Health -   

1
'My Baby' brand silicone pacifier with cap has been recalled by Health Canada.

Health Canada recalls lead-tainted toys, pacifiers

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: John Vennavally-Rao on toxic toys
Health Canada has ordered thousands of toys pulled from store shelves for containing potentially lethal levels of lead. Most of the pulled items were made in China.
CTV Newsnet: Caroline Brown, Parent educator for Environmental Health, on which toys to look out for.
With Health Canada pulling thousands of Chinese made toys from shelves for containing lead, parents are wondering which toys are safe, and which could be deadly.
CTV Newsnet: Health Minister Tony Clement on the recall of toxic toys
The fact that lead-laced toys are still available on store shelves in Canada is a big concern for Health Canada.
CTV Newsnet: Gideon Forman, Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment, on the dangers
Health Canada is pulling thousands of toys off store shelves after a newspaper investigation found dangerous levels of lead.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (35) Facebook   

Date: Fri. Oct. 24 2008 6:55 PM ET

Health Canada is ordering retailers in Ontario to pull tens of thousands of items off their shelves after finding they were selling lead-tainted toys and children's products, according to a report.

The Toronto Star reported Friday that Health Canada wants the retailers to get rid of the items, which officials say contain lead-levels in excess of allowable amounts. The lead-tainted items were sold in a variety of stores, including "dollar stores," and range from toys to products children put directly in their mouths, such as baby pacifiers.

According to the government of Canada's "Healthy Canadians" website, the recalled items include:

  • "My Baby" brand pacifier twin pack and silicone pacifier
  • Children's Charm craft kits ("Super Dooper Charms" and "Shoelace charms")
  • "GTZ Kool Charmz" charm gift bracelet
  • "Pop Pop Toy Boats," specifically, the 13-inch versions of the "Titanic" and "Hut"
  • "Fairy Dust Pendants" and "Candle Charms"
  • Orange "Mini Hockey Stick" with black painted lettering spelling out "Canada" on the shaft

In some cases, several thousand items of each of the recalled products, many of them manufactured in China, landed on store shelves, according to Health Canada.

For example, approximately 10,000 of the recalled pacifiers were sold in Canada, the agency reported in the recall notice for "My Baby" brand pacifiers. Health Canada has not received any reports of illness or injury due to the recalled products.

Can't force recalls: Clement

Last spring, the Conservative government introduced new consumer protection legislation, comprehensively overhauling Canada's food and product safety laws.

Health Minister Tony Clement spoke to CTV Newsnet on Friday by phone from Bracebridge, ON.

Clement said that he was "deeply disturbed" by the findings and he hopes to be able to do more when it comes to recalling products in the future.

"We have to have a regime where the health minister can enforce a recall - right now I have to request that a manufacturing company recalls its products," Clement said. "I want to have the power... to enforce a recall."

Gideon Forman of the Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment told CTV Newsnet on Friday that there is never a safe amount of lead because it is a "brain poison" that attacks the nervous system and lowers IQ.

"The generally accepted view in scientific literature is that there is no safe level of lead," he said. "Any amount, even a tiny, tiny trace amount can harm a child."

Forman said while parents call their doctors to check on their child's well-being, there should be another call they should make.

"There is also a political demand that should be made - our government should protect us from lead," Forman said. "In addition to calling your doctor, we should be calling out Members of Parliament (and) saying there should be a complete ban on anything that could come into contact with a child that has lead in it."

As for preventing children from getting their hands on toys with lead in them, Forman said there is no hard and fast rule, but he said parents are better off if they avoid imported toys and try to buy unpainted wooden ones that are locally made.

Comments are now closed for this story

To Buy or Not to Buy
said

It seems people select boycotting China as the ultimate solution to quality improvement. That is not the solution.

My wife and I have done some self research comparing quality and price of products in stores. Our conclusion is: Within a same price range, Made in China brands carry better quality than those from other countries (US, Canada, Vietnam, Mexico, you name it). Please note that the key is “same price”. Better quality requires better design, better materials, and more working time to be put into the product. Yes, we can believe products from America represent better quality due to good design and good materials. You know what? Companies in China can provide good design and materials as well, if they receive the message that quality is what we consumers think is more important than affordability. Please do not forget that working hours is an important factor in improving the quality. As long as labours in China cost less than over here, Chinese companies can always invest more human hours and provide better products than we do. They will always win. Hey, who says Chinese companies can not make fancy and pricy goods?


