public inquiry has concluded.

"The whole of the health system, to varying degrees, can be said to have failed the ER/PR (estrogen receptor/progesterone receptor) patients," Justice Margaret Cameron wrote.

The 495-page inquiry report includes 60 recommendations to ensure what went wrong won't happen again, including:

  • more training for clinicians
  • mandatory continuing education for laboratory technologists
  • improved record-keeping

Breast cancer survivor Marie Hickey, who was among hundreds of patients to receive a botched test, said the report has given her "great expectations" the same problems will not happen again.

"I have confidence now that this how come to light in such a big way," she told NTV News. "I think people will be more careful and will be more accountable."

Cameron has asked the provincial government to report by March 31, 2010, on how her recommendations have been implemented. The province's health minister Ross Wiseman promised to do just that at news conference later in the day, where he apologized again on behalf of the provincial government to those affected.

"The recommendations in the report provide clear direction on the next steps to making enhancements to the health care system provincially," said Wiseman. "And I have no doubt these recommendations will benefit other jurisdictions across the country that have experienced similar issues.

The seven-month-long inquiry looked into why almost 400 breast cancer patients received the wrong results on tests that were intended to determine the appropriate treatment for their breast cancer.

The inquiry heard testimony about inept work at the lab that processed the botched tests, and poor communication between health authorities and the government. Former employees testified that staff were improperly trained, handled the samples incorrectly, allowed poor quality control and had inadequate supervision.

But because the errors are thought to have begun in 1997 and weren't revealed publicly until 2005, there must have been "not only deficiencies within the laboratory but also the failure of Healthcare's management system," the report reads.

Even after the problems became public, the health board, Eastern Health, continued to fail to notify affected patients, the inquiry found. One patient told the inquiry on its last day of hearings that she had only learned she was affected by the scandal last summer - eight years after her tests.

The provincial government also shares some of the blame, the inquiry heard, since it allowed several warnings from Eastern Health about problems at the lab to go largely unheeded.

"It really was a disaster for the health authority here," Peter Dawe of the Canadian Cancer Society said Tuesday afternoon on CTV Newsnet.

"They withheld information from individuals, they withheld information from the general public, they actually withheld information from the minister of health at times."

Dr. Jagdish Butany of the Canadian Association of Pathologists, says the problems that occurred at the St. John's lab could have happened anywhere in Canada.

"The major problem was there were no standards for this particular type of test. Keep in mind that this is an extremely complicated test," he told CTV Newsnet, adding that his group began setting standards for tests two years ago to ensure they are done uniformly across the country.

Louise Sellars was one of those who received incorrect test results. She was diagnosed with breast cancer more than six years ago. After undergoing surgery, radiation and chemotherapy, she was told that her cancer was receptor-negative and that she didn't need to take further medication, such as tamoxifen.

But the lab in St. John's that had performed her hormone test had gotten her results wrong -- along with the results of at least 385 others. Sellars was in fact receptor-positive and had already missed out on three years of medication that might have kept her healthy.

"It's been horrendous," she told Canada AM of the years that have passed since. "Terrible, sleepless nights. It never leaves you. It's there 24/7."

She says she still worries that her cancer may come back, even six years later, because she didn't go on the medications that could have helped her particular form of cancer.

Myrtle Lewis, whose tests were also botched, told Newsnet she underwent a double mastectomy and six months of chemotherapy but learned later she only had pre-cancerous cells and that her treatments were unnecessary. She says she was sickened by what she heard from the inquiry.

"Hearing all this bickering back and forth, with one who don't know what the other one is doing and putting the blame on one another, I've got no faith in (the health care system) whatsoever," Lewis said.

Premier Danny Williams launched the inquiry in 2007, after documents filed with the provincial Supreme Court as part of a class-action lawsuit against Eastern Health revealed the full extent of the errors.

Williams has been critical of the way the inquiry has operated, accusing it of conducting an inquisition in the way it questioned government officials.

Comments are now closed for this story

Joyce
said

First of all, I wish to say to all those affected,my thoughts are with you all and that I would not wish this on anyone else.
I can imagine the trauma these women have gone through, and I really do not understand as to why the communications between the Health Care Deptartments and the Government did not send any signals to those responsible for setting up an inquiry earlier.
It is already dramatic when one has to go for biopsies and the like and go through the motions of facing the knife if anything is wrong.

There must have been signs of whether everyone got the truth or not.
I would have hoped that Premier Danny Williams would have been adequately satisfied with the indepth way of Questions being asked to Government Officials and all those who had to appear before this Inquiry, especially when this Inquiry is to come to grips with to why peoples lives were given incorrect diagnosis which affected their life, and ultimately death for many.





CJ Alberta
said

Actually, coming from someone who works in a lab, a huge part of the issue is the government! I would not fully blame lab workers, many are over-worked, and forced to work with aging technology. If labs were properly funded a part of this issue could be avoided.


M
said

While the bulk of the blame should go to those working in the labs... quality control must come from somewhere. Are supervisors and lab managers properly trained?
Clearly this is what we can continue to expect from our workforce. I've seen it in many industries whether it's service, health or otherwise. No one seems to have a work ethic anymore. No one seems to be worried about doing things right... they just seem to worry about getting paid.
I agree, the folks involved in this fiasco should face serious consequences on top of obtaining better training which THEY should have to pay for-not the tax-payers. This is a different world, things you learned 10, 20, 30 years ago no longer apply and practices are much more stringent... and for good reason!


FR NL
said

No doubt our premier as made mistakes but however I do not blame this on the government.....personally i blame the ones working in the lab...they are the ones who do the tests not the government...


not a danny fan
said

Danny Williams should stick to looking after his province and what goes on, not ABC


Roger T
said

So much Gov't & rpivate fundings wasted on its poor staffs with low or no expectations of anything worth bragging about on their research and studies.

The Gov't should hold each and everyone that was involved in the research and testing responsible for the intend or careless mistakes. They should be fired and have their research licenses revoked so they can not seep into other organizations to work again.




beeman
said

Compare the public response of Eastern Health to that of the President of Maple Leaf Foods, who was out front and centre during the listeriosis crisis which faced his company.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Health Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   10 Comments 10    1 Video(s) 1

The labels of three Maalox products sold in Canada: Maalox Multi-Action, Maalox Regular Strength, and Maalox Extra-Strength

Supplies of Maalox dwindling across Canada

More