Jack in Hamilton
said

The article does not state where the various parts and materials where manufactured in these products. Although China is the highly visible and most likely suspect, wouldn't it just be a kick in the stomach to discover that perhaps some of these materials were made closer to home? I would like to see the newspaper disclose this information


Angry Maria !
said

MADE IN CHINA ! These are the words I look for before I buy any product. Why blame a government (although I believe imports from China should stop immediately). We are all able to read those 3 little words - DON'T BUY IT !!!! When these items go unsold, maybe somebody will wake up.
I try to buy as much MADE IN CANADA as those 3 little words allow me - although hard to find, and a bit more expensive. Come on Canada, wake up !


Doug BC
said

I don't totally disagree with "MagnuS from Ottawa" regarding imports from China.But,we have to recognize that a blanket ban on Chinese products is likely illegal under WTO trade rules.And,even if it is not,we can hardly expect them to be a market for our goods if we refuse to buy from them.
But,we MUST continue to improve product testing and DEMAND the removal of products containing materials known to be dangerous to people.There are no trade laws requiring us to allow poison toys onto our store shelves.
But at a time when the USA is poised to elect a very protectionist Democratic party to the Whitehouse,the Senate,and Congress,we can ill afford to lose access to any markets for our export goods.Access to the USA is almost certain to be diminished very,very soon.
Frankly,I think this was a more troubling subject at our premiers recent meeting than was the global economic meltdown.Clearly USA borders closed to Canadian exports are now the biggest threat to our eventual economic recovery.


Gail (Hamilton)
said

People are missing the point here and blaming capitalism. These products are manufactured in countries where ingredients are not banned. Any trade agreements we make should clearly state the unacceptable health related ingredients and they should be warned of manufacturing trade embargoes if they persist. What good are items that people don't and won't buy? Both sides lose. Importers should also be held to account and face stiff penalties. The government must do whatever it can to ensure product safety.


CYL
said

Probably another Made In China product for companies who want cheap retail products. Has anyone wondered what those pacifiers are really made from. Mmmmm ?? That's what ya givin your baby to suck on. The thought is making my stomach turn. Can we ban Made In China products, or stop buying them, go back to the old fashion way of doing things.


Vinny in brooklyn
said

But they are such a good price !


Cathy
said

I challenge you to name me three baby pacifier products that don’t have any trace of lead in it.


Marc
said

I think Health Canada should be doing the inspections before the products hit store shelves, not after the fact. Also, why is the lead paint in excess of allowable levels. Can a non toxic paint not be used? Can the manufacturer not be audited for compliance by health Canada before the product is imported? Can the importer not take some responcibility to see that the manufacturer is in complience with recomended lead levels if lead based paint must be used? I will wait for 2 more months until we read a similer recall. Our standards are pathetic


Henry Wysmulek
said

Do we need anymore evidence that China is nor a responsible country and the communists cannot be trusted?

It is time to ban all products made by communist China.




Prof. A
said

I would like to point out that buying non-Chinese....Canadian goods is no guarantee. It may be a better bet but by no means a guarantee. Did you know that most electronic and computer goods contain lead....especially the power cords. However, no warning is issued except in California where their progressive laws make it mandatory to attach a warning label the devices. Our homes are full of warmed up plastic from electronics and we absorb this everyday. Recycling the stuff is another story for another day.....it can't be recycled safely.


Peter from Whitby
said

There is not a SINGLE politian at any level that has the guts to shut down the importation of off shore garbage. Every year its the same old story. You want to fight back, read the labels and don't buy Chinese!


MRC in Hamilton
said

First of all, for those who are ill-informed and blame the government for not being proactive, you must understand that the Conservatives recently INITIATED a program ("comprehensive overhaul") to CHECK Chinese toys, period. Did you read the last paragraph in the article?! In time, if more & more products are found defective, perhaps they will consider an import ban but give things time!

Welcome to globalization (cheapest labour on the planet). THERE'S NOTHING WRONG WITH CAPITALISM, IT IS TOLERANCE AND THE HANDOVER OF TECHNOLOGY THAT'S THE PROBLEM. There's too many ignorant or extreme socialists who think that, under capitalism, the "little" guy doesn't have a voice...do you wanna' bet that if all us little guys STOPPED buying products (especially children's toys) from China, that things would change overnight?! I'd bet that.
Now, the other side of that equation is that labourers here at home would have to accept a DECENT wage and respect our modern labour laws...


Barry in Saskabush
said

I think we have our head in the sand if we think lead is only in the silicone used for baby pacifiers - what about all the Made in China silicone cookware in the stores? What about all the food canisters with silicone air-tight seals? - the silicone spatulas? - the silicone muffin and bread tins? People are buying this stuff like crazy and not stopping to look at the Made in China lable on most of them. Are people so gullable as to think lead is only in the silicone of baby pacifiers? Of course, nobody is required by law to check lead levels in these other products, but if lead is in baby pacifiers from China (along with being found in a lot of toys from China) why should we believe all the kitchen-ware from China is squeeky clean? I think we have been deceived into filling our homes with stuff that is toxic to us. Until the Chinese PROVE their products are clean - then, enough already of the Made in China label!!!


SICK OF THIS CRAP!!!
said

I can't believe this! More Chinese crap which is too poisonous for human use is sold in Canada? Once again Canadian children are poisoned by Chinese products? WHEN WILL THIS END??!?

Wake up, you stupid sheep! Pay the extra 20% and buy Canadian goods! Two things happen:
1. YOU WON'T POISON YOUR CHILDREN!
2. YOU KEEP CANADIAN JOBS!

When will people learn: DON'T TRUST ANYTHING MADE IN CHINA!!



Laszlo
said

LEGO IS NOT MADE IN CHINA. The box perhaps is but my kids don't eat the box. IT is more expensive and let me tell you, it is a life long toy.

I DONT BUY ANYTHING FROM DOLLAR STORES. What possibly can be under $1 that is NOT made with toxins or some other waste product.

Sadly, 10 thousand baby pacifiers were sold? OMG. Again, when it comes to my children, I am VERY selective in where I buy things and "Anything for a buck" store, DOES NOT QUALIFY. MADE IN CANADA ONLY for the most part and yes it is hard, but NOT impossible.


Rob
said

Buy Canadian products, if you can find them, boycott China, their products are cheap and unsafe, just look at the milk issues in there own country, 50,000 children got sick, until they clean up their act stop buying cheap made in China garbage.


Melanie
said

I am going to have to agree with RJ in China. I am going to definatley make more of an effort not to bring anything made in China into my house. Toys, food, etc. This is out of control!!!! When is the gov't going to take action??? Wait, I know, when something bad happens, right?


Gina Smith
said

We need a "Not Made In China" store. I'd shop there every chance I could. It's terribly hard finding alot of items made anywhere but there, but I try. Our country though is bound by foolish trade agreements that they willingly signed on to, the same ones that have destroyed our auto industry - amongst others, and I doubt they are allowed to stop importing from China, as bizarre as that sounds. It's up to us to JUST STOP BUYING CHINESE.


Kevin
said

People as long as you continue to scream "Punish China" to our gov't but rush out to WalMart (used as an example only) as soon as your weekly flyer shows up in your mailbox then things will never change.
We as the consumer are actually the ones who hold all of the power. If we don't buy it then they don't get the money for it. If they don't provide what we want in their shop then we go next door or across town where we can get exactly what it is we want. That practice doesn't have to be limited to the actual product purchased but also to how the business operates, treats it's employees, treats it's customer (me), and the greater community as a whole. In my mind, buying products from a country that has a deplorable human rights record, next to no regulation or real oversight in production and agriculture fields, and an extensive history of shipping substandard and even TOXIC products to other countries, is not looking out for my best interests as your customer. What it does tell me is that you are willing to sacrafice my life,as well as those of my family, friends, and neighbours for the all mighty buck. So I gotta ask myself "And so why should I give you my money?".
What it comes down to is are you willing to sacrafice your convience for your own convictions and are you willing to play Russian Roulette for a couple pennies and precious moments of your time?

Kevin
Chatham,Ontario


RJ in Calgary
said

In my house we DO NOT BY ANY CHILDREN PRODUCTS ADE IN CHINA!!! It is increadably hard to find toys but guess what people its no toys or no children its your choice and obligation to protect your children. LOOK AT THE MANUFACTURER BEFORE YOU BUY!!!


Tracy in Newmarket
said

It is not just dollar store goods. Mattels expensive, Fisher Price toys, were recalled, a while back, because of toxic materials. The CEO of Mattel, initially blamed the Chinese manufacturer, then a week later issued an apology, because they were only obeying Mattels cost-cutting orders. It is the Corporations themselves that let it happen. Yes 'Made in China' seems to be the main source. Always turn over anything, Kids toys, tools, kitchenware or food items BEFORE you buy. Welcome to the 21st century.


Andy in Markham
said

Anybody checking on products sold at Wal-Mart for lead content ?? A lot of their stuff is from China. Check before you buy !!


Romeo
said

Welcome to Capitalism. Where the leaders of organizations are after making money not your health issues. Cheap labour, cheap products, low costs with a maximum profit why not anyone would do such a thing?

It is Health Canada's fault for allowing such products at first place to reach our Local Cities. I don't blame the business people.


trunorth
said

But let's not lay all the blame on China. Canadian distributors are importing this junk because it's cheaper than making it domestically. The almighty dollar rules! We've got just the government to crack down on this immoral and unethical practice. So, let's get at 'em boys!


Pam
said

I say ban any products that come from China. Until products are regulated. Seems everytime we turn around a product(s)are being recalled. What is wrong with the Government just turning a blind eye to everything. Makes me wonder what else is going to be recalled.


Iain - Toronto
said

Obviously, the Canadian Government does not believe in being proactive. They would rather wait until possibly 1000's of kids have been poisoned before reacting. Why are these items not checked before the reach the store shelves? Maybe the government is more concerned about running a surplus than hiring enough employees to check products for problems just like this.


Jayne
said

At what point are we going to stop trading with China until they show the world that the products they are distributing are not going to harm anybody. To date, we have poisoned our pets, given our children lead laced toys, milk products are tainted. It seems to indicate that the people who are making these products have no conscience and continue to flood the market with these toxic products.


Derrick Duby
said

If a Canadian company continually sold toys with lead paint they would be shut down and charged, no questions asked. Why on Earth does the Canadian government continue to allow imported toys from China? Stop all toy imports from China and they will be forced to clean up their act or companies will go elsewhere for their manufactoring needs. WRITE OR CALL YOUR MP's!!

Derrick
Grande Prairie, AB


DaveM, Ottawa
said

Any bets on where these products were manufactured? I'll give you three guesses and the first two don't count.


GM
said

"excess of allowable amounts" Why is any amount of lead allowed in baby's pacifiers?


trunorth
said

Do we have to ask where these hazardous products were made? I have a hard time finding anything that isn't made in China. Isn't it time that the brakes were put on imports from China until they clean up their act.


MagnuS from Ottawa
said

How are these getting onto the shelves after the ordeals we went through last year...are we still ordering from China?? When is the Government going to put a stop to it? We should not have to "recall" these products...they should not be making it to the shelves in the first darn place!!


Hmmmm
said

And where do we think these items were manufactured??


Jack in Hamilton
said

I'd like to know just where these products were manufactured.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

Today's Health Stories

Brent Adamoski used to be afraid of needles but after his 450th blood donation, he doesn't think anything of giving blood anymore. Jan. 5, 2012. (CTV)

Bloodletting might cut some health risks of obesity

More

A man smokes on a street of Beijing, China, Sunday, May 1, 2011. (AP / Ng Han Guan)

Global cancer cases to rise 75 per cent by 2030: study

More   6 Comments 6  

chocolate, acne

Can a daily dose of chocolate prevent heart attacks?

More   7 Comments 